驻村工作队与乡村精英互助作用下的乡村治理研究

张园林; 刘玉亭

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.04.004

PDF(4190 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2020, Vol. 35 ›› Issue (4) : 23-31. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.04.004

社会

驻村工作队与乡村精英互助作用下的乡村治理研究

张园林, 刘玉亭

作者信息 +

RURAL GOVERNANCE UNDER THE MUTUAL ASSISTANCE OF VILLAGE WORKING TEAM AND RURAL ELITE

ZHANG Yuan-lin, LIU Yu-ting

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

基于乡村“公”、“共”、“私”三分领域的治理理论，以G省F贫困村为例，运用实地考察、深度访谈等质性研究方法，结合F村实证特征和问题分析，探讨政府（驻村工作队）与社会（乡村精英）互助作用下的乡村治理特征。研究指出，驻村工作队代表政府权威，领导并协助村两委工作；新乡贤利用自身社会资本，与驻村工作队在项目确定、资金使用、村庄发展等方面协商互助，降低治理成本；村两委则以维持乡村生产、生活秩序为主，并领导/协助新乡贤参与村中事务。总体而言，驻村工作队嵌入乡村，代表上层政府的外部政府权威，乡村精英代表乡村内生权威，二者作为“中间者”在乡村层面协作互助，实现“上、中、下相结合”的较为均衡的乡村治理。

Abstract

Based on the theoretical perspective of rural governance which was divided into three fields of "government", "community" and "market", this paper takes F poverty village in G Province as an example, and combines the empirical characteristics and problem analysis of F village to explore the rural governance model under the mutual assistance of the government (village working team) and the society (rural elite) through qualitative research methods such as field investigation and in-depth interviews. The study points out that, the village working team, as the representative of governmental authority, guilds and assists the village committee's work. The rural elite uses their own social capital to negotiate and help each other with village working team in terms of project determination, fund use and village development, so as to reduce the cost of governance. The village committee mainly maintains the order of production and life in the countryside, and leads/assists rural elite to participate in village affairs. Generally speaking, village working team embeds into the village, representing the external government authority of upper government, while rural elite represents the endogenous authority of the countryside. As "intermediaries", they need to cooperate and help each other at the rural level in order to form a more balanced rural governance model of "combination of the top, the middle and the bottom".

导出引用

张园林, 刘玉亭. 驻村工作队与乡村精英互助作用下的乡村治理研究[J]. 人文地理. 2020, 35(4): 23-31 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.04.004

ZHANG Yuan-lin, LIU Yu-ting. RURAL GOVERNANCE UNDER THE MUTUAL ASSISTANCE OF VILLAGE WORKING TEAM AND RURAL ELITE[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2020, 35(4): 23-31 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.04.004

中图分类号： K901.8

参考文献

[1] 刘彦随,李进涛.中国县域农村贫困化分异机制的地理探测与优化决策[J]. 地理学报,2017,72(1):161-173.[Liu Yansui, Li Jintao. Geographic detection and optimizing decision of the differentiation mechanism of rural poverty in China[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2017,72(1):161-173.]
[2] 郑小玉,刘彦随.新时期中国"乡村病" 的科学内涵、形成机制及调控策略[J]. 人文地理,2018,33(2):100-106.[Zheng Xiaoyu, Liu Yansui. Connotation, formation mechanism and regulation strategies of rural disease in the new epoch in China[J]. Human Geography, 2018, 33(2):100-106.]
[3] 申明锐.乡村项目与规划驱动下的乡村治理-基于南京江宁的实证[J]. 城市规划,2015,39(10):83-90.[Shen Mingrui. An emerging mode of rural governance driven by program and planning:Evidence from Jiangning, Nanjing[J]. City Planning Review, 2015,39(10):83-90.]
[4] Chen A. How has the abolition of agricultural taxes transformed village governance in China? Evidence from agricultural regions[J]. The China Quarterly, 2014,219:715-735.
[5] 刘彦随,周扬,刘继来.中国农村贫困化地域分异特征及其精准扶贫策略[J]. 中国科学院院刊,2016,31(3):269-278.[Liu Yansui, Zhou Yang, Liu Jilai. Regional differentiation characteristics of rural poverty and targeted poverty alleviation strategy in China[J]. Bulletin of Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2016,31(3):269-278.]
[6] 吴唯佳,吴良镛,何兴华,等.人居科学与乡村治理[J]. 城市规划, 2017,41(3):103-108.[Wu Weijia, Wu Liangyong, He Xinghua, et al. Science of human settlements and rural governance[J]. City Planning Review, 2017,41(3):103-108.]
[7] 杨芳.驻村"第一书记" 与村庄治理变革[J]. 学习论坛,2016,32(2):52-55.[Yang Fang. The first secretary in village and the reform of village governance[J]. Tribune of Study, 2016,32(2):52-55.]
[8] 唐燕,赵文宁,顾朝林.我国乡村治理体系的形成及其对乡村规划的启示[J]. 现代城市研究,2015(4):2-7.[Tang Yan, Zhao Wenning, Gu Chaolin. The evolution of rural governance system in China and its influences to rural spatial planning[J]. Modern Urban Research, 2015(4):2-7.]
[9] 朱余斌.建国以来乡村治理体制的演变与发展研究[D]. 上海:上海社会科学院,2017:19-24.[Zhu Yubin. Research on the Evolution and Development of Rural Governance System Since the Founding of The People's Republic of China[D]. Shanghai:Shanghai Academy of Social Sciences, 2017:19-24.]
[10] 田原史起.日本视野中的中国农村精英:关系、团结、三农政治[M]. 济南:山东人民出版社,2012:6-16.[Fumiki Tahara. Rural Leaders in China:Connection, Cohesion and Agrarian Politics[M]. Jinan:Shandong People's Publishing House, 2012:6-16.]
[11] 郐艳丽.我国乡村治理的本原模式研究——以巴林左旗后兴隆地村为例[J]. 城市规划,2015,39(6):59-68.[Gui Yanli. Research on basic models of rural governance:A case study on Houxinglongdi village in Balin Left Banner[J]. City Planning Review, 2015,39(6):59-68.]
[12] Tewdwr-Jones M. Rural government and community participation:The planning role of community councils[J]. Journal of Rural Studies, 1998,14(1):51-62.
[13] Edwards B, Goodwin M, Pemberton S, et al. Partnerships, power, and scale in rural governance[J]. Environment and Planning C:Government and Policy, 2001,19(2):289-310.
[14] Jones O, Little J. Rural challenge:Partnership and new rural governance[J]. Journal of Rural Studies, 2000,16(2):171.
[15] Rhodes R A W. The new governance:Governing without government[J]. Political Studies, 1996,44(4):652-667.
[16] Shen J. Scale, state and the city:Urban transformation in post-reform China[J]. Habitat International, 2007,31(3):303-316.
[17] 苏海新,吴家庆.论中国乡村治理模式的历史演进[J]. 湖南师范大学社会科学学报,2014,43(6):35-40.[Su Haixin, Wu Jiaqing. On the evolution of Chinese rural governance model[J]. Journal of Social Science of Hunan Normal University, 2014,43(6):35-40.]
[18] 张尚武,李京生,郭继青,等.乡村规划与乡村治理[J]. 城市规划, 2014,38(11):23-28.[Zhang Shangwu, Li Jingsheng, Guo Jiqing, et al. Rural planning and rural governance[J]. City Planning Review, 2014,38(11):23-28.]
[19] 费孝通.乡土中国生育制度乡土重建[M]. 北京:商务印书馆,2011:24-30,48-53.[Fei Xiaotong. From the Soil:The Foundations of Chinese Society, Family Planning System and From the Soil:The Constructions of Chinese Society[M]. Beijing:The Commercial Press, 2011:24-30,48-53.]
[20] 陆学艺.培育形成合理的社会阶层结构是构建和谐社会的基础[J]. 中国党政干部论坛,2005(9):9-11.[Lu Xueyi. Cultivating and forming a reasonable social stratum structure is the foundation of building a harmonious society[J]. Chinese Cadres Tribune, 2005(9):9-11.]
[21] 贺雪峰.缺乏分层与缺失记忆型村庄的权力结构——关于村庄性质的一项内部考察[J]. 社会学研究,2001(2):68-73.[He Xuefeng. Lack of stratification and power structure of memory village:An internal investigation on the nature of villages[J]. Sociological Studies, 2001(2):68-73.]
[22] 覃国慈,田敏.民族地区新农村建设的推动力量:乡村精英——以湖北省巴东县为个案[J]. 中南民族大学学报(人文社会科学版), 2006(6):81-85.[Qin Guoci, Tian Min. New impetus to building new countryside in ethnic areas-countryside elites taking Badong county, Hubei province as the example[J]. Journal of South-Central University for Nationalities (Humanities and Social Sciences), 2006(6):81-85.]
[23] 程朋飞,刘云刚.明清时期乡村社会治理的空间机制——基于领域性视角[J]. 人文地理,2017,32(1):29-36.[Cheng Pengfei, Liu Yungang. The territory and territoriality in the spatial governance of Chinese rural society in Ming and Qing dynasties[J]. Human Geography, 2017,32(1):29-36.]
[24] 付翠莲.我国乡村治理模式的变迁、困境与内生权威嵌入的新乡贤治理[J]. 地方治理研究,2016(1):67-73.[Fu Cuilian. The changes and difficulties of rural governance model in China and the governance of new rural elites embedded with endogenous authority[J]. Local Governance Research, 2016(1):67-73.]
[25] 王勇,李广斌.裂变与再生:苏南乡村公共空间转型研究[J]. 城市发展研究,2014,21(7):112-118.[Wang Yong, Li Guangbin. Fission and regeneration:The transformation of rural public space and its mechanism in Southern Jiangsu[J]. Urban Development Studies, 2014,21(7):112-118.]
[26] 田先红,陈玲.再造中间层:后税费时代的乡村治理模式变迁研究[J]. 甘肃行政学院学报,2010(6):36-43.[Tian Xianhong, Chen Ling. Practice and innovation on the classified governance of urban community public affairs:A case study of Hangzhou[J]. Journal of Gansu Administration Institute, 2010(6):36-43.]
[27] 唐朗诗,郭圣莉.重塑社区的"文化网络":城镇化进程中的新乡贤治理——基于上海市外冈镇"老大人" 治理的实证研究[J]. 南通大学学报(社会科学版),2018(5):129-135.[Tang Langshi, Guo Shengli. Reshaping the cultural nexus of community:New rural sage governance in the process of urbanization:An empirical study on the "Laodaren" governance in Waigang Town, Shanghai[J]. Journal of Nantong University (Social Science Edition), 2018(5):129-135.]
[28] 张春华.缺位与补位:乡村治理中的现代乡贤[J]. 重庆社会科学, 2018(3):74-80.[Zhang Chunhua. Absence and replacement:The modern elites in rural governance[J]. Chongqing Social Sciences, 2018(3):74-80.]
[29] 王嘉燕,徐奇峰.乡村精英:乡村治理现代化的推动力量——以德清乡贤参事会为例[J]. 怀化学院学报,2018,37(9):74-77.[Wang Jiayan, Xu Qifeng. Rural elite:The driving force of rural governance modernization:A case study of village sage council in Deqing[J]. Journal of Huaihua University, 2018,37(9):74-77.]
[30] 韩广富,周耕.党政机关选派干部下乡扶贫制度的建立[J]. 理论学刊,2013(11):22-25,127.[Han Guangfu, Zhou Geng. Establishment of system of party and government offices' sending cadres to countryside for poverty-alleviation[J]. Theory Journal, 2013(11):22-25, 127.]
[31] 高莉娟.乡村振兴背景下干部驻村精准扶贫研究述评与展望[J]. 地方治理研究,2018(2):66-77,80.[Gao Lijuan. Research review and prospect of targeted poverty alleviation with officials stationed in villages under the background of rural revitalization[J]. Local Governance Research, 2018(2):66-77,80.]
[32] 贾姝宁.乡村振兴战略视角下"第一书记" 引导乡村治理新模式[J]. 改革与开放,2018(2):80-81.[Jia Shuning. "The first secretary" guides the new model of rural governance from the perspective of Rural Revitalization Strategy[J]. Reform & Openning, 2018(2):80-81.]
[33] 王晓毅.驻村工作队要参与村庄治理[J]. 中国老区建设,2016(10):15.[Wang Xiaoyi. Village task force should participate in village governance[J]. China's Construction of Old Revolutionary Basic Area, 2016(10):15.]
[34] 李鑫诚.乡村权力下沉治理模式的运行策略及其反思[J]. 湖北社会科学,2017(4):22-27.[Li Xingchen. The operation strategy and reflection of the governance model of rural power sinking[J]. Hubei Social Sciences, 2017(4):22-27.]
[35] 贺雪峰.论中国农村的区域差异——村庄社会结构的视角[J]. 开放时代,2012(10):108-129.[He Xuefeng. On regional differences in rural China:A perspective of village social structure[J]. Open Times, 2012(10):108-129.]
[36] 戴碧涛,张景.农村集体产权制度改革与扶贫工作中的精英俘获成因及治理[J]. 农业经济,2018(7):40-42.[Dai Bitao, Zhang Jing. The cause and management of elite capture in the reform of rural collective property right system and poverty alleviation[J]. Agricultural Economy, 2018(7):40-42.]
[37] 胡红霞,李达,王俊程.精准扶贫与乡村治理创新[J]. 西南科技大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2017,34(5):53-58.[Hu Hongxia, Li Da, Wang Juncheng. Targeted poverty alleviation and rural governance innovation[J]. Journal of Southwest University of Science and Technology (Philosophy and Social Science Edition), 2017,34(5):53-58.]
[38] 贺雪峰.农村精英与中国乡村治理——评田原史起著《日本视野中的中国农村精英:关系、团结、三农政治》[J]. 人民论坛·学术前沿,2012(12):90-94.[He Xuefeng. The rural elite and rural governance in China:Comments on Tahara Fumiki's China's Rural Elite in the Eyes of Japan:Relationship, Unity and Sannong Politics[J]. Frontiers, 2012(12):90-94.]
[39] 徐瑾,万涛.由"村外人" 到"新乡贤" 的乡村治理新模式——以H省G村为例[J]. 城市规划,2017,41(12):65-72.[Xu Jin, Wan Tao. Outsiders to rural elites-based rural governance model:A case study of a village, H province[J]. City Planning Review, 2017,41(12):65-72.]
[40] 张园林,刘玉亭,权东计.关中地区乡村公共空间的演变特征及其机制研究[J]. 地域研究与开发,2018,37(4):150-155.[Zhang Yuanlin, Liu Yuting, Quan Dongji. Evolution characteristics and dynamics of public spaces in villages of Guanzhong area[J]. Areal Research and Development, 2018,37(4):150-155.]
[41] 王汉生,吴莹.基层社会中"看得见" 与"看不见" 的国家——发生在一个商品房小区中的几个"故事"[J]. 社会学研究,2011,25(1):63-95.[Wang Hansheng, Wu Ying. Visible and invisible state in grass-roots society:Episodes in a commercial housing enclave[J]. Sociological Studies, 2011,25(1):63-95.]
[42] 万涛.权力的文化网络视角下的新乡贤返乡困境及对策——基于H省G村的调查和实验[J]. 城市规划,2016(11):21-29.[Wan Tao. Predicaments and countermeasures of new country squires refluxing from the perspective of the cultural nexus of power:Based on the investigation and experiment of G village, H province[J]. City Planning Review, 2016(11):21-29.]