地缘环境评估中的尺度陷阱

王丰龙

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2022.02.004

PDF(2096 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2022, Vol. 37 ›› Issue (2) : 24-30. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2022.02.004

地缘环境研究专栏

地缘环境评估中的尺度陷阱

王丰龙^1,2

作者信息 +

SCALAR TRAPS IN ASSESSMENT OF GEO-SETTING

WANG Feng-long^1,2

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

地缘环境评估是政治地理学的一个重要研究方向，对于地缘风险评估和地缘战略制定具有重要意义。但是，现有研究较少论及地缘环境评估中的尺度问题。本文基于地理学中的尺度研究，尤其是王丰龙所提出的尺度陷阱理论，系统归纳了地缘环境评估中面临的 4 类尺度陷阱。首先，在地缘环境评估中，分析的空间范围和单元划分与地缘环境的评估结果存在相互依赖关系，从而造成分析尺度选择陷阱；第二，地缘环境评估需要涵盖不同尺度上的因素，从而产生多尺度耦合陷阱；第三，地缘环境评估需要将不同尺度形式的因素同时纳入，从而面临不同尺度形式的叠合陷阱；第四，地缘环境评估需要兼顾指标的综合全面与分析问题的重点突出两个相矛盾的需求，进而产生了综合化尺度陷阱。建议后续研究在认识到这些尺度陷阱的基础上，选择更优的分析尺度，提升评估结果的稳健性，从而增强相关研究结论对于地缘风险判断和地缘战略制定的参考价值。

Abstract

Assessment of geo-setting is an important field in political geographical studies and is critical for identifying geopolitical risks and making geopolitical strategies. However, few studies have examined the scale problem in assessing geo-setting. Based on previous geographical research on the concept of scale and the theoretical perspective of scalar traps proposed by Fenglong Wang, this paper summarizes 4 types of scalar traps in research on assessment of geo-setting. First, since the selection of geographical scopes and level of resolution is mutually dependent with the results of assessing geo-setting, there is a scalar trap of selecting the optimal scale for assessing geo-setting. Second, since we should consider components of geo-setting at different scales yet the indicators at different scales may be incomparable, assessment of geo-setting need to deal with the trap of multiple-scale coupling. Third, because assessment of geo-setting should incorporate different elements of different scalar forms, e.g. some indicators are calculated based on areal region yet some others are calculated based on network, it is difficult to integrate these indicators into a unified framework. Forth, to balance the demands of evaluating comprehensive indicators and proposing priorities for making geopolitical strategies in assessing geo-setting, it is necessary to overcome the scalar trap of trade-off between extensiveness and conciseness.

导出引用

王丰龙. 地缘环境评估中的尺度陷阱[J]. 人文地理. 2022, 37(2): 24-30 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2022.02.004

WANG Feng-long. SCALAR TRAPS IN ASSESSMENT OF GEO-SETTING[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2022, 37(2): 24-30 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2022.02.004

中图分类号： K901.4

参考文献

[1] 杨吾扬.论中国发展的地缘环境[J].大自然探索,1995,14(1):7-10.[Yang Wuyang. On the geo-setting of China's development[J]. Exploration of Nature, 1995,14(1):7-10.]
[2] 胡志丁,葛岳静,骆华松,等.地缘环境解析:理论与方法笔谈[J].世界地理研究,2019,28(2):2-12.[Hu Zhiding, Ge Yuejing, Luo Huasong, et al. Analysis of geo-setting:Theory and method[J]. World Regional Studies, 2019,28(2):2-12.]
[3] 王丰龙,胡志丁,刘承良,等.中国政治地理与地缘政治理论研究展望:青年学者笔谈[J].世界地理研究,2020,29(2):232-251.[Wang Fenglong, Hu Zhiding, Liu Chengliang, et al. A prospect on the theoretical studies of political geography and geopolitics in China:Viewpoints from some young scholars[J]. World Regional Studies, 2020, 29(2):232-251.]
[4] 胡志丁,曹原,刘玉立,等.我国政治地理学研究的新发展:地缘环境探索[J].人文地理,2013,28(5):123-128.[Hu Zhiding, Cao Yuan, Liu Yuli, et al. A new development of political geography research in China:Geo-setting[J]. Human Geography, 2013,28(5):123-128.]
[5] Raj B, Singh A K, Giri A K. Geo-Environmental Study and Groundwater Quality Assessment:Hydro- geochemistry, Analytical Methods and Environmental Significance of Water Quality Parameters[M]. Chisinau:LAP Lambert Academic Publishing, 2011:1-100.
[6] Monakhov S, Esina O, Monakhova G, et al. Environmental quality assessment:Geoenvironmental indices[M]//Armon Robert H, Hänninen Osmo. Environmental Indicators. Dordrecht:Springer Netherlands, 2015:461-478.
[7] 宋长青,葛岳静,刘云刚,等.从地缘关系视角解析"一带一路"的行动路径[J].地理研究,2018,37(1):3-19.[Song Changqing, Ge Yuejing, Liu Yungang, et al. Undertaking research on Belt and Road initiative from the geo-relation perspective[J]. Geographical Research, 2018,37(1):3-19.]
[8] 胡伟,胡志丁,葛岳静.中国地缘环境研究进展与思考[J].地理科学进展,2019,38(4):477- 488.[Hu Wei, Hu Zhiding, Ge Yuejing. Review of geo- setting research in China[J]. Progress in Geography, 2019,38(4):477-488.]
[9] 冯长强,张晓楠,曹一冰,等.地缘环境定量研究综述[J].地理与地理信息科学,2019,35(3):78- 84.[Feng Changqiang, Zhang Xiaonan, Cao Yibing, et al. Review of quantitative study on geo-environment[J]. Geography and Geo-Information Science, 2019,35(3):78-84.]
[10] Fairgrieve J. Geography and World Power (8th Edition)[M]. London:University of London Press, 1941:1-364.
[11] 陈军,葛岳静,华一新,等."数字周边"总体架构与研究方向[J].测绘通报,2013(2):1-4.[Chen Jun, Ge Yuejing, Hua Yixin, et al. Digital border-land:Conceptual framework and research agenda[J]. Bulletin of Surveying and Mapping, 2013(2):1-4.]
[12] 葛全胜,江东,陆锋,等.地缘环境系统模拟研究探讨[J].地理学报, 2017,72(3):371-381.[Ge Quansheng, Jiang Dong, Lu Feng, et al. Views on the study of geopolitical environment system simulation[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2017,72(3):371-381.]
[13] 潘峰华,赖志勇,葛岳静. 经贸视角下中国周边地缘环境分析——基于社会网络分析方法[J].地理研究,2015,34(4):775-786.[Pan Fenghua, Lai Zhiyong, Ge Yuejing. The surrounding geopolitical environment of China:A social network analysis based on trade data[J]. Geographical Research, 2015,34(4):775-786.]
[14] 胡丹露.基于事件的地缘环境评估方法研究[J].军事运筹与系统工程,2018,32(1):5-10.[Hu Danlu. Research on the methods of assessing geo-setting based on event data[J]. Military Operations Research and Systems Engineering, 2018,32(1):5-10.]
[15] 熊琛然,王礼茂,屈秋实,等.地缘政治环境中的情景分析:中国的视角[J].世界地理研究,2019,28(3):1-10.[Xiong Chenran, Wang Limao, Qu Qiushi, et al. Application of scenario analytical method in geopolitical environment from the perspective of China[J]. World Regional Studies, 2019,28(3):1-10.]
[16] 赵文双,江南,谢雨芮,等.地缘环境可视化方法综述[J].测绘科学, 2022,47(1):172- 180.[Zhao Wenshuang, Jiang Nan, Xie Yurui, et al. Review of the geo-setting visualization methods[J]. Science of Surveying and Mapping, 2022,47(1):172-180.]
[17] 温荟琦,蒋秉川,万刚,等.大数据下的地缘环境可视分析研究探讨[J]. 测绘科学,2018,43(12):77- 84.[Wen Huiqi, Jiang Bingchuan, Wan Gang, et al. Discussion of research on visual analysis of geosetting based on big data[J]. Science of Surveying and Mapping, 2018,43(12):77-84.]
[18] 冯长强,江南,张晓楠,等.地缘环境分析模型图形化建模[J].测绘科学技术学报,2017,34(1):91- 95.[Feng Changqiang, Jiang Nan, Zhang Xiaonan, et al. Graphical modeling of geo-environment analysis model[J]. Journal of Geomatics Science and Technology, 2017, 34(1):91-95.]
[19] 陈健,李宏伟,张斌.基于标准差方法的地缘环境单元划分研究[J]. 测绘工程,2014,23(8):6-9.[Chen Jian, Li Hongwei, Zhang Bin. Research on geographical environment unit division based on the method of standard deviation[J]. Engineering of Surveying and Mapping, 2014,23(8):6-9.]
[20] 周秋文,杨胜天,廖华,等.地缘环境单元划分方法及实例研究[J].世界地理研究,2016,25(4):58-66.[Zhou Qiuwen, Yang Shengtian, Liao Hua, et al. Building and application of a geopolitical environment unit regionalization method[J]. World Regional Studies, 2016, 25(4):58-66.]
[21] 韩增林,彭飞,张耀光,等.海洋地缘政治研究进展与中国海洋地缘环境研究探索[J].地理科学,2015,35(2):129-136.[Han Zenglin, Peng Fei, Zhang Yaoguang, et al. Updated progress of marine geopolitics and research of the marine geo-setting in China[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2015,35(2):129-136.]
[22] 彭飞,富宁宁,张琦琦,等.海洋地缘环境系统构建及其脆弱性解析[J].世界地理研究,2019,28(2):133- 140.[Peng Fei, Fu Ningning, Zhang Qiqi, et al. Analysis of systematic construction and vulnerability of marine geo-setting[J]. World Regional Studies, 2019,28(2):133-140.]
[23] 胡志丁,杜德斌.日本德川幕府时期的地缘环境分析——兼论国别地缘环境分析框架[J].地理学报,2020,75(10):2047-2060.[Hu Zhiding, Du Debin. An investigation of Japanese geo-setting during the period of Tokugawa Bakufu:A tentative examination of the analytical framework for geo-setting research[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2020,75(10):2047-2060.]
[24] 胡志丁,葛岳静,鲍捷,等.南亚地缘环境的空间格局与分异规律研究[J]. 地理科学,2013,33(6):685- 692.[Hu Zhiding, Ge Yuejing, Bao Jie, et al. The spatial pattern and differentiation laws of geo-setting in south Asia[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2013,33(6):685- 692.]
[25] 胡志丁,刘玉立,李灿松,等.权力、地缘环境与地缘位势评价——以中日钓鱼岛之争为例[J].热带地理,2014,34(1):50-57.[Hu Zhiding, Liu Yuli, Li Cansong, et al. Power, geo-setting and evaluation method of geo- potential:A case study of the dispute over China and Japan on the Diaoyu islands[J]. Tropical Geography, 2014, 34(1):50-57.]
[26] 林刚,丁方宇,付晶莹,等. 南亚地缘环境风险等级的智能判别与分析[J].科技导报,2018,36(3):70-74.[Lin Gang, Ding Fangyu, Fu Jingying, et al. Intelligent recognition of risk levels of geopolitical system for south Asia[J]. Science & Technology Review, 2018,36(3):70-74.]
[27] 胡伟,刘晓凤,葛岳静,等.美国地缘环境解析及其对中国的启示[J]. 科技导报,2019,37(16):95- 107.[Hu Wei, Liu Xiaofeng, Ge Yuejing, et al. Analysis of American geo-setting and its enlightenment for China[J]. Science & Technology Review, 2019,37(16):95-107.]
[28] 吴良,秦奇,张丹,等.印度洋通道及其对中国地缘环境影响[J].地理科学进展,2018,37(11):1510-1520.[Wu Liang, Qin Qi, Zhang Dan, et al. Indian ocean passages and their geopolitical impacts on China[J]. Progress in Geography, 2018,37(11):1510-1520.]
[29] 洪菊花,骆华松.中国与东南亚地缘环境和跨境河流合作[J].世界地理研究,2015,24(1):29-37.[Hong Juhua, Luo Huasong. Geopolitical environment and cooperation of transboundary river between China and southeast Asia[J]. World Regional Studies, 2015,24(1):29-37.]
[30] 彭飞,韩增林.东海问题的周边地缘环境解析[J].世界地理研究, 2014,23(2):35- 42.[Peng Fei, Han Zenglin. The geopolitical environment of greater neighborhood of the East China Sea[J]. World Regional Studies, 2014,23(2):35-42.]
[31] 胡浩,葛岳静,胡志丁.南海问题的大周边地缘环境[J].世界地理研究,2012,21(3):36-44.[Hu Hao, Ge Yuejing, Hu Zhiding. The geopolitical environment of greater neighborhood of the south China sea[J]. World Regional Studies, 2012,21(3):36-44.]
[32] Herod A. Scale:The local and the global[M]//Clifford Nicholas J. Key Concepts in Geography. London:Sage, 2003:209-228.
[33] Marston S A, Woodard K, Jones J P. Scale[M]//Gregory Derek, Johnston Ron J, Pratt Geraldine, et al. The Dictionary of Human Geography (5th ed.). Cambridge, MA:Blackwell, 2009:664-666.
[34] Montello D R. Scale in geography[M]//Smelser Neil J., Baltes Paul B. International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences. Oxford:Pergamon, 2001:13501-13504.
[35] Sayre N F, Vittorio A V D. Scale[M]//Kobayashi Audrey, Kitchin Rob, Thrift Nigel. International Encyclopedia of Human Geography (2nd Edition):Volume 12. Oxford:Elsevier, 2020:79-87.
[36] 刘云刚,王丰龙.尺度的人文地理内涵与尺度政治——基于1980年代以来英语圈人文地理学的尺度研究[J].人文地理,2011,26(3):1-6.[Liu Yungang, Wang Fenglong. Concept of scale in human geography and politics of scale:Based on anglophone human geography since 1980s[J]. Human Geography, 2011,26(3):1-6.]
[37] Openshaw S. Concepts and Techniques in Modern Geography No.38:The Modifiable Areal Unit Problem[M]. Norwich:Geobooks, 1984:1-41.
[38] 吕一河,傅伯杰.生态学中的尺度及尺度转换方法[J].生态学报, 2001,21(12):2096- 2105.[Lv Yihe, Fu Bojie. Ecological scale and scaling[J]. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 2001,21(12):2096-2105.]
[39] 王丰龙,刘云刚.中国行政区划调整的尺度政治[J].地理学报,2019, 74(10):2050- 2060.[Wang Fenglong, Liu Yungang. "Politics of scale" in Chinese administrative division adjustment[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2019,74(10):2050-2060.]
[40] 刘云刚,王丰龙.三鹿奶粉事件的尺度政治分析[J].地理学报,2011, 66(10):1368-1378.[Liu Yungang, Wang Fenglong. Politics of scale in "Sanlu-milkpowder scandal"[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2011, 66(10):1368-1378.]
[41] da Silva L P B, Hussein H. Production of scale in regional hydropolitics:An analysis of La Plata river basin and the guarani aquifer system in south America[J]. Geoforum, 2019,99:42-53.
[42] 王丰龙.幸福地理学研究中的时空间尺度陷阱[J].人文地理,2021, 36(2):11-19.[Wang Fenglong. Spatio-temporal scalar traps in geographical studies of subjective well- being[J]. Human Geography, 2021,36(2):11-19.]
[43] Openshaw S. Concepts and Techniques in Modern Geography No.38:The Modifiable Areal Unit Problem[M]. Norwich:Geo Books, 1984:1-41.
[44] Marshall J U. Beyond the rank-size rule:A new descriptive model of city sizes[J]. Urban Geography, 1997,18(1):36-55.
[45] Kwan M-P. The uncertain geographic context problem[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 2012,102(5):958-968.
[46] 胡志丁,王丰龙,安宁,等.洋能否为中用?西方政治地理与地缘政治发展的借鉴与反思[J]. 地理研究,2020,39(2):217-231.[Hu Zhiding, Wang Fenglong, An Ning, et al. Can foreign theories be used in China? Reflections and references on the development of western political geography and geopolitics[J]. Geographical Research, 2020,39(2):217-231.]
[47] 王丰龙,刘云刚.尺度政治理论框架[J].地理科学进展,2017,36(12):1500- 1509.[Wang Fenglong, Liu Yungang. Towards a theoretical framework of "politics of scale"[J]. Progress in Geography, 2017, 36(12):1500-1509.]
[48] 王丰龙,司月芳,傅行行,等.谁是我们的朋友,谁是我们的"敌人"?——基于联合国投票的中国地缘政治准则研究[J].世界地理研究,2020,29(2):252- 263.[Wang Fenglong, Si Yuefang, Fu Xingxing, et al. Who are our friends and who are our "enemies"? A quantitative analysis of China's geopolitical codes based on the UN votes[J]. World Regional Studies, 2020,29(2):252-263.]
[49] 沈伟烈.地缘政治关系简析[J].人文地理,1991,6(1):65-71.[Shen Weilie. A brief analysis of geopolitical relationships[J]. Human Geography, 1991,6(1):65-71.]
[50] Swyngedouw E. Neither global nor local:"Glocalization" and the olitics of scale[M]//Cox Kevin. Spaces of Globalization. New York:Guilford Press, 1997:137-166.
[51] Bathelt H, Malmberg A, Maskell P. Clusters and knowledge:Local buzz, global pipelines and the process of knowledge creation[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2004,28(1):31-56.
[52] 王丰龙,刘云刚.尺度概念的演化与尺度的本质:基于二次抽象的尺度认识论[J].人文地理,2015,30(1):9-15.[Wang Fenglong, Liu Yungang. An analytical framework of scale based on second abstraction[J]. Human Geography, 2015,30(1):9-15.]
[53] 陈彦光,姜世国.城市集聚体、城市群和城镇体系[J].城市发展研究,2017,24(12):8- 15.[Chen Yanguang, Jiang Shiguo. Urban agglomeration body, urban agglomeration and urban system[J]. Urban Development Studies, 2017,24(12):8-15.]
[54] Taylor P J, Catalano G, Walker D R F. Exploratory analysis of the world city network[J]. Urban Studies, 2002,39(13):2377-2394.
[55] 王垚,钮心毅,宋小冬". 流空间"视角下区域空间结构研究进展[J]. 国际城市规划,2017,32(6):27-33.[Wang Yao, Niu Xinyi, Song Xiaodong. Research progress of regional spatial structure under the perspective of space of flow[J]. Urban Planning International, 2017, 32(6):27-33.]
[56] 王士君,廉超,赵梓渝.从中心地到城市网络——中国城镇体系研究的理论转变[J].地理研究,2019,38(1):64-74.[Wang Shijun, Lian Chao, Zhao Ziyu. From central place to city network:A theoretical change in China's urban system study[J]. Geographical Research, 2019,38(1):64-74.]
[57] Flint C, Taylor P J. Political Geography:World- economy, Nationstate and Locality (7th Edition)[M]. New York:Routledge, 2018:1- 370.