市场资本驱动下的乡村空间生产与治理重构&mdash;&mdash;对婺源县Y村的实证观察

杨洁莹; 张京祥; 张逸群

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.03.010

PDF(10414 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2020, Vol. 35 ›› Issue (3) : 86-92,114. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.03.010

乡村

市场资本驱动下的乡村空间生产与治理重构——对婺源县Y村的实证观察

杨洁莹, 张京祥, 张逸群

作者信息 +

RURAL SPACE PRODUCTION AND GOVERNANCE RESTRUCTURING DRIVEN BY MARKET CAPITAL: A CASE STUDY OF Y VILLAGE IN WUYUAN

YANG Jie-ying, ZHANG Jing-xiang, ZHANG Yi-qun

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

乡村振兴不能回避资本，然而资本下乡会改变乡村内部治理结构，如何善用资本以实现乡村善治成为一个难题。文章以江西省婺源县Y村作为典型案例，基于空间生产理论视角，深度剖析资本介入后村庄治理主体的关系转换和资本运行的内在机制，并揭示资本介入后乡村善治面临的难题。文章认为，市场资本介入乡村重构了空间生产主体，并倾向于构建符合自身需求的新空间形态。新空间形态进一步形成了新社会关系网络，新社会关系网络在市场资本的助推下稳固，并逐步将村民主体排挤出村庄，导致资本下乡后空间非正义等问题凸显。未来的乡村治理模式应当发挥资本的触媒作用；维持政府公正性角色，保持乡村空间正义；明确村民主体地位，鼓励村民作为村庄营建的主体；强化集体力量，保持村集体对空间的有效控制权。

Abstract

Market capital is an important element to achieve rural revitalization. However, capital flow in rural area will change the internal governance structure of the village. How to make good use of capital to achieve good governance in the rural area has become a problem. The article takes Y Village inWuyuan County, Jiangxi Province as a typical case. Based on the perspective of the production of space theory, it deeply analyzes the relationship between the transformation of the main body of village governance and the internal mechanism of capital operation, and reveals the difficulties faced by rural governance after capital intervention. The article points out that after the capital goes to rural areas, the government-capital alliance jointly creates space and maintains the order of rights; the transformation of rural space leads to the separation of main bodies; the space of daily life of villagers is weakened and the subjective status of governance is weakened; the separation of old and new residential areas of villagers has led to a weakening of social connections.The paper believes that market capital intervenes in rural areas to reconstruct the main body of production of space, and tends to construct a new spatial form that meets their own needs. The new spatial form has further formed a new social relationship network. The new social relationship network has been stabilized by the help of market capital, and gradually squeezed out the villagers' main body out of the village, leading to problems such as inequality in space after capital going to the countryside.

导出引用

杨洁莹, 张京祥, 张逸群. 市场资本驱动下的乡村空间生产与治理重构——对婺源县Y村的实证观察[J]. 人文地理. 2020, 35(3): 86-92,114 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.03.010

YANG Jie-ying, ZHANG Jing-xiang, ZHANG Yi-qun. RURAL SPACE PRODUCTION AND GOVERNANCE RESTRUCTURING DRIVEN BY MARKET CAPITAL: A CASE STUDY OF Y VILLAGE IN WUYUAN[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2020, 35(3): 86-92,114 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.03.010

中图分类号： C912.82

参考文献

[1] Gorbuntsova T, Dobson S, Palmer N. Diverse geographies of power and spatial production:Tourism industry development in the Yamal Peninsula, Northern Siberia[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2019(76):67-79.
[2] Fowler C, Forsdick C, Kostova L, et al. Travel and Ethics:Theory and Practice[M]. London:Taylor & Francis, 2014:128-150.
[3] Liu Z, Müller M, Rommel J, et al. Community-based agricultural land consolidation and local elites:Survey evidence from China[J]. Journal of Rural Studies, 2016(47):449-458.
[4] 何慧丽,程晓蕊,宗世法.当代新乡村建设运动的实践总结及反思——以开封10年经验为例[J].开放时代,2014(4):149-169.[He Huili, Cheng Xiaorui, Zong Shifa. Contemporary new rural construction movement:Summary and reflection based on ten years of experience in Kaifeng[J]. Open Times, 2014(4):149-169.]
[5] 渠岩. "归去来兮"——艺术推动村落复兴与"许村计划"[J].建筑学报,2013(12):22-26.[Qu Yan. Back to the traditional art promotes village rejuvenation and "Xucun Plan"[J]. Architectural Journal, 2013(12):22-26.]
[6] 张京祥,姜克芳.解析中国当前乡建热潮背后的资本逻辑[J].现代城市研究,2016(10):2-8.[Zhang Jingxiang, Jiang Kefang. Analyzing capital logic behind rural construction boom in contemporary China[J]. Modern Urban Research, 2016(10):2-8.]
[7] 张京祥,邓化媛.解读城市近现代风貌型消费空间的塑造——基于空间生产理论的分析视角[J].国际城市规划,2009,23(1):43-47.[Zhang Jingxiang, Deng Huayuan. On the forming of consumer space in modern urban historical & cultural areas:An analysis from the perspective of spatial production theory[J]. Urban Planning International, 2009,23(1):43-47.]
[8] 方远平,易颖,毕斗斗.传承与嬗变:广州市小洲村的空间转换[J].地理研究,2018,37(11):2318-2330.[Fang Yuanping, Yi Ying, Bi Doudou. Inheritance and transmutation:Space transformation of Xiaozhou village, Guangzhou[J]. Geographical Research, 2018,37(11):2318-2330.]
[9] 魏开,许学强,魏立华.乡村空间转换中的土地利用变化研究——以滘中村为例[J].经济地理,2012,32(6):114-119.[Wei Kai, Xu Xueqiang, Wei Lihua. Land use change in rural space transition:A case study of Jiaozhong village[J]. Economic Geography, 2012,32(6):114-119.]
[10] 李云新,王晓璇.资本下乡中利益冲突的类型及发生机理研究[J]. 中州学刊,2015(10):43-48.[Li Yunxin, Wang Xiaoxuan. Study on the types and mechanisms of conflicts of interests in capital going to the countryside[J]. Academic Journal of Zhongzhou, 2015(10):43-48.]
[11] 李云新,阮皓雅.资本下乡与乡村精英再造[J].华南农业大学学报(社会科学版),2018,17(5):117-125.[Li Yunxin, Ruan Haoya. Capital going to the countryside and reconstruction of rural elite[J]. Journal of South China Agricultural University (Social Science Edition), 2018,17(5):117-125.]
[12] 安永军.政权"悬浮"、小农经营体系解体与资本下乡——兼论资本下乡对村庄治理的影响[J].南京农业大学学报(社会科学版), 2018,18(1):33-40.[An Yongjun. Regime "suspension", disintegration of small-scale operating system and capital downward to rural units:The latter's influence on village governance[J]. Journal of South China Agricultural University (Social Science Edition), 2018, 18(1):33-40.]
[13] Greiner R. Improving the net benefits from tourism for people living in remote northern Australia[J]. Sustainability, 2010,2(7):2197-2218.
[14] Bennett N, Lemelin R H, Koster R, et al. A capital assets framework for appraising and building capacity for tourism development in aboriginal protected area gateway communities[J]. Tourism Management, 2012,33(4):752-766.
[15] Coria J, Calfucura E. Ecotourism and the development of indigenous communities:The good, the bad, and the ugly[J]. Working Papers in Economics, 2011,73(73):47-55.
[16] 曼纽尔·卡斯特,王红扬,李祎.城市意识形态[J].国外城市规划, 2006(5):15-29.[Castells M, Wang Hongyang, Li Yi. The urban ideology[J]. Urban Planning International, 2006(5):15-29.]
[17] Goffman E. The interaction order:American sociological association, 1982 presidential address[J]. American Sociological Review, 1983,48(1):1-17.
[18] 王勇,李广斌,王传海.基于空间生产的苏南乡村空间转型及规划应对[J].规划师,2012,28(04):110-114.[Wang Yong, Li Guangbin, Wang Chuanhai. Space production based southern Jiangsu province countryside space transition[J]. Planners, 2012,28(4):110-114.]
[19] 赵纯.旅游影响下乡村空间治理中的伦理重塑——基于空间生产理论视角[J].云南师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2019,51(3):142-148.[Zhao Chun. A study of ethical reconstruction in the rural spatial planning under tourism impact from the perspective of the spatial production theory[J]. Journal of Yunnan Normal University (Humanities and Social Sciences Edition), 2019,51(3):142-148.]
[20] 戈夫曼·欧文.日常生活中的自我呈现[M].黄爱华,冯钢,译.北京:浙江人民出版社,1989:118-124.[Goffman E. The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life[M]. Huang Aihua, Feng Gang, trans. Beijing:Zhejiang People's Publishing House, 1989:118-124.]
[21] 米歇尔·福柯.规训与惩罚:监狱的诞生[M].刘北成,杨远婴,译.北京:三联书店,2003:194-200.[Foucault M. Surveiller Et Punir[M]. Liu Beicheng, Yang Yuanyin, trans. Beijing:Joint Publishing Corporation, 2003:194-200.]
[22] Henri L. The Production of Space[M]. Blackwell:Oxford, 1991:68-79.
[23] 叶超,柴彦威,张小林. "空间的生产" 理论、研究进展及其对中国城市研究的启示[J].经济地理,2011,31(3):409-413.[Ye Chao, Chai Yanwei, Zhang Xiaolin. Review on studies on production of urban space[J]. Economic Geography, 2011,31(3):409-413.]
[24] 孙全胜.论列斐伏尔"空间生产" 的资本批判[J].武汉科技大学学报(社会科学版),2016,18(3):274-280.[Shun Quansheng. On the capital critique of Lefebvre's "space production"[J]. Journal of Wuhan University of Science and Technology (Social Science Edition), 2016,18(3):274-280.]
[25] Soja E W. Postmodern geographies:The reassertion of space in critical social theory[J]. Geographical Review, 1989,18(5):803-805.
[26] 张京祥,胡毅,孙东琪.空间生产视角下的城中村物质空间与社会变迁——南京市江东村的实证研究[J].人文地理,2014,29(2):1-6.[Zhang Jingxiang, Hu Yi, Sun Dongqi. The physical space change and social variation in urban village from the perspective of space production:A case study of Jiangdong villalge in Nanjing[J]. Human Geography, 2014,29(2):1-6.]
[27] 王丹.基于空间生产理论的古村落文化景观研究[D].西安:西安建筑科技大学,2016:63-65.[Wang Dan. Research on the ancient villages' cultural landscape from the theory of space production[D]. Xi'an:Xi'an University of Architecture and Technology, 2016:63-65.]
[28] 庄友刚.空间生产与资本逻辑[J].学习与探索,2010(1):14-18.[Zhuang Yougang. Space production and capital logic[J]. Study & Exploration, 2010(1):14-18.]
[29] Rigg J, Ritchie M. Production, consumption and imagination in rural Thailand[J]. Journal of Rural Studies, 2002,18(4):359-371.
[30] Goffman E E. The presentation of self in everyday life[J]. Threepenny Review, 2009,21(116):14-15.
[31] 徐晖.空间秩序与空间生产——昆明桦村的空间形态变迁[D].昆明:云南大学,2015:15-16.[Xu Hui. Spatial Order and Production of Space:The Spatial Morphology's Transition of Kunming's Huacun[D]. Kunming:Yunnan University, 2015:15-16.]
[32] 刘怀玉.现代性的平庸与神奇——列斐伏尔日常生活批判哲学的文本学解释[M].北京:中央编译出版社,2006:379-400.[Liu Huaiyu. Textological Reading[M]. Beijing:Central Compilation & Translation Press, 2006:379-400.]
[33] 洪世键,张衔春.租差、绅士化与再开发:资本与权利驱动下的城市空间再生产[J].城市发展研究,2016,23(3):101-110.[Hong Shijian, Zhang Xianchun. Rent gap, gentrification and urban redevelopment:The reproduction of urban space diven by capital and right[J]. Urban Studies, 2016,23(3):101-110.]
[34] Harvey D. From managerialism to entrepreneurialism:The transformation in urban governance in late capitalism[J]. Geografiska Annaler, 1989,71(1):3-17.
[35] Bunce M. The ‘leisuring’ of rural landscapes in Barbados:New spatialities and the implications for sustainability in small island states[J]. Geoforum, 2008,39(2):969-979.
[36] 孙全胜.列斐伏尔"空间生产" 的理论形态研究[M].北京:中国社会科学出版社,2017:147-148.[Sun Quansheng. Study on the Theoretical Forms of Henri Lefebvre's "The Production of Space"[M]. Beijing:China Social Sciences Press, 2017:147-148.]
[37] 黄晓星,郑姝莉.作为道德秩序的空间秩序——资本、信仰与村治交融的村落规划故事[J].社会学研究,2015,30(1):190-214.[Huang Xiaoxing, Zheng Shuli. Space order as moral order:A village planning story with a blend of capital, ethics and village governance[J]. Sociological Study, 2015,30(1):190-214.]
[38] Cassell C, Symon G. Essential Guide to Qualitative Methods in Organizational Research[M]. London:SAGE Publications Ltd, 2004:154-164.
[39] Patton M Q. Qualitative Evaluation and Research Methods[M]. London:Sage Publications, 1990:532-535.
[40] Copena D, Simón X. Wind farms and payments to landowners:Opportunities for rural development for the case of Galicia[J]. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2018,95:38-47.
[41] 范颖.基于空间生产理论的四川乡村建设理想空间发展探寻——四川省宜宾县"西部第一‘香’村" 建设实证研究[J].农村经济, 2017(2):77-82.[Fan Ying. Exploring the ideal space development of Sichuan rural construction based on space production theory:A case study of Yibin in Sichuan province[J]. Rural Economy, 2017(2):77-82.]
[42] 胡毅,张京祥,孙东琪,等.资本的空间不平衡发展:城中村的空间生产[J].城市发展研究,2014,21(5):32-38.[Hu Yi, Zhang Jingxiang, Sun Dongqi, et al. The uneven development of capital:The production of space in China's urban village[J]. Urban Studies, 2014,21(5):32-38.]
[43] Nelson P B. Rural restructuring in the American west:Land use, family and class discourses[J]. Journal of Rural Studies, 2001,17(4):395-407.
[44] Woods M. Performing rurality and practising rural geography[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2011,34(6):835-846.
[45] 冯小.资本下乡的策略选择与资源动用——基于湖北省S镇土地流转的个案分析[J].南京农业大学学报(社会科学版), 2014,14(1):36-42.[Feng Xiao. Strategies of capital allocation to countryside and use of resources:A case study of S town in Hubei province[J]. Journal of Nanjing Agricultural University (Social Sciences Edition), 2014,14(1):36-42.]
[46] 费孝通.乡土中国[M].北京:人民出版社,2018:58-65.[Fei Xiaotong. Xiangtu China[M]. Beijing:People's Publishing House, 2018:58-65.]
[47] 李惠斌,杨雪冬.社会资本与社会发展[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2000:155-165.[Li Huibin, Yang Xuedong. Social Capital and Social Development[M]. Beijing:Social Sciences Academic Press, 2000:155-165.]
[48] 朴昌根.韩国新村运动成功经验简析[J].韩国研究论丛,2007(4):168-179.[Piao Changgen. A brief analysis of the successful experience of the new village movement in Korea[J]. Korean Studies, 2007(4):168-179.]
[49] 晁伟鹏,乐永海.发达国家(地区)农业现代化进程中农户与市场对接模式比较[J].资源开发与市场,2012,28(10):926-929.[Chao Weipeng, Yue Yonghai. Comparison of docking modes between small holders and large market in process of agricultural modernization in developed countries and areas[J]. Resource Development and Market, 2012,28(10):926-929.]
[50] 乔杰,洪亮平.从"关系" 到"社会资本":论我国乡村规划的理论困境与出路[J].城市规划学刊,2017(4):81-89.[Qiao Jie, Hong Liangping. From "guanxi" to "social capital":The predicament of and prospect for planning theory in rural China[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2017(4):81-89.]
[51] 郑雄飞.地租的时空解构与权利再生产——农村土地"非农化" 增值收益分配机制探索[J].社会学研究,2017,32(4):70-93.[Zheng Xiongfei. Space-time deconstruction and the reproduction of the rights to land rent:An exploration of non-agricultural value-added revenue distribution mechanisms of rural land[J]. Sociological Study, 2017,32(4):70-93.]