企业主义视角下大城市保障房建设的策略选择及其社会空间后果

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.04.008

PDF(5159 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2018, Vol. 33 ›› Issue (4) : 52-59,87. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.04.008

城市

企业主义视角下大城市保障房建设的策略选择及其社会空间后果

刘玉亭^1,2, 邱君丽¹

作者信息 +

SELECTIVE STRATEGIES OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING CONSTRUCTION AND ITS SOCIO-SPATIAL EFFECTS IN LARGE CHINESE CITIES FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF ENTREPRENEURIALISM

LIU Yu-ting^1,2, QIU Jun-li¹

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

城市企业主义是理解地方政府行为与城市空间变迁的重要政治经济视角，在中国推进经济全球化和住房市场化的背景下，企业化的地方政府，特别是大城市政府，在保障房的建设实践中往往采取偏向性的策略选择。本文着重讨论企业主义视角下大城市政府保障房建设的策略选择及其社会空间后果。研究发现，大城市政府主要通过实施保障房政策的异化和保障房住区的边远化策略，来履行其住房保障职责。然而，这种选择性策略带来的直接的社会空间后果是低收入群体的边缘化，具体表现为外来务工人员等在保障政策上的边缘化，以及保障房居民在社会空间上的边缘化。文章进一步指出，保障房应回归其保障本位，以满足低收入群体的真实需求。

Abstract

Originated in North America in the 1970s, gradually broadcast to Western European countries, urban entrepreneurialism is now an important political-economical view used widely by Chinese scholars to explain the role of local government and urban evolution in transitional urban China. Under the context of marketization and globalization in the post reform era, especially after housing commercialization in 1998, local governments (especially municipal city governments) in large Chinese cities, often carried out selective strategies in the practice of affordable housing construction. This paper puts emphasis on strategies of affordable housing construction and its socio-spatial effects. Based on our research group's empirical studies in Guangzhou and Chongqing separately in May and June, 2015, combined with secondary materials analysis, such as statistical data and government plans and policy documents in Shanghai, Beijing and Shenzhen, this study examined entrepreneurial strategies of affordable housing construction and its implications in large Chinese cities nowadays. It is argued that "alienation of affordable housing policies" and "suburbanization of affordable housing estates" are two frequently-used implementation strategies of affordable housing policy in large Chinese cities. A civilized city is defined not only by its quality of living, but also by the "right to the city" of citizens. This research further points out that affordable housing should be returned to its own "security" post so as to meet real demands of low-income groups.

导出引用

刘玉亭, 邱君丽. 企业主义视角下大城市保障房建设的策略选择及其社会空间后果[J]. 人文地理. 2018, 33(4): 52-59,87 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.04.008

LIU Yu-ting, QIU Jun-li. SELECTIVE STRATEGIES OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING CONSTRUCTION AND ITS SOCIO-SPATIAL EFFECTS IN LARGE CHINESE CITIES FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF ENTREPRENEURIALISM[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2018, 33(4): 52-59,87 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.04.008

中图分类号： K901.2

参考文献

[1] 叶开.全国保障房开工747万套,"十二五" 总计约4000万套[N/OL]. (2015-11-10)[2017-06-27]. http://finance.sina.com.cn/china/20151110/143923728250.shtml.[Ye Kai. 7.47 million affordable housing un-its begun to be built nationwide, about 40 million units totally during the 12^th-Five-Year-Plan period[N/OL]. (2015-11-10)[2017-06-27]. http://finance.sina.com.cn/china/20151110/143923728250.shtml.]

[2] 郑思齐,张英杰.保障性住房的空间选址:理论基础、国际经验与中国现实[J].现代城市研究,2010,25(9):18-22.[Zheng Siqi, Zhang Yingjie. Location patterns of social indemnificatory housing:Theories, international practices and the reality in China[J]. Modern Urban Research, 2010,25(9):18-22.]

[3] 于一凡,李继军.保障性住房的双重边缘化陷阱[J].城市规划学刊, 2013(6):107-111.[Yu Yifan, Li Jijun. The duple-marginalization trap of social housing[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2013(6):107-111.]

[4] 宋伟轩.大城市保障性住房空间布局的社会问题与治理途径[J].城市发展研究,2011,18(8):103-108.[Song Weixuan. Social problems incurred from spatial distribution of indemnificatory housing in large cities and governing measures[J]. Urban Studies, 2011,18(8):103-108.]

[5] 郑思齐,张英杰. "十二五" 期间保障房建设如何"保障"——基于地方政府策略选择的分析[J].探索与争鸣,2013(4):66-70,71.[Zheng Siqi, Zhang Yingjie. How to "secure" affordable housing construction during the the 12^th-Five-Year-Plan period:An analysis based on local governments' choice of strategies[J]. Exploration and Free Views, 2013(4):66-70,71.]

[6] 朱莉娜.地方政府偏好对保障房供给的影响——以南京市为例[D].南京:南京财经大学,2014:44-45.[Zhu Lina. The Impact of Local Government Preference for the Supply of Affordable Housing:A Case Study of Nanjing[D]. Nanjing:Nanjing University of Finance & Economics,2014:44-45.]

[7] Harvey D. From managerialism to entrepreneurialism:The transformation of urban governance in late capitalism[J]. Geografiska Annaler:Series B, Human Geography, 1989,71(1):3-17.

[8] Leitner H. Cities in pursuit of economic growth:The local state as entrepreneur[J]. Political Geography Quarterly, 1990,9(2):146-170.

[9] Hall T, Hubbard P. The entrepreneurial city:New urban politics, new urban geographies?[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 1996,20(2):153-174.

[10] MacLeod G. From urban entrepreneurialism to a "revanchist city"? on the spatial injustices of glasgow's renaissance[J]. Antipode, 2002,34(3):602-624.

[11] 刘长岐,肖岚,张楠楠.企业家城市视角下的杭州城市国际化研究[J].规划师,2011,27(2):42-46.[Liu Changqi, Xiao Lan, Zhang Nannan. Study on Hangzhou internationalization under perspective of entrepreneurial city[J]. Planners, 2011,27(2):42-46.]

[12] Wu F. The (Post-) Socialist entrepreneurial city as a state project:Shanghai's reglobalisation in question[J]. Urban Studies, 2003,40(9):1673-1698.

[13] 张京祥,殷洁,罗小龙.地方政府企业化主导下的城市空间发展与演化研究[J].人文地理,2006,21(4):1-6.[Zhang Jingxiang, Yin Jie, Luo Xiaolong. Research of urban spatial development under the circumstances of local government's entrepreneurialization[J]. Human Geography, 2006,21(4):1-6.]

[14] He S, Wu F. China's emerging neoliberal urbanism:Perspectives from urban redevelopment[J]. Antipode, 2009,41(2):282-304.

[15] 殷洁,张京祥,罗小龙.转型期的中国城市发展与地方政府企业化[J]. 城市问题,2006(4):36-41.[Yin Jie, Zhang Jingxiang, Luo Xiaolong. Urban development and local state entrepreneurialism under transformational China[J]. Urban Problems, 2006(4):36-41.]

[16] 曹湛,彭震伟,毕胜. "城市企业主义"——一个转轨期我国城乡空间现象的分析视角[J].现代城市研究,2016(10):79-86,101.[Cao Zhan, Peng Zhenwei, Bi Sheng. "Urban Entrepreneurialism":A perspective of China's urban and rural space phenomenon in transition period[J]. Modern Urban Research, 2016(10):79-86,101.]

[17] Boyle M, Hughes G. The politics of urban entrepreneurialism in Glasgow[J]. Geoforum, 1994,25(4):453-470.

[18] Cross V. Resisting the entrepreneurial city:Street vendors' struggle in Mexico City's Historic Center[J]. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 2009,33(1):43-63.

[19] Jessop B, Sum N L. An entrepreneurial city in action:Hong Kong's emerging strategies in and for (inter) urban competition[J]. Urban Studies, 2000,37(12):2287-2313.

[20] Oi J C. The role of the local state in China's transitional economy[J]. The China Quarterly, 1995(144):1132-1149.

[21] Walder A G. Local government as industrial corporations:An organizational analysis of China's transitional economy[J]. American Journal of Sociology, 1995,101(2):263-301.

[22] Lin G C S, Zhang L A Y. China's metropolises in transformation:Neoliberalizing politics, land commodification, and uneven development in Beijing[J]. Urban Geography, 2017,38(5):643-665.

[23] 何深静,袁振杰,李洁华.广州亚运会旧城改造项目对社区居民的影响研究[J].规划师,2010,12(26):21-27.[He Shenjing, Yuan Zhenjie, Li Jiehua. The influence of Asian Games old city renovation projects on community residents in Guangzhou[J]. Planners, 2010, 12(26):21-27.]

[24] 王根贤.财政分权激励与土地财政、保障性住房的内在逻辑及其调整[J].中央财经大学学报,2013,1(5):1-5.[Wang Genxian. Internal logic of fiscal decentralization incentive and land fiscal and insurance house along with adjusting[J]. Journal of Central University of Finance&Economics, 2013,1(5):1-5.]

[25] 谭锐,黄亮雄,韩永辉.保障性住房建设困境与土地财政压力——基于城市层面数据的实证研究[J].现代财经(天津财经大学学报), 2016,36(12):61-72.[Tan Rui, Huang Liangxiong, Han Yonghui. The dilemma of public housing project and land finance pressure:An empirical study based on city level data[J]. Modern Finance and Economics-Forum of Tianjin University of Finance and Economics, 2016,36(12):61-72.]

[26] 贾春梅.地方政府行为规制与保障房有效供给[J].上海立信会记学院学报,2011,25(6):72-77.[Jia Chunmei. Behavior regulation of local government and effective supply of affordable housing[J]. Journal of Shanghai Lixin University of Commerce, 2011,25(6):72-77.]

[27] 高义.保障房建设中地方政府群体行为进化博弈与治理机制研究[J].中国经济问题,2011(6):52-56.[Gao Yi. A Study on the evolutionary game of local governments' group behavior in the indemnificatory housing policy and its governance mechanism[J]. Economic Issues in China, 2011(6):52-56.]

[28] Wang Y. The new affordable and social housing provision system in china:Implications for comparative housing studies[J]. International Journal of Housing Policy, 2011,11(3):237-254.

[29] Chen J, Yang Z, Wang Y. The new chinese model of public housing:A step forward or backward?[J]. Housing Studies, 2014,29(4):534-550.

[30] 广州市国土资源和房屋管理局.广州市城市建设拆迁安置新社区住宅管理办法[Z].广州:2006-01-01.[Guangzhou Land Resources and Property Management Bureau. Management Rules of New Demolition and Resettlement Communities for Urban Construction in Guangzhou City[Z]. Guangzhou:2006-01-01.]

[31] 宋伟轩,陈培阳,徐旳.内城区户籍贫困空间剥夺式重构研究——基于南京10843份拆迁安置数据[J].地理研究,2013,32(8):1467-1476.[Song Weixuan, Chen Peiyang, Xu Di. Research on the deprivation-type reconstruction of inner-city registered poverty space based on resettlement data of Nanjing[J]. Geographical Research, 2013,32(8):1467-1476.]

[32] 孙东琪,张京祥,陈浩,等.中国大城市拆迁安置居民补偿方式与受益率测度——以南京为例[J].地理科学,2016,36(2):161-169.[Sun Dongqi, Zhang Jingxiang, Chen Hao, et al. The Measure of displaced households' compensation approaches and benefits rate based on regression model:A case of Nanjing[J]. Scientia Geographical Sinica, 2016,36(2):161-169.]

[33] 深圳市人民政府办公厅.深府办

[2011] 46号.深圳市人民政府办公厅关于印发深圳市住房保障发展规划(2011-2015)的通知[Z].深圳:2011-11-07.[General Office of the People's Government of Shenzhen. GOPGS

[2011] NO46. Notice of General Office of the People's Government of Shenzhen on printing and distributing the plan for affordable housing development in 2011-2015[Z]. Shenzhen:2011-11-07.]

[34] 杨立勋.后特区时代的深圳人才发展战略与对策[J].特区经济, 2003(6):34-37.[Yang Lixun. Talent strategies in Shenzhen during the time of post-special-zone[J]. Special Zone Economy, 2003(6):34-37.]

[35] 吴振兴.深圳人才战略选择与发展路径初探[J].特区实践与理论, 2006(6):52-54.[Wu Zhenxing. Choice of talent strategies and developmental path in Shenzhen[J]. Practice and Theory of Sezs, 2006(6):52-54.]

[36] 深圳市人力资源和社会保障局.深发

[2011] 9号.中共深圳市委深圳市人民政府关于实施引进海外高层次人才"孔雀计划" 的意见[Z].深圳:2011-04-13.[Shenzhen Bureau of Human Rresources and Social Security. Opinions of Shenzhen Municipal Party Committee and Shenzhen Municipal People's Government on implementing the Peacock Plan to introduce high level overseas talents[Z]. Shenzhen:2011-04-13.]

[37] 张越,叶高斌,姚士谋.开发区新城建设与城市空间扩展互动研究——以上海、杭州、南京为例[J].经济地理,2015,35(2):84-91.[Zhang Yue, Ye Gaobin, Yao Shimou. The interactive study on new town construction of development zone and urban expansion:Taking Shanghai, Hangzhou and Nanjing as an example[J]. Economic Geography, 2015,35(2):84-91.]

[38] 张学勇,李桂文,曾宇.新城建设及其功能成长路径[J].城市问题, 2011(3):43-48.[Zhang Xueyong, Li Guiwen, Zeng Yu. New town construction and its developmental path[J]. Urban Problems, 2011(3):43-48.]

[39] 重庆市规划研究中心.重庆市主城区公共租赁住房专项规划[Z]. 重庆:重庆市规划局,2010.[Chongqing Planning Research Institute. Special planning of public rental housing in Chongqing[Z]. Chongqing:Urban Planning Bureau,2010.]

[40] Yaping Wang, Murie A. Social and spatial implications of housing reform in China[J]. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 2000,24(2):397-417.

[41] Liu Y, Wu F, He S. The making of the new urban poor in transitional China:Market versus institutionally based exclusion[J]. Urban Geography, 2008,29(8):811-834.

[42] 佚名.本市首批"新北京人" 专配公租房启动登记, 将摇号选房[N/OL].(2017-04-11)[2017-06-27].北京日报, http://www.beijing.gov.cn/bmfw/zxts/t1474071.htm.[Anonymous. The first batch of public rental housing for "new Peking man" begun to register, houses will be allocated by a license-plate lottery system[N/OL].(2017-04-11)[2017-06-27]. Beijing Daily, http://www.beijing.gov.cn/bmfw/zxts/t1474071.htm.]

[43] 佚名. 第二批"新北京人" 公租房开始申请[N/OL].(2017-06-07)[2017-06-27]. 北京日报, http://www.beijing.gov.cn/bmfw/zxts/t1482160.htm.[Anonymous. The second batch of public rental housing for "new Peking man" begun declaring[N/OL]. (2017-06-07)[2017-06-27]. Beijing Daily, http://www.beijing.gov.cn/bmfw/zxts/t1482160.htm.]

[44] Yanliu Lin, Bruno de Meulder, Shifu Wang. Understanding the ‘Villages in the City’ in Guangzhou:Economic integration and development issue and their implications for the urban migrant[J]. Urban Studies, 2011,48(16):3583-3598.

[45] Huang Y, Yi C. Invisible migrant enclaves in Chinese cities:Underground living in Beijing, China[J]. Urban Studies, 2015,52(15):2948-2973.

[46] 周素红,程璐萍,吴志东.广州市保障性住房社区居民的居住——就业选择与空间匹配性[J].地理研究,2010,29(10):1735-1745.[Zhou Suhong, Cheng Luping, Wu Zhidong. The jobs-housing relcation and spatial matching of residents in alleviatory housing neighborhoods in Guangzhou[J]. Geographical Research, 2010,29(10):1735-1745.]

[47] 穆晓燕,王扬.大城市社会空间演化中的同质聚居与社区重构——对北京三个巨型社区的实证研究[J].人文地理,2013,28(5):24-30.[Mu Xiaoyan, Wang Yang. Homogeneity of habitation and the community reconstruction in urban spatial evolvement in big cities:A case study of three mega-communities in Beijing[J]. Human Geography, 2013,28(5):24-30.]

[48] 王宇凡,冯健.基于生命历程视角的郊区居民迁居行为重构——以北京回龙观居住区为例[J].人文地理,2013,28(3):34-41,50.[Wang Yufan, Feng Jian. Restructuring of suburban residents' intraurban migration behavior based on life course:A case study of Huilongguan community in Beijing[J]. Human Geography, 2013,28(3):34-41,50.]

[49] 姚华松.贫困区的生产:广州同德围地区的空间演化逻辑[J].广东社会科学,2016(2):185-193.[Yao Huasong. The production of poverty areas:Logics of spatial evolution of Tongdewei Area, Guangzhou[J]. Social Science in Guangdong, 2016(2):185-193.]

[50] Priemus H. Growth and stagnation in social housing:What is ‘social’ in the social rented sector?[J]. Housing Studies, 1997,12(4):549-560.

[51] Forrest R. Public housing futures[J]. Housing Studies, 2014,29(4):463-466.