近20年国内外社区恢复力研究脉络、进展与逻辑框架

王菲; 陈佳

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2024.02.004

PDF(3945 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2024, Vol. 39 ›› Issue (2) : 31-43. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2024.02.004

专栏：社会—生态系统转型与恢复力

近20年国内外社区恢复力研究脉络、进展与逻辑框架

王菲¹, 陈佳^1,2

作者信息 +

EVOLUTION, PROGRESS AND LOGICAL FRAMEWORK OF COMMUNITY RESILIENCE AT HOME AND ABROAD FOR 20 YEARS

WANG Fei¹, CHEN Jia^1,2

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

面对全球复杂多变的环境，提升社区恢复力是促进可持续发展的重要路径之一。社区恢复力在近20年发展中研究成果丰富，研究领域逐渐拓展，却尚未形成统一的研究框架，需要对已有成果进行回顾和评述，以推动社区恢复力理论和方法体系发展。首先，借助文献计量分析方法对2001—2021年的国内外社区恢复力发文情况、研究脉络进行了梳理，总结划分了社区恢复力研究领域演变的三个阶段，分析概括了其发文特征、主题内容以及各阶段特点和趋势。其次，针对社区恢复力在发展中以框架、评价、影响因素和建设管理为主要理论和实践成果的研究进展进行系统总结和述评。继而基于其概念内涵、核心内容和相关框架的综合思考，提出了聚焦可持续科学领域的社区恢复力研究基本逻辑框架。最后，立足目前社区恢复力研究成果和发展困境，提出未来议题需要强调从多学科融合方法体系构建，多领域整合和注重中国地方化实践以强化和深入未来社区恢复力领域研究。

Abstract

In today's complex and ever-changing global environment, enhancing community resilience has become a critical pathway towards promoting the sustainability of social ecological systems. Over the past two decades, research on community resilience has yielded valuable insights, and the research field has gradually expanded. To this end, this thesis employs bibliometric analysis to identify and categorize three stages of community resilience research from 2001 to 2021 at the domestic and international levels:the embryonic development stage (2001-2006), the sustainable development stage (2007-2014), and the rapid development and fluctuation stage (2015-2021). And the paper summarizes the unique characteristics of each stage, such as publication themes, content, and trends.Furthermore, the thesis provides an overview of the research progress made in the framework, evaluation, influencing factors, and construction management of community resilience. Based on an understanding of the conceptual framework, core content, and related framework of community resilience, the paper proposes a basic logical framework for community resilience research in the field of sustainable science. Finally, the thesis emphasizes the need to focus on constructing a multidisciplinary integration method system, multi-field integration, and emphasizing local practice in China. This will strengthen and deepen research on community resilience in the future.

导出引用

王菲, 陈佳. 近20年国内外社区恢复力研究脉络、进展与逻辑框架[J]. 人文地理. 2024, 39(2): 31-43 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2024.02.004

WANG Fei, CHEN Jia. EVOLUTION, PROGRESS AND LOGICAL FRAMEWORK OF COMMUNITY RESILIENCE AT HOME AND ABROAD FOR 20 YEARS[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2024, 39(2): 31-43 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2024.02.004

中图分类号： K901

参考文献

[1] 刘彦随.现代人地关系与人地系统科学[J].地理科学,2020,40(8):1221-1234.[Liu Yansui. Modern human-earth relationship and human-earth system science[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2020, 40(8):1221-1234.]
[2] Rolf P, Foster K A, Cowell M. Resilience and regions:building un-derstanding of the metaphor[J]. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society, 2010,3(1):71-84.
[3] 葛全胜,王芳,陈泮勤,等.全球变化研究进展和趋势[J].地球科学进展,2007,22(4):417-427.[Ge Quansheng, Wang Fang, Chen Panqin, et al. Review on global change research[J]. Advances in Earth Sci-ence, 2007,22(4):417-427.]
[4] Gallopín G C. Linkages between vulnerability, resilience, and adap-tive capacity[J]. Global Environmental Change, 2006,16(3):293-303.
[5] 刘焱序,傅伯杰,王帅,等.空间恢复力理论支持下的人地系统动态研究进展[J].地理学报,2020,75(5):891-903.[Liu Yanxu, Fu Bojie, Wang Shuai, et al. Research progress of human-earth system dynam-ics based on spatial resilience theory[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2020,75(5):891-903.]
[6] 陈德亮,秦大河,效存德,等.气候恢复力及其在极端天气气候灾害管理中的应用[J].气候变化研究进展,2019,15(2):167-177.[Chen Deliang, Qin Dahe, Xiao Cunde, et al. Climate resilience and its im-plications for China[J]. Climate Change Research, 2019,15(2):167-177.]
[7] Pain R, Barke M, Gough J, et al. Introducing Social Geographies[M]. London:Routledge, 2001:69-73.
[8] 郭永锐,张捷.社区恢复力研究进展及其地理学研究议题[J].地理科学进展,2015,34(1):100-109.[Guo Yongrui, Zhang Jie. Research progress and themes of geography on community resilience[J]. Prog-ress in Geography, 2015,34(1):100-109.]
[9]
[9] The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Cli-mate Change 2022:Impacts, Adaptation, and Vulnerability[R]. Cam-bridge, UK:Cambridge University Press, 2022. https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/wg2/.
[10] 韩文维,陈佳,袁倩文,等.恢复力视角下秦岭贫困山区乡村振兴潜力研究[J].自然资源学报,2021,36(10):2571-2584.[Han Wenwei, Chen Jia, Yuan Qianwen, et al. Rural revitalization potential and in-fluencing factors in poor mountainous areas of Qinling Mountains from the perspective of resilience[J]. Journal of Natural Resources, 2021,36(10):2571-2584.]
[11] Ayyoob S. A critical review of selected tools for assessing commu-nity resilience[J]. Ecological Indicators, 2016,69:629-647.
[12] Frankenberger T, Mueller M, Spangler T, et al. Community Resil-ience:Conceptual Framework and Measurement Feed the Future Learning Agenda[M]. Rockville, MD:Westat, 2013.
[13] Maru Y T, Smith M S, Sparrow A, et al. A linked vulnerability and resilience framework for adaptation pathways in remote disadvan-taged communities[J]. Global Environmental Change, 2014,28:337-350.
[14] Nguyen H L, Akerkar R. Modelling, measuring, and visualising community resilience:A systematic review[J]. Sustainability, 2020, 12(19):7896.
[15] Cutter S L, Barnes L, Berry M, et al. A place-based model for un-derstanding community resilience to natural disasters[J]. Global En-vironmental Change, 2008,18(4):598-606.
[16] Cafer A, Green J, Goreham G. A community resilience framework for community development practitioners building equity and adap-tive capacity[J]. Community Development, 2019,50(2):201-216.
[17] Holling C S. Resilience and stability of ecological systems[J]. An-nual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 1973,4(1):1-23.
[18] 汪辉,徐蕴雪,卢思琪,等.恢复力,弹性或韧性?——社会-生态系统及其相关研究领域中"Resilience"一词翻译之辨析[J].国际城市规划, 2017,32(4):29-39.[Wang Hui, Xu Yunxue, Lu Siqi, et al. A comparative study of chinese translation of resilience terminology in socio-ecological system and its related research field[J]. Urban Planning International, 2017,32(4):29-39.]
[19] Carpenter S, Walker B, Anderies J M, et al. From metaphor to mea-surement:Resilience of what to what?[J]. Ecosystems, 2001,4(8):765-781.
[20] Adger W N. Social and ecological resilience:Are they related?[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2000,24(3):347-364.
[21] Brenkert A L, Malone E L. Modeling vulnerability and resilience to climate change:A case study of India and Indian states[J]. Climatic Change, 2005,72(1):57-102.
[22] 孙晶,王俊,杨新军.社会-生态系统恢复力研究综述[J].生态学报, 2007(12):5371-5381.[Sun Jing, Wang Jun, Yang Xinjun. An over view on the resilience of social-ecological systems[J]. Acta Ecologica Si-nica, 2007(12):5371-5381.]
[23] Gunderson L H, Holling C S. Panarchy:Understanding Transforma-tions in Human and Natural Systems[M]. Washington, D.C:Island Press, 2002:25-63.
[24] Walker B, Holling C S, Carpenter S R, et al. Resilience, adaptabil-ity and transformability in social-ecological systems[J]. Ecology and Society, 2004,9(2):5-12.
[25] Berkes F, Folke C. Linking Social and Ecological Systems:Man-agement Practices and Social Mechanisms for Building Resilience[M]. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 2000:355-359.
[26] Walker B, Carpenter S, Anderies J, et al. Resilience management in social-ecological systems:A working hypothesis for aparticipatory approach[J]. Conservation Ecology, 2002,6(1):14.
[27] Adger W N. Vulnerability[J]. Global Environmental Change, 2006, 16(3):268-281.
[28] Arbon P, Gebbie K, Cusack L, et al. Developing a model and tool to measure community disaster resilience:Final Report October 2012[R]. South Australia:Torrens Resilience Institute, 2012.
[29] Mulligan M, Steele W, Rickards L, et al. Keywords in planning:what do we mean by'community resilience'?[J]. International Plan-ning Studies, 2016,21(4):348-361.
[30] Elkington J. Partnerships from cannibals with forks:the triple bot-tom line of 21st-century business[J]. Environmental Quality Man-agement, 1998,8(1):37-51.
[31] 陈悦,陈超美,刘则渊,等.CiteSpace知识图谱的方法论功能[J].科学学研究,2015,33(2):242-253.[Chen Yue, Chen Chaomei, Liu Zeyuan, et al. The methodology function of Cite Space mapping knowledge domains[J]. Studies in Science of Science, 2015,33(2):242-253.]
[32] Anderies J M, Folke C, Walker B, et al. Aligning key concepts for global change policy:Robustness, resilience, and sustainability[J]. Ecology and Society, 2013,18(2):8. http://dx.doi.org/10.5751/ES-05178-180208.
[33] Cox R S, Perry K M E. Like a fish out of water:Reconsidering di-saster recovery and the role of place and social capital in commu-nity disaster resilience[J]. Am J Community Psychol, 2011,48:395-411.
[34] Harte E W, Childs I R W, Hastings P A. Imizamo Yethu:A case study of community resilience to fire hazard in an informal settle-ment Cape Town, South Africa[J]. Geographical Research, 2009, 47(2):142-154.
[35] Oktari R S, Shiwaku K, Munadi K, et al. Enhancing community re-silience towards disaster:The contributing factors of schoolcommunity collaborative network in the tsunami affected area in Aceh[J]. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2018,29:3-12.
[36] Burton C G. A validation of metrics for community resilience to natural hazards and disasters using the recovery from Hurricane Ka-trina as a case study[J]. Annals of the Association of American Ge-ographers, 2015,105(1):67-86.
[37] Cutter S L, Ash K D, Emrich C T. The geographies of community disaster resilience[J]. Global Environmental Change, 2014, 29:65-77.
[38] Poland B, Gloger A, Morgan G T, et al. A connected community ap-proach:Citizens and formal institutions working together to build community-centred resilience[J]. International Journal of Environ-mental Research and Public Health, 2021, 18(19):10175. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34639478/.
[39] Berkes F, Ross H. Panarchy and community resilience:Sustainabil-ity science and policy implications[J]. Environmental Science Policy, 2016,61:185-193.
[40] Wilson G A. Community resilience, policy corridors and the policy challenge[J]. Land Use Policy, 2013,31:298-310.
[41] 王群,陆林,杨兴柱.旅游地社区恢复力认知测度与影响因子分析:以千岛湖为例[J].人文地理,2017,32(5):139-146.[Wang Qun, Lu Lin, Yang Xingzhu. Cognition measurement and influence analysis of tourism community resilience:A case study of Qiandao Lake[J]. Human Geography, 2017,32(5):139-146.]
[42] 郭永锐,张捷,张玉玲.旅游目的地社区恢复力的影响因素及其作用机制[J].地理研究,2018,37(1):133-144.[Guo Yongrui, Zhang Jie, Zhang Yuling. Influencing factors and mechanism of community re-silience in tourism destinations[J]. Geographical Research, 2018,37(1):133-144.]
[43] 杨涛,陈海,刘迪,等.黄土丘陵沟壑区乡村社区恢复力时空演变及影响因素研究:以陕西省米脂县高渠乡为例[J].地理科学进展, 2021,40(2):245-256.[Yang Tao, Chen Hai, Liu Di, et al. Spatiotem-poral change of rural community resilience in loess hilly-gully re-gion and influencing factors:A case study of Gaoqu Township in Mizhi county, Shannxi province[J]. Progress in Geography, 2021, 40(2):245-256.]
[44] 陈佳,杨新军,尹莎.农户贫困恢复力测度、影响效应及对策研究:基于农户家庭结构的视角[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2016,26(1):150-157.[Chen Jia, Yang Xinjun, Yin Sha. Measures of the resil-ience, effect and countermeasures of household poverty:The per-spective of household structure[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 2016,26(1):150-157.]
[45] 何艳冰,张娟,乔旭宁,等.精准扶贫背景下贫困山区农户生计恢复力研究:以河南秦巴山片区为例[J].干旱区资源与环境,2020, 34(9):53-59.[He Yanbin, Zhang Juan, Qiao Xunin, et al. Rural households'livelihood resilience in poor mountainous areas under the background of targeted poverty alleviation:A case study of Qinba mountain areas in Henan province[J]. Journal of Arid Land Re-sources and Environment, 2020,34(9):53-59.]
[46] 年四锋,张捷,张宏磊,等.基于危机响应的旅游地社区参与研究:以汶川地震后大九寨环线区域为例[J].地理科学进展,2019,38(8):1227-1239.[Nian Sifeng, Zhang Jie, Zhang Honglei, et al. Tourism community participation of tourism areas based on a crisis response perspective:Taking the Dajiuzhai region after the Wenchuan Earth-quake as an example[J]. Progress in Geography, 2019,38(8):1227-1239.]
[47] Lew A A,何景明,高彬.尺度、变化和恢复力:社区旅游规划的视角[J].资源科学,2016,38(9):1635-1642.[Lew A A, He Jingming, Gao Bin. Scale, change and resilience in community tourism plan-ning[J]. Resources Science, 2016,38(9):1635-1642.]
[48] Kruse S, Abeling T, Deeming H, et al. Conceptualizing community resilience to natural hazards-the emBRACE framework[J]. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2017,17(12):2321-2333.
[49] Almutairi A, Mourshed M, Ameen R F M. Coastal community resil-ience frameworks for disaster risk management[J]. Natural Haz-ards, 2020,101(2):595-630.
[50] UNISDR. Disaster Preparedness for Effective Response:Guidance and Indicator Package for Implementing Priority Five of the Hyogo Framework[R]. United Nations, New York:Geneva, 2008.
[51] Haggag M, Yosri A, El-Dakhakhni W, et al. Interpretable data-driven model for climate-induced disaster damage prediction:The first step in community resilience planning[J]. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2022,73(1):102884. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijdrr. 2022.102884.
[52] Zolli A, Healy A M. Resilience:Why Things Bounce Back[M]. Londen:Hachette Publishing Group, 2012:88-110.
[53] 葛怡,史培军,徐伟,等.恢复力研究的新进展与评述[J].灾害学, 2010,25(3):119-124,129.[Ge Yi, Shi Peijun, Xu Wei, et al. Review and development of restoring force research[J]. Journal of Catastro-phology, 2010,25(3):119-124,129.]
[54] Curt C, Tacnet J M. Resilience of critical infrastructures:Review and analysis of current approaches[J]. Risk Analysis, 2018,38(11):2441-2458.
[55] Rachunok B, Bennett J, Flage R, et al. A path forward for leverag-ing social media to improve the study of community resilience[J]. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2021,59:102236. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.IJDRR.2021.102236.
[56] Pfefferbaum R L, Pfefferbaum B, Van H R L, et al. The communi-ties advancing resilience toolkit (CART)[J]. Journal of Public Health Management and Practice, 2013,19(3):250-258.
[57] Moreno J, Lara A, Torres M. Community resilience in response to the 2010 tsunami in Chile:The survival of a small-scale fishing community[J]. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2019,33:376-384.
[58] Simonovic S P, Peck A. Dynamic resilience to climate change caused natural disasters in coastal megacities quantification frame-work[J]. British Journal of Environment and Climate Change, 2013, 3(3):378-401.
[59] Yoon D K, Kang J E, Brody S D. A measurement of community di-saster resilience in Korea[J]. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 2016,59(3):436-460.
[60] Sherrieb K, Norris F H, Galea S. Measuring capacities for commu-nity resilience[J]. Social Indicators Research, 2010,99(2):227-247.
[61] Fox-Lent C, Bates M E, Linkov I. A matrix approach to community resilience assessment:An illustrative case at Rockaway Peninsula[J]. Environment Systems and Decisions, 2015,35(2):209-218.
[62] Jordan E, Javernick-Will A. Indicators of community recovery:Content analysis and Delphi approach[J]. Natural Hazards Review, 2013,14(1):21-28.
[63] Rahman M S, Kausel T. Coastal community resilience to tsunami:A study on planning capacity and social capacity, Dichato, Chile[J]. IOSR Journal of Humanities and Social Science, 2013,12(6):55-63.
[64] Longstaff P H, Armstrong N J, Perrin K, Parker W M, et al. Build-ing resilient communities:A preliminary framework for assessment[J]. Homeland Security Affairs, 2010, 6. https://www.hsaj.org/ar-ticles/81.
[65] d'Armengol L, Castillo M P, Ruiz-Mallén I, et al. A systematic re-view of co-managed small-scale fisheries:Social diversity and adaptive management improve outcomes[J]. Global Environmental Change, 2018,52:212-225.
[66] Bubeck P, Thieken A H. What helps people recover from floods?In-sights from a survey among flood-affected residents in Germany[J]. Regional Environmental Change, 2018,18(1):287-296.
[67] Bruneau M, Chang S E, Eguchi R T, et al. A framework to quantita-tively assess and enhance the seismic resilience of communities[J]. Earthquake Spectra, 2003,19(4):733-752.
[68] Sutton-Grier A E, Wowk K, Bamford H. Future of our coasts:The potential for natural and hybrid infrastructure to enhance the resil-ience of our coastal communities, economies, and ecosystems[J]. Environmental Science Policy, 2015,51:137-148.
[69] Chang S E, McDaniels T L, Mikawoz J, et al. Infrastructure failure interdependencies in extreme events:Power outage consequences in the 1998 Ice Storm[J]. Natural Hazards, 2007,41(2):337-358.
[70] Filimonau V, Coteau D D. Tourism resilience in the context of inte-grated destination and disaster management (DM2)[J]. International Journal of Tourism Research, 2020,22(2):202-222.
[71] Qasim S, Qasim M, Shrestha R P, et al. Community resilience to flood hazards in Khyber Pukhthunkhwa province of Pakistan[J]. In-ternational Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2016,18:100-106.
[72] 唐红林,陈佳,石若晗,等.乡村类型视角下干旱区社区恢复力评估及优化策略:以民勤绿洲为例[J].中国沙漠,2022,42(4):199-208.[Tang Honglin, Chen Jia, Shi Ruohan, et al. Evaluation and optimi-zation strategy of community resilience under perspective of rural types in arid areas:A case study in the Minqin Oasis in Gansu, China[J]. Journal of Desert Research, 2022,42(4):199-208.]
[73] 杨莹,林琳,钟志平,等.基于应对公共健康危害的广州社区恢复力评价及空间分异[J].地理学报,2019,74(2):266-284.[Yang Ying, Lin Lin, Zhong Zhiping, et al. Comprehensive evaluation and spa-tial differentiation of community resilience in Guangzhou based on response of the city to public health hazards[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2019,74(2):266-284.]