城乡迁移背景下&ldquo;消极&rdquo;地方感研究&mdash;&mdash;以广州市棠下村为例

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2017.03.004

PDF(2040 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2017, Vol. 32 ›› Issue (3) : 27-35. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2017.03.004

文化

城乡迁移背景下“消极”地方感研究——以广州市棠下村为例

李如铁¹, 朱竑¹, 唐蕾²

作者信息 +

THE RESEARCH ON THE NEGATIVE SENSE OF PLACE IN THE BACKGROUND OF URBAN-RURAL MIGRATION: BASED ON THE URBAN VILLAGE TANGXIA, TIANHE DISTRICT, GUANGZHOU

LI Ru-tie¹, ZHU Hong¹, TANG Lei²

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

在对国内外地方感的各种概念辨析梳理的基础上，结合中国本土文化特点及实例研究对地方感给予了重新解读，提出"消极地方感"的概念。研究指出：①地方感是人对地方的一种综合性情感体验，有积极的，也有消极的，而地方依恋、地方依赖、地方认同、地方疏远、地方厌恶、地方恐惧等均属于地方感的某一类表现形式；②城中村被周边繁华的都市环境围绕，具有明显的空间分异特征，其居住环境繁杂、邻里关系淡薄，城中村移民缺少地方情感的依附，形成一种"无根式"的消极地方感；③移民在无法融入迁入地的同时，由于无法接受迁出地的变迁与衰退，而在心中形成另一种"失根式"的乡村消极地方感。

Abstract

There are plenty of Human's emotions to places. Sometimes they are strong and positive, but for particular places, sometimes they may be oppressive and restrictive. Based on the characteristics of Chinese native culture, the author re-conceptualize the sense of place by reviewing the relevant literatures at home and abroad, the author argues that: 1) the sense of place may have both positive affect and negative affect in Chinese version, and the place attachment, place identity, place dependent, place alienation, place detachment and place of fear are the specific forms of sense of place; 2)In-depth interviews with 33 migrants who live in the urban village in Canton exposes the fact that there are negative senses of place both on the urban where they are living and the villages where they came from; 3)The negative sense of place may exist in any other place and we are here call more attention to the negative sense of place. The negative sense of place has abundant conceptual connotations and empirical analysis, it has far-reaching profound and lasting effect to human's lives. The research has made a new conclusion about the human's emotion to place, especially for the sense of place and its relationships to the place identity, place dependence and place attachment after a deep literatures preview. The research may improve the theoretical framework of place. These have bring a new idea to the research of China's social problem and enlarge the research of culture geography.Documentary method, field research, depth interview are the main methods we used here.

导出引用

李如铁, 朱竑, 唐蕾. 城乡迁移背景下“消极”地方感研究——以广州市棠下村为例[J]. 人文地理. 2017, 32(3): 27-35 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2017.03.004

LI Ru-tie, ZHU Hong, TANG Lei. THE RESEARCH ON THE NEGATIVE SENSE OF PLACE IN THE BACKGROUND OF URBAN-RURAL MIGRATION: BASED ON THE URBAN VILLAGE TANGXIA, TIANHE DISTRICT, GUANGZHOU[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2017, 32(3): 27-35 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2017.03.004

中图分类号： C912.8

参考文献

[1] 唐晓峰. 还地理学一份人情[J]. 读书,2002,24(11):59-64. [Tang Xiaofeng. Return a human feeling to geography[J]. Reading, 2002, 24(11):59-64.]

[2] 薛婧,黄希庭.怀旧心理研究述评[J].心理科学进展,2011,19(4):608-616. [Xue Jing, Huang Xiting. The psychological research of nostalgia[J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2011,19(4):608-616.]

[3] 唐文跃.地方感研究进展及研究框架[J].旅游学刊,2007,22(11):70-77. [Tang Wenyue. A study progress of sense of locality and research framework[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2007,22(11):70-77.]

[4] Hidalgo M C, Bernardo H. Place attachment: Conceptual and empirical questions[J]. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2001,21(2): 273-281.

[5] 朱竑,刘博.地方感、地方依恋与地方认同等概念的辨析及研究启示[J].华南师范大学学报(自然科学版),2011,56(1):1-8. [Zhu Hong, Liu Bo. Concepts analysis and research implications: Sense of place, place attachment and place identity[J]. Journal of South China Normal University(Natural Science Edition), 2011,56(1):1-8.]

[6] Susan H. Ten Geographic Ideas That Changed the World[M]. New Brunswich: Rutgers University Press,1997:1.

[7] Russell J A. A circumplex model of affect[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1980,39(10):1161-1178.

[8] Diener E, Iran-Nejad A. The relationship in experience between various types of affect[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1986,50(5):1031-1038.

[9] Watson D, Clark L. Development and validation of brief measures of positive and negative affect: The PANAS scales[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1988,54(6):1063-1070.

[10] Lynne C M. Beyond house and haven: Toward a revisioning of emotional relationships with places[J]. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2003,23(1):47-61.

[11] Relph E. Place and Placeless[M]. London: Pion,1976:9.

[12] Tuan Y F. Topophilia: A Study of Environmental Perception, Attitudes and Values[M]. New York: Columbia University Press, 1974: 23.

[13] 段义孚,著.无边的恐惧[M].徐文宁,译.北京:北京大学出版社, 2011:1. [Tuan Y F. Landscapes of Fear[M]. Xu Wenning, trans. Beijing: Peking University Press, 2011:1.]

[14] R J 约翰斯顿.人文地理学词典[M].柴彦威,等译. 北京:商务印书馆,2004:637. [Johnston R J. The Dictionary of Human Geography[M]. Chai Yanwei, et al, trans. Beijing: The Commercial Press, 2004:637.]

[15] Jorgensen B S, Stedman R C. A comparative analysis of predictors of sense of place dimensions: Attachment to, dependence on, and identification with lakeshore properties[J]. Journal of Environmental Management, 2006,79(3):316-327.

[16] 龙人.诗人眼里的地方感[J].语文教学通讯,1992(21):55. [Longren. The sense of place in peot's eyes[J]. Language Teaching Communication, 1992(21):55.]

[17] 张焕君". 地方感"与"大晋学"研究的推进——首届"晋学与区域文化"学术研讨会概述[J].山西师范大学学报(社会科学版),2013, 40(6):159-160. [Zhang Huanjun. The promotion of the study on the sense of place and ‘Dajinxue’[J]. Journal of Shanxi Normal University( Social Science Edition), 2013,40(6):159-160.]

[18] Tuan Y F. Space and place: Humanistic perspective[M]//Gale S, Olsson G. Philosophy in Geography. Netherlands: Springer, 1979: 387-427.

[19] Steele F. The Sense of Place[M].Boston: CBI Publishing,1981:2．

[20] Shamai S. Sense of place: An empirical measurement[J]. Geoforum, 1991,22(3):347-358.

[21] Ryden K C. Mapping the Invisible Landscape: Folklore, Writing,and the Sense of Place[M]. Iowa:University of Iowa Press, 1993:3.

[22] Gesler W M. Therapeutic landscapes: Medical issues in light of new cultural geography[J]. Social Science and Medicin, 1992,34 (7):735-746.

[23] Foote K E, Azaryahu M. Sense of place[J]. International Encyclopedia of Human Geography, 2009,8:96-100.

[24] Cresswell T. Place: An Introduction[M]. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, 2014:169-177.

[25] Ulrich R S. Natural versus urban scenes: Some psychophysiological effects[J]. Environment and Behavior, 1981,13(5):523-556.

[26] Kaplan R, Kaplan S. The Experience of Nature: A Psychological Perspective[M]. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989:89.

[27] Williams A. Therapeutic landscapes in holistic medicine[J]. Social Science and Medicine,1998,46(9):1193-1203.

[28] 廖娟.国内旅游者地方感研究文献述评[J].商业时代,2014,33(22): 125-126. [Liao Juan. Literature preview on the research on the tourist sense of place in China[J]. Commercial Times, 2014,33(22):125-126.]

[29] Jorgensen B S, Stedman R C. A comparative analysis of predictors of sense of place dimensions: Attachment to, dependence on, and identification with lakeshore properties[J]. Journal of Environmental Management, 2006,79(3):316-327.

[30] 王兴中,刘永刚. 人文地理学研究方法论的进展与"文化转向"以来的流派[J]. 人文地理,2007,22(3):1-11.[Wang Xingzhong, Liu Yonggang. The progress of the research methodology on human geography and the schools since "cultural turn"[J]. Human Geography, 2007,22(3):1-11.]

[31] Setha M L. Symbolic ties that bind: Place attachment in the plaza[M]//Altman I, Low S M. Place Attachment. New York: Plenum Press, 1992:165-186.

[32] Jackson J B. A Sense of Place, A Sense of Time[M]. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1994:5.

[33] 杨念群". 地方性知识"、"地方感"与"跨区域研究"的前景[J].中国社会史研究,2004,24(6):119-126. [Yang Nianqun. The prospect of locality, sense of place and the cross region research[J]. Research of Chinese Social History, 2004,24(6):119-126.]

[34] 张中华,张沛,王兴中.地方理论应用社区研究的思考——以阳朔西街旅游社区为例[J]. 地理科学,2009,29(2):141-146. [Zhang Zhonghua, Zhang Pei, Wang Xingzhong. Application of place theory on communities: A case study of the west street tourism community at Yangshuo[J]. Scientia Geographica Cinica, 2009,29(2):141-146.]

[35] 江莉莉.21 世纪的中国与中国地理学:一场文化地理革命?[J].人文地理,2013,28(1):1-9. [Lily K. China and geography in the 21st century: A cultural (geographic) revolution?[J]. Human Geogrophy, 2013,28(1):1-9.]

[36] Zube E H, Sell J L, Taylor J G. Landscape perception: Research, application and theory[J]. Landscape Planning, 1982,9(1):1-33.

[37] Hummon D M. Community attachment[M]//Altman I, Low S M. Place Attachment. New York: Springer, 1992: 253-278.

[38] McCreanor T, Penney L, Jensen V, et al. ‘This is like my comfort zone’: Senses of place and belonging within Oruāmo/Beachhaven, New Zealand[J]. New Zealand Geographer, 2006,62(3):196-207.

[39] Howard F. Healthy places: Exploring the evidence[J]. The American Journal of Public Health, 2003,93(9):1451-1456.

[40] Wirth L. Urbanism as a way of life[J]. American Journal of Sociology, 1938,44(1):1-24.

[41] Moore J. Placing home in context[J]. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2000,20(3):207-217.

[42] Anthony K H. Bitter homes and gardens: The meanings of home to families of divorce[J]. Journal of Architectural and Planning Research, 1997,14(1):1-19.

[43] McDowell L. Gender, Identity and Place: Understanding Feminist Geographies[M]. Minnesota: University of Minnesota Press, 1999: 2-10.

[44] Lennon J J, Foley M. Interpretation of the unimaginable: The US Holocaust memorial museum, Washington, DC, and "dark tourism"[J]. Journal of Travel Research, 1999,38(1):46-50.

[45] Hartig K V, Dunn K M. Roadside memorials: Interpreting new deathscapes in Newcastle, New South Wales[J]. Australian Geographical Studies,1998,36(1):5-20.

[46] 张中华.地方理论——迈向"人地"居住环境科学体系建构研究的广义思考[J].发展研究,2012,29(7):47-55. [Zhang Zhonghua. Place theory: A generalized thinking of the scientific construction of living condition toward ‘human and place’[J]. Development Research, 2012,29(7):47-55.]

[47] 仝德,冯长春.国内外城中村研究进展及展望[J].人文地理,2009,24 (6):29-35. [Tong De, Feng Changchun. Review and progress of the research on urban villages[J]. Human Geography, 2009,24(6):29-35.]

[48] 林道良,蔡维朗.棠下村志[M].北京:中华书局,2003:13. [Lin Daoliang, Cai Weilang. Village Annals of Tang Xia[M]. Peking: Zhonghua Book Company, 2003:13.]

[49] 张胜波,陈枫.棠下变迁折射广州城市化梦想[N].南方日报,2009-07-25(A08). [Zhang Shengbo, Chen Feng. The Tangxia's changing reflects the dream of the urbanization, Guangzhou[N]. Nanfang Daily, 2009-07-25(A08).]

[50] 李培林. 透视"城中村"——我研究"村落终结"的方法[J].思想战线,2004,30(1):21-26. [Li Peilin. Villages in urban area: My approaches to the ending of villages[J]. Thinking, 2004,30(1):21-26.]

[51] 李培林.从"农民的终结"到"村落的终结"[J].传承,2012,22(15):84-85. [Li Peilin. From ‘the ending of farmer’ to ‘the ending of village’[J]. Inheritance & Innovation, 2012,22(15):84-85.]

[52] 李怀. 城市空间扩展中失地农民"种楼"的理性与维权——从"握手楼"景观到农民消极应对"城中村"改造的个案观察[J]. 西北师大学报(社会科学版),2010,47(5):9-15. [Li Huai. Lost land peasants' rationality of Building Planting and their right protection during urban space expansion[J]. Journal of Northwest Normal University (Social Sciences), 2010,47(5):9-15.]

[53] McCreanor T, Penney L, Jensen V, et al. ‘This is like my comfort zone’: Senses of place and belonging within Oruāmo/Beachhaven, New Zealand[J]. New Zealand Geographer, 2006,62(3):196-207.

[54] Lewicka M. On the varieties of people's relationships with places Hummon's typology revisited[J]. Environment and Behavior, 2011, 43(5):676-709.

[55] Soini K, Vaarala H, Pouta E. Residents' sense of place and landscape perceptions at the rural-urban interface[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2012,104(1):124-134.

[56] 单菁菁.居住空间分异及贫困阶层聚居的影响与对策[J].现代城市研究,2011,26(10):19-23. [Shan Jingjing. The influence and countermeasure of residential space differentiation and poverty concentration[J]. Modern Urban Research, 2011,26(10):19-23.]

[57] 余佳,丁金宏.大都市居住空间分异及其应对策略[J].华东师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2007,39(1):67-71. [Yu Jia, Ding Jinhong. Residential spatial differentiations in a metropolis and their solutions[J]. Journal of East China Normal University ( Philosophy and Social Sciences), 2007,39(1):67-71.]

[58] 袁振龙.社区认同与社区治安——从社会资本理论视角出发的实证研究[J].中国人民公安大学学报(社会科学版),2010,26(4):110-116. [Yuan Zhenglong. Community identity and public security: An empirical study on the view of social capital theory[J]. Journal of Chinese People's Public Security University ( Social Sciences Edition), 2010,26(4):110-116.]

[59] 余建辉,张文忠,王岱,等.基于居民视角的居住环境安全性研究进展[J].地理科学进展,2011,30(6):699-675. [Yu Jianhui, Zhang Wenzhong, Wang Dai, et al. Living environment safety based on the residents' perception: A review[J]. Progress in Geography, 2011,30 (6):699-675.]

[60] 刘博,朱竑.新创民俗节庆与地方认同建构——以广府庙会为例[J].地理科学进展,2014,33(4):574-583. [Liu Bo, Zhu Hong. Construction of place identity and created folk festival: A case study of ‘Yuexiu Temple Fair’ in Canton[J]. Progress in Geography, 2014,33 (4):574-583.]

[61] 张立璞,靳颖姝,王志海,等.公园门上挂非本村村民不准入内牌子[N]. 南方都市报,2011-07-22(GA07). [Zhang Lipu, Jin Yinshu, Wang Zhihai, et al. The notice ‘No entrance for the migrant’ on the gate of the park[N]. Nanfang Metropolis Daily, 2011-07-22(GA07).]

[62] 范可.信任、认同与"他者":族群和民族省思[J].广西民族大学学报 (哲学社会科学版),2013,35(6):44-52. [Fan Ke. Trust, identity and others: Introspection ethnicity and nationality[J]. Journey of Guangxi University for Nationality (Phylosophy and Social Science Edition), 2013,35(6):44-52.]

[63] Liu Y T, He S J, Wu F L, et al. Urban villages under China's rapid urbanization: Unregulated assets and transitional neighbourhoods[J]. Habitat International, 2010,34(2):135-144.

[64] Wu F L. Neighborhood attachment, social participation, and willingness to stay in China's low-income communities[J]. Urban Affairs Review, 2012,48(4):547-570.

[65] 符晓波.中国每天消失100 个村庄[N/OL].(2012-12-26)[2015-01-01].http://news.jxgdw.com/jszt/zlq/1959965.html. [FuXiaobo.Thereare 100 Villages which disappear every day in China[N/OL].(2012-12-26)[2015-01-01].http://news.jxgdw.com/jszt/zlq/1959965.html.]