ADVANCES AND PROSPECTS IN NIGHTTIME TOURISM RESEARCH HOME AND ABROAD
TANG Cheng-cai1,2, XIAO Xiao-yue1,2
1. School of Tourism Sciences, Beijing International Studies University, Beijing 100024, China;
2. Research Center of Beijing Tourism Development, Beijing 100024, China
摘要 随着夜间经济推动与旅游高质量发展需要,夜间旅游现象日益普遍,并受到各地政府的支持和国内外学者的关注。以Web of Science和中国知网等数据库为数据源,对境内外夜间旅游相关研究进行系统梳理分析。研究发现,境外学者重点关注了夜间旅游开发的载体和体验类型、利益相关者及夜间旅游带来的积极和消极影响;境内夜间旅游研究发展呈现出阶段性特点,学者们主要探究了夜间旅游概念特征、产品类型、发展动力及影响。境内外相关研究以定性研究方法居多且主要聚焦于城市地区,对夜间旅游发展演化规律、社会生态影响、服务管理等内容仍缺乏深入系统的探究。丰富研究内容、完善研究方法以及拓展研究区域是未来深化夜间旅游研究的方向和目标。
Abstract：With the promotion of nighttime economy and the need of high-quality development of tourism,nighttime tourism is becoming more and more popular. The development of nighttime tourism has been supported by local governments in many regions and has attracted the attention of scholars at home and abroad.With Web of Science and CNKI as the main data sources, researches related to nighttime tourism were combed and analyzed systematically. Through the analysis of nighttime tourism literature at home and abroad, it is found that scholars outbound mainly focus on the carriers and types, stakeholders and the positive and negative impacts of nighttime tourism; domestic research shows the characteristics of stage development and scholars mainly focus on the concepts and characteristics, product types, driving forces and influences of nighttime tourism. However, most studies on nighttime tourism at home and abroad only use qualitative research methods and lack the widely usage of multiple scientific research methods. At the same time,urban areas are the study cases mainly chosen and there is a lack of variety of study cases. Last but not least,there is still a lack of in-depth and systematic research on the development and evolution of nighttime tourism. Also, the social and ecological impact brought by nighttime tourism, the service quality and management of nighttime tourism are not fully investigated either. Therefore, the enrichment of research content, the improvement of research methods and the expansion of research areas are the direction and main goals for deepening future research of nighttime tourism.
唐承财, 肖小月. 境内外夜间旅游研究综述与展望[J]. 人文地理, 2022, 37(3): 21-29,98.
TANG Cheng-cai, XIAO Xiao-yue. ADVANCES AND PROSPECTS IN NIGHTTIME TOURISM RESEARCH HOME AND ABROAD. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY, 2022, 37(3): 21-29,98.
Harvey D.The Condition of Postmodernity:An Enquiry into the Origins of Cultural Change[M].Oxford:Blackwell Publishing, 1990:260-307.
[2]
靳泓,应文.城市夜间经济研究综述[J].灯与照明,2018,42(1):26-30.[Jin Hong, Ying Wen.A review of night-time economic research[J].Light&Lighting, 2018,42(1):26-30.]
[3]
李小蒙,房京臣,张明雪,等.乡村夜间旅游开发研究[J].科技经济导刊,2019,27(27):104,103.[Li Xiaomeng, Fang Jingchen, Zhang Mingxue, et al.Study on the development of rural night tourism[J].Technology and Economic Guide, 2019,27(27):104,103.]
[4]
毛中根,龙燕妮,叶胥.夜间经济理论研究进展[J].经济学动态,2020(2):103-116.[Mao Zhonggen, Long Yanni, Ye Xu.Research progress on night-time economy[J].Economic Perspectives, 2020(2):103-116.]
[5]
Rowe D, Stevenson D, Tomsen S A, et al.The city after dark:Cultural planning and governance of the night-time economy in Paramatta[R].Penrith South:University of Western Sydney, 2008:11.
[6]
徐颖,储德平,陈银春,等.基于Web of Science的国际夜间经济研究热点与脉络[J].资源开发与市场,2021,37(3):320-326.[Xu Ying,Chu Deping, Chen Yinchun, et al.Research highlights and evolution of international night-time economy on Web of Science[J] Resource Development&Market, 2021,37(3):320-326.]
[7]
Zmy?lony P, Pawlusiński R.Tourism and the night-time economy:The perspective article[J].Tourism Review, 2019,75(1):194-197.
[8]
Collison F M, Poe K."Astronomical Tourism":The astronomy and dark sky program at Bryce Canyon National Park[J].Tourism Management Perspectives, 2013,7:1-15.
[9]
Ingle M.Making the most of "nothing":Astro-tourism, the Sublime and the Karoo as a "space destination"[J].Transformation:Critical Perspectives on Southern Africa, 2010,74(1):87-111.
[10]
AubéM, Roby J.Sky brightness levels before and after the creation of the first international dark sky reserve, Mont-Mégantic Observatory, Québec, Canada[J].Journal of Quantitative Spectroscopy and Radiative Transfer, 2014,139:52-63.
[11]
Giordano E.Outdoor lighting design as a tool for tourist development:The case of Valladolid[J].European Planning Studies, 2018,26(1):55-74.
[12]
Giordano E, Ong C-E.Light festivals, policy mobilities and urban tourism[J].Tourism Geographies, 2017,19(5):699-716.
[13]
Alves T.Art, light and landscape new agendas for urban development[J].European Planning Studies, 2007,15(9):1247-1260.
[14]
Evans G.Hold back the night:Nuit Blanche and all-night events in capital cities[J].Current Issues in Tourism, 2012,15(1/2):35-49.
[15]
Wolf I D, Croft D B.Observation techniques that minimize impacts on wildlife and maximize visitor satisfaction in night-time tours[J].Tourism Management Perspectives, 2012,4:164-175.
[16]
Orange H.Flaming smokestacks:Kojo Moe and night-time factory tourism in Japan[J].Journal of Contemporary Archaeology, 2017,4(1):59-72.
[17]
Bristow R S, Jenkins I S.Geography of fear:Fright tourism in urban revitalization[J].Journal of Policy Research in Tourism, Leisure and Events, 2020,12(2):262-275.
[18]
Tsai C-T L.Culinary tourism and night markets in Taiwan[J].International Journal of Business and Information, 2013,8(2):247-266.
[19]
Hsieh A-T, Chang J.Shopping and tourist night markets in Taiwan[J].Tourism Management, 2006,27(1):138-145.
[20]
Eldridge A, Smith A.Tourism and the night:Towards a broader understanding of nocturnal city destinations[J].Journal of Policy Research in Tourism, Leisure and Events, 2019,11(3):371-379.
[21]
Giovanardi M, Lucarelli A, Decosta P LE.Co-performing tourism places:The"Pink Night "festival[J].Annals of Tourism Research,2014,44:102-115.
[22]
Chevrier M-H.Nocturnal ritual activities in tourist development of pilgrimage cities[J].Journal of Policy Research in Tourism, Leisure and Events, 2019,11(3):436-454.
[23]
Huang W-J, Wang P." All that's best of dark and bright ":Day and night perceptions of Hong Kong cityscape[J].Tourism Management, 2018,66:274-286.
[24]
???,??.The effect of difference between day and night on the experience of cultural heritage tourists[J].Journal of Tourism Studies, 2019,31(2):109-132.
[25]
Derrien M M, Stokowski P A.Discursive constructions of night sky experiences:Imagination and imaginaries in national park visitor narratives[J].Annals of Tourism Research, 2020,85:103038.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.annals.2020.103038.
[26]
Cook M, Edensor T.Cycling through dark space:Apprehending landscape otherwise[J].Mobilities, 2017,12(1):1-19.
[27]
Chen N, Wang Y, Li J, et al.Examining structural relationships among night tourism experience, lovemarks, brand satisfaction, and brand loyalty on" cultural heritage night"in South Korea[J].Sustainability, 2020,12(17):6723.
[28]
Chang J, Hsieh A-T.Leisure motives of eating out in night markets[J].Journal of Business Research, 2006,59(12):1276-1278.
[29]
Kuo C-T, Chung M-L, Kuo F-C.To explore Taiwanese night markets culture and tourism experience and behavior[J].Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2012,40:435-440.
[30]
Chou H-J.The effect of the visitor's consumption experience and tourism image on tourist satisfaction and revisit intention of Taiwan's night markets[J].GSTF Journal on Business Review (GBR),2013,3(1):6-11.
[31]
Williams R.Night spaces:Darkness, deterritorialization, and social control[J].Space and Culture, 2008,11(4):514-532.
[32]
Eldridge A, Roberts M.A comfortable night out?Alcohol, drunkenness and inclusive town centers[J].Area, 2008,40(3):365-374.
[33]
Ngesan M R, Karim H A, Zubir S S, et al.Urban community perception on nighttime leisure activities in improving public park design[J].Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2013,105:619-631.
[34]
Plyushteva A.Commuting and the urban night:Nocturnal mobilities in tourism and hospitality work[J].Journal of Policy Research in Tourism, Leisure and Events, 2019,11(3):407-421.
[35]
Bjelajac D, Djercan B, Bozic S.Dark skies and dark screens as a precondition for astronomy tourism and general well-being[J].Information Technology&Tourism, 2021,23(2):19-43.
[36]
Weaver D.Celestial ecotourism:New horizons in nature-based tourism[J].Journal of Ecotourism, 2011,10(1):38-45.
[37]
Edensor T.Reconnecting with darkness:Gloomy landscapes, lightless places[J].Social&Cultural Geography, 2013,14(4):446-465.
[38]
Baker, Julian C T.Darkness, travel and landscape:India by fire and starlight, c1820-c1860[J].Environment and Planning D:Society and Space, 2015,33(4):749-765.
[39]
Kim H, Choi S, Park H.An analysis in city tourist behavior at day and night time:Focused on Mokpo City in Jeonnam Province[J].Culinary Science&Hospitality Research, 2020,26(2):19-24.
[40]
Rodrigues A L O, Rodrigues A, Peroff D M.The sky and sustainable tourism development:A case study of a dark sky reserve implementation in Alqueva[J].International Journal of Tourism Research, 2014,17(3):292-302.
[41]
Song H, Kim M, Park C.Temporal distribution as a solution for over-tourism in night tourism:The case of Suwon Hwaseong in South Korea[J].Sustainability, 2020,12(6):2182-2196.
[42]
Pinke-Sziva I, Smith M, Olt G, et al.Overtourism and the nighttime economy:A case study of Budapest[J].International Journal of Tourism Cities, 2019,5(1):1-16.
[43]
Grenier C M.Costa Rican beach towns as liminal spaces:Tourism,transgressions and the night-time economy[J].International Journal of the Sociology of Leisure, 2020,4(2):119-136.
[44]
Hadfield P.Regulating the night:Race, culture and exclusion in the making of the night-time economy[J].The British Journal of Criminology, 2008,48(5):694-697.
[45]
Aramayona B, García-Sánchez R.Decoding middle-class protest against low-cost nocturnal tourism in Madrid[J].Journal of Policy Research in Tourism, Leisure and Events, 2019,11(3):380-393.
[46]
Eldridge A.Strangers in the night:Nightlife studies and new urban tourism[J].Journal of Policy Research in Tourism, Leisure and Events, 2019,11(3):422-435.
[47]
Olt G, Smith M K, Csizmady A, et al.Gentrification, tourism and the night-time economy in Budapest's district VII-the role of regulation in a post-socialist context[J].Journal of Policy Research in Tourism, Leisure and Events, 2019,11(3):394-406.
[48]
宋雪茜,赵陈.夜间旅游:城市休闲旅游发展之路[J].天府新论,2005(S1):188-189.[Song Xueqian, Zhao Chen.Nighttime tourism:The road of urban leisure tourism development[J].Tian Fu New Idea (Bimonthly), 2005(S1):188-189.]
[49]
张倩,李玉洁.关于河南休闲夜间游的探索[J].山西农业大学学报(自然科学版),2007(S2):135-137.[Zhang Qian, LI Yujie.The exploration on Henan leisure travel at night[J].Journal of Shanxi Agricultural University (Natural Science Edition), 2007(S2):135-137.]
[50]
邓勇勇.基于游客需求的丽江大研古镇夜间旅游产品调查分析[J].生态经济(学术版),2011(2):246-250.[Deng Yongyong.Analysis of night tourism products in Lijiang Dayan old town based on the needs of visitors[J].Ecological Economy, 2011(2):246-250.]
[51]
李军红.基于低碳旅游的夜空公园开发研究[J].地域研究与开发,2014,33(3):106-110.[Li Junhong.Analysis of night sky park development based on the low carbon travel[J].Areal Research and Development, 2014,33(3):106-110.]
[52]
徐金华,王扬,谭石榴.海岛景区夜间旅游开发研究——以朱家尖为例[J].旅游纵览(下半月),2014(7):78-80.[Xu Jinhua, Wang Yang, Tan Shiliu.Study on night tourism development of island scenic spot:Taking Zhujiajian as an example[J].Tourism Overview,2014(7):78-80.]
[53]
葛益娟.基于历史传承的景区夜间旅游开发策略——以南京夫子庙秦淮风光带为例[J].江苏商论,2015(3):48-51.[Ge Yijuan.The historical legacy of the scenic area tourism development strategy based on the night:A case study of the Nanjing Confucius temple Qin-huai Scenery[J].Jiangsu Commercial Forum, 2015(3):48-51.]
[54]
邓勇勇,郭文.国内夜间旅游产品研究概述[J].广东农业科学,2011,38(20):150-152.[Deng Yongyong, Guo Wen.Research overview of domestic night tourism products[J].Guangdong Agricultural Sciences, 2011,38(20):150-152.]
[55]
李艳丽,孙斌.旅游休闲度假村夜景照明设计初探——以张家界仙静湖度假村为例[J].灯与照明,2015,39(4):53-55.[Li Yanli, Sun Bin.On the night lighting design tourism relax resort:Taking Zhangjiajie as an example of Xian Lake Resort[J].Light&Lighting, 2015,39(4):53-55.]
[56]
刘琼英,方美.乐山乡村旅游产品提升对策分析[J].中共乐山市委党校学报,2017,19(1):38-40.[Liu Qiongying, Fang Mei.Analysis on countermeasures of promoting rural tourism products in Leshan[J].Journal of Leshan Municipal Party School, 2017,19(1):38-40.]
[57]
熊英,温庆林.夜间旅游中的演艺科技[J].演艺科技,2019(8):8-12.[Xiong Ying, Wen Qinglin.Entertainment technology in night tourism[J].Entertainment Technology, 2019(8):8-12.]
[58]
瓦哈甫·哈力克,朱永凤,何琛.从夜间灯光看中国旅游经济发展及其空间溢出效应——基于空间面板计量模型的实证研究[J].生态经济,2018,34(3):126-131.[Wahapu Halike, Zhu Yongfeng, He Chen.China's tourism economic growth and its spatial spillover effects:Based on nighttime light data[J].Ecological Economy, 2018,34(3):126-131.]
[59]
曹新向.我国城市夜间旅游的开发——以开封市为例[J].商业研究,2008(11):213-216.[Cao Xinxiang.The development of urban night tourism in China:A case study of Kaifeng city[J].Commercial Research, 2008(11):213-216.]
[60]
于萍.夜间旅游与夜经济:城市发展的新动力[J].改革与战略,2010,26(10):32-33.[Yui Ping.Night tourism and night economy:The new impetus for urban development[J].Reformation&Strategy,2010,26(10):32-33.]
[61]
岳超,荆延德.中国夜间旅游研究综述[J].旅游论坛,2013,6(4):71-76.[Yue Chao, Jing Yande.Literature review of nighttime tourism research in China[J].Tourism Forum, 2013,6(4):71-76.]
[62]
卢冬梅,骆培聪.厦门城市夜间旅游意愿与行为研究[J].旅游论坛,2010,3(4):407-412.[Lu Dongmei, Luo Peicong.Research on the present situation of urban night leisure and tourism in Xiamen[J].Tourism Forum, 2010,3(4):407-412.]
[63]
陈晓芬,李柏文.夜间旅游内涵辨析及其发展与管控研究[J].中国旅游评论,2019(4):43-52.[Chen Xiaofen, Li Bowen.Study on connotation differentiation, development and control of night tourism[J].China Tourism Review, 2019(4):43-52.]
[64]
文彤.城市夜间旅游产品研究[J].城市问题,2007(8):42-45.[Wen Tong.Study on the urban night tourism products[J].Urban Problems, 2007(8):42-45.]
[65]
曹新向.发展我国城市夜间旅游的对策研究[J].经济问题探索,2008(8):125-128.[Cao Xinxiang.Research on countermeasures in development of cities'night tourism in China[J].Inquiry into Economic Issues, 2008(8):125-128.]
[66]
雒珊珊.关于夜间旅游模式的探讨[J].黑龙江生态工程职业学院学报,2019,32(5):27-28,85.[Luo Shanshan.Discussion on night tourism model[J].Journal of Heilongjiang Vocational Institute of Ecological Engineering, 2019,32(5):27-28,85.]
[67]
顾至欣.城市夜间旅游产品定义及分类[J].城市问题,2013(11):98-102.[Gu Zhixin.Urban night tourism product definition and classification[J].Urban Problems, 2013(11):98-102.]
[68]
高怡,陈曦,池娜.城市园林夜间游憩产品开发研究——以福州西湖公园为例[J].林业勘察设计,2010(2):42-45.[Gao Yi, Chen Xi,Chi Na.Night recreation product development of urban landscape:Take Fuzhou West Lake Park as an example[J].Forestry Prospect and Design, 2010(2):42-45.]
[69]
黄洋,廖一洁.国内博物馆夜间开放的实践、问题及思考[J].东南文化,2017(1):121-126.[Huang Yang, Liao Yijie.The museum's night opening in China:Practices, issues and thoughts[J].Southeast Culture, 2017(1):121-126.]
[70]
魏云刚.城市夜间经济发展问题研究[J].泰山学院学报,2010,32(4):117-121.[Wei Yungang.The research of urban night-time economy development[J].Journal of Taishan University, 2010,32(4):117-121.]
[71]
葛枫呐.谈夜景经济对城市经济发展的促进作用——以河南省开封市为研究对象[J].商业时代,2013(26):141-142.[Ge Fengna.Discussion on the promoting effect of night scene economy on urban economic development:Taking Kaifeng City of Henan Province as the research object[J].Commercial Times, 2013(26):141-142.]
[72]
梁曦.让乡土有光——乡村照明建设中的景观经济策略研究[J].中外建筑,2020(2):115-117.[Liang Xi.Light up the rural:Research on landscape economic strategy in rural lighting construction[J].Chinese&Overseas Architecture, 2020(2):115-117.]
[73]
杨蓁.关于成都城市夜间旅游的初步探索[J].成都电子机械高等专科学校学报,2009,12(3):78-82.[Yang Zhen.A tentative study on night-tour in Chengdu[J].Journal of Chengdu Electromechanical College, 2009,12(3):78-82.]
[74]
刘文萍,刘丽梅.我国夜间旅游发展的问题和对策分析[J].内蒙古财经大学学报,2020,18(2):119-122.[Liu Wenping, Liu Limei.Problems and countermeasures of night tourism development in China[J].Journal of Inner Mongolia University of Finance and Economics, 2020,18(2):119-122.]
