景观社会：当代旅游研究的情境主义视角

孙佼佼; 谢彦君

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.03.002

PDF(1733 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2020, Vol. 35 ›› Issue (3) : 10-16. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.03.002

进展与动态

景观社会：当代旅游研究的情境主义视角

孙佼佼¹, 谢彦君^2,3

作者信息 +

THE SOCIETY OF THE SPECTACLE: A NEW RESEARCH PERSPECTIVE OF MODERN TOURISM FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF SITUATIONISM

SUN Jiao-jiao¹, XIE Yan-jun^2,3

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

景观社会理论范式可以溯源于马克思的消费理论，如今已成为当代颇具解释力的社会研究范式之一，对旅游研究尤具启发性。本文梳理了景观社会范式的理论渊源，归纳了其本体论、认识论和方法论，说明了它为景观消费、景观空间文化、情境体验以及后现代景观生产等领域提供的理论框架与方法进路，阐释了其核心概念群和基本理念，展示了景观社会理论范式与旅游现象和研究的双向关系。该研究亦梳理了景观社会范式在国内外旅游领域中已有的实践与方法变迁，进而指出该范式日益丰富的未来领域与本土化实践，为旅游体验研究领域的拓展和深化提供新的理论视角，为分析和解决旅游发展中的社会、文化、空间、消费，以及景观建构等问题提供新的理论路径。

Abstract

The society of the spectacle is a theory developed by Guy Debord, the founder of the Situationism International. It originated from the consume theory of Carl Max and has become one of the theories with the most explanatory power in social science. This paper explains how the theory of the society of the spectacle not only involves consumption, it is also the philosophy of art, design, planning, individual experience and gaze in tourism study. This article also summarizes the theoretical origin of the theory of the society of the spectacle; explains its ontology, epistemology and methodology; introduces its core conceptions and ideas; summarizes the bidirectional relationship between tourism and the society of spectacle paradigm; interprets its function in the field of spectacle consumption, spectacle space culture, situation experience, and the post-modern spectacle production. This research also illustrates the application of the theory of the society of the spectacle in tourism study and the transitions of its method. The theories in Debord's system are closely connected with the tourism theories from MacCannell, Boorstin, and Urry, etc., and shows a more systematical structure as a whole paradigm. For tourism study, the society of the spectacle as a paradigm offers a theory system to explain the supply and demand of modern tourism. At last， this research points out the increasing fields of this paradigm an its local practice in China in order to offer a new theoretical entrance for the analysis of social, cultural, spatial and consumption issues in the development of tourism.

导出引用

孙佼佼, 谢彦君. 景观社会：当代旅游研究的情境主义视角[J]. 人文地理. 2020, 35(3): 10-16 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.03.002

SUN Jiao-jiao, XIE Yan-jun. THE SOCIETY OF THE SPECTACLE: A NEW RESEARCH PERSPECTIVE OF MODERN TOURISM FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF SITUATIONISM[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2020, 35(3): 10-16 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.03.002

中图分类号： F590

参考文献

[1] Debord G. The Society of the Spectacle[M]. Nicholson-Smith D, trans. New York:Zone Books, 1995:12,13,111,113,120,125,141.
[2] Debord G. The commodity as spectacle[M]//Durham M G, Kellner D M, eds. Media and Cultural Studies:Keyworks. Malden:Blackwell Publishing, 2006:117-121.
[3] 居伊·德波.景观社会[M].王昭凤,译.南京:南京大学出版社,2006:13,77,173,174.[Debord G. The Society of the Spectacle[M]. Wang Zhaofeng, trans. Nanjing:Nanjing University Press, 2006:13,77,173, 174.]
[4] 陈丽坤. 城镇化进程下民族旅游社区景观商品化研究——以西双版纳近郊傣楼景观为例[J].旅游学刊,2015,30(11):51-62.[Chen Likun. Commoditization of ethnic tourism community landscapes under urbanization:A case study of Xishuangbanna inner suburban Dai vernacular houses[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2015,30(11):51-62.]
[5] Hecken T, Grzenia A. Situationism[M]//Klimke M, Scharloth J, eds. 1968 in Europe:A History of Protest and Activism, 1956-1977. New York:Palgrave Macmillan, 2008:23-32.
[6] Crary J. Spectacle, attention, counter-memory[J]. October, 1989,50:96-107.
[7] 杨珺婷,蔡君.旅游博客中的"景观" 与"观景"[J].北京林业大学学报(社会科学版),2018,17(1):53-58.[Yang Junting, Cai Jun. "Spectacle" and "gaze" in travel blogs[J]. Journal of Beijing Forestry University (Social Sciences), 2018,17(1):53-58.]
[8] 刘润,杨永春,王梅梅,等.转型期中国城市更新背景下旅游地视觉景观生产研究——以成都宽窄巷为例[J].人文地理,2016,31(3):136-144.[Liu Run, Yang Yongchun, Wang Meimei, et al. The visual landscape production of tourist destination under the circumstance of Chinese urban regeneration in transition period:A case study of Kuanzhai Alleys[J]. Human Geography, 2016,31(3):136-144.]
[9] 赵红梅,李庆雷.旅游情境下的景观"制造" 与地方认同[J].广西民族大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2011,33(3):14-20.[Zhao Hongmei, Li Qinglei. The manufactured landscape and local identification in the context of tourism[J]. Journal of Guangxi University for Nationalities (Philosophy and Social Science Edition), 2011,33(3):14-20.]
[10] 朱旭佳.视觉景观生产与乡村空间重构[D].南京:南京大学,2019.[Zhu Xujia. The Production of Spectacle and the Restructuring of Rural Local Space[D]. Nanjing:Nanjing University, 2019.]
[11] 张涵. Debord的"景观社会" 理论评析[J].山东大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2009(3):126-131.[Zhang Han. Comments on Debord's theory of "the society of the spectacle"[J]. Journal of Shandong University (Philosophy and Social Science Edition), 2009(3):126-131.]
[12] 张一兵.德波和他的《景观社会》[M]//居伊·德波.景观社会.王昭凤,译.南京:南京大学出版社,2006:10.[Zhang Yibing. Debord and his the society of spectacle[M]//Debord G. The Society of the Spectacle. Wang Zhaofeng, trans. Nanjing:Nanjing University Press, 2006:10.]
[13] Gotham K F, Krier D A. From the culture industry to the society of the spectacle:Critical theory and the situationist international[J]. Current Perspectives in Social Theory, 2008,25(25):155-192.
[14] Osumare H. Becoming a "society of the spectacle":Ghanaian Hiplife music and corporate recolonization[J]. Popular Music and Society, 2014,37(2):187-209.
[15] Swyngedouw E. The strange respectability of the situationist city in the society of the spectacle[J]. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 2002,26(1):153-165.
[16] Kaplan R L. Between mass society and revolutionary praxis:The contradictions of Guy Debord's society of the spectacle[J]. European Journal of Cultural Studies, 2012,15(4):457-478.
[17] Boorstin D. The Image:A Guide to Pseudo-Events in America[M]. New York:Atheneum, 1964:16-22,77-117.
[18] 仰海峰.商品社会、景观社会、符号社会——西方社会批判理论的一种变迁[J].哲学研究,2003(10):21-26.[Yang Haifeng. Society of the commodity, society of the spectacle and society of the signs:A variance of the western social critique theory[J]. Philosophical Research, 2003(10):21-26.]
[19] 仰海峰.德波与景观社会批判[J].南京社会科学,2008(10):9-16.[Yang Haifeng. Debord and the criticism on the society of the spectacle[J]. Social Science in Nanjing, 2008(10):9-16.]
[20] Bridger A J. Visualising Manchester:Exploring new ways to study urban environments with reference to situationist theory, the dérive, and qualitative research[J]. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 2014,11(1):78-97.
[21] McGarrigle C. The construction of locative situations:Locative media and the Situationist International, recuperation or redux?[J]. Digital Creativity, 2010,21(1):55-62.
[22] Davis J B. Commentary:Tourism research and social theory expanding the focus[J]. Tourism Geographies, 2001,3(2):125-134.
[23] Angelini A. Ludic maps and capitalist spectacle in Rio de Janeiro[J]. Geoforum, 2015,65:421-430.
[24] Whybrow N. Situation venice:Towards a performative ‘explanation’ of a city[J]. Research in Drama Education:The Journal of Applied Theatre and Performance, 2011,16(2):279-298.
[25] 王昭风.景观社会的文化——一种否定的文化或文化的否定[J]. 山东社会科学,2006(1):38-41.[Wang Zhaofeng. The culture of the society of the spectacle:A culture of denial or a denial of the culture[J]. Shandong Social Sciences, 2006(1):38-41.]
[26] 黄应全.当代资本主义等于形象社会?——如何理解居伊·德波的《景象社会》[J].文艺研究,2009(4):134-142.[Huang Yingquan. The contemporary capitalism equals to the society of image? How to understand Debord's "The Society of the Spectacle"[J]. Literature & Art Studies, 2009(4):134-142.]
[27] 石可.景观社会与后布莱希特式表演[J].新美术,2013(2):24-39.[Shi Ke. The society of the spectacle and the performance of postBrecht[J]. New Art, 2013(2):24-39.]
[28] Debord G. Dérive[EB/OL].(2019-05-25)[2019-10-17]. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dérive#cite_ref-Debord1958Definitions_2-1.
[29] Debord G. Situationist International online[EB/OL].(2018-08-07)[2019-10-17].https://www.cddc.vt.edu/sionline/si/definitions.html.
[30] Debord G. Détournement[EB/OL].(2019-09-18)[2019-10-17]. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Détournement#cite_ref-8.
[31] McDonough T F. Situationist space[J]. October, 1994,67:58-77.
[32] 王昭风.从景观空间中突围——一种心理地理学的批判[J].现代哲学,2004(4):52-57.[Wang Zhaofeng. The breakout from the spectacle space:A critic of Psychogeography[J]. Modern Philosophy, 2004(4):52-57.]
[33] 胡娟,叶忠元.新巴比伦:基于日常生活的情境空间建构[J].国际城市规划,2010,25(1):77-81.[Hu Juan, Ye Zhongyuan. New Babylon:The construction of the situational space based on daily life[J]. Urban Planning International, 2010,25(1):77-81.]
[34] 胡娟.对现代理性主义的反思——"情境主义" 城市思想研究[J]. 华中建筑,2010,28(5):14-17.[Hu Juan. Reflection on modern rationalism:The study on the urban planning thoughts of Situationism[J]. Huazhong Architecture, 2010,28(5):14-17.]
[35] Bridger A J. Psychogeographical Counter-tour Guiding:Theory and Practice[M]. Estoril:Escola Superior de Hotelaria e Turismo do Estoril, 2015:48-54.
[36] Pretes M. Postmodern tourism:The Santa Claus industry[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 1995,22(1):1-15.
[37] Venkatesh A. Postmodernism, consumer culture and the society of the spectacle[J]. Advances in Consumer Research, 1992,19:199-202.
[38] 张一兵.颠倒再颠倒的景观世界——Debord 《景观社会》的文本学解读[J].南京大学学报(哲学·人文科学·社会科学),2006,43(1):5-17.[Zhang Yibing. Reversing the reversal of the world spectacle:A textual reading of Guy Debord's society of the spectacle[J]. Journal of Nanjing University (Philosophy, Humanities and Social Sciences), 2006,43(1):5-17.]
[39] 李拉扬.旅游凝视:反思与重构[J].旅游学刊,2015,30(2):118-126.[Li Layang. Tourist gaze:Rethinking and reconstructing[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2015,30(2):118-126.]
[40] MacCannell D. The Tourist:A New Theory of the Leisure Class[M]. Berkeley:University of California Press, 1976:14,41.
[41] Urry J. The tourist gaze "revisited"[J]. American Behavioral Scientist, 1992,36(2):172-186.
[42] 斯蒂芬·贝斯特,凯尔纳.后现代转向[M].陈刚,等,译.南京:南京大学出版社,2002:114.[Best S, Kellner D. The Postmodern Turn[M]. Chen Gang, trans. Nanjing:Nanjing University Press, 2002:114.]
[43] Gotham K F. Marketing Mardi Gras:Commodification, spectacle and the political economy of tourism in New Orleans[J]. Urban Studies, 2002,39(10):1735-1756.
[44] 黄燕,赵振斌,褚玉杰,等.互联网时代的旅游地视觉表征:多元建构与循环[J]. 旅游学刊,2015,30(6):91-101.[Huang Yan, Zhao Zhenbin, Chu Yujie, et al. The visual representation of tourism destinations in the internet era:Multiple constructions and circulations[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2015,30(6):91-101.]
[45] Joyce A. Reclaiming the dérive:The tourist, the souvenir, and the search for the utopic[J]. The Word Hoard, 2015,1(3):115-123.
[46] Crang M. Knowing, tourism and practices of vision[M]//Crouch D. Leisure/Tourism Geographies:Practices and Geographical Knowledge. London:Routledge, 1999:238-257.
[47] Rollason C. The passageways of Paris:Walter Benjamin's Arcades project and contemporary cultural debate in the West[M]//Rollason C, Mittapalli R, eds. Modern Criticism. New Delhi:Atlantic Publishers and Distributors, 2002:262-296.
[48] Canestrino R, Magliocca P, Nigro C. Drivers and implications of medical tourism:A neo-institutional perspective[J]. Sinergie Italian Journal of Management, 2015,11:271-290.
[49] 谢小芹.旅游景观是如何被制造出来的?——基于黔东南州J村苗寨旅游开发的实证调研[J].中国行政管理,2017(1):90-95.[Xie Xiaoqin. How a tourism landscape is made? An investigation on tourism development of J Miao village in Qiandongnan[J]. Chinese Public Administration, 2017(1):90-95.]
[50] 刘昆.空间生产机制下城市景观的拼贴[J].人文地理,2015,30(1):50-55.[Liu Kun. The collage of cityscape under mechanisms of the production of space[J]. Human Geography, 2015,30(1):50-55.]
[51] 周宪.审美现代性批判[M].北京:商务印书馆,2005:159.[Zhou Xian. Critique of Aesthetic Modernity[M]. Beijing:The Commercial Press, 2005:159.]
[52] 钱俊希,朱竑.新文化地理学的理论统一性与话题多样性[J].地理研究,2015,34(3):422-436.[Qian Junxi, Zhu Hong. Theoretical unity and thematic diversity in new cultural geography[J]. Geographical Research, 2015,34(3):422-436.]
[53] 秦虹,苏鑫.城市更新[M].北京:中信出版社,2018:12.[Qin Hong, Su Xin. Urban Regeneration[M]. Beijing:CITIC Press, 2018:12.]
[54] 李佳一.论景观社会的城市文化新景观[J].艺术百家,2013(A02):62-68.[Li Jiayi. On the new spectacle of city culture in the society of spectacle[J]. Hundred Schools in Arts, 2013(A02):62-68.]
[55] 于初初,赵凯茜,姚朋.基于时间和空间差异的事件性景观服务设施设计研究——以河北省第二届园林博览会为例[J].北京林业大学学报,2019,41(1):109-118.[Yu Chuchu, Zhao Kaixi, Yao Peng. Design and planning of infrastructures in event landscape based on time and space difference:A case study of the 2nd Hebei Garden Exposition[J]. Journal of Beijing Forestry University, 2019,41(1):109-118.]
[56] Palang H, Külvik M, Printsmann A, et al. Revisiting futures:Integrating culture, care and time in landscapes[J]. Landscape Ecology, 2019,34(7):1807-1823.
[57] Barnard A. The legacy of the Situationist International:The production of situations of creative resistance[J]. Capital & Class, 2004,28(3):103-124.
[58] Rustin M. Sport, spectacle and society:Understanding the Olympics[M]//Poynter G, MacRuryL, eds. Olympic Cities:2012 and the Remaking of London. London:Routledge, 2017:21-40.
[59] Gotham K F. Theorizing urban spectacles[J]. City, 2005,9(2):225-246.
[60] McMichael C. Clearly blown away by the end of the morning's drama':Spectacle, pacification and the 2010 World Cup, South Africa[J]. Socialist Studies, 2013,9(2):111-129.
[61] Richards G. The festivalization of society or the socialization of festivals? The case of Catalunya[M]//Richards G. Cultural Tourism:Global and Local Perspectives. London:Psychology Press, 2007:257-280.
[62] Rojek C. Ways of Escape[M]. Basingstoke:MacMillan, 1993:137-138.
[63] Stone P, Sharpley R. Consuming dark tourism:A thanatological perspective[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2008,35(2):574-595.
[64] Gotham K F. Critical theory and Katrina:Disaster, spectacle and immanent critique[J]. City, 2007,11(1):81-99.
[65] Crysler C G. Violence and empathy:National museums and the spectacle of society[J]. Traditional Dwellings and Settlements Review, 2006,17(2):19-38.
[66] Morten R, Stone P R, Jarratt D. Dark tourism as psychogeography:An initial exploration[M]//Stone P R, Hartmann R, Seaton T, Sharpley R, White L, eds. The Palgrave Handbook of Dark Tourism Study. London:Palgrave Macmillan, 2018:227-255.
[67] 郑诗琳,薛熙明,朱竑.新生的旅游地:灾后重建背景下的地方重构——以四川省彭州市白鹿镇为例[J].旅游学刊,2017,32(5):59-70.[Zheng Shilin, Xue Ximing, Zhu Hong. Newborn tourist place:The place reconstruction in "post-disaster recovery" contextualized Bailu village, Pengzhou city, Sichuan province[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2017,32(5):59-70.]
[68] 郑荣娟,白凯,马耀峰.基于旅华美国游客手绘认知地图的中国旅游目的地意象研究[J]. 人文地理,2014,29(3):150-158.[Zheng Rongjuan, Bai Kai, Ma Yaofeng. Research on the China destination image based on American tourists' sketch cognitive map[J]. Human Geography, 2014,29(3):150-158.]
[69] 魏鹏,石培基,杜婷.基于空间意象的旅游者空间决策过程研究[J]. 旅游学刊,2015,30(9):43-51.[Wei Peng, Shi Peiji, Du Ting. Tourists' spatial decision-making process based on space images[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2015,30(9):43-51.]
[70] 蒋春燕,冯学钢,凌善金.基于视觉形态的旅游地图符号分类探究[J].桂林旅游高等专科学校学报,2008,19(3):355-359.[Jiang Chunyan, Feng Xuegang, Lin Shanjin. Research on the new classification of tourist map symbols based on the visual patterns[J]. Journal of Guilin Institute of Tourism, 2008,19(3):355-359.]
[71] 张一兵.景观意识形态及其颠覆——Debord 《景观社会》的文本学解读[J].学海,2005(5):67-72.[Zhang Yibing. The ideology of the spectacle and its overtune[J]. Academia Bimestris, 2005(5):67-72.]