海外&ldquo;乡村复兴&rdquo;研究&mdash;&mdash;脉络走向与理论反思

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.01.003

PDF(1332 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2018, Vol. 33 ›› Issue (1) : 16-23. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.01.003

进展与动态

海外“乡村复兴”研究——脉络走向与理论反思

沈费伟, 刘祖云

作者信息 +

STUDY OF OVERSEAS “RURAL REVIVAL”: CONTEXTUAL TREND AND THEORETICAL REFLECTION

SHEN Fei-wei, LIU Zu-yun

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

海外乡村复兴研究涉及乡村社会学、乡村地理学和乡村经济学三大学科。从这三大学科出发，遵循着“点—线—面”的研究逻辑，本文首先从学术背景和社会背景两方面来考察“乡村复兴研究缘何兴起”；其次从研究主题和研究共识两方面来探究“何谓乡村复兴”；再次从研究视角和研究方法两方面来论述海外学者“从事怎样的乡村复兴研究”；最后从研究论点和研究焦点两方面来讨论学者们“从事什么内容的乡村复兴研究”。在梳理和总结好海外乡村复兴研究的基础上，本文提出了海外乡村复兴研究对于国内研究的四点启示和借鉴。

Abstract

Overseas rural revival studies involves rural sociology, rural geography and rural economics. This paper reviews the study of overseas rural revival by following the research logic of "point-line-face". In the "point" level, overseas scholars are mainly concerned with the study of rural revival of the three academic propositions by reviewing of the literature of rural revival, one of them is an analysis of the concept of rural renaissance; the second is the realistic basis of rural revival; the third is the way to realize rural renaissance which is trying to answer "what is rural revival" and reach some consensus. In the "line" level, scholars focus on "rural revival" academic interest form a wide range of research perspective to a variety of methodology and try to answer "how to do rural revival research", so that the rural revival study can be expand from a certain direction linear. In the "face" level, scholars are mainly for the "rural revival" of the subject itself to start a systematic consideration and explore, and form different research topics and research orientation, trying to answer "do what rural revival research", so they can extract a more mature theoretical analysis framework and research content. This paper puts forward four revelation and reference for the study of overseas rural revival for domestic research by combing and summing up the study of overseas rural revival. The first is to deepen the theme of rural revival by conducting interdisciplinary research. The second is the way to use a variety of research perspective and a comprehensive methodology system to explore the theme of rural revival. The thrid is to expand the content of rural revival research, break the focus of the study, and promote the development of rural revival. Therefore, at the present stage, the domestic political and academic circles should take into account the differences of the theoretical research in the practical use.

导出引用

沈费伟, 刘祖云. 海外“乡村复兴”研究——脉络走向与理论反思[J]. 人文地理. 2018, 33(1): 16-23 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.01.003

SHEN Fei-wei, LIU Zu-yun. STUDY OF OVERSEAS “RURAL REVIVAL”: CONTEXTUAL TREND AND THEORETICAL REFLECTION[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2018, 33(1): 16-23 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.01.003

中图分类号： C912.82

参考文献

[1] 葛丹东.中国村庄规划的体系与模式——当今新农村建设的战略与技术[M].南京:东南大学出版社,2010:31-36.[Ge Dandong.The System and Mode of Village Planning in China:The Strategy and Technology of New Rural Construction[M].Nanjing:Southeast University Press,2010:31-36.]

[2] 沈费伟,刘祖云.精英培育、秩序重构与乡村复兴[J].人文杂志,2017,60(3):120-128.[Shen Feiwei,Liu Zuyun.Elite cultivation,order reconstruction and rural revival[J].The Journal of Humanities,2017,60(3):120-128.]

[3] 沈费伟,刘祖云.发达国家乡村治理的典型模式与经验借鉴[J].农业经济问题,2016,37(9):93-102.[Shen Feiwei,Liu Zuyun.Typical patterns of rural governance in developed countries and experiential learning[J].Issues in Agricultural Economy,2016,37(9):93-102.]

[4] Cloke P.Country backwater to virtual village?Rural studies and the cultural turn[J].Journal of Rural Studies,1997,13(4):367-375.

[5] Cooke P.Flexible Intergration,Scope Economies and Strategic Alliances:Social and Spatial Mediation,Society and Space[M].London:Verso,1988:7-15.

[6] Buttel F H.Some reflections on late twentieth century agrarian political economy[J].Sociologia Ruralis,2001,41(3):165-181.

[7] Woods M.Rural Geography:Processes,Responses and Experiences in Rural Restructuring[M].London:Sage,2005:11.

[8] Roche M.Rural geography:Searching rural geographies[J].Progress in Human Geography,2002,26(6):823-829.

[9] Thrift N,Kitchin R.International Encyclopedia of Human Geography[M].London:Elsevier Science&Technology,2009:429-441.

[10] Kiss E.Rural restructuring in hungary in the period of socio-economic transition[J].Geo-Journal,2000,51(3):221-233.

[11] 西奥多·W·舒尔茨.改造传统农业[M].北京:商务印书馆,2010:4-12.[Schultz T W.Transforming Traditional Agriculture[M].BeiJing:Commercial Press,2010:4-12.]

[12] Batten T R.The Non-directive Approach in Group and Community Work[M].London:Oxford University Press,1967:146-178.

[13] 沈费伟,肖泽干.国外农民协会发展模式及对中国的经验启示[J].世界农业,2016,38(9):23-29.[Shen Feiwei,Xiao Zegan.The development model of foreign farmers association and its enlightenment to China[J].World Agriculture,2016,38(9):23-29.]

[14] Cruickshank J.A play for rurality modernization versus local autonomy[J].Journal of Rural Studies,2009,25(1):98-107.

[15] Schumacher E.Residential situation in urban village:A case study of Ningbo city[J].Economic and Social System Comparison,1973,12(5):35-38.

[16] Woods M.Performing rurality and practising rural geography[J].Progress in Human Geography,2010,34(6):835-846.

[17] Marsden T.Constructing the Countryside[M].London:UCL Press,1993:253-286.

[18] Grimes S.Rural areas in the information society:Diminishing distance or increasing learning capacity[J].Journal of Rural Studies,2000,16(10):13-21.

[19] Madsen L M,Adriansen H K.Understanding the use of rural space:The need for multi-methods[J].Journal of Rural Studies,2004,20(8):485-497.

[20] Hoggart K,Paniagua A.The restructuring of rural Spain[J].Journal of Rural Studies,2001,17(1):24-41.

[21] Bell K P,Bockstael N E.Applying the generalized moments estimation approach to spatial problems involving micro-level data[J].Review of Economics&Statistics,2006,82(1):72-82.

[22] Frenkel A.The potential effect of national growth management policy on urban sprawl and the depletion of open spaces and farmland[J].Land Use Policy,2004,21(6):357-369.

[23] Mormont M.Rural nature and urban natures[J].Sociologia Ruralis,1987,27(6):3-20.

[24] Murata Y.Rural-urban interdependence and industrialization[J].Journal of Development Economics,2002,68(1):1-34.

[25] Audas R.Rural-urban migration in the 1990s[J].Canadian Social Trends,2004,73(2):17-18.

[26] Njega?D,Toski?A.Rural diversification and socio-economic transformation in Croatia[J].Geo-Journal,1998,46(3):263-269.

[27] Bronwyn H.The rural-urban digital divide in New Zealand:Factor fable[J].Prometheus,2001,19(3):231.

[28] Naveh Z.Interactions of landscapes and cultures[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,1995,32(1):43-54.

[29] Ruda G.Rural buildings and environment[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,1998,41(2):93-97.

[30] 王华,陈烈.西方城乡发展理论研究进展[J].经济地理,2006,25(3):463-468.[Wang Hua,Chen Lie.Review on the development theories of rurals and urban areas in west[J].Economic Geography,2006,25(3):463-468.]

[31] Inayatullah.Approaches to Rural Development:Some Asian Experiences[M].Kuala Lumpur:Asian and Pacific Development Administration Center,1979:32-47.

[32] Pretty J.The Living Land:Agriculture,Food and Community Regeneration in Rural Europe[M].London:Earths Publications,1998:99-107.

[33] Vos W,Meekes H.Trends in European culturallandscape development:Perspectives for a sustainable future[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,1993,46(1):3-14.

[34] Edward A.Landscape Planning and Ecological Networks[M].Amsterdam:Elsevier,1994:221-233.

[35] Poudevigne I.Dynamics of rural landscape and their main driving factors:A case study in the Seine Valley,Normandy,France[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,1997,38(5):93-103.

[36] Nelson P.Rural restructuring in the American West:Land use,family and class discourses[J].Journal of Rural Studies,2001,17(4):395-407.

[37] Ilbery B.From Agricultural Productivism to Post-productivism[M].London:Longman,1998:409-421.

[38] Morris C,Evans N,Winter M.Conceptualizing agriculture:A critique of post-productivism as the New Orthodoxy[J].Progress in Human Geography,2002,26(3):313-332.

[39] Smithers J.Across the divide:Reconciling farmland town views of agriculture community linkages[J].Journal of Rural Studies,2005,21(4):281-295.

[40] Lowe P,Murdoch J.A Civilized retreat?Anti-urbanism,Rurality and the Making of an Anglocentric Culture[M].London:Wiley,1995:467-479.

[41] Shucksmith M.Farm household behavior and the transition to postproductivism[J].Journal of Agricultural Economic,1993,44(8):466-478.

[42] 王丽华,俞金国,张小林.国外乡村社会地理研究综述[J].人文地理,2006,21(1):100-105.[Wang Lihua,Yu Jinguo,Zhang Xiaolin.Review on literature of social rural geography overseas[J].Human Geography,2006,21(1):100-105.]

[43] Wilson G,Rigg J.Post-productivist Agricultural Regimes and the South:Discordant Concepts[M].Progress in Human Geography,2003,27(5):605-631.

[44] 沈费伟,刘祖云.中国乡村复兴研究:学术进展与未来走向[J].领导科学,2016,32(23):12-15.[Shen Feiwei,Liu Zuyun.Study on Chinese rural revial:Academic progress and future trend[J].Leadership Science,2016,32(23):12-15.]

[45] 沈费伟,刘祖云.村庄重建的实践逻辑与运作模式——以湖州市荻港村为例[J].南京农业大学学报(社会科学版),2017,17(2):19-29.[Shen Feiwei,Liu Zuyun.The practical logic and operation mode for rural reconstruction:A case of Digang village in Huzhou city[J].Journal of Nanjing Agricultural University (Social Sciences Edition),2017,17(2):19-29.]

[46] Murdoch J.Networks a new paradigm of rural development[J].Journal of Rural Studies,2000,16(4):407-419.