中外人文地理学论文写作之差别

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.01.020

PDF(2031 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2018, Vol. 33 ›› Issue (1) : 152-158. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.01.020

旅游

中外人文地理学论文写作之差别

汤茂林^1,2

作者信息 +

THE WRITING DIFFERENCE OF HUMAN GEOGRAPHY PAPERS BETWEEN MAINLAND CHINAAND WESTERN EUROPE AND NORTH AMERICA

TANG Mao-lin^1,2

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

对人文地理学者而言，论文的写作与发表至关重要。基于新世纪以来的个人学术阅读，认为国内人文地理学论文写作在不断进步，但与欧美人文地理期刊上的论文相比，还存在一些差距。这种差距主要表现在研究思路、理论框架、文献综述、引证、讨论等部分，笔者作了初步的探讨。在学术论文写作中，我们需要基于自己的方法论，认真交待研究问题和研究思路，阐明理论框架，完善文献综述，认真对待引证，并改进讨论部分的写作。

Abstract

Writing and publishing academic papers are of vital importance to human geographers in the world. Based on the personal academic reading the author believes that the writing of human geography paper in Mainland China has made great progress in the new century, there is some gap when compared with the Anglo-American counterparts. This gap is mainly illustrated on the sections of paper's research approach, theoretical background (framework), literature review, citing and discussion. The author makes a preliminary investigation on the related issues and suggests that we should speak clearly the research question and methodology, state the theoretical framework, enrich the literature review, take the citing serious and improve the discussion section. The success of a particular study resides with its ability to contextualize itself in a larger corpus of knowledge, it is vital to include detailed knowledge background at the beginning of a paper. Since main purpose of research is to develop theories and models it is necessary to introduce the approach, methodology, theoretical framework used in the research. The related statements should be based on the published literature, details and information. Engaged pluralism in human geography can contribute to human geography. If we use positivism as the working methodology, we should obey the rules of deduction to construct theories. Many so-called Chinse positivist human geographical studies are actually using induction and cannot be classified as positivist research. Another misconception related to positivist research is the wildly use of assumption for hypothesis. What is to be tested in a particular study is the hypothesis, not the assumption. We need to (re-)read the methodological books such as Explanation in Geography, Philosophy and Human Geography, and Approaches to Human Geography.

导出引用

汤茂林. 中外人文地理学论文写作之差别[J]. 人文地理. 2018, 33(1): 152-158 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.01.020

TANG Mao-lin. THE WRITING DIFFERENCE OF HUMAN GEOGRAPHY PAPERS BETWEEN MAINLAND CHINAAND WESTERN EUROPE AND NORTH AMERICA[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2018, 33(1): 152-158 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.01.020

中图分类号： K901

参考文献

[1] 方创琳,周尚意,柴彦威,等.中国人文地理学研究进展与展望[J].地理科学进展,2011,30(12):1470-1478.[Fang Chuanglin,Zhou Shangyi,Chai Yanwei,et al.Updated progress and perspectives of the discipline of human geography in China[J].Progress in Geography,2011,30(12):1470-1478.]

[2] 何金廖,黄贤金.21世纪中国人文地理学研究的国际影响定量分析与挑战[J].地理科学进展,2017,36(1):112-124.[He Jingliao,Huang Xianjin.Quantitative analysis and challenges of Chinese human geography in the international academia since 2000[J].Progress in Geography,2017,36(1):112-124.]

[3] Dong G P,Ma J,Harris R,et al.Spatial random slope multilevel modeling using multivariate conditional autoregressive models:A case study of subjective travel satisfaction in Beijing[J].Annals of the American Association of Geographers,2016,106(1):19-35.

[4] Qiao J J,Lee J,Ye X Y.Spatiotemporal evolution of specialized villages and rural development:A case study of Henan province,China[J].Annals of the American Association of Geographers,2016,106(1):57-75.

[5] Long Y,Shen Y,Jin X B.Mapping block-level urban areas for all Chinese cities[J].Annals of the American Association of Geographers,2016,106(1):96-113.

[6] 刘云刚,李志刚,黎斌.西方人文地理学研究评述与借鉴——面向知行合一的中国人文地理学[J].地理学报,2014,69(8):1224-1233.[Liu Yungang,Li Zhigang,Li Bin.A critical review of research methods of Western human geography:A combination of knowing and doing for Chinese human geography[J].Acta Geographica Sinica,2014,69(8):1224-1233.]

[7] 刘云刚,王丰龙.西方主义与实证主义幻象:近三十年来中国人文地理学理论研究透视[J].人文地理,2013,28(1):14-19.[Liu Yungang,Wang Fenglong.Reexamining Chinese human geography:Perspective of theoretical studies in recent thirty years[J].Human Geography,2013,28(1):14-19.]

[8] 刘云刚,许学强.实用主义vs科学主义:中国城市地理学的研究取向[J].地理研究,2010,29(11):2059-2069.[Liu Yungang,Xu Xueqiang.Pragmatism vs.scientism:Which is the sponsor of urban geography in China?[J].Geographical Research,2010,29(11):2059-2069.]

[9] 王兴中,刘永刚.人文地理学研究方法论的进展与"文化转向"以来的流派[J].人文地理,2007,23(3):1-6.[Wang Xingzhong,Liu Yonggang.The progress of the research methodology on human geography and the schools since "cultural turn "[J].Human Geography,2007,23(3):1-6.]

[10] 白光润.地理学的哲学贫困[J].地理学报,1995,50(3):279-287.[Bai Guangrun.The philosophical poverty of geography[J].Acta Geographica Sinica,1995,50(3):279-287.]

[11] 汤茂林.我国人文地理学研究方法多样化问题[J].地理研究,2009,28(4):865-882.[Tang Maolin.The diversification of research approaches in human geography in Mainland China[J].Geographical Research,2009,28(4):865-882.]

[12] 邓正来.知识生产机器的反思与批判——迈向中国学术规范化讨论的第二阶段[J].西南政法大学学报,2004,26(3):3-6.[Deng Zhenglai.Retrospecting and criticizing the apparatus which knowledge is made out of[J].Journal of Southwest University of Political Science and Law,2004,26(3):3-6.]

[13] 汤茂林.我国人文地理学研究的若干基本意识问题[J].人文地理,2010,25(4):1-6.[Tang Maolin.The methodological issues of human geography researches in mainland China[J].Human Geography,2010,25(4):1-6.]

[14] 汤茂林,蒋永华.我国人文地理学研究、教学与出版关系论——以出版为中心的探讨[J].人文地理,2011,26(1):154-159.[Tang Maolin,Jiang Yonghua.On the relationship among research,teaching and publishing of human geography in mainland China:A publication-centered discussion[J].Human Geography,2011,26(1):154-159.]

[15] 魏也华.人文地理学研究与学术论文写作漫谈[J].世界地理研究,2010,19(3):159-166.[Wei Yehua.On scholarly research and writing in human geography[J].World Regional Studies,2010,19(3):159-166.]

[16] 姚鲁烽,何书金,赵歆.地理学论文写作[M].北京:科学出版社,2015.[Yao Lufeng,He Shujin,Zhao Xin.Geographic Paper Writing[M].Beijing:Science Press,2015.]

[17] Lin C S.The growth and structural change of Chinese cities:A contextual and geographic analysis[J].Cities,2002,19(5):299-316.

[18] Zhao X B,Chan C K,Sit T O.Globalization and the dominance of large cities in contemporary China[J].Cities,2003,20(4):265-278.

[19] 艾肯特·S,瓦伦丁·G.人文地理学方法[M].柴彦威,周尚意,等,译.北京:商务印书馆,2016:7.[Aitken S,Valentine G.Approaches to Human Geography[M].Chai Yanwei,Zhou Shangyi,et al,trans.Beijing:The Commercial Press,2016:7.]

[20] 贺灿飞,潘峰华.溢出效应还是挤出效应——对北京市制造业外商直接投资的实证分析[J].中国软科学,2006(7):96-106.[He Canfei,Pan Fenghua.Spillover effects or crowding out effects:An empirical study on FDI in the manufacturing industry in Beijing[J].China Soft Science,2006(7):96-106.]

[21] 黄耿志,薛德升.1990年以来广州市摊贩空间政治的规训机制[J].地理学报,2011,66(8):1063-1075.[Huang Gengzhi,Xue Desheng.Discipline and anti-discipline:Spatial politics of urban street vending in Guangzhou since the 1990s[J].Acta Geographica Sinica,2011,66(8):1063-1075.]

[22] 陈果.基于广州实证的后改革时代中国城市住房权问题[J].地理学报,2015,70(12):1973-1986.[Chen Guo.Housing rights in postreform urban China:A case study of housing differentiation and justice in Guangzhou,China[J].Acta Geographica Sinica,2015,70(12):1973-1986.]

[23] Sheppard E.Thinking geographically:Globalizing capitalism and beyond[J].Annals of the Association of American Geographers,2015,105(6):1113-1134.

[24] Lin C S.Evolving spatial form of urban-rural interaction in the Pearl River Delta,China[J].The Professional Geographer,2001,53(1):56-70.

[25] 梁鹤年.比较研究:论方法[J].城市规划,2003,27(11):46-55.[Liang Henian.Comparative research:On method[J].City Planning Review,2003,27(11):46-55.]

[26] 李旭旦.现代地理学的几个问题[J].地理知识,1979(9):1-2,5.[Li Xudan.Several problems of modern geography[J].Geographical Knowledge,1979(9):1-2,5.]

[27] 汤茂林.问题主导还是方法主导?——对我国人文地理学研究的方法论思考[J].人文地理,2013,28(5):19-23.[Tang Maolin.Problem-dominated versus method-dominated?A reflection on the methodology of human geography research in mainland China[J].Human Geography,2013,28(5):19-23.]

[28] 大卫·哈维.地理学中的解释[M].高泳源,刘立华,蔡运龙,译.北京:商务印书馆,1996.[Harvey D.Explanation in Geography[M].Gao Yongyuan,Liu Lihua,Cai Yonglong,trans.Beijing:The Commercial Press,1996.]

[29] 周一星.城市研究的第一科学问题是基本概念的正确性[J].城市规划学刊,2006(1):1-5.[Zhou Yixing.The primary scientific issue of urban research in China is the correctness of basic urban concepts[J].Urban Planning Forum,2006(1):1-5.]

[30] 约翰斯顿·R J.地理学与地理学家——1945年以来的英美人文地理学[M].唐晓峰,李平,叶冰,等,译.北京:商务印书馆,1999:93.[Johnston R J.Geography and Geographers:Anglo-American Human Geography Since 1945[M].Tang Xiaofeng,Li Ping,Ye Bing,et al,trans.Beijing:The Commercial Press,1999:93.]

[31] 周尚意,主编.人文地理学野外方法[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2010.[Zhou Shangyi,ed.Fieldwork Methods of Human Geography[M].Beijing:Higher Education Press,2010.]

[32] 陈学飞.谈学术规范及其必要性[J].中国高等教育,2003(11):23.[Chen Xuefei.On academic norm and the necessity[J].Chinese Higher Education,2003(11):23.]

[33] Marton M A.Mega-urbanization in southern Jiangsu:Enterprise location and the reconstitution of local space[J].Chinese Environment and Development,1995,6(1/2):9-42.

[34] Tacoli C.Rural-urban interactions:A guide to the literature[J].Environment and Urbanization,1998,10(1):147-166.

[35] Douglass M.A regional network strategy for reciprocal rural-urban linkages[J].Third World Planning Review,1998,20(1):1-33.

[36] Landes D S.为什么是欧洲和西方,而不是中国?[J].舒萍,译.开放时代,2008(3):36-50.[Landes D S.Why Europe and the West,Why not China?[J].Shu Ping,trans.Open Times,2008(3):36-50.]

[37] 李小玲.学术论文中引言与讨论的核心内容及其对应关系[J].热带地理,2014,34(1):130-132.[Li Xiaoling.Core contents of the introduction and discussion in an academic paper and their corresponding relationship[J].Tropical Geography,2014,34(1):130-132.]

[38] Harris C D,Ullman E L.The nature of cities[J].Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science,1945,242(1):7-17.

[39] Harris C D."The nature of cities" and urban geography in the last half century[J].Urban Geography,1997,18(1):15-35.

[40] 彭玉生."洋八股"与社会科学规范[J].社会学研究,2010(2):180-210.[Peng Yusheng.The structure of empirical social research[J].Sociological Research,2010(2):180-210.]