旅游地理学视角下第二居所旅居研究

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2019.01.012

PDF(1663 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2019, Vol. 34 ›› Issue (1) : 90-98. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2019.01.012

进展与动态

旅游地理学视角下第二居所旅居研究

王金莲^1,2, 苏勤¹, 吴骁骁¹, 段圣奎¹

作者信息 +

RESEARCH ON SECOND HOME SOJOURN: A REVIEW FROM TOURISM GEOGRAPHY PERSPECTIVE

WANG Jin-lian^1,2, SU Qin¹, WU Xiao-xiao¹, DUAN Sheng-kui¹

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

后现代流动性范式下，旅游正经历从单一化的观光到多元化的生活方式转变，旅游与日常生活的界限逐步被打破。一种基于“休闲度假”与“居住生活”为一体的第二居所旅居现象方兴未艾，并因其独特的流动性特征及引发的新的“人—地”互动关系，引起学界的高度关注。本文在对国内外第二居所旅居发展历程进行梳理的基础上，以旅游地理学“人—地”关系为研究脉络，对第二居所旅居研究内容进行归纳，并总结出基于“人—地”关系的研究内容体系。对比国内外研究成果，发现我国现有研究对第二居所旅居引发的新的“人—地”关系关注相对较少，整体上还处于起步阶段。最后，基于旅游地理学的本质特征，按照人地关系理论的“要素与结构—特性与演化—作用与机制—协调与优化”的研究主线，对未来第二居所旅居研究提出展望，以期形成具有旅游地理学特色的第二居所旅居研究的理论体系。

Abstract

The development of globalization and post-modern cities have promoted the increase of personal mobility. The phenomenon of second home sojourn, which is based on "leisure vacation" and "living life" is in the ascendant. The unique mobility characteristics of the second home sojourners and the interactive relationships between human and environment have become the frontier field and a hot topic in tourism geography research, and arouse the high concern of academic circle. This paper is based on a review of the development history of second home both at home and abroad. Taking geography's "human-environment interaction" relationship as the research themes, and summarize the content of second home research, and summed up a second home research content system based on the "human-environment interaction" relationship. In contrast to foreign research, we discovered that the research on the second home in our country pays little attention to the effects of second sojourn. There are deficiencies in the study of the sojourners' social networks, and local attachment. Finally, based on the nature of research in tourism geography and the background of China's economic development, provide some superficial suggestion on this proposition. The study aims to promote the application of tourism geography in the field of the second homes, hoped that academic circles will expand more in-depth research in this field, further enrich and improve the second home research content system. And expand the research objects and deepen the research contents of tourism geography, and to provide scientific basis for the planning, construction and sustainable development of the destinations for sojourners.

导出引用

王金莲, 苏勤, 吴骁骁, 段圣奎. 旅游地理学视角下第二居所旅居研究[J]. 人文地理. 2019, 34(1): 90-98 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2019.01.012

WANG Jin-lian, SU Qin, WU Xiao-xiao, DUAN Sheng-kui. RESEARCH ON SECOND HOME SOJOURN: A REVIEW FROM TOURISM GEOGRAPHY PERSPECTIVE[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2019, 34(1): 90-98 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2019.01.012

中图分类号： K901

参考文献

[1] Milstein T. Transformation abroad:Sojourning and the perceived enhancement of self-efficacy[J]. International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 2005,29(2):217-238.
[2] Tuan Y F. Space and Place:The Perspective of Experience[M]. Minneapolis:University of Minnesota Press, 1977:387-388.
[3] Clifford J. Routes:Travel and Translation in the Late Twentieth Century[M]. Cambridge:Harvard University Press, 1997:68-69.
[4] Ursic S, Misetic R, Misetic A. New perspectives on sustainable development of second homes in Croatia:Strategic planning or proliferation of building?[J] Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2016,216(6):80-86.
[5] 文谨,白凯,孙星.地理学视角下的出国旅居研究综述[J].地理科学进展,2013,32(7):1148-1158.[Wen Jin, Bai Kai, Sun Xing. Research on international sojourn:A review from geographical perspective[J]. Progress in Geography, 2013,32(7):1148-1158.]
[6] Hall C M, Müller D K. Tourism, Mobility and Second Homes:Between Elite Landscape and Common Ground[M]. Clevedon:Channel View Publication, 2004:1-101.
[7] Upchurcha R S, Gruberb K. The evolution of a sleeping giant:Resort time sharing[J]. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 2002,21(3):211-225.
[8] Lofgren O. On Holiday:A History of Vacationing[M]. Berkeley:University of California Press, 1999:4.
[9] Nordin U. Second homes[M]//Aldskogius H. Cultural Life, Recreation and Tourism:National Atlas of Sweden. Stockholm:Royal Swedish Academy of Science, 1993:72-79.
[10] Aldskogius H. Modelling the Evolution of Settlement Patterns:Two Studies of Vacation House Settlement[M]. Uppsala:Uppsala Universitet, 1969:6-10.
[11] Finnveden B. Den dubbla bosattningen och sommarmigrationen:Exempel fran Hallanskustens fritidsbebyggelse[J]. Svensk Geografisk Arsbok, 1960,36(3):58-84.
[12] Wolfe R I. Summer cottagers in Ontario[J]. Economic Geography, 1951,27(1):10-32.
[13] Ragatz R L. Vacation homes in the northeastern United States:Seasonality in population distribution[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 1970,60(3):447-455.
[14] Ragatz R L. Vacation housing:A missing component in urban and regional theory[J]. Land Economics, 1970,46(2):118-126.
[15] Burby R J, Donnelly T G, Weiss S F. Vacation home location:A model for simulating the residential development of rural recreation areas[J]. Regional Studies, 1972,6(4):421-439.
[16] Geisler C C, Martinson O B. Local control of land use:Profile of a problem[J]. Land Economics, 1976,52(3):371-381.
[17] Tombaugh L W. Factors influencing vacation home location[J]. Journal of Leisure Research, 1970,2(1):54-63.
[18] Coppock J T. Second Home:Curse or Blessing?[M]. Oxford:Pergamon Press, 1977:1-216.
[19] Bielckus C L. Second homes in Scandinavia[M]//Coppock J T. Second Homes:Curse or Blessing? Oxford:Pergamon Press, 1977:35-47.
[20] Coppock J T. Issues and conflicts[M]//Coppock J T. Second Homes:Curse or Blessing? Oxford:Pergamon Press, 1977:195-216.
[21] 朱晨.西方第二住宅的发展、研究与政策实践[J].中国房地产,2010(9):75-76.[Zhu Chen. The development, research and policy of second home in western countries[J]. China Real Estate, 2010(9):75-76.]
[22] Buller H, Hoggart K. The social integration of British home owners into French rural communities[J]. Journal of Rural Studies, 1994,10(2):197-210.
[23] Casado-Diaz M A. Socio-demographic impacts of residential tourism:A case study of Torrevieja, Spain[J]. International Journal of Tourism Research, 1999,1(4):223-237.
[24] King R, Warnes A M, Williams A M. Sunset lives:British retirement to the Mediterranean[M]. London:Berg, 2000:14-17.
[25] Müller D K. German second homeowners in Sweden:Some remarks on the tourism migration-nexus[J]. Revue Européenne des Migrations Internationales, 2002,18(6):67-86.
[26] 冯健,刘之浩.中国第二住宅发展的研究——动力机制、特征、效应与规划展望[J].地理学与国土研究, 2000,16(1):30-35.[Feng Jian, Liu Zhihao. On the development of China's second residence:Dynamic mechanism, characteristics, effect and prospect for planning[J]. Geography and Territorial Research, 2000,16(1):30-35.]
[27] 杨继瑞.第二居所现象的分析与思考[J].国土经济,2006(6):19-21.[Yang Jirui. The analysis of the second home phenomenon[J]. Natural Resource Economics, 2006(6):19-21.]
[28] 仝德,冯长春.旅游住宅的概念特点及市场定位分析[J].开发与建设,2006(3):35-37.[Tong De, Feng Changchun. The analysis of the concept, characteristics and market positioning of vacation property[J]. Development and Construction, 2006(3):35-37.]
[29] 姚余.浅析我国第二居所的发展现状[J].四川建筑,2013,33(3):9-30.[Yao Yu. A brief analysis of the development status of second home in China[J]. Sichuan Architecture, 2013,33(3):9-30.]
[30] 吴悦芳,徐红罡.基于流动性视角的第二居所旅游研究综述[J].地理科学进展,2012,31(6):799-807.[Wu Yuefang, Xu Honggang. A literature review of second residence tourism:Implication on mobility analysis[J]. Progress in Geography, 2012,31(6):799-807.]
[31] 保继刚,邓粒子.气候因素对度假地型第二居所需求的影响——基于云南腾冲与西双版纳的比较研究[J].热带地理,2018,38(4):487-497.[Bao Jigang, Deng Lizi. Impact of climate on vacation-oriented second home demand:A comparative study of tengchong and Xishuangbanna[J]. Tropical Geography, 2018,38(4):487-497.]
[32] 徐文雄,保继刚.对郊区型第二住宅空间分布的初步研究——以广东省佛山市为例[J].规划师,2006,22(10):71-74.[Xu Wenxiong, Bao Jigang. A preliminary research on the spatial distribution of suburban second home:A case study on Foshan city, Guangdong province[J]. Planners, 2006,22(10):71-74.]
[33] 徐文雄,保继刚.度假地型第二居所空间分布和影响研究——以三亚市为例[J].云南师范大学学报,2006,38(5):63-67.[Xu Wenxiong, Bao Jigang. On the spatial distribution and the influential factors of vacation-oriented second homes:A case study on Sanya city[J]. Journal of Yunnan Normal University, 2006,38(5):63-67.]
[34] Timothy D J. Tourism and the growth of urban ethnic islands[M]//Hall C M, Williams A M. Tourism and Migration:New Relationships Between Production and Migration. Dordrecht:Kluwer, 2002:135-152.
[35] Casado-Diaz M A, Kaiser C, Warnes A M. Northern European retired residents in nine southern European areas:Characteristics, motivations and adjustment[J]. Ageing and Society, 2004,24(3):353-381.
[36] Chaplin D. Consuming work/productive leisure:The consumption patterns of second home environments[J]. Leisure Studies, 1999,18(1):41-55.
[37] Jaakson R. Second-home domestic tourism[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 1986,13(3):357-391.
[38] Williams D R, Kaltenborn B P. Leisure places and modernity:The use and meaning of recreational cottages in Norway and the USA[M]//Crouch D. Leisure/Tourism Geographies:Practices and Geographical Knowledge. London:Routledge, 1999:214-230.
[39] Wolfe R I. Summer cottages in Ontario:Purpose-built for an inessential purpose[M]//Coppock J T. Second Home:Curse or Blessing? Oxford:Pergamon Press, 1977:17-34.
[40] Halseth G. Cottage Country in Transition:A Social Geography of Change and Contention in the Rural-recreational Countryside[M]. Montreal:McGills-Queen's University Press, 1998:52-53.
[41] Kaltenborn B P. Nature of place attachment:A study among recreation homeowners in Southern Norway[J]. Leisure Sciences, 1997, 19(3):175-189.
[42] Löfgren O. On Holiday:A History of Vacationing[M]. Berkeley:University of California Press, 1999:89-156.
[43] Breuer T. Retirement migration or rather second-home tourism? German senior citizens on the Canary islands[J]. Die Erde, 2005, 136(3):313-333.
[44] 薛帅.第二居所消费者购买行为影响因素、特点及模式探究——以海南省、山西省两地人群为例[J].中山大学研究生学刊(自然科学、医学版), 2010,31(4):57-67.[Xue Shuai. Research on the influencing factors, features and models on purchasing behaviors of China's second home owners:Taking the people in Hainan and Shanxi as the Example[J]. Journal of the Graduates Sun Yat-sen University (Natural Sciences Medicine), 2010,31(4):57-67.]
[45] Michelle N, Nessa W. Second-home owners:Escaping, investing or retiring?[J]. Tourism Geographies, 2010,12(4):546-567.
[46] 冯健,周一星.郊区化进程中北京城市内部迁居及相关空间行为——基于千份问卷调查的分析[J].地理研究, 2004,23(2):227-242.[Feng Jian, Zhou Yixing. Intra-urban migration and correlative spatial behavior in Beijing in the process of suburbanization:Based on 1000 questionnaires[J]. Geographical Research, 2004,23(2):227-242.]
[47] Müller D K. The attractiveness of second home areas in Sweden:A quantitative analysis[J]. Current Issues in Tourism, 2006,9(4):335-350.
[48] Overvag K. Second homes and urban growth in the Oslo area, Norway[J]. Norsk Geografisk Tid skrift-Norwegian Journal of Geography, 2009,63(3):154-165.
[49] Harvey D. The Condition of Postmodernity:An Enquiry into the Orgins of Cultural Change[M]. Oxford:Basil Blackwell, 1989:114-115.
[50] Shellito B A. Second-home distributions in the USA's Upper Great Lakes States:Analysis and implications[M]//McIntyre N, Williams D, McHugh K, et al. Multiple Dwelling and Tourism:Negotiating Place, Home and Identity. Cambrige:Cabi, 2006:194-206.
[51] Wong B K, Musa G, Zarina A. Malaysia my second home:The influence of push and pull motivations on satisfaction[J]. Tourism Management, 2017,61(8):394-410.
[52] Müller D K. German second home owners in the Swedish countryside:On the internationalization of the leisure space[J]. Journal of Architecture & Building Science, 1999,50(3):1017-1022.
[53] Hiltunen M J, Rehunen A. Second home mobility in Finland:Patterns, practices and relations of leisure oriented mobile lifestyle[J]. Fennia, 2014,192(1):1-22.
[54] Dallen J T. Recreational second homes in the United States:Development issues and contemporary patterns[M]//Hall C M, Müller D K. Tourism, Mobility and Second Homes:Between Elite Landscape and Common Ground. Clevedon:Channel View Publication, 2004:133-148.
[55] Michelle C K, Rivera R. Protecting the idyll but not the environment:Second homes, amenity migration and rural exclusion in Washington State[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2012,106(3):174-182.
[56] Adamiak C. Cottage sprawl:Spatial development of second homes in Bory Tucholskie, Poland[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2016,147(3):96-106.
[57] Müller D K, Hall M, Keen D, et al. Second home tourism impact, planning and management[M]//Hall C M, Müller D K. Tourism, Mobility and Second Homes:Between Elite Landscape and Common Ground. Clevedon:Channel View Publication, 2004:112-187.
[58] Hoggart K, Buller H. Property agents as gatekeepers in British house purchases in rural France[J]. Geoforum, 1994,25(2):173-187.
[59] Jansson B, Müller D K. Fritidsboende i Kvarken. Ett forskningsprojekt i uppdrag av Kvarkenrådet. (Interreg ⅢA)[J]. Vasa, 2003,32(3):123-129.
[60] Pirie G H, Kitchin R, Thrift N, et al. International encyclopedia of human geography[J]. Amsterdam, Elsevier, 2009,48(1):242-251.
[61] Tjørve E, Flognfeldt T, Tjørve K M C. The effects of distance and belonging on second-home markets[J]. Tourism Geographies, 2013, 15(2):268-291.
[62] 朱晨.中国中心城市第二住宅的地理空间分布特征[J].经济地理, 2006,26(6):945-948.[Zhu Chen. An analysis of second homes geographic distribution characters of Chinese regional central cities[J]. Economic Geography, 2006,26(6):945-948.]
[63] 张仲伍,孙桂平,赵志超.我国第二住宅空间分布特征的初步研究[J]. 河北师范大学学报(自然科学版), 2005,29(3):309-312.[Zhang Zhongwu, Sun Guiping, Zhao Zhichao. Study of the second house space in China[J]. Journal of Hebei Normal University (Natural Science Edition), 2005,29(3):309-312.]
[64] Atkinson R, Picken F, Tranter B. Home and away from home:The urban regional dynamics of second home ownership in Australia[J]. Urban Research & Practice, 2015,2(1):1-7.
[65] Müller D K. Second homes in rural areas:Reflections on a troubled history[J]. Norwegian Journal of Geography, 2011,65(3):137-143.
[66] Mendez L A. Second Homes in Mexico:An Exploration of the Social Connections of International Residents in the City of Merida[M]. Waterloo:University of Waterloo, 2017:1-85.
[67] Gallent N. Bridging social capital and the resource potential of second homes:The case of Stintino, Sardinia[J]. Journal of Rural Studies, 2015,38(4):99-108.
[68] 吴悦芳.三亚第二居所发展及社会-空间特征研究研究[D]. 广州:中山大学,2010:65-98.[Wu Yuefang. Second Home Development and the Socio:Spatial Characteristic of Sanya[D]. Guangzhou:Sun Yat-sen University, 2010:65-98.]
[69] 黄向,保继刚, Wall Geoffrey.场所依赖(place attachment):一种游憩行为现象的研究框架[J].旅游学刊,2006,21(6):19-24.[Huang Xiang, Bao Jigang, Wall Geoffrey. Place attachment:A conceptual framework for understanding recreational behavior[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2006,21(6):19-24.]
[70] Stedman R C. Understanding place attachment among second home owners[J]. American Behavioral Scientist, 2006,50(2):187-205.
[71] McIntire N, Pavlovich K. Changing places:Amenity coastal communities in transition[M]//Hall C M, Müller D K. Tourism, Mobility and Second Homes:Between Elite Landscape and Common Ground. Clevedon:Channel View Publication, 2004:239-261.
[72] Lew A A. Consumption-led mobilized urbanism:Socio-spatial separation in the second-home city of Sanya[J]. Mobilities, 2015,10(1):136-154.
[73] Dias J A, Correia A, Lopez F J M. The meaning of rental second homes and places:The owners' perspectives[J]. Tourism Geographies, 2015,17(2):244-261.
[74] Müller D K. Second homes in rural areas:Reflections on a troubled history[J]. Norwegian Journal of Geography. 2011,65(3):137-143.
[75] Kelly G, Hosking K. Nonpermanent residents, place attachment, and "Sea change" communities[J]. Environment & Behavior, 2008, 40(4):575-594.
[76] 聂淼.北京郊区第二居所业主地方依恋探索性研究[D].北京:北京大学,2013:32-55.[Nie Miao. Exploratory Research on the Place Attachment of Second Home Owners in the Suburbs of Beijing[D]. Beijing:Beijing University, 2013:32-55.]
[77] 朱晨.西方度假住宅研究进展[J].人文地理,2011,26(3):24-28.[Zhu Chen. A research on the development of vacation property in western countries[J]. Human Geography, 2011,26(3):24-28.]
[78] Gallent N. The social value of second homes in rural communities in housing[J]. Housing Theory & Society, 2014,31(2):174-191.
[79] Halseth G, Hall C M, Müller D K. The "cottage" privilege:Increasingly elite landscapes of second homes in Canada[M]//Hall C M, Müller D K. Tourism, Mobility and Second Homes:Between Elite Landscape and Common Ground. Clevedon:Channel View Publication, 2004:35-54.
[80] Mathieson A, Wall G. Tourism:Economic, Physical and Social Impacts[M]. London:Longman, 1982:212-245.
[81] Dijst M, Lanzendorf M, Barendregt A, et al. Second homes in Germany and the Netherlands:Ownership and travel impact explained[J]. Tijdschrift Voor Economische En Sociale Geografie, 2005,96(2):139-152.
[82] Kaltenborn B P, Andersen O, Nellemann C. Amenity development in the Norwegian mountains effects of second home owner environmental attitudes on preferences for alternative development options[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2009,91(4):195-201.
[83] Gallent N, Tewdwrjones M. Second homes and the UK planning system[J]. Planning Practice & Research, 2001,16(1):59-69.
[84] Alipour H, Hossein G T, Hassanzadeh B. Second home tourism impact and governance:Evidence from the Caspian Sea region of Iran[J]. Ocean & Coastal Management, 2017,136(2):165-176.
[85] Marcouiller D W, Green G P, Deller S C, et al. Recreational Homes and Regional Development:A Case Study from the Upper Great Lakes States[M]. Madison:Cooperative Extension Publications, 1998:102-104.
[86] 黄震方,黄睿.基于人地关系的旅游地理学理论透视与学术创新[J].地理研究,2015,34(1):15-26.[Huang Zhenfang, Huang Rui. The theoretical perspective and academic innovation of tourism geography based on human-environment interactions[J]. Geographical Research, 2015,34(1):15-26.]
[87] 保继刚,张捷,徐红罡,等.中国旅游地理研究:在他乡与故乡之间[J].地理研究,2017,36(5):803-823.[Bao Jigang, Zhang Jie, Xu Honggang, et al. Tourism geography in China:Between hometown and alien land[J]. Geographical Research, 2017,36(5):803-823.]
[88] 周尚意,唐顺英,戴俊骋". 地方" 概念对人文地理学各分支意义的辨识[J].人文地理,2011,26(6):10-13.[Zhou Shangyi, Tang Shunying, Dai Juncheng. Identification of the significance of the concept of place to branches under human geography[J]. Human Geography, 2011,26(6):10-13.]