基于集体记忆的震后北川老县城空间重构

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.06.007

PDF(5745 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2018, Vol. 33 ›› Issue (6) : 53-61. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.06.007

文化

基于集体记忆的震后北川老县城空间重构

钱莉莉^1,2, 张捷¹, 郑春晖³, 张宏磊¹, 郭永锐⁴, 颜丙金⁵

作者信息 +

SPATIAL RECONSTRUCTION OF BEICHUAN RUINED COUNTRY TOWN POST-EARTHQUAKE BASED ON COLLECTIVE MEMORY THEORY

QIAN Li-li^1,2, ZHANG Jie¹, ZHENG Chun-hui³, ZHANG Hong-lei¹, GUO Yong-rui⁴, YAN Bin-jing⁵

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

汶川地震重灾区北川老县城为案例地，以地震受灾群体老县城居民为研究样本，通过问卷调查与访谈挖掘灾后遗址唤起居民的集体记忆和空间，通过认知地图和GIS空间分析对比遗址官方记忆空间、居民集体认知-情感空间、行为空间的差异，揭示现实空间与居民集体记忆空间互动影响机制。灾后日常记忆、灾难记忆夹杂在一起，产生怀旧、创伤等情感，构成居民复杂的集体记忆。尽管具体空间引发的情感以负面为主，但居民对老县城整体还是充满了积极的地方依恋和认同。

Abstract

Collective memory is related with time and space, which plays an important role in arousing the relationship between people and place and building sense of place. Thus, it is an important theory for the studies of post-disaster recovery and place reconstruction.This paper takes the ruined country town of Beichuan, which was the most stricken area in 5.12 Wenchuan earthquake, as a study case, and local residents as study samples, to explore the aroused collective memory of local residents post-quake through questionnaires and interviews. Through the method ofmental map and spatial analysis of GIS, itexplores the differences among the official exhibition space, collective cognition-emotion space and collective behaviors space of local residents, which reflects the interaction mechanism between the official exhibition space and the locals' mental space through collective memory. The study also discovers the contents of locals' collective memory, finds that the daily life memory before quake, and the disaster memoryafter quake mixed together, which contribute to complex emotions, includingsorrow, fear, sympathize, calm, yearning, happy, grateful, pride and so on. Although the specific spacestriggerthe negative emotion mostly, the residents are still full of highly positive sense of place attachment and place identity towards the whole town.

导出引用

钱莉莉, 张捷, 郑春晖, 张宏磊, 郭永锐, 颜丙金. 基于集体记忆的震后北川老县城空间重构[J]. 人文地理. 2018, 33(6): 53-61 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.06.007

QIAN Li-li, ZHANG Jie, ZHENG Chun-hui, ZHANG Hong-lei, GUO Yong-rui, YAN Bin-jing. SPATIAL RECONSTRUCTION OF BEICHUAN RUINED COUNTRY TOWN POST-EARTHQUAKE BASED ON COLLECTIVE MEMORY THEORY[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2018, 33(6): 53-61 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2018.06.007

中图分类号： C912.8

参考文献

[1] 史培军,张欢.中国应对巨灾的机制——汶川地震的经验[J].清华大学学报:哲学社会科学版, 2013(3):96-113.[Shi Peijun, Zhang Huan. China's response to the catastrophe:The experience of Wenchuan earthquake[J]. Journal of Tsinghua University(Philosophy and Social Sciences, 2013(3):96-113.]
[2] 钱莉莉,张捷,郑春晖,等.地理学视角下的集体记忆研究综述[J].人文地理,2015,30(6):7-12.[Qian Lili, Zhang Jie, Zheng Chunhui, et al. A review of studies on collective memory from the perspective of geography[J]. Human Geography, 2015,30(6):7-12.]
[3] Legg S. Reviewing geographies of memory and forgetting[J]. Environment and Planning A, 2007,39(2):456-466.
[4] Hoelscher S, Alderman D H. Alderman. Memory and place:Geographies of a critical relationship[J]. Social and Cultural Geography, 2004,5(3):347-355.
[5] Halbwachs M. On Collective Memory[M]. Chicago:University of Chicago Press, 1992:10.
[6] Nora P. Between Memory and History[M]. California:University of California Press, 1989:1-23.
[7] 邱建,蒋蓉.关于构建地震灾后恢复重建规划体系的探讨——以汶川地震为例[J].城市规划,2009,33(7):11-15.[Qiu Jian, Jiang Rong. Exploration of building a planning system of post-earthquake reconstruction:A case study of Wenchuan earthquake[J]. City Planning Review, 2009,33(7):11-15.]
[8] 陈果,王沛.基于KJ法的地震灾后恢复重建规划特征研究——以汶川县12个乡镇灾后重建规划为例[J].现代城市研究,2015(10):12-18.[Chen Guo, Wang Pei. Study on the characteristics of the post-earthquake recovery and reconstruction planning based on the KJ method:A case study of 12 post-earthquake planning of towns and villages in the Wenchuan county[J]. Modern Urban Research, 2015(10):12-18.]
[9] 余慧,邱建.灾后重建的历史文化名城保护:汶川地震的经验及其对芦山地震的启示[J].城市发展研究,2013,20(9):32-36.[Yu Hui, Qiu Jian. Protection of historic and cultural cities in the post-disaster reconstruction:Experiences from Wenchuan earthquake and the implications for Lushan earthquake[J]. Urban Development Studies, 2013,20(9):32-36.]
[10] 李佳洺,孙威,张文忠.灾后重建中工业产业选择与布局——以芦山地震灾后重建为例[J].中国科学院大学学报,2015,32(2):207-213.[Li Jiaming, Sun Wei, Zhang Wenzhong. Selection and spatial arrangement of industries in reconstruction of disaster-hit area[J]. Journal of University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2015,32(2):207-213.]
[11] 杨振之,马琳,胡海霞.论旅游功能区规划——以四川汶川地震灾后恢复重建为例[J].地域研究与开发,2013,32(6):90-95.[Yang Zhenzhi, Ma Lin, Hu Haixia. On tourist function zone planning:A case of Wenchuan post-earthquake recovery and reconstruction, Sichuan province[J]. Areal Research and Development, 2013,32(6):90-95.]
[12] 高峻.基于汶川地震重建的农居建筑范式及其策略研究[D].杭州:浙江大学,2012.[Gao Jun. Rural Housing Construction Paradigm and Strategy Research based on Wenchuan Earthquake Reconstruction and Settlement[D]. Hangzhou:Zhejiang University, 2012.]
[13] 李昕悦,张鲲.汶川地震灾后重建住居设计构想研究——家族多户式农村居民自建住居方案思考[J].四川建筑,2009,29(5):50-52.[Li Xinyue, Zhang Kun. A study on the housing design of post earthquake reconstruction in Wenchuan:Thoughts on multi-family rural self-housing construction program[J]. Sichuan Architecture, 2009,29(5):50-52.]
[14] 谭斯颖.中国模式的灾后重建:精英化的景观改造实践——以汶川地震灾后重建为例[J].城市发展研究,2016,23(11):39-44.[Tan Siying. Post-disaster reconstruction in China:The landscape recreate by elites:Case studies in Wenchuan earthquake[J]. Urban Development Studies, 2016,23(11):39-44.]
[15] Till K E. Wounded cities:Memory-work and a place-based ethics of care[J]. Political Geography, 2012,31(1):3-14.
[16] Nagel C. Reconstructing space, recreating memory:Sectarian politics and urban development in post-war Beirut[J]. Political Geography, 2002,21(2):715-725.
[17] Lewicka M. Place attachment, place identity, and place memory:Restoring the forgotten city past[J]. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2008,28(3):209-231.
[18] Ardakani M K, Oloonabadi S S A. Collective memory as an efficient agent in sustainable urban conservation[J]. Procedia Engineering, 2011,21:985-988.
[19] Simpson E, Corbridge S. The geography of things that may become memories:The 2001 earthquake in Kachchh Gujarat and the politics of rehabilitation in the prememorial era[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 2006,96(3):566-585.
[20] Morrice S. Heartache and Hurricane Katrina:Recognising the influence of emotion in postdisaster return decisions[J]. Area, 2013,45(1):33-39.
[21] BlazKomac. Social memory and geographical memory of natural disasters[J]. Acta geographica Slovenica, 2009,49(1):199-226.
[22] McEwen L, Garde-Hansen J, Holmes A, et al. Sustainable flood memories, lay knowledges and the development of community resilience to future flood risk[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2017,42(1):14-28.
[23] Osborne B S. Landscapes, memory, monuments, and commemoration:Putting identity in its place[J]. Canadian Ethnic Studies, 2001, 33(3):39-77.
[24] Lynch K. The Image of the City[M]. Cambridge:MIT Press, 1960:56.
[25] Maddrell A. Mapping grief. A conceptual framework for understanding the spatial dimensions of bereavement, mourning and remembrance[J]. Social & Cultural Geography, 2016,17(2):166-188.
[26] Carruthers M J. The Book of Memory:A Study of Memory in Medieval Culture[M]. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 1992:71.
[27] Yates F A. The Art of Memory[M]. New York:Random House, 1992:25.
[28] Hutton P H, History as an Art of Memory[M]. Hanover:University of Vermont, 1993:78-80.
[29] Withers C W, Landscape, memory, history:Gloomy memories and the 19th century Scottish Highlands[J]. Scottish Geographical Journal, 2005,121(1):29-44.
[30] Walsh C S. Crossroads of Identity and Memory:Mapping the Cultural Landscape of Taylor's Bridge[D]. Newark:University of Delaware, 2007.
[31] Muzaini H, Yeoh B S A. War landscapes as ‘battlefields’ of collective memories:Reading the reflections at Bukit Chandu, Singapore[J]. Cultural Geographies, 2005,12(3):345-365.
[32] Maddrell A. Mapping grief. A conceptual framework for understanding the spatial dimensions of bereavement, mourning and remembrance[J]. Social & Cultural Geography, 2016, 17(2):166-188.
[33] Olick J K, Collective memory:The two cultures[J]. Sociological Theory, 1999,17(3):333-348.
[34] 李凡,朱竑,黄维.从地理学视角看城市历史文化景观集体记忆的研究[J].人文地理,2010,25(4):60-66.[Li Fan, Zhu Hong, Huang Wei. A geographical study on the collective memory of urban historical cultural landscape[J]. Human Geography, 2010,25(4):60-66.]
[35] 周玮,黄震方.城市街巷空间居民的集体记忆研究——以南京夫子庙街区为例[J].人文地理,2016,31(1):42-49.[Zhou Wei, Huang Zhenfang. Research on collective memory of the street space of city:A case study of the block of Confucius Temple of Nanjing[J]. Human Geography, 2016,31(1):42-49.]
[36] Tuan Y F. Landscapes of Fear[M]. London:Pantheon, 1979:120.
[37] Osborne B S. Landscapes, memory, monuments, and commemoration:Putting identity in its place[J]. Canadian Ethnic Studies, 2001, 33(3):39-77.
[38] Relph E. Place and Placelessness[M]. London:Pion Limited, 1976:43.
[39] Revels C S. Placing Managua:A landscape narrative in post-earthquake Nicaragua[J]. Journal of Cultural Geography, 2014,31(1):81-105.
[40] Hutchison E, Bleiker R. Emotional reconciliation:Reconstituting identity and community after trauma[J]. European Journal of Social Theory, 2008,11(3):385-403.
[41] Drozdzewski D, Dominey-Howes D. Research and trauma:Understanding the impact of traumatic content and places on the researcher[J]. Emotion, Space and Society, 2015,17(6):17-21.
[42] Blunt A, Collective memory and productive nostalgia:Anglo-Indian homemaking at McCluskieganj[J]. Environment and Planning D:Society and Space, 2003,21(6):717-738.
[43] Cox R S, Perry K M E. Like a fish out of water:Reconsidering disaster recovery and the role of place and social capital in community disaster resilience[J]. American Journal of Community Psychology, 2011,48(3/4):395-411.
[44] Devine-Wright P. Rethinking NIMBYism:The role of place attachment and place identity in explaining place protective action[J]. Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology, 2009,19(6):426-441.
[45] Fullilove M T. Psychiatric implications of displacement:Contributions from the psychology of place[J]. The American Journal of Psychiatry, 1996,153(12):15-16.
[46] Tuan Y F. Space and Place:The Perspective of Experience[M]. Minneapolis:University of Minnesota Press, 1977:5.
[47] Proshansky H M, Fabian A K, Kaminoff R. Place identity:Physical world socialization of the self[J]. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 1983,3(1):57-83.
[48] Connerton P. How Societies Remember[M]. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 1989:113.