旅游目的地社区居民相对剥夺感研究回顾与展望

唐文跃; 龚晶晶; 赵多平; 张良泉

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2021.06.003

PDF(5409 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2021, Vol. 36 ›› Issue (6) : 19-27. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2021.06.003

进展与动态

旅游目的地社区居民相对剥夺感研究回顾与展望

唐文跃¹, 龚晶晶^2,3, 赵多平^4,5, 张良泉⁶

作者信息 +

RELATIVE DEPRIVATION OF COMMUNITY RESIDENTS IN TOURIST DESTINATION: A REVIEW

TANG Wen-yue¹, GONG Jing-jing^2,3, ZHAO Duo-ping^4,5, ZHANG Liang-quan⁶

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

旅游地居民与多元利益主体间的矛盾和冲突，是旅游领域发展不平衡不充分的重要表现。相对剥夺感是认识旅游地居民行为逻辑的新视角，也为化解旅游地居民与多元利益主体间的矛盾冲突、改善旅游领域基层社会治理提供了新的思路。文章从研究源起、概念内涵和测量维度、影响因素和形成机制、行为效应、应用范畴和研究方法等6个方面对旅游地居民相对剥夺感研究进行了分析回顾。在此基础上，讨论了旅游地居民相对剥夺感研究对于新时期我国旅游地社会治理的现实意义和学术价值，同时构建了旅游地居民相对剥夺感研究框架，并提出了未来研究的方向和重点。

Abstract

The conflicts between community residents and tourism stakeholders are an important manifestation of the imbalanced and inadequate development in the tourism field. Community residents' relative deprivation in tourist destination has become a new topic in social governance, but its theoretical foundation has not yet been formed. To fill this gap and provide a useful reference for its domestic research, the current study reviews foreign language literature on Web of Science, ProQuest, Wiley and reviews Chinese literature on CNKI, VIP and WANFANG with "tourism" + "relative deprivation" as theme words. Based on the systematic combing of the existing literature, this paper reviews the six major topics including:research sources, concept connotation and measurement dimensions, influencing factors and formation mechanism, behavioral effects, application categories and research methods. Furthermore, the paper discusses the practical significance and academic value of the research of tourist destination residents' relative deprivation on the social governance of tourist destinations in the new era and indicates the limitations of every theme and give its comments.

导出引用

唐文跃, 龚晶晶, 赵多平, 张良泉. 旅游目的地社区居民相对剥夺感研究回顾与展望[J]. 人文地理. 2021, 36(6): 19-27 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2021.06.003

TANG Wen-yue, GONG Jing-jing, ZHAO Duo-ping, ZHANG Liang-quan. RELATIVE DEPRIVATION OF COMMUNITY RESIDENTS IN TOURIST DESTINATION: A REVIEW[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2021, 36(6): 19-27 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2021.06.003

中图分类号： F590

参考文献

[1] Wang L G, Yotsumoto Y. Conflict in tourism development in rural China[J]. Tourism Management, 2019,70(2):188-200.
[2] Coser L A. The Functions of Social Conflict[M]. London:Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1956:35-46.
[3] 张书维,周洁,王二平.群体相对剥夺前因及对集群行为的影响——基于汶川地震灾区民众调查的实证研究[J].公共管理学报, 2009,6(4):69-77,126.[Zhang Shuwei, Zhou Jie, Wang Erping. The antecedents of group relative deprivation and its effects on collective action:Empirical research on the people of Wenchuan earthquake area[J]. Journal of Public Management, 2009,6(4):69-77,126.]
[4] Stouffer S A, Suchman E A, Devinney L C, et al. The American Soldier:Adjustment during Army Life[M]. New Jersey:Princeton University Press, 1949:557-559.
[5] Merton R K. Social Theory and Social Structure[M]. New York:Free Press, 1957:62.
[6] Smith H J, Pettigrew T F, Pippin G M, et al. Relative deprivation:A theoretical and meta-analytic review[J]. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 2012,16(3):203-232.
[7] Gurr T R. Why Men Rebel[M]. New Jersey:Princeton University Press, 1971:13.
[8] 李俊.相对剥夺理论的价值论视角[J].学海,2005(4):175-178.[Li Jun. The value perspective of relative deprivation theory[J]. Academia Bimestrie, 2005(4):175-178.]
[9] Smith H J, Pettigrew T F. Advances in relative deprivation theory and research[J]. Social Justice Research, 2015,28(1):1-6.
[10] 孙灯勇,郭永玉.相对剥夺感:想得、应得、怨愤于未得[J].心理科学,2016,39(3):714-719.[Sun Dengyong, Guo Yongyu. Relative deprivation:Wanting, deserving, resentment for not having[J]. Psychological Science, 2016,39(3):714-719.]
[11] Verme P. Relative deprivation and satisfaction:Empirical findings[M]//Ambrosio C D. Handbook of Research on Economic and Social Well-Being. Durham:University of Durham, 2018:356-376.
[12] Runciman W G. Relative Deprivation and Social Justice[M]. London:Routledge, 1966:69-76.
[13] Yitzhaki S. Relative deprivation and the Gini coefficient[J]. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1979,93(2):321-324.
[14] Kakwani N. The relative deprivation curve and its applications[J]. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics, 1984,4(2):384-405.
[15] Podder N. Relative deprivation, envy and economic inequality[J]. Kyklos, 1996,49(3):353-376.
[16] 付允,牛文元.社会群体多维剥夺感模型及应用[J].中国管理科学, 2009,17(3):107-114.[Fu Yun, Niu Wenyuan. Social groups multidimensional deprivation model and its application[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2009,17(3):107-114.]
[17] 雷星晖,代同亮,苏涛永.谦卑领导与员工离职倾向——相对剥夺感的调节作用[J].华东经济管理,2018,32(1):5-11.[Lei Xinghui, Dai Tongliang, Su Taoyong. Humble leadership and employees turnover intention:The moderating role of relative deprivation[J]. East China Economic Management, 2018,32(1):5-11.]
[18] Obaidi M, Bergh R, Akrami N, et al. Group-based relative deprivation explains endorsement of extremism among western-born Muslims[J]. Psychological Science, 2019,30(4):596-605.
[19] 翁堂梅.从纵向到横向:农村户籍大学生相对剥夺感探究[J].中国青年研究,2018(7):73-81.[Weng Tangmei. From vertical to horizontal:A study on the relative deprivation of rural household registered college students[J]. Youth Studies in China, 2018(7):73-81.]
[20] Xu Z C, Sun B D. Influential mechanism of farmers' sense of relative deprivation in the sustainable development of rural tourism[J]. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2020,28(1):110-128.
[21] Bryden J M. Tourism and development:A case study of the commonwealth Caribbean[J]. International Affairs, 1974,50(1):110.
[22] Macnaught T J. Mass tourism and the dilemmas of modernization in Pacific Island communities[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 1982,9(3):359-381.
[23] Richter L K. Political implications of Chinese tourism policy[J]. Pergamon, 1983,10(3):395-413.
[24] Seaton A V. Demonstration effects or relative deprivation? The counter-revolutionary pressures of tourism in Cuba[J]. Progress in Tourism and Hospitality Research, 1997(3):307-320.
[25] 王剑.民族地区旅游业与社区互动发展研究[D].南京:南京师范大学,2009:141.[Wang Jian. Study on Interaction Development between Tourism and Community in Ethnic Areas[D]. Nanjing:Nanjing Normal University, 2009:141.]
[26] 彭建,王剑.旅游研究中的三种社会心理学视角之比较[J].旅游科学,2012,26(2):1-9.[Peng Jian, Wang Jian. A comparative analysis of the three social psychological perspectives in tourism research[J]. Tourism Science, 2012,26(2):1-9.]
[27] Walker I, Smith H J. Relative Deprivation:Specification, Development and Integration[M]. New York:Cambridge University Press, 2002:239.
[28] 李俊.相对剥夺理论与弱势群体的心理疏导机制[J].社会科学, 2004(4):74-78.[Li Jun. Relative deprivation theory and psychological guidance mechanism of vulnerable groups[J]. Social Sciences, 2004(4):74-78.]
[29] 王文辉,白冰,张茵.相对剥夺视角下的乡村旅游地居民不规范行为研究——以江西婺源县李坑、思溪为例[J].地理科学,2019,39(11):1814-1821.[Wang Wenhui, Bai Bing, Zhang Yin. A relative deprivation analysis on the host resistance towards tourism in rural destinations:Case from Wuyuan, China[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2019,39(11):1814-1821.]
[30] Tougas F, Rinfret N, Beaton A M, et al. Policewomen acting in selfdefense:Can psychological disengagement protect self-esteem from the negative outcomes of relative deprivation?[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2005,88(5):790-800.
[31] Goeke-Morey M C, Merrilees C E, Taylor L K, et al. Predictors of strength of in-group identity in Northern Ireland:Impact of past sectarian conflict, relative deprivation, and church attendance[J]. Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology, 2015,25(4):283-295.
[32] Zoogah D B. Why should I be left behind? Employees' perceived relative deprivation and participation in development activities[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2010,95(1):159-173.
[33] Cho B, Lee D, Kim K. How does relative deprivation influence employee intention to leave a merged company? The role of organizational identification[J]. Human Resource Management, 2014,53(3):421-443.
[34] Sablonniere R D L, Tougas F. Relative deprivation and social identity in times of dramatic social change:The case of nurses[J]. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 2008,38(9):2293-2314.
[35] Chung K S, Hwang G, Ryu D S. Scandal and social inequality:How young Koreans feel relative deprivation to sport celebrities[J]. Sport in Society, 2019,22(8):1396-1414.
[36] Birt C M, Dion K L. Relative deprivation theory and responses to discrimination in a gay male and lesbian sample[J]. British Journal of Social Psychology, 1987,26(2):139-145.
[37] 熊猛.流动儿童相对剥夺感:特点、影响因素与作用机制[D].福州:福建师范大学,2015:71.[Xiong Meng. Relative Deprivation of Migrant Children:Characteristics, Influencing Factors and Mechanism[D]. Fuzhou:Fujian Normal University, 2015:71.]
[38] Peng J, Chen X, Wang J. Applying relative deprivation theory to study the attitudes of host community residents towards tourism:The case study of the Zhangjiang National Park, China[J]. Current Issues in Tourism, 2014,19(7):734-754.
[39] 王剑,彭建.基于结构方程的旅游地社区居民旅游影响感知与参与意愿研究——以樟江风景名胜区为例[C]//中国旅游研究院.2014中国旅游科学年会论文集.北京:中国旅游研究院,2014:63-71.[Wang Jian, Peng Jian. Study on the tourism impact perception and community participation willingness based on the Structural Equation Modelling (SEM):A case study of the Zhangjiang National Park[C]//China Tourism Acadamy. Proceedings of the 2014 Annual Conference of Chinese Tourism Science. Beijing:China Tourism Acadamy, 2014:63-71.]
[40] 吴丽敏.文化古镇旅游地居民"情感-行为"特征及其形成机理[D].南京:南京师范大学,2015:54.[Wu Limin. Characteristics and Formation Mechanism of "Emotion-Action" of Residents in Cultural Town Tourist Destination[D]. Nanjing:Nanjing Normal University, 2015:54.]
[41] 张大钊,马秋芳,赵振斌.乡村旅游地居民相对剥夺感的前因和后果研究:基于个体心理学视角[J].人文地理,2020,35(4):32-39,98.[Zhang Dazhao, Ma Qiufang, Zhao Zhenbin. A study on the cause and effect variables of relative deprivation of rural tourism residents:An individual-based psychological perspective[J]. Human Geography, 2020,35(4):32-39,98.]
[42] 罗湘阳,张诗汝,龚箭.国家公园体制试点区居民可持续旅游感知与态度研究——基于相对剥夺理论横向视角[J].华中师范大学学报(自然科学版),2021,55(3):483-493.[Luo Xiangyang, Zhang Shiru, Gong Jian. Residents' perceptions and attitudes on sustainable tourism impacts towards national park system pilot area:A horizontal perspective of relative deprivation theory[J]. Journal of Central China Normal University(Natural Sciences), 2021,55(3):483-493.]
[43] 卢世菊,江婕,余阳.民族地区旅游扶贫中贫困人口的相对剥夺感及其疏导研究——基于恩施州5个贫困村的调查[J].学习与实践, 2018(1):111-118.[Lu Shiju, Jiang Jie, Yu Yang. A study on the relative deprivation guidance of the poor population in pro-poor tourism in ethnic areas:A survey of five poor villages in Enshi[J]. Learning and Practice, 2018(1):111-118.]
[44] 左冰.分配正义:旅游发展中的利益博弈与均衡[J].旅游学刊, 2016,31(1):12-21.[Zuo Bing. Distributive justice:Interest games and equilibrium in tourism development[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2016, 31(1):12-21.]
[45] 李燕琴.反思旅游扶贫:本质、可能陷阱与关键问题[J].中南民族大学学报(人文社会科学版),2018,38(2):99-104.[Li Yanqin. Reflection on poverty alleviation in tourism:Essence, possible trap and key issues[J]. Journal of South-Central University for Nationalities(Humanities and Social Sciences), 2018,38(2):99-104.]
[46] 王剑,赵媛.风景名胜区旅游发展与农村社区居民权益受损分析——以樟江风景名胜区为例[J].人文地理,2009,24(2):120-124.[Wang Jian, Zhao Yuan. Analysis on tourism development at national park and its damage of the right and interests of rural community residents:A case study of Zhangjiang National Park, Guizhou[J]. Human Geography, 2009,24(2):120-124.]
[47] Hall D. Transport and tourism:Some policy issues[J]. Scottish Geographical Journal, 2004,120(4):311-325.
[48] Wolf R. Tourism oriented policing:An examination of a Florida/Caribbean partnership for police training[J]. International Journal of Police Science & Management, 2008,10(4):402-416.
[49] 熊猛,叶一舵.相对剥夺感:概念、测量、影响因素及作用[J].心理科学进展,2016,24(3):438-453.[Xiong Meng, Ye Yiduo. The concept, measurement, influencing factors and effects of relative deprivation[J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2016,24(3):438-453.]
[50] Chen N, Hsu C H C, Li X. Feeling superior or deprived? Attitudes and underlying mentalities of residents towards Mainland Chinese tourists[J]. Tourism Management, 2018,66(6):94-107.
[51] 王汝辉,吴涛,樊巧.基于扎根理论的三圣花乡旅游景区原住民生存感知研究[J].旅游学刊,2014,29(7):31-38.[Wang Ruhui, Wu Tao, Fan Qiao. Research on native residents' perceptions of life in Sansheng Flower Village tourism scenic area based on grounded theory[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2014,29(7):31-38.]
[52] 蔡克信,潘金玉,贺海.利益、权力和制度:旅游社会冲突的成因机制[J].四川师范大学学报(社会科学版), 2017,44(1):48-55.[Cai Kexin, Pan Jinyu, He Hai. Interests, powers and institutions:On genetic mechanism for tourism social conflicts[J]. Journal of Sichuan Normal University(Social Sciences Edition), 2017,44(1):48-55.]
[53] 张春燕.乡村振兴背景下旅游地居民相对剥夺感的形成与疏导[J].湖北大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2020,47(3):163-171.[Zhang Chunyan. The formation and diversion of the relative deprivation of residents in tourist destination under the background of rural revitalization[J]. Journal of Hubei University(Philosophy and Social Science), 2020,47(3):163-171.]
[54] Zhou L X, Chan E, Song H Y. Social capital and entrepreneurial mobility in early-stage tourism development:A case from rural China[J]. Tourism Management, 2017,63(11):338-350.
[55] 张大钊,曾丽.旅游地居民相对剥夺感的应对方式理论模型[J].旅游学刊,2019,34(2):29-36.[Zhang Dazhao, Zeng Li. Theoretical model of reaction mechanism for residents' relative deprivation in tourist destinations[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2019,34(2):29-36.]
[56] 赖斌.民族地区旅游开发对当地群众民生感的影响——基于旅游公平的视角[J].地域研究与开发,2016,35(5):105-109.[Lai Bin. Effect of tourism development on livelihood perception in ethnic minority areas:Based on the perspective of tourist equity[J]. Areal Research and Development, 2016,35(5):105-109.]
[57] Banki M B, Ismail H N. Understanding the characteristics of family owned tourism micro businesses in mountain destinations in developing countries:Evidence from Nigeria[J]. Tourism Management Perspectives, 2015(13):18-32.
[58] 蔡克信,蔡溢.基于相对剥夺感的旅游社区居民类型研究——以贵州西江千户苗寨为例[J].四川师范大学学报(社会科学版), 2018,45(2):84-91.[Cai Kexin, Cai Yi. Residents' classification in tourist destination based on relative deprivation theory:A case study of Xijiang Miao scenic area[J]. Journal of Sichuan Normal University(Social Sciences Edition), 2018,45(2):84-91.]
[59] 笪玲,刘晓鹰.相对剥夺视角下乡村旅游扶贫研究——以贵州兴义万峰林社区为例[J].地域研究与开发,2019,38(2):124-128.[Da Ling, Liu Xiaoying. Study on rural tourism poverty alleviation from relative deprivation perspective:Taking Xingyi Wanfenglin community of Guizhou province as example[J]. Areal Research and Development, 2019,38(2):124-128.]
[60] 任国强,尚明伟,潘秀丽.参照群与群间相对剥夺:理论与实证[J]. 财经研究,2014,40(8):130-144.[Ren Guoqiang, Shang Mingwei, Pan Xiuli. Reference groups and intergroup relative deprivation:Theoretical and empirical analysis[J]. Journal of Finance and Economics, 2014,40(8):130-144.]
[61] 郭星华.城市居民相对剥夺感的实证研究[J].中国人民大学学报, 2001(3):71-78.[Guo Xinghua. The positive research on the relative deprivation of urban population[J]. Journal of Renmin University of China, 2001(3):71-78.]