RESEARCH PROGRESS, THEORETICAL DEBATES AND FRONTIER FIELDS OF THE GLOBAL CITY
JIANG Yan-peng1, CHEN You-hua1, MA Ren-feng2
1. Institute of Global Innovation and Development, The Centre for Modern Chinese City Studies & Centre for China Administrative Division, East China Normal University, Shanghai 200062, China;
2. Department of Geography and Spatial Information Techniques, Centre for Land and Marine Spatial Utilization and Governance Research, Ningbo University, Ningbo 315211, China
Abstract：Global city, as hub city, controls and influences global politics, economy and culture. This research systematically sorts out the research hotspots, theoretical debates and the evolution of research fields in global city at home and abroad, and compares the perspectives of global city research between China and the West, and proposes new possible paradigms of global city research under the new globalization situation. The research found that:1)Global cities are divided into three types:Super-global cities, emerging global cities, and global city- state, focusing on the origin and concept of global city, growth mechanism and its types specialization division and other issues from the perspective of scale-network-level; 2)Chinese scholars have gradually shifted from introducing the concept of global city and its identification indicators, formation mechanisms and other fields to the functions and roles, comparison and evaluation of global cities; 3) The further research of global city under the new globalization situation should pay attention to scalar politics and construction, dynamics, institutions of global cities and proposeresearch focus of global city in the context of the world situation changes.
姜炎鹏, 陈囿桦, 马仁锋. 全球城市的研究脉络、理论论争与前沿领域[J]. 人文地理, 2021, 36(5): 4-14.
JIANG Yan-peng, CHEN You-hua, MA Ren-feng. RESEARCH PROGRESS, THEORETICAL DEBATES AND FRONTIER FIELDS OF THE GLOBAL CITY. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY, 2021, 36(5): 4-14.
林坦,杨超,李蕾.丝路城市网络与上海提升全球城市能级[J].科学发展,2019(6):59-65.[Lin Tan, Yang Chao, Li Lei. Silk road urban network and Shanghai to upgrade the global city level[J]. Scientific Development, 2019(6):59-65.]
[2]
姜炎鹏,王腾飞,陈明星,等.全球城市研究热点与进展[J].世界地理研究,2019,28(1):40-46.[Jiang Yanpeng, Wang Tengfei, Chen Mingxing, et al. Research hotspots and progress of global cities[J]. World Regional Studies, 2019,28(1):40-46.]
[3]
谢守红,宁越敏.世界城市研究综述[J].地理科学进展,2004,23(5):56-66.[Xie Shouhong, Ning Yuemin. A review of world city studies[J]. Progress in Geography, 2004,23(5):56-66.]
[4]
Taylor P J, Derudder B. World City Network[M]. London:Routledge, 2004:194-210.
[5]
Beaverstock J V, Smith R G, Taylor P J. A roster of world cities[J]. Cities, 1999,16(6):445-458.
[6]
Sassen S. The Global City[M]. New Jersey:Princeton University Press, 1991:3-15.
[7]
Knox P L, Taylor P J. World Cities in a World-system[M]. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 1995:21-47.
[8]
Rossi E C, Beaverstock J V, Taylor P J. Transaction Links through cities[J]. Geoforum, 2007,38(4):628-642.
[9]
Parnreiter C. Global cities in global commodity chains[J]. Global Networks, 2010,10(1):35-53.
[10]
Jacobs W, Koster H, Hall P. The location and global network structure of maritime advanced producer services[J]. Urban Studies, 2011,48(13):2749-2769.
[11]
Hanssens H, Derudder B, Witlox F. Managing organizational and geographical complexit[J]. Erdkunde, 2012,66(1):45-55.
[12]
Jacobs W. Rotterdam and Amsterdam as trading places? In search of the economic-geographical nexus between global commodity chains and world cities[J]. Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie, 2014,105(4SI):483-491.
[13]
Parnreiter C. Global cities and the geographical transfer of value[J]. Urban Studies, 2019,56(1):81-96.
[14]
Acuto M. Finding the global city[J]. Urban Studies, 2011,48(14):2953-2973.
[15]
Acuto M, Steele W. Global City Challenges[M]. London:Palgrave Macmillan, 2013:15-32.
[16]
Derudder B, Parnreiter C. Introduction:The interlocking network model for studying urban networks[J]. Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie, 2014,105(4SI):373-386.
[17]
顾朝林,孙樱.经济全球化与中国国际性城市建设[J].城市规划汇刊,1999(3):1-6.[Gu Chaolin, Sun Ying. Economic globalization and international city construction in China[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 1999(3):1-6.]
[18]
杨亚琴,丹王.国际大都市现代服务业集群发展的比较研究[J].世界经济研究,2005(1):61-66.[Yang Yaqing, Dan Wang. A comparative study on the development of modern service industry clusters in international metropolis[J]. World Economy Studies, 2005(1):61-66.]
[19]
诸大建.上海建设循环经济型国际大都市的思考[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2004,14(1):69-74.[Zhu Dajian. Thinking on the construction of Shanghai as an international metropolis with circular economy[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 2004, 14(1):69-74.]
[20]
房国坤,姚士谋,李昌峰,等.上海市空间扩展与环境演化的若干问题[J].人文地理,2000,15(6):17-20.[Fang Guokun, Yao Shimou, Li Changfeng, et al. Some problems of spatial expansion and environmental evolution in Shanghai[J]. Human Geography, 2000,15(6):17-20.]
[21]
马学广,李贵才.全球流动空间中的当代世界城市网络理论研究[J].经济地理,2011,31(10):1630-1637.[Ma Xueguang, Li Guicai. A theoretical study of the contemporary world city network in the space of global mobility[J]. Economic Geography, 2011,31(10):1630-1637.]
[22]
沈丽珍,顾朝林,甄锋.流动空间结构模式研究[J].城市规划学刊, 2010(5):26-32.[Shen Lizhen, Gu Chaolin, Zhen Feng. Study on spatial structure model of flow[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2010(5):26-32.]
[23]
周振华.全球化、全球城市网络与全球城市的逻辑关系[J].社会科学,2006(10):17-26.[Zhou Zhenhua. The logic relation of globalization, global city network and global city[J]. Journal of Social Sciences, 2006(10):17-26.]
[24]
沈丽珍,顾朝林.区域流动空间整合与全球城市网络构建[J].地理科学,2009,29(6):787-793.[Shen Lizhen, Gu Chaolin. Integration of regional flow space and construction of global city network[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2009,29(6):787-793.]
[25]
杨勃,王茂军,王成.世界城市网络研究的热点变迁及主题判别-基于WOS数据库的知识图谱分析[J].人文地理,2019,34(5):26-35.[Yang Bo, Wang Maojun, Wang Cheng. Hotspot change and topic recognition in the study of world cities network[J]. Human Geography, 2019,34(5):26-35.]
[26]
曹清峰,倪鹏飞,马洪福.全球城市体系的网络结构与可持续竞争力研究[J].经济体制改革,2019(6):39-45.[Cao Qingfeng, Ni Pengfei, Ma Hongfu. Research on the network structure and sustainable competitiveness of global urban system[J]. Reform of Economic System, 2019(6):39-45.]
[27]
李恩康,陆玉麒,杨星,等.全球城市网络联系强度的时空演化研究[J].地理科学,2020,40(1):32-39.[Li Enkang, Lu Yuqi, Yang Xing, et al. Spatial and temporal evolution of global urban network connection strength[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2020,40(1):32-39.]
[28]
屠启宇.21世纪全球城市理论与实践的迭代[J].城市规划学刊, 2018(1):41-49.[Tu Qiyu. Interation of global city theory and practice in the 21st Century[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2018(1):41-49.]
[29]
诸大建.3.0升级版:全球城市的双元竞争力概念模型[J].探索与争鸣,2019(3):15-19.[Zhu Dajian. Upgrade 3.0:Conceptual model of dual competitiveness of global cities[J]. Exploration and Free Views, 2019(3):15-19.]
[30]
马仁锋,杨阳,解鹏超.中国沿海城市全球化与地方化博弈逻辑与研究架构[J].上海城市管理,2021,30(2):52-60.[Ma Renfeng, Yang Yang, Xie Pengchao. Game logic and research framework of globalization and localization of coastal cities in China[J]. Shanghai Urban Management, 2021,30(2):52-60.]
[31]
胡彬.生产网络、新型空间形式与全球城市崛起——亚太路径之比较与启示[J].经济管理,2015,37(1):22-32.[Hu Bin. Production networks, new spatial forms, and the rise of the global city[J]. Business Management Journal, 2015,37(1):22-32.]
[32]
屠启宇.建设卓越的全球城市[J].探索与争鸣,2019(3):24-27.[Tu Qiyu. Building a great global city[J]. Exploration and Free Views, 2019(3):24-27.]
[33]
陈建华.全球城市的空间二元化机理研究[J].社会科学,2018(5):42-52.[Chen Jianhua. Study on spatial dualization mechanism of global city[J]. Journal of Social Sciences, 2018(5):42-52.]
[34]
葛天任.国外学者对全球城市理论的研究述评[J].国外社会科学, 2018(5):35-44.[Ge Tianren. A review of foreign scholars' research on global city theory[J]. Social Sciences Abroad, 2018(5):35-44.]
[35]
刘铭秋.全球城市:空间转型与历史记忆[J].理论与改革,2019(1):163-174.[Liu Mingqiu. Global cities:Spatial transformation and historical memory[J]. Theory and Reform, 2019(1):163-174.]
[36]
Knight R V, Gappert G. Cities in a Global Society[M]. Newbury Park, CA:SAGE, 1989:58-67.
[37]
Geddes P. Cities in Evolution[M]. London:Williams, 1915:22-32.
[38]
Hall P. The World Cities[M]. London:Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1984.
[39]
Friedmann J, Wolff G. World city formation[J]. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 1982,6(3):309-344.
[40]
Friedmann J. The world city hypothesis[J]. Development and Change, 1986,17(1):69-83.
[41]
Dear M, Scott A J. Urbanization and Urban Planning in Capitalist Society[M]. London:Routledge, 1981:245-275.
[42]
Castells M. The Rise of the Network Society[M]. New York:John Wiley& Sons, 2011:407-460.
[43]
Abrahamson M. Global Cities[M]. New York:Oxford University Press, 2004.
[44]
Taylor P J. Specification of the world city network[J]. Geographical Analysis, 2001,33(2):181-194.
[45]
Taylor P J, Walker D R, Catalano G, et al. Diversity and power in the world city network[J]. Cities, 2002,19(4):231-241.
[46]
胡彬.基于区域化生产平台的全球城市成长路径[J].城市问题, 2014(10):10-16.[Hu Bin. Global urban growth path based on regional production platform[J]. Urban Problems, 2014(10):10-16.]
[47]
Taylor P J. World cities and territorial states under conditions of contemporary globalization[J]. Political Geography, 2000,19(1):5-32.
[48]
Bhagwati J. Economics and World Order[M]. New York:Free Press, 1972:113-140.
[49]
Taylor P J, Doel M A, Hoyler M, et al. World cities in the pacific rim[J]. Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography, 2000,21(3):233-245.
[50]
King A. Metropolis:The world's great cities[J]. Journal of Historical Geography, 1990,16(4):455-457.
[51]
Robinson J, Doel M, Hubbard P. Global and world cities[J]. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 2002,2(3):531-554.
[52]
Doel M, Hubbard P. Taking world cities literally[J]. City, 2002,6(3):351-368.
[53]
Robinson J. Colonialism and space in urban Africa[J]. Journal of Southern African Studies, 2006,32(1):182-183.
[54]
Deleuze G, Guattari F. A Thousand Plateaus:Capitalism and Schizophrenia[M]. New York:Bloomsbury Publishing, 1988:501-514.
[55]
Ma X, Timberlake M. World city typologies and national city system deterritorialization[J]. Urban Studies, 2013,50(2):255-275.
[56]
Godfrey B J, Zhou Y. Ranking world cities[J]. Urban Geography, 1999,20(3):268-281.
[57]
蔡建明,薛凤旋.界定世界城市的形成——以上海为例[J].国外城市规划,2002(5):16-24.[Cai Jianming, Xue Fengxuan. Defining the formation of a world city[J]. Urban Planning International, 2002(5):16-24.]
[58]
Shen S. Re-Branding without Re-Developing[J]. The Pacific Review, 2010,23(2):203-224.
[59]
Insch A, Bowden B. Possibilities and limits of brand repositioning for a second-ranked city[J]. Cities, 2016,56(1):47-54.
[60]
Derudder B, Taylor P. Change in the world city network, 2000-2012[J]. The Professional Geographer, 2016,68(4):624-637.
[61]
Neal Z. Brute force and sorting processes[J]. Urban Studies, 2013, 50(6):1277-1291.
[62]
Watson A, Beaverstock J V. World city network research at a theoretical impasse[J]. Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie, 2014,105(4):412-426.
[63]
Lefebvre H. The Urban Revolution[M]. Minnesota:University of Minnesota Press, 2003:103-114.
[64]
Sassen S. The global city:Strategic site/new frontier[J]. American Studies, 2000,41(2/3):79-95.
[65]
陈明星,陆大道,唐常春,等.人文与经济地理学的传承与创新[J].地理研究,2018,37(10):2096-2124.[Chen Mingxing, Lu Dadao, Tang Changchun, et al. Research on modern tourism industry system in global urban area[J]. Geographical Research, 2018,37(10):2096-2124.]
[66]
Robinson J. Development and Displacement[M]. Oxford:Oxford University Press, 2002:1-18.
[67]
Sassen S. The globalization and development reader[M]//Sassen S (ed.) Cities in a World Economy. CA:SAGE, 2018:195-215.
[68]
Waley P. Tokyo as World City[J]. Urban Studies, 2007,44(8):1465-1490.
[69]
Brenner N. Global cities, glocal states[J]. Review of International Political Economy, 1998,5(1):1-37.
[70]
Olds K, Yeung H. Pathways to global city formation[J]. Review of International Political Economy, 2004,11(3):489-521.
[71]
Beaverstock J V. Transnational elites in global cities[J]. Geoforum, 2002,33(4):525-538.
[72]
May J, Wills J, Datta K, et al. Keeping London working[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2007,32(2):151-167.
[73]
Persky J, Wiewel W. The growing localness of the global city[J]. Economic Geography, 1994,70(2):129-143.
[74]
Taylor P J, Derudder B, Faulconbridge J, et al. Advanced producer service firms as strategic networks, global cities as strategic places[J]. Economic Geography, 2014,90(3):267-291.
[75]
Jones A. The ‘global city’ misconceived:The myth of ‘global management’ in transnational service firms[J]. Geoforum, 2002,33(3):335-350.
[76]
褚劲风.试论全球城市的基本特征[J].人文地理,1996,11(2):37-40.[Chu Jinfeng. On the basic characteristics of global cities[J]. Human Geography, 1996,11(2):37-40.]
[77]
寇静,朱晓青.世界城市的特性、主导产业及对北京的启示[J].新视野,2012(1):36-39.[Kou Jing, Zhu Xiaoqing. The characteristics, leading industries of the world city and its enlightenment to Beijing[J]. Expanding Horizons, 2012(1):36-39.]
[78]
陆军.世界城市判别指标体系及北京的努力方向[J].城市发展研究,2011,18(4):16-23.[Lu Jun. The world city discriminant index system and the direction of Beijing's efforts[J]. Urban Development Studies, 2011,18(4):16-23.]
[79]
段霞,文魁.基于全景观察的世界城市指标体系研究[J].中国人民大学学报,2011,25(2):61-71.[Duan Xia, Wen Kui. Research on world city index system based on panoramic observation[J]. Journal of Renmin University of China, 2011,25(2):61-71.]
[80]
杨培雷.全球性城市形成机制、结构与功能特征探析——兼谈上海世界性城市建设中的几个问题[J].外国经济与管理,2003(2):18-23.[Yang Peilei. Analysis on the formation mechanism, structure and functional characteristics of a global city[J]. Foreign Economics & Management, 2003(2):18-23.]
[81]
吴灿燃.全球化与跨国网络中心:理解全球城市[J].国际论坛, 2011,13(3):54-59,80-81.[Wu Canran. Globalization and transnational network centers[J]. International Forum, 2011,13(3):54-59, 80-81.]
[82]
马海倩,杨波.上海迈向2040全球城市战略目标与功能框架研究[J].上海城市规划,2014(6):12-18.[Ma H, Yang B. Research on the strategic goal and functional framework of Shanghai towards 2040 global city[J]. Shanghai Urban Planning Review, 2014(6):12-18.]
[83]
许鑫,汪阳.中国全球城市构建的三维逻辑[J].经济与管理研究, 2017,38(9):36-44.[Xu Xin, Wang Yang. Three-dimensional logic of China's global city construction:Institutional environment, locational gravity and spatial justice[J]. Research on Economics and Management, 2017,38(9):36-44.]
[84]
刘波,赵继敏.世界城市住房保障政策比较研究[J].国际城市规划, 2012,27(1):16-20.[Liu Bo, Zhao Jimin. Comparative study on housing security policies in world cities[J]. Urban Planning International, 2012,27(1):16-20.]
[85]
陈强,刘笑.城市三螺旋创新体系测度[J].中国科技论坛,2015(9):17-23.[Chen Qiang, Liu Xiao. Measurement of urban three-spiral innovation system[J]. Forum on Science and Technology in China, 2015(9):17-23.]
[86]
黄江松,鹿春江,徐唯燊.基于马斯洛需求理论构建宜居城市指标体系及对北京的宜居评价[J].城市发展研究,2018,25(5):89-93.[Huang Jiangsong, Lu Chunjiang, Xu Weishen. Based on Maslow's demand theory, the livable city index system is constructed[J]. Urban Development Studies, 2018,25(5):89-93.]
[87]
王宝平,徐伟,黄亮.全球价值链:世界城市网络研究的新视角[J]. 城市问题,2012(6):9-16.[Wang Baoping, Xu Wei, Huang Liang. Global value chain:A new perspective for the study of world city network[J]. Urban Problems, 2012(6):9-16.]
[88]
曹湛,彭震伟.全球城市与全球城市-区域"属性与网络" 的关联性[J].经济地理,2017,37(5):1-11.[Cao Zhan, Peng Zhenwei. The relationship between global cities and global cities-regional "attributes and networks"[J]. Economic Geography, 2017,37(5):1-11.]
[89]
薛德升,邹小华.基于中资商业银行全球空间扩展的世界城市网络及其影响因素[J].地理学报,2018,73(6):989-1001.[Xue Desheng, Zou Xiaohua. The global city network based on the global space expansion of Chinese commercial banks and its influencing factors[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2018,73(6):989-1001.]
[90]
张凡,宁越敏.基于全球航班流数据的世界城市网络连接性分析[J]. 南京社会科学,2015(11):54-62.[Zhang Fang, Ning Yuemin. Network connectivity analysis of world cities based on global flight flow data[J]. Nanjing Journal of Social Sciences, 2015(11):54-62.]
[91]
周韬.基于价值链的城市空间演化及增值机理研究[J].技术经济与管理研究,2015(5):115-120.[Zhou Tao. Research on urban spatial evolution and value-added mechanism based on value chain[J]. Journal of Technical Economics & Management, 2015(5):115-120.]
[92]
苏雪串.经济活动的空间分散与世界城市的产业集聚[J].中央财经大学学报,2009(9):50-54.[Su Xuechuan. The spatial dispersion of economic activities and the industrial agglomeration of world cities[J]. Journal of Central University of Finance & Economics, 2009(9):50-54.]
[93]
尹德挺,史毅.人口分布、增长极与世界级城市群孵化[J].人口研究,2016,40(6):87-98.[Yin Deting, Shi Yi. Population distribution, growth poles and world-class city agglomeration incubation[J]. Population Research, 2016,40(6):87-98.]
[94]
薛莹,吕拉昌,滕丽.全球城市区域下的现代旅游产业体系研究[J]. 世界地理研究,2009,18(4):17-23.[Xue Ying, Lu Lachang, Teng Li. Research on modern tourism industry system in global urban area[J]. World Regional Studies, 2009,18(4):17-23.]
[95]
季小立,洪银兴,刘东皇. "第四方物流" 与"全球城市" 建设[J].经济体制改革,2015(4):20-25.[Ji Xiaoli, Hong Yinxing, Liu Donghuang. "Fourth party logistics" and the construction of "global city"[J]. Reform of Economic System, 2015(4):20-25.]
[96]
李玮,黄耿志,薛德升.世界城市制造业地域嵌入生产性服务业的过程及其影响因素[J].地理研究,2021,40(2):343-355.[Li Wei, Huang Gengzhi, Xue Desheng. The process of regional embedding of producer services in the world's urban manufacturing industry and its influencing factors[J]. Geographical Research, 2021,40(2):343-355.]
