基于西方学生化理论建构的中国本土研究进展及思考

侍非; 蒋志杰; 尹立杰; 唐天意; 徐海英

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2021.05.004

PDF(3560 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2021, Vol. 36 ›› Issue (5) : 24-31,62. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2021.05.004

进展与动态

基于西方学生化理论建构的中国本土研究进展及思考

侍非¹, 蒋志杰², 尹立杰³, 唐天意⁴, 徐海英⁵

作者信息 +

RESEARCH REVIEW AND REFLECTIONS ON THE INDIGENIZATION OF WESTERN STUDENTIFICATION THEORY IN CHINESE CONTEXT

SHI Fei¹, JIANG Zhi-jie², YIN Li-jie³, TANG Tian-yi⁴, XU Hai-ying⁵

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

近20年来，学生化现象呈全球化趋势，与城市空间交互密切。西方城市地理学界最早关注学生化现象，并系统建构学生化理论。约10年前，该理论被引入中国，开始了本土化研究。鉴于助推学生化理论中国本土化建构的研究仍较少，本文首先介绍了中西方学生化现象及其理论建构的时代背景，阐释了针对学生化理论本土化思考的必要性及意义。随后，通过梳理西方学生化理论建构及其本土化研究，思考了中西方共同关注的理论焦点和研究理论框架，以及对研究中国学生化可能有益的研究方法。最后，文章探讨了基于中国国情的学生化概念界定思考的重要性。

Abstract

Over the last two decades, there has been a tendency toward studentification becoming a global issue and closely interacting with urban spaces. Western urban geographers were the first to pay attention to "studentification" as an urban phenomenon and start theoretical construction of it systematically. However, academic study on the indigenization process of the studentification theory in the Chinese context is still in its early stages. On account of this, this paper begins by illustrating the phenomena of studentification in the West and in China, and different historical backgrounds from which the theory of studentification has been constructed, and then goes on to demonstrate the necessity of thinking over the indigenization process of the studentification theory. By critically examining the Western and Chinese (unfledged) theoretical constructionism of studentification from the dimensions of conceptualizations, key questions, theories, and methodologies, this paper finds the theoretical emphasis that are common to both Chinese and Western research and suggests some prospective approaches and methods to study studentification in China. In particular, this paper recommends the following three theoretical focus to be worthy of attention, namely the distinct characters of transient studentification in China, the evolution of urban space towards social segregation or mix, and the future of Chinese studentification as influenced by a combination of economic, social, political, and cultural factors.

导出引用

侍非, 蒋志杰, 尹立杰, 唐天意, 徐海英. 基于西方学生化理论建构的中国本土研究进展及思考[J]. 人文地理. 2021, 36(5): 24-31,62 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2021.05.004

SHI Fei, JIANG Zhi-jie, YIN Li-jie, TANG Tian-yi, XU Hai-ying. RESEARCH REVIEW AND REFLECTIONS ON THE INDIGENIZATION OF WESTERN STUDENTIFICATION THEORY IN CHINESE CONTEXT[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2021, 36(5): 24-31,62 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2021.05.004

中图分类号： K901

参考文献

[1] Gu H, Smith D P. "Living off the campus":Urban geographies of change and studentification in Beijing, China[J]. Urban Goegraphy, 2020,41(2):205-224.
[2] Brockliss L. Gown and town:The univiersity and the city in Europe, 1200-2000[J]. Minerva, 2000,38(2):147-170.
[3] Davison G. Carlton and the campus:The university and the gentrification of inner Melbourne 1958-75[J]. Urban Policy and Research, 2009,27(3):253-264.
[4] Sage J L. The Micro-geographies of Studentification in Brighton and Hove[D]. Brighton:University of Brighton, 2010:26-27.
[5] Smith D P. "Studentification":The gentrification factory?[M]//Atkinson R, Bridge G. Gentrification in a Global Context:The New Urban Colonialism. London:Routledge, 2005:73-90.
[6] Kinton C, Smith D P, Harrison J. De-studentification:Emptying housing and neighbourhoods of student populations[J]. Environment and Planning A, 2016,48(8):1617-1635.
[7] Mulhearn C, Franco M. If you build it will they come? The boom in purpose-built student accommodation in central Liverpool:Destudentification, studentification and the future of the city[J]. Local Economy, 2018,33(5):477-495.
[8] He S J. Consuming urban living in "villages in the city":Studentification in Guangzhou, China[J]. Urban Studies, 2015,52(15):2849-2873.
[9] Garmendia M, Coronado J M, Ureña J M. University students sharing flats:When studentification becomes vertical[J]. Urban Studies, 2012,49(12):2651-2668.
[10] Kinton C. Processes of Destudentification and Studentification in Loughborough[D]. Loughborough:Loughborough University, 2013:28.
[11] Fincher R, Shaw K. The unintended segregation of transnational students in central Melbourne[J]. Environment and Planning A, 2009, 41(8):1884-1902.
[12] 余思奇,朱喜钢,孙洁.地方感视角下撤村建居社区学生化现象解析——以浙江大学新校区周边望月社区为例[J].城市问题,2018(6):36-42.[Yu Siqi, Zhu Xigang, Sun Jie. Analysis of studentification phenomenon of the residential community under the perspective of the sense of place:A case of the new community near Zhejiang University[J]. Urban Problems, 2018(6):36-42.]
[13] Sabri S, Ludin A N M. "Studentification" is it a key factor within the residential decision-making process in Kuala Lumpur?[C]//Johor B. Proceedings of South East Asian Technical Universities Consortium-3rd SEATUC Symposium. Tokyo:South East Asian Technical Universities Consortium (SEATUC), 2009:69-75.
[14] Prada J. Understanding studentification dynamics in low-income neighbourhoods:Students as gentrifiers in Concepción (Chile)[J]. Urban Studies, 2019,56(14):2863-2879.
[15] 何深静,钱俊希,吴敏华. "学生化" 的城中村社区——基于广州下渡村的实证分析[J].地理研究,2011,30(8):1508-1519.[He Shenjing, Qian Junxi, Wu Minhua. Studentification in urban village:A case study of Xiadu village, Guangzhou[J]. Geographical Research, 2011,30(8):1508-1519.]
[16] Donaldson R, Benn J, Campbell M, et al. Reshaping urban space through studentification in two South African urban centres[J]. Urbani Izziv, 2014,25(S):176-188.
[17] He S J, Lin G C S. Producing and consuming China's new urban space:State, market and society[J]. Urban Studies, 2015,52(15):2757-2773.
[18] Nakazawa T. Expanding the scope of studentification studies[J]. Geography Compass, 2017,11(1):1-13.
[19] Kinton C, Smith D P, Harrison J, et al. New frontiers of studentification:The commodification of student housing as a driver of urban change[J]. The Geographical Journal, 2018,184(3):242-254.
[20] Smith D P. Studentification[M]//Orum A M. The Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia of Urban and Regional Studies. New Jersey:WileyBlackwell, 2019:1-3.
[21] Calvo D M. Understanding international students beyond studentification:A new class of transnational urban consumers. The example of Erasmus students in Lisbon (Portugal)[J]. Urban Studies, 2018, 55(10):2142-2158.
[22] 郑杭生.社会学概论新修(第五版)[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2019:312-314.[Zheng Hangsheng. New Introduction to Sociology[M]. Beijing:China Renmin University Press, 2019:312-314.]
[23] Lees L. Afterword[J]. Environment and Planning A, 2007,39(1):228-234.
[24] Butler T. For gentrification?[J]. Environment and Planing A, 2007, 39(1):162-181.
[25] Eshelby E M. Gown and Town:The Unfolding Presence of Studentification in Clarendon Park, Leicester[D]. Leicester:University of Leicester, 2015:49.
[26] Holton M, Mouat C M. The rise (and rise) of vertical studentification:Exploring the drivers of studentification in Australia[J]. Urban Studies, 2021,58(9):1866-1884.
[27] Wattis L. Class, students and place:Encountering locality in a postindustrial landscape[J]. Urban Studies, 2013,50(12):2425-2440.
[28] Rérat P. Highly qualified rural youth:Why do young graduates return to their home region?[J]. Children's Geographies, 2014,12(1):70-86.
[29] Haartsen T, Thissen F. The success-failure dichotomy revisited:Young adults' motives to return to their rural home region[J]. Children's Geography, 2014,12(1):87-101.
[30] Hubbard P. Regulationg the social impacts of studentification:A Loughborough case study[J]. Environment and Planning A, 2008,40(2):323-341.
[31] Smith D P. The politics of studentification and "(un)balanced" urban population:Lessons for gentrification and sustainable communities?[J]. Urban Studies, 2008,45(12):2541-2564.
[32] Smith D P, Holt L. Studentification and "apprentice" gentrifiers within Britain's provincial towns and cities:Extending the meaning of gentrificaion[J]. Environment and Planning A, 2007,39(1):142-161.
[33] Redfern P A. What makes gentrification "gentrification"?[J]. Urban Studies, 2003,40(12):2351-2366.
[34] 周一星.城市地理学[M].北京:商务印书馆,1995:10-11.[Zhou Yixing. Urban Geography[M]. Beijing:The Commercial Press, 1995:10-11.]
[35] Ruiu M L. Collaborative management of studentification processes:The case of Newcastle upon Tyne[J]. Journal of Housing and the Built Environment, 2017,32(4):843-857.
[36] Kenna T. Studentification in Ireland? Analysing the impacts of students and student accommodation on Cork city[J]. Irish Geography, 2011,44(2/3):191-213.
[37] Sage J, Smith D, Hubbard P. The rapidity of studentification and population change:There goes the (student)hood[J]. Population, Space and Place, 2012,18(5):597-613.
[38] Munro M, Livingston M. Student impacts on urban neighbournhoods:Policy approaches, discourses and dilemmas[J]. Urban Studies, 2012,49(8):1679-1694.
[39] Revington N, Moos M, Henry J, et al. The urban dormitory:Planning, studentification, and the construction of an off-campus student housing market[J]. International Planning Studies, 2020,25(2):189-205.
[40] Munro M, Turok I, Livingston M. Students in cities:A preliminary analysis of their patterns and effects[J]. Environment and Planning A, 2009,41(8):1805-1825.
[41] Laidley T M. The privatization of college housing:Poverty, affordability, and the U.S. public university[J]. Housing Policy Debate, 2014,24(4):751-768.
[42] Foote N S. Beyond studentification in United States college towns:Neighborhood change in the knowledge nodes, 1980-2010[J]. Environment and Planning A, 2017,49(6):1341-1360.
[43] Gu H. Studentification in China:Changing Geographies of Haidian District, Beijing[D]. Loughborough:Loughborough University, 2015:198-201.
[44] 余思奇.城郊学生化新社区研究——以杭州望月社区为例[D].南京:南京大学,2017:5-7.[Yu Siqi. The New Studentification Community in the Suburb:A Case Study of Wangyue, Hanghzou[D]. Nanjing:Nanjing University, 2017:5-7.]
[45] 陈培阳.西方城市学生化研究进展综述[J].人文地理,2017,32(1):9-15.[Chen Peiyang. A review on studentification research of western countries[J]. Human Geography, 2017,32(1):9-15.]
[46] 孙洁,余思奇,朱喜钢.国外学生化研究评述及其对本土化研究的启示[J].国际城市规划,2019,34(6):56-62.[Sun Jie, Yu Siqi, Zhu Xigang. Review of overseas research on studentification and its implication for China[J]. Urban Planning Internation, 2019,34(6):56-62.]
[47] 陈煊.拼贴城市——以武昌高校密集区及其周边"学生村" 拼贴发展研究为例[J].城市规划,2012,36(11):20-28.[Chen Xuan. Collage city:A case study on collage development in universities-concentrated area and surrounding "student villages" in Wuchang[J]. City Planning Review, 2012,36(11):20-28.]
[48] 徐雨璇,何深静,钱俊希.基于新制度经济学视角的学生化社区房屋租赁现象研究——以广州南亭村为例[J].人文地理,2014,29(4):36-43.[Xu Yuxuan, He Shenjing, Qian Junxi. An investigation on the emerging housing rental market in a studentified village in Guangzhou:A new institutional economics perspective[J]. Human Geography, 2014,29(4):36-43.]
[49] Zhao W X, Zou Y H. Un-gating the gated community:The spatial restructuring of a resettlement neighborhood in Nanjing[J]. Cites, 2017,62:78-87.
[50] 郑顺利.大学生校外租房调查分析与管理对策[J].南通大学学报(教育科学版),2006,22(3):67-69.[Zheng Shunli. On the phenomenon of college students renting houses outside campus[J]. Journal of Nantong University (Education Sciences Edition), 2006,22(3):67-69.]
[51] 周璐.民办高校学生校外住宿现状调查与对策——以江西X学院为例[D].南昌:江西师范大学,2014:10-11.[Zhou Lu. Research and Strategy on Living Off-Campus Management of Private College:Take Jiangxi X College as an Example[D]. Nanchang:Jiangxi Normal University, 2014:10-11.]
[52] 周立,丁德群.大学生校外租房状况及影响——以浙师大为例[J]. 现代交际,2013(6):179.[Zhou Li, Ding Dequn. The situation of offcampus rental of college students and its influence:A case study of Zhejiang Normal University[J]. Modern Communication, 2013(6):179.]
[53] 程静. "禁租令" 下的大学生校外租房问题研究[D].成都:西南交通大学,2016:7-10.[Cheng Jing. A Study of Off-Campus Rental among College Students in the Backdrop of the Rental Prohibition[D]. Chengdu:Southwest Jiaotong University, 2016:7-10.]
[54] Smith D P, Hubbard P. The segregaiton of educated youth and dynamic geographies of studentification[J]. Area, 2014,46(1):92-100.
[55] 曹海军,侯甜甜.区块链技术驱动社会治理创新:价值审视、可能挑战与路径展望[J].东南学术,2020(4):103-111.[Cao Haijun, Hou Tiantian. Social governance innovation driven by blockchain technology:Value review, possible challenges and path prospect[J]. Southeast Academic Research, 2020(4):103-111.]