旅游体验质量评价述评:研究进展、要素解读与展望

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.01.019

PDF(3238 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2018, Vol. 33 ›› Issue (1) : 143-151. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.01.019

旅游

旅游体验质量评价述评:研究进展、要素解读与展望

孙小龙^1,2, 林璧属², 郜捷³

作者信息 +

A REVIEW ON THE QUALITY ASSESSMENT OF TOURISM EXPERIENCE: ADVANCES, ELEMENTS AND PROSPECTS

SUN Xiao-long^1,2, LIN Bi-shu², GAO Jie³

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

旅游体验是游客情感价值的累积。旅游体验质量评价是对游客心理累积情感的测度，科学、准确的核算游客体验质量是旅游景区、旅游企业等可持续发展及竞争力提升的重要保障。本文通过对1980—2015年发表于国内外旅游及管理领域重要期刊文献的梳理，从服务质量研究的历史、科学视角及与旅游融合的角度对旅游体验质量评价的研究进展、理论基础等进行系统的回顾，并从体验质量评价的理论视角、思路、特征、类型与准确性、可操作性、应用范围等中观层面，对所梳理出的4类国外主流质量评价范式进行旅游体验哲学视角下的解读、比较分析和总评，最后对该领域未来研究重点进行展望。

Abstract

Tourism experience is the accumulation of emotional value of tourists. The quality of tourism experience is the calculation for tourists' subjective perceived value. It is important to count the quality of tourism experience scientifically and accurately through various assessment models, and its results will also contribute to the sustainable development and competitiveness improvement of tourism destinations and enterprises. Based on the articles published between 1980-2015 in field of tourism and management research, this paper reviewed the advances and theory foundation of the assessment model for tourism experience quality, from the perspective of history, science. Firstly, this article traced the source of tourism experience in theory. As the basic concept of philosophical epistemology since the mid-19th century, experience (Das Erleben) is the core of Dilthey's life philosophy. Dilthey believed that the experience is the people's inner sense and the inner consciousness of the state of mind and the process. The quality of tourism experience is a reflection of the inner sense, the sum of the different stages for emotion in accumulation process. Secondly, this study reviewed the research histories from both domestic and foreign aspects. There were two development stages. Before the 1990s, the quality of tourism experience evaluation was still in start-up phase. Since the 1990s, the studies on the quality of tourism experience have entered a stage of rapid development. The evaluation of experience quality began to change gradually from a single product quality to comprehensive quality evaluation, which emphasizing on experience service process and tourists' value. Thirdly, this research made a comparative analysis and general comments between four kinds of assessment model based on theoretical basis, ideas, characteristics, type and accuracy, operability, applications, etc.

导出引用

孙小龙, 林璧属, 郜捷. 旅游体验质量评价述评:研究进展、要素解读与展望[J]. 人文地理. 2018, 33(1): 143-151 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.01.019

SUN Xiao-long, LIN Bi-shu, GAO Jie. A REVIEW ON THE QUALITY ASSESSMENT OF TOURISM EXPERIENCE: ADVANCES, ELEMENTS AND PROSPECTS[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2018, 33(1): 143-151 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.01.019

中图分类号： F590

参考文献

[1] 谢彦君.基础旅游学[M].北京:中国旅游出版社,2004:248.[Xie Yanjun.Tourism Studies[M].Beijing:China Travel&Tourism Press,2004:248.]

[2] Cole S T,Scott D.Examining the mediating role of experience quality in a model of tourist experiences[J].Journal of Travel&Tourism Marketing,2004,16(1):79-90.

[3] Jin N P,Lee S,Lee H.The effect of experience quality on perceived value,satisfaction,image and behavioral intention of water park patrons:New versus repeat visitors[J].International Journal of Tourism Research,2015,17(1):82-95.

[4] Grönroos C.A service quality model and its marketing implications[J].European Journal of Marketing,1984,18(4):36-44.

[5] Kano N,Seraku N,Takahashi F,et al.Attractive quality and must-be quality[J].The Journal of the Japanese Society for Quality Control,1984,14(2):39-48.

[6] 苏勤.旅游者类型及其体验质量研究——以周庄为例[J].地理科学,2004,24(2):506-511.[Su Qin.A study on the types of tourists and their experience quality:A case study of Zhouzhang[J].Scientia Geographica Sinica,2004,24(2):506-511.]

[7] Fornell C,Johnson M D,Anderson E W,et al.The American customer satisfaction index:Nature,purpose,and findings[J].The Journal of Marketing,1996,60(4):7-18.

[8] Tsaur S,Chang T,Yen C.The evaluation of airline service quality by fuzzy MCDM[J].Tourism Management,2002,23(2):107-115.

[9] Chris R.The Tourism Experience:A New Introduction[M].London:Cassell,1997:20.

[10] 安延明.狄尔泰的体验概念[J].复旦学报(社会科学版),1990(5):47-55.[An Yanming.Dilthey's concept of experience[J].Fudan Journal (Social Sciences Edition),1990(5):47-55.]

[11] 李红宇.狄尔泰的体验概念[J].史学理论研究,2001(1):88-99.[Li Hongyu.Dilthey's concept of experience[J].Historiography Quarterly,2001(1):88-99.]

[12] Csikszentmihalyi M.Flow:The Psychology of Optimal Experience[M].New York:Harper Perennial,1991:7.

[13] Cohen E.A phenomenology of tourist experiences[J].Sociology,1979,13(2):179-201.

[14] Graefe A R,Vaske J J.A framework for managing quality in the tourist experience[J].Annals of Tourism Research,1987,14(3):390-404.

[15] Maslow A H.Music education and peak experience[J].Music Educators Journal,1968,54(6):72-171.

[16] Goffman E.The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life[M].New York:Doubleday,1959:66.

[17] Csikszentmihalyi M,LeFevre J.Optimal experience in work and leisure.[J].Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1989,56(5):815-822.

[18] Parasuraman A,Zeithaml V A,Berry L L.A conceptual model of service quality and its implications for future research[J].The Journal of Marketing,1985,49(4):41-50.

[19] Otto J E,Ritchie J B.The service experience in tourism[J].Tourism Management,1996,17(3):165-174.

[20] Erto P,Vanacore A.A probabilistic approach to measure hotel service quality[J].Total Quality Management,2002,13(2):165-174.

[21] Reichel A,Lowengart O,Milman A.Rural tourism in Israel:Service quality and orientation[J].Tourism Management,2000,21(5):451-459.

[22] Lin L,Yeh H,Wang M.Integration of Kano's model into FQFD for Taiwanese Ban-Doh banquet culture[J].Tourism Management,2015,46:245-262.

[23] Caro L M,García J A M.Developing a multidimensional and hierarchical service quality model for the travel agency industry[J].Tourism Management,2008,29(4):706-720.

[24] Jiang H.The Tourist satisfaction research of service quality of cruise ports:A case of Wusongkou cruise port in Shanghai,China[J].Business and Management Research,2013,2(4):12-18.

[25] 谢彦君,吴凯.期望与感受:旅游体验质量的交互模型[J].旅游科学,2000(2):1-4.[Xie Yanjun,Wu Kai.From expectations to feelings:An interactive model for quality tourist experience[J].Tourism Science,2000(2):1-4.]

[26] 吴丽霞,赵现红.旅华外国游客旅游体验质量评价实证研究[J].地理与地理信息科学,2007,23(3):96-99.[Wu Lixia,Zhao Xianhong.A demonstration research on the experience quality of the foreigners traveling in China[J].Geography and Geo-Information Science,2007,23(3):96-99.]

[27] 白凯,马耀峰.入境旅游者体验质量动态评价研究——以西安入境欧美旅游者为例[J].城市问题,2007(2):96-100.[Bai Kai,Ma Yaofeng.An appraisal research on inbound tourists experience quality:A case study of Xi'an[J].Urban Problems,2007(2):96-100.]

[28] 李普男,吴相利,潘玲玲.影视主题公园旅游体验质量研究——以无锡影视主题公园为例[J].企业经济,2011(9):114-118.[Li Punan,Wu Xiangli,Pan Linling.A study on the tourist experience quality of film and television theme park:A case study of Wuxi[J].Enterprise Economy,2011(9):114-118.]

[29] 秦美玉.民族节事旅游体验质量评价及对策研究——以凉山彝族火把节为例[J].贵州民族研究,2013,34(3):94-97.[Qin Meiyu.Study on the evaluation and countermeasures of minority area festival and events tourism experience quality[J].Guizhou Ethnic Studies,2013,34(3):94-97.]

[30] 胡道华,赵黎明.基于旅游体验过程的游客感知评价[J].湘潭大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2011,35(2):80-84.[Hu Daohua,Zhao Liming.Evaluation of tourists' perception based on tourists' feedback[J].Journal of Xiangtan University (Philosophy and Social Sciences),2011,35(2):80-84.]

[31] 李丽娟.旅游体验价值共创影响机理研究——以北京香山公园为例[J].地理与地理信息科学,2012,28(3):96-100.[Li Lijuan.Study on influence mechanism of visitor experience value Co-creation:A case study of Xiangshan Park in Beijing[J].Geography and Geo-information Science,2012,28(3):96-100.]

[32] 刘军林.旅游体验质量评价体系模型及分析[J].天津商业大学学报,2010,30(6):20-23.[Liu Junlin.System model and analysis of tourism experience quality evaluation[J].Journal of Tianjin University of Commerce,2010,30(6):20-23.]

[33] 吴承照,马林志,詹立.户外游憩体验质量评价研究——以上海城市公园自行车活动为例[J].旅游科学,2010,24(1):45-51.[Wu Chengzhao,Ma Linzhi,Zhan Li.Research on experience quality assessment of outdoor recreation:A case study of cycling in city parks of Shanghai[J].Tourism Science,2010,24(1):45-51.]

[34] Lee Y,Huang S.A new fuzzy concept approach for Kano's model[J].Expert Systems with Applications,2009,36(3):4479-4484.

[35] Kano N.Special issue on Kano's methods for understanding customer-defined quality[J].Center of Quality Management Journal,1993,2(4):3-28.

[36] Matzler K,Hinterhuber H H.How to make product development projects more successful by integrating Kano's model of customer satisfaction into quality function deployment[J].Technovation,1998,18(1):25-38.

[37] 赵仕红.基于KANO模型的休闲农业游客满意度研究[J].江苏商论,2013(12):28-31.[Zhao Shihong.A study on satisfaction degree of leisure agriculture tourists based on KANO model[J].Jiangsu Commercial Forum,2013(12):28-31.]

[38] Hogstrom C,Rosner M,Gustafsson A.How to create attractive and unique customer experiences:An application of Kano's theory of attractive quality to recreational tourism[J].Marketing Intelligence&Planning,2010,28(4):263-4503.

[39] Shahin A,Zairi M.Kano model:A dynamic approach for classifying and prioritising requirements of airline travellers with three case studies on international airlines[J].Total Quality Management,2009,20(9):1003-1028.

[40] Hsuan W C,Shin R Y,Yung H T,et al.Application of Kano model and IPA model to discuss tourist satisfaction on national science and technology museum in Taiwan[C]//International Conference on Applied System Innovation.Okinwa:IEE,2016:1-5.

[41] 蔡礼彬,王琼.基于精细化KANO和TRIZ理论的展会服务品质提升研究——以第113届广交会为例[J].江汉学术,2014,33(4):105-116.[Cai Libing,Wang Qiong.Research on promotion of exhibition service quality based on KANO and TRIZ theory[J].Jianghan Academic,2014,33(4):105-116.]

[42] 龚伟.基于Kano和DEMATEL模型的农家乐服务质量改进策略研究——以上海市崇明前卫村为例[J].资源开发与市场,2014,30(6):681-686.[Gong Wei.Research on strategy to improve service quality of farmhouse tourism based on model of Kano and DEMATEL-Taking Qianwei village,Shanghai Chongming as an example[J].Resource Development&Market,2014,30(6):681-686.]

[43] Randall B.How service marketers can identify value-enhancing service elements[J].Journal of Services Marketing,1988,2(3):35-41.

[44] Lin S,Yang C,Chan Y,et al.Refining Kano's ‘quality attributes-satisfaction’ model:A moderated regression approach[J].International Journal of Production Economics,2010,126(2):255-263.

[45] Grönroos C.Marketing services:The case of a missing product[J].Journal of Business&Industrial Marketing,1998,13(4/5):322-338.

[46] Rust R T,Oliver R L.Service Quality:New Directions in Theory and Practice[M].London:Sage Publications,1993:1-19.

[47] Parasuraman A,Zeithaml V A,Berry L L.SERVQUAL:A multipleitem scale for measuring consumer perceptions of service quality[J].Journal of Retailing,1994,64(1):12-40.

[48] Augustyn M,Ho S K.Service quality and tourism[J].Journal of Travel Research,1998,37(1):71-75.

[49] Shonk D J,Chelladurai P.Service quality,satisfaction,and intent to return in event sport tourism[J].Journal of Sport Management,2008,22(5):587-602.

[50] Kouthouris C,Alexandris K.Can service quality predict customer satisfaction and behavioral intentions in the sport tourism industry?An application of the SERVQUAL model in an outdoors setting[J].Journal of Sport&Tourism,2005,10(2):101-111.

[51] ?abkar V,Bren?i?M M,Dmitrovi?T.Modelling perceived quality,visitor satisfaction and behavioural intentions at the destination level[J].Tourism Management,2010,31(4):537-546.

[52] Khan M.ECOSERV:Ecotourists' quality expectations[J].Annals of Tourism Research,2003,30(1):109-124.

[53] Tribe J,Snaith T.From SERVQUAL to HOLSAT:Holiday satisfaction in Varadero,Cuba[J].Tourism Management,1998,19(1):25-34.

[54] 张维亚,汤澍,严伟,等.农业遗产旅游服务质量感知评价研究——以南京市农业遗产旅游者感知为例[J].金陵科技学院学报,2009,23(4):94-98.[Zhang Weiya,Tang Shu,Yan Wei,et al.Research on perception and evaluation of service quality for agricultural heritage tourism:A case on Nanjing agricultural heritage tourists[J].Journal of Jingling Institute of Technology,2009,23(4):94-98.]

[55] Brady M K,Cronin Jr J J.Some new thoughts on conceptualizing perceived service quality:A hierarchical approach[J].Journal of Marketing,2001,65(3):34-49.

[56] 祁黄雄,谢钱.基于BCM模型的乡村旅游企业服务质量测评——湖州顾渚村的实证调查[J].地理研究,2011,30(7):1331-1340.[Qi Huangxiong,Xie Qian.Evaluation study on service quality of rural tourism industry based on BCM model:Empirical investigation of Guzhu village,Huzhou city[J].Geographical Research,2011,30(7):1331-1340.]

[57] Ko Y J,Pastore D L.A hierarchical model of service quality for the recreational sport industry[J].Sport Marketing Quarterly,2005,14(2):84-97.

[58] Zeithaml V A.Consumer perceptions of price,quality,and value:A means-end model and synthesis of evidence[J].The Journal of Marketing,1988,52(3):2-22.

[59] Knutson B J,Singh A J,Yen H,et al.Guest satisfaction in the US lodging industry using the ACSI model as a service quality scoreboard[J].Journal of Quality Assurance in Hospitality&Tourism,2004,4(3-4):97-118.

[60] 王群,丁祖荣,章锦河,等.旅游环境游客满意度的指数测评模型——以黄山风景区为例[J].地理研究,2006,25(1):171-181.[Wang Qun,Ding Zurong,Zhang Jinhe,et al.Study on the model of tourist satisfaction index about tourism environment:A case study of Huangshan mountain[J].Geographical Research,2006,25(1):171-181.]