西方选举地理学的研究进展

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2019.01.006

PDF(5402 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2019, Vol. 34 ›› Issue (1) : 37-45. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2019.01.006

政治地理专栏

西方选举地理学的研究进展

刘玄宇¹, 刘云刚²

作者信息 +

THE TREND AND PROGRESS IN ELECTORAL GEOGRAPHY

LIU Xuan-yu¹, LIU Yun-gang²

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

选举地理学是政治地理学的重要研究领域之一。本文以Web of Science中选举地理学的学术论文为依据，借助科学计量工具，系统回顾了1982—2018年选举地理学的发展脉络，归纳了西方选举地理学的主要研究领域和研究范式。研究表明：选举地理学主要包括投票地理、选举制度、选区划分、选票转化四个领域；与此相应，西方学界对选举地理的研究范式可归纳为空间分析、地理制图、政治经济学、后结构主义。展望未来，选举地理学在解释中国的地方政治、基层选举、社区自治，以及推动中国政治地理学的学科发展方面将值得期待。

Abstract

Electoral geography has a long and complex history and once possessed a distinguished status within the discipline of political geography, which focused on relationships among democracy, space and political power involved in election. This dominance decreased after 1980 and the thematic coverage of electoral geography became partially obsolete. While social geography began to deal with more conceptual questions, electoral geography became utterly positivist and sank into its own ‘moribund backwater’. Electoral geographers had to face the challenges of renewal. To understand electoral geography better, and to learn how to develop it in a contemporary Chinese context. The paper uses a tool for measurement based on the amounts of research papers-579 articles published mainly in English language journals after 1982-from Web of Science. We have teased the venation of electoral geography development from 1982 to 2018, summarized and analyzed the directions and trends of research on this field. From the perspective of a quantitative literature statistics method. Electoral geography mainly includes four dimensions:The geography of voting, Electoral systems, Redistricting and gerrymandering and ballot/seat conversion, which corresponds to four research paradigms of electoral geography in the western academia:Spatial Analysis, Geographic mapping, Political Economy, Post-Structuralism; the relative concepts and theories of electoral geography, which perhaps explains social movement and public issue, local politics and grassroots election, migration and community autonomous, global geopolitics and diplomatic policy decisions, as well it also facilitates comprehensive knowledge and theoretical system of Chinese political geography.

导出引用

刘玄宇, 刘云刚. 西方选举地理学的研究进展[J]. 人文地理. 2019, 34(1): 37-45 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2019.01.006

LIU Xuan-yu, LIU Yun-gang. THE TREND AND PROGRESS IN ELECTORAL GEOGRAPHY[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2019, 34(1): 37-45 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2019.01.006

中图分类号： K901.6

参考文献

[1] Shelley F, Johnston R, Taylor P J. Developments in electoral geography[J]. Developments in Electoral Geography, 1990,3(3):1-11.
[2] Agnew J. Political Geography:A Reader[M]. London:Edward Arnold, 1996:1-2.
[3] McGing C. Towards a feminist electoral geography[J]. Social Science Electronic Publishing, 2014,47(2):86-87.
[4] Leib J. On the Shores of the "Moribund Backwater"?:Trends in Electoral Geography Research Since 1990[M]//Warf B, Leib J. Revitalizing Electoral Geography. Burlington:Routledge, 2016:21-40.
[5] Siegfried A, Vandermotten C. Tableau politique de la France de l'Ouest sous la Troisième République[M]. Paris:A. Colin, 1913:32-47.
[6] Prescott J R V. The function and methods of electoral geography[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 1959,49(3):296-304.
[7] Rowley G. Elections and population changes[J]. Area, 1970,2(3):13-18.
[8] Forest B. Electoral geography:From mapping votes to representing power[J]. Geography Compass, 2018,12(1):1-17.
[9] Krehbiel E. Geographic influences in British elections[J]. Geographical Review, 1916,2(6):419-432.
[10] Wright J K. Voting habits in the United States:A note on two maps[J]. Geographical Review, 1932,22(4):666-672.
[11] Downs A. An economic theory of political action in a democracy[J]. Journal of Political Economy, 1957,65(2):135-150.
[12] Berry D. Party membership and social participation[J]. Political Studies, 1969,17(2):196-207.
[13] Taylor P J, Johnston R J. Geography of Elections[M]. London:Croom Helm, 1979:35-42.
[14] Stewart C, Reynolds M. Television markets and US senate elections[J]. Legislative Studies Quarterly, 1990,15(4):495-523.
[15] Agnew J A. Classics in human geography revisited[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2003,27(5):605-614.
[16] Giordano B. ‘Institutional thickness’, political sub-culture and the resurgence of (the ‘new’) regionalism in Italy-a case study of the Northern League in the province of Varese[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2001,26(1):25-41.
[17] Clem R S, Craumer P R. Urban-rural voting differences in Russian elections, 1995-1996:A rayon-level analysis[J]. Post-Soviet Geography and Economics, 1997,38(7):379-395.
[18] Pattie C, Dorling D, Johnston R. The electoral geography of recession:Local economic conditions, public perceptions and the economic vote in the 1992 British general election[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 1997,22(2):147-161.
[19] Kohfeld C W, Sprague J. Race, space, and turnout[J]. Political Geography, 2002,21(2):175-193.
[20] Lucia L, Carlos T. If Quebec goes… The ‘Exodus’ impact?[J]. Professional Geographer, 2010,50(4):481-498.
[21] Hodge D C, Staeheli L A. Social relations and geographic patterns of urban electoral behavior[J]. Urban Geography, 1992,13(4):307-333.
[22] Brown M, Knopp L, Morrill R. The culture wars and urban electoral politics:Sexuality, race, and class in Tacoma, Washington[J]. Political Geography, 2005,24(3):267-291.
[23] O'Loughlin J, Shin M, Talbot P. Political geographies and cleavages in the Russian parliamentary elections[J]. Post-Soviet Geography and Economics, 1996,37(6):355-385.
[24] Chapman T, Leib J I, Webster G. Race, the creative class, and political geographies of same sex marriage in Georgia[J]. Southeastern Geographer, 2007,47(1):27-54.
[25] Johnston R J, Pattie C J, Dorling D F L, et al. New labour landslidesame old electoral geography?[J]. British Elections & Parties Review, 1998,8(1):35-64.
[26] Walks R A. The causes of city-suburban political polarization? A Canadian case study[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 2006,96(2):390-414.
[27] Pattie C, Johnston R. ‘People who talk together vote together’:An exploration of contextual effects in Great Britain[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 2000,90(1):41-66.
[28] Agnew J. Models of spatial variation in political expression:The case of the Scottish National Party[J]. International Political Science Review, 1985,6(2):171-196.
[29] Agnew J. Mapping politics:How context counts in electoral geography[J]. Political Geography, 1996,15(2):129-146.
[30] Johnston R, Pattie C. Putting Voters in Their Place:Geography and Elections in Great Britain[M]. Oxford:Oxford University Press, 2006:61-68.
[31] Johnson M, Shively W P, Stein R M. Contextual data and the study of elections and voting behavior:Connecting individuals to environments[J]. Electoral Studies, 2002,21(2):219-233.
[32] O'Loughlin J, Flint C, Anselin L. The geography of the Nazi vote:Context, confession, and class in the Reichstag election of 1930[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 1994,84(3):351-380.
[33] Perdomo C J V. The local context and the spatial diffusion of multiparty competition in Urban Mexico, 1994-2000[J]. Political Geography, 2004,23(4):403-423.
[34] Gimpel J G, Karnes K A, Mctague J, et al. Distance-decay in the political geography of friends-andneighbors voting[J]. Political Geography, 2008,27(2):231-252.
[35] Agnew J, Mamadouh V, Secor A J, et al. Electoral Geography in the Twenty-first Century[M]. Hoboken:Wiley Online Library. The Wiley Blackwell Companion to Political Geography, 2015:281.
[36] Forrest J. The effects of local campaign spending on the geography of the flow-of-the-vote at the 1991 New South Wales state election[J]. The Australian Geographer, 1997,28(2):229-240.
[37] Sui D Z, Hugill P J. A GIS-based spatial analysis on neighborhood effects and voter turn-out:A case study in College Station, Texas[J]. Political Geography, 2002,21(2):159-173.
[38] Johnston R, Wickham-Jones M, Pattie C, et al. Friends and neighbours voting revisited:The geography of support for candidates to lead the UK's Labour Party[J]. Political Geography, 2016,55(3):1-9.
[39] Lijphart A. Patterns of Democracy:Government Forms and Performance in Thirty-six Countries[M]. London:Yale University Press, 2012:44-51.
[40] Benoit K. Models of electoral system change[J]. Electoral Studies, 2004,23(3):363-389.
[41] Gallagher M. The political impact of electoral system change in Japan and New Zealand, 1996[J]. Party Politics, 1998,4(2):203-228.
[42] Perepechko A S, Kolossov V A, ZumBrunnen C. Remeasuring and rethinking social cleavages in Russia:Continuity and changes in electoral geography 1917-1995[J]. Political Geography, 2007,26(2):179-208.
[43] Lemon A, Fox R. Consolidating democracy in South Africa:The second open election[J]. Area, 2000,32(3):337-344.
[44] Waterman S, Zefadia E. Political geography in practice Ⅱ:Israeli electoral reforms in action[J]. Political Geography, 1992,11(6):563-578.
[45] Cox G W, Rosenbluth F. The electoral fortunes of legislative factions in Japan[J]. American Political Science Review, 1993,87(3):577-589.
[46] Cirincione C, Darling T A, O'Rourke T G. Assessing South Carolina's 1990s congressional districting[J]. Political Geography, 2000, 19(2):189-211.
[47] Drewry G. The complementarity of audit and judicial review:The ‘homes for votes’ scandal in the UK[J]. International Review of Administrative Sciences, 2005,71(3):375-389.
[48] Kendall M G, Stuart A. The law of the cubic proportion in election results[J]. The British Journal of Sociology, 1950,1(3):183-196.
[49] McKee S C, Teigen J M. Probing the reds and blues:Sectionalism and voter location in the 2000 and 2004 US presidential elections[J]. Political Geography, 2009,28(8):484-495.
[50] Murphy C, Yoshinaka A. Are mapmakers able to target and protect congressional incumbents? The institutional dynamics of electoral competition[J]. American Politics Research, 2009,37(6):955-982.
[51] Webster G R. Reflections on current criteria to evaluate redistricting plans[J]. Political Geography, 2013,32(1):3-14.
[52] Flint C. The theoretical and methodological utility of space and spatial statistics for historical studies:The Nazi Party in geographic context[J]. Historical Methods:A Journal of Quantitative and Interdisciplinary History, 2002,35(1):32-42.
[53] Morrill R, Knopp L, Brown M. Anomalies in red and blue:Exceptionalism in American electoral geography[J]. Political Geography, 2007,26(5):525-553.
[54] Archer J C, Taylor P J. Section and Party:A Political Geography of American Presidential Elections, from Andrew Jackson to Ronald Reagan[M]. Chichester:Research Studies Press Limited, 1981:71-83.
[55] Webster G R, Leib J I. Whose south is it anyway? Race and the confederate battle flag in South Carolina[J]. Political Geography, 2001, 20(3):271-299.