旅游减贫与旅游再贫困:旅游发展中不同土地利用方式对贫困人口的影响

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2017.04.017

PDF(4138 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2017, Vol. 32 ›› Issue (4) : 121-128,114. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2017.04.017

旅游

旅游减贫与旅游再贫困:旅游发展中不同土地利用方式对贫困人口的影响

罗鲜荣^1,2, 王玉强³, 保继刚^1,2

作者信息 +

TOURISM REDUCING POVERTY AND TOURISM RE-IMPOVERISHMENT:EXAMINING THE IMPACTS OF DIFFERENT LAND USES IN TOURISM ON THE POOR

LUO Xian-rong^1,2, WANG Yu-qiang³, BAO Ji-gang^1,2

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

旅游发展能否真正减贫以及如何实现减贫应是当前旅游减贫大背景下备受讨论的焦点，并受到了国内外学术界积极关注。然纵观现有研究，对旅游减贫效果的实证探讨及细致剖析尚十分缺乏。本文选取旅游发展中对土地资源的利用作为研究视角，探讨这一过程对贫困人口生存状态的影响。研究以三亚亚龙湾度假区发展对周边两个村庄的土地使用（征用、租用）为例，采用多维贫困概念，探讨旅游发展给两村村民在收入、居住条件、就业及生产方式以及话语权等带来的影响。研究提出了旅游再贫困的概念，意在说明旅游发展在使贫困人口短暂富裕后再次陷入贫困状态的发展现象，是旅游发展之于贫困人口负面影响的一种表征。

Abstract

Whether tourism development can really reduce poverty and how this could happen have been the point for discussion in the background of reducing poverty through tourism national wide. And these issues have also been actively attained by both the domestic and international academia. Yet when we review the existing literature, it is found that there has been rare empirical studies or in-depth analysis of such issues. Therefore in this study, we particularly concern about the land use in tourism development and aims to examine how tourism would impact on the living situations of the poor during the process. The study was conducted in two villages around Sanya Yalong Bay Tourism Resort. We made the land uses (in two different ways respectively as land recruitment and land rent) caused by tourism development of the resort in the two villages as our cases. A conceptualization of poverty with multiple dimensions was employed in the study. In specific, we investigated the impacts of the land uses in the process of local tourism development on the villagers' living conditions like income, housing situations, employment and means of production, and discourse power. In this study, we proposed the concept of "tourism re-impoverishment" to illustrate the phenomenon that tourism development makes the poor to become rich yet just after a short time fall into poverty again. This is also one of the representations of the negative impacts produced by tourism development on the poor.

导出引用

罗鲜荣, 王玉强, 保继刚. 旅游减贫与旅游再贫困:旅游发展中不同土地利用方式对贫困人口的影响[J]. 人文地理. 2017, 32(4): 121-128,114 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2017.04.017

LUO Xian-rong, WANG Yu-qiang, BAO Ji-gang. TOURISM REDUCING POVERTY AND TOURISM RE-IMPOVERISHMENT:EXAMINING THE IMPACTS OF DIFFERENT LAND USES IN TOURISM ON THE POOR[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2017, 32(4): 121-128,114 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2017.04.017

中图分类号： F590

参考文献

[1] Schilcher D. Growth versus equity:The continuum of pro-poor tourism and neoliberal governance[J]. Current Issue in Tourism, 2007,10(2/3):166-193.

[2] Scheyvens R. Exploring the tourism-poverty nexus[J]. Current Issue in Tourism, 2007,10(2/3):231-254.

[3] Spenceley A, Meyer D. Tourism and poverty reduction:Theory and practice in less economically developed countries[J]. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2012,20(3):297-317.

[4] Chok S, Macbeth J, Warren C. Tourism as a tool for poverty alleviation:A critical analysis of "pro-poor tourism" and implications for sustainability[J]. Current Issue in Tourism, 2007,10(2/3):144-165.

[5] 王亚娟.基于行动者中心的旅游减贫研究——以漓江杨堤-兴坪段为例[D].广州:中山大学,2013:16-27.[Wang Yajuan. Tourism and poverty reduction based on actor-centered approach:Cases study of Yangdi-Xingping in Li Revier[D]. Guangzhou:Sun Yat-sen University, 2013:16-27.]

[6] Scheyvens R, Russell M. Tourism and poverty alleviation in Fiji:Comparing the impacts of small-and large-scale tourism enterprises[J]. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2012,20(3):417-436.

[7] 李南洁,姜树辉.乡村旅游用地获取途径研究——基于保障农民土地权益的视角[J].安徽农业科学,2012,40(2):1189-1190.[Li Nanjie, Jiang Shuhui. Study on ways of land acquisitions for rural tourism[J]. Journal of Anhui Agricultural Science, 2012,40(2):1189-1190.]

[8] 梁明珠,王为.生态旅游区原著居民迁移和村落改造的难点与对策——以广东南昆山生态旅游区为例[J].经济地理,2004,4(4):553-555.[Liang Mingzhu, Wang wei. Difficulties and countermeasures of local resident transferring and village reutilization at an ecotourism site:A case study of Nankunshan ecotourism zone, Guangdong[J]. Economic Geography, 2004,24(4):553-555.]

[9] 罗曼,赵俊.关于海南省三亚市失地农民问题及应对策略[J].经济研究参考,2014(27):69-72.[Luo Man, Zhao Jun. The peasants in Sanya of Hainan province who lost their farmlands:Problems and strategies[J]. Review of Economic Research, 2014(27):69-72.]

[10] Sofield T, De Lacy T, Lipman G, et al. Sustainable Tourism-Eliminating Poverty:An overview[M]. Australia:Cooperative Research Centre for Sustainable Tourism, 2004.

[11] WTO-OMT. Tourism and poverty alleviation[R]. Madrid:WTOOMT, 2002:37-64.

[12] Roe D, Urquhart P. Pro-poor tourism:Harnessing the world's largest industry for the world's poor; turning the rhetoric into action for sustainable development and poverty reduction[M]//Bigg T (ed.) Survival for a Small Planet-The Sustainable Development Agenda. London:Earthscan, 2004:309-325.

[13] Meyer D. Pro-Poor tourism:From leakages to linkages. A conceptual framework for creating linkages between the accommodation sector and ‘poor’ neighbouring communities[J]. Current Issues in Tourism, 2007,10(6):558-583.

[14] Garrigós-Simón F J, Galdón-Salvador J L, Gil-Pechuán I. The economic sustainability of tourism growth through leakage calculation[J]. Tourism Economics, 2015,21(4):721-739.

[15] 刘俊,楼枫烨.旅游开发背景下世居少数民族社区边缘化——海南三亚六盘黎族安置区案例[J].旅游学刊,2010,25(9):44-50.[Liu Jun, Lou Fenghua. On the marginalization ethnic minority community under the backdrop of tourism development:A case of Liupan Li nationality settlement area, Sanya, Hainan[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2010,25(9):44-50.]

[16] Scheyvens R, Momsen J H. Tourism and poverty reduction:Issues for small island states[J]. Tourism Geographies, 2008,10(1):22-41.

[17] Deller S. Rural poverty, tourism and spatial heterogeneity[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2010,37(1):180-205.

[18] Truong V D, Hall M C, Garry T. Tourism and poverty alleviation:Perceptions and experiences of poor people in Sapa, Vietnam[J]. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2014,22(7):1071-1089.

[19] 周歆红.关注旅游扶贫的核心问题[J].旅游学刊,2002,17(1):17-21.[Zhou Xinhong. Concerning for the basic elements in "Tourismbased poverty elimination"[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2002,17(1):17-21.]

[20] Pritchard A, Morgan N. Constructing tourism landscapes:Gender, sexuality and space[J]. Tourism Geographies, 2000,2(2):115-139.

[21] Cheong S, Miller M. Power and tourism:A Foucauldian observation[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2000,27(2):371-390.

[22] Ryan C, Huang S. The role of tourism in China's transition:An introduction[M]//Ryan C, Huang S (eds). Tourism in China:Destinations, Planning and Experiences. Bristol:Channel View Publications, 2013:1-8.

[23] Xu H, Sofield T. Sustainability in Chinese development tourism policies[J]. Current Issues in Tourism, 2016,19(13):1337-1355.

[24] 李国平.基于政策实践的广东立体化旅游扶贫模式探析[J].旅游学刊,2004,19(5):56-60.[Li Guoping. An analysis of Guangdong's multi-directional pattern for poverty elimination by tourism based on policy practice[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2004,19(5):56-60.]

[25] 饶勇,黄福才,魏敏.旅游扶贫、社区参与和习俗惯例的变迁——博弈论视角下的可持续旅游扶贫模式研究[J].社会科学家,2008(3):88-92.[Rao Yong, Huang Fucai, Wei Min. Tourism-led poverty alleviation, community participation and the change of custom:Research on the sustainable mode of tourism-led poverty alleviation from the perspective of game theory[J]. Social Scientist, 2008(3):88-92.]

[26] 李佳,成升魁,马金刚,等.基于县域要素的三江源地区旅游扶贫模式探讨[J]. 资源科学,2009,31(11):1818-1824.[Li Jia, Cheng Shengkui, Ma Jingang, et, al. Investigating modes for poverty elimination through developing tourism resources at country levels in the Sanjiangyuan region[J]. Resources Science, 2009,31(11):1818-1824.

[27] 张伟,张建春,魏鸿雁.基于贫困人口发展的旅游扶贫效应评估——以安徽省铜锣寨风景区为例[J].旅游学刊,2005,20(5):43-49.[Zhang Wei, Zhang Jianchun, Wei Hongyan. Effect evaluation of tourism based poverty elimination on the poor's benefit:An example of Tongluozhai Resorts in Anhui province[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2005,20(5):43-49.]

[28] 李佳,钟林生,成升魁.民族贫困地区居民对旅游扶贫效应的感知和参与行为研究——以青海省三江源地区为例[J].旅游学刊, 2009,24(8):71-76.[Li Jia, Zhong Linsheng, Cheng Shengkui. Study on residents' perception and participational behavior on the effect of poverty-elimination by tourism in ethnic poverty-stricken areas[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2009,24(8):71-76.]

[29] 李燕琴.旅游扶贫中社区居民态度的分异与主要矛盾——以中俄边境村落室韦为例[J].地理研究,2011,30(11):2030-2042.[Li Yanqin. Differentiation and principal contradictions of residents' attitudes during pro-poor tourism development in poor rural communities:The case of Shiwei village on the Sino-Russian border[J]. Geographical Research, 2011,30(11):2030-2042.]

[30] Roehl W, Fesenmaier D. Tourism land use conflict in the United States[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 1987,14:471-485.

[31] Nelson F. Blessing or curse? The political economy of tourism development in Tanzania[J]. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2012,20(3):359-375.

[32] Scheyvens R, Russell M. Tourism, land tenure and poverty alleviation in Fiji[J]. Tourism Geographies, 2012,14(1):1-25.

[33] 徐琴,张亚蕾.论征地权过度使用的防止与中国征地制度改革——国际经验对中国征地制度改革的启示[J].中国土地科学, 2007,21(2):70-75.[Xu Qin, Zhang Yalei. Prevention of land requisition power abuse and reform of land requisition system in China[J]. China Land Science, 2007,21(2):70-75.]

[34] 齐睿,李珍贵,李梦洁.被征地农民安置制度探析[J].中国土地科学, 2014,28(3):39-45.[Qi Rui, Li Zhengui, Li Mengjie. Studies on resettlement institutions of land-expropriated peasants[J]. China Land Science, 2014,28(3):39-45.]

[35] 袁媛,许学强.国外综合贫困研究及对我国贫困地理研究的启示[J].世界地理研究,2008,17(2):121-128.[Yuan Yuan, Xu Xueqiang. Review on foreign geography of deprivation and its enlightenments to urban poverty studies in China[J]. World Regional Studies, 2008, 17(2):121-128.]

[36] 阿玛蒂亚·森,著.贫困与饥荒[M].王宇,王文玉,译.北京:商务印书馆,2001:61-69.[Amartya Sen. Poverty and Famines[M]. Wang Yu, Wang Wenyu, trans. Beijing:The Commercial Press, 2001:61-69.]

[37] 阿玛蒂亚·森,著.以自由看待发展[M].任赜,于真,译.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2012:9-28.[Amartya Sen. Development as Freedom[M]. Ren Ji, Yu Zhen, trans. Beijing:China Renmin University Press, 2001:9-28.]

[38] Betti G, Verma V. Fuzzy measures of the incidence of relative poverty and deprivation:A multi-dimensional perspective[J]. Statistical Methods and Applications, 2008,17:225-250.

[39] World Bank. World Development Report 2000/2001:Attacking Poverty[M]. New York:Oxford University Press, Inc., 2000:31-44.

[40] Lewis O. The culture of poverty[J]. Society, 1998,35(2):7-9.

[41] Geoffrey R, Sanjay K. Dependency and development in northern Thailand[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2010,37(4):947-968.

[42] 罗庆,李小建.国外农村贫困地理研究进展[J].经济地理,2014,34(6):1-8.[Luo Qing, Li Xiaojian. The research progress of foreign rural poverty geography[J]. Economic Geography, 2014,34(6):1-8.]

[43] 刘俊,保继刚.三亚亚龙湾度假区开发管理模式研究及启示[J].旅游学刊,2008,23(1):13-18.[Liu Jun, Bao Jigang. Study on the development and management model of Yalong Bay Holiday-making Resort, Sanya and its enlightenment[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2008,23(1):13-18.]