&ldquo;理想的家就是普通的家&rdquo;&mdash;&mdash;上海流动儿童地方感的实证分析

朱晓丹; 叶超

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2022.03.007

PDF(19043 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2022, Vol. 37 ›› Issue (3) : 60-71,109. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2022.03.007

文化

“理想的家就是普通的家”——上海流动儿童地方感的实证分析

朱晓丹, 叶超

作者信息 +

"AN IDEAL HOME IS AN ORDINARY HOME": A CASE STUDY OF MIGRANT CHILDREN’S SENSE OF PLACE IN SHANGHAI

ZHU Xiao-dan, YE Chao

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

流动儿童正在成为一个重要的研究主题和现实话题,但对其地方感学界缺乏关注。本文以上海市主要服务流动儿童的X社区儿童服务中心为例,综合运用感知地图、深度访谈和参与式观察等质性研究方法,探究流动儿童地方感的特征与形成机制。流动儿童地方感存在社区与上海、市区与郊区和对地方的态度三个维度的差异;流动儿童对家的认知包括认同、迷失和流动三种,流动儿童地方感是基于亲人、朋友和其他社会网络所建立的,涉及多地方的,不断发展变化的积极地方感;流动儿童地方感的形成受到社会环境和自然环境的共同影响,受政府权力影响的X中心、家庭和学校,以及智能设备和自然环境是五个直接影响流动儿童地方感的因素,流动儿童的主观能动性也会重塑其地方感。从地理视角研究流动儿童具有重要的理论价值和现实意义。

Abstract

The number of migrant children in Shanghai accounts for more than half of the total, but the sense of place and other issues of migrant children lack extensive attention of the researchers. Migrant children are faced with the difficulty of going to school and are forced to move continuously. It is difficult for them to establish long-term ties with a place. Therefore, this paper took Shanghai X community children's service center(The service groups are mainly migrant children) as an example and through the qualitative research methods such as cognitive map, in-depth interview and participatory observation, this paper explores the characteristics and formation mechanism of migrant children's sense of place, and analyzes migrant children's perception of home. The results show that: 1) Migrant children's sense of place is different in three scales: Community and city, urban and suburban, and emotion; 2) Migrant children's cognition of home includes three forms: Identification, loss and mobility. Migrant children's sense of place does not depend on specific places, but a positive sense of place based on relatives, friends and other social networks, moving among many places, evolving, inclusive and open; 3) The formation mechanism of migrant children's sense of place is jointly affected by the social environment and the natural environment. Government power affects X center, family and school respectively, and these three, together with intelligent devices and the natural environment, directly affect migrant children's sense of place.

导出引用

朱晓丹, 叶超. “理想的家就是普通的家”——上海流动儿童地方感的实证分析[J]. 人文地理. 2022, 37(3): 60-71,109 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2022.03.007

ZHU Xiao-dan, YE Chao. "AN IDEAL HOME IS AN ORDINARY HOME": A CASE STUDY OF MIGRANT CHILDREN’S SENSE OF PLACE IN SHANGHAI[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2022, 37(3): 60-71,109 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2022.03.007

中图分类号： K901.3

参考文献

[1] 段义孚.空间与地方:经验的视角[M].王志标,译.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2017:110-111.[Tuan Yifu.Space and Place:The Perspective of Experience[M].Wang Zhibiao, trans.Beijing:China Renmin University Press Co.,Ltd., 2017:110-111.]
[2] Gregory D, Johnston R, Pratt G, et al.The Dictionary of Human Geography 5th Edition[M].Malden:Blackwell Publishing Ltd, 2009:467.
[3] Houtum H V, Lacy R B.The migration map trap.On the invasion arrows in the cartography of migration[J].Mobilities, 2020,15(2):196-219.
[4] Haan A D.Livelihoods and poverty:The role of migration-a critical review of the migration literature[J].Journal of Development Studies, 1999,36(2):1-47.
[5] 陈淳,袁振杰,朱竑.城镇化背景下广州流动儿童对"家"空间的建构[J].地理学报,2018,73(12):2440-2451.[Chen Chun, Yuan Zhenjie, Zhu Hong.Floating children in Guangzhou:The construction of "home" in the context of urbanization[J].Acta Geographica Sinica,2018, 73(12):2440-2451.]
[6] 教育部.流动儿童少年就学暂行办法[EB/OL].(1998-03-02)[2020-12-18].http://old.moe.gov.cn/publicfiles/business/htmlfiles/moe/moe_621/200409/3192.html.[Ministry of Education of the People's Republic of China.Interim Measures for schooling of migrant children and juveniles[EB/OL].(1998-03-02)[2020-12-18].http://old.moe.gov.cn/publicfiles/business/htmlfiles/moe/moe_621/200409/3192.html.]
[7] 彭善民.NPO与流动儿童的社会教育——以上海为例[J].社会科学,2014(2):76-82.[Peng Shanmin.NPO and social education problem of migrant children:Based on the case study of Shanghai[J].Journal of Social Sciences, 2014(2):76-82.]
[8] 周皓,荣珊.我国流动儿童研究综述[J].人口与经济,2011(3):94-103.[Zhou Hao, Rong Shan.Migrant children in China:Review and appraisal[J].Population&Economics, 2011(3):94-103.]
[9] Sibley D.Geographies of Exclusion[M].London and New York:Routledge, 1995:1-224.
[10] 陈淳,朱竑.冲突与协商:西方儿童地理学的发展及启示[J].热带地理,2015,35(4):489-497.[Chen Chun, Zhu Hong.Conflict and negotiation:A review on children's geographies in recent western geography[J].Tropical Geography, 2015,35(4):489-497.]
[11] James S.Is there a'place'for children in geography?[J].Area, 1990,22(3):278-283.
[12] Thorne B.Re-visioning women and social change:Where are the children?[J].Gender and Society, 1987,1(1):85-109.
[13] Machemer P L, Bruch S P, Kuipers R.Comparing rural and urban children's perceptions of an ideal community[J].Journal of Planning Education and Research, 2008,28(2):143-160.
[14] Jamme H-T W, Bahl D, Banerjee T.Between "broken windows" and the"eyes on the street:"Walking to school in inner city San Diego[J].Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2018,55:121-138.
[15] Babb C, Olaru D, Curtis C, et al.Children's active travel, local activity spaces and wellbeing:A case study in Perth, WA[J].Travel Behaviour and Society, 2017,9:81-94.
[16] Langley M C.Space to play:Identifying children's sites in the Pleistocene archaeological record[J].Evolutionary Human Sciences,2020,2:1-28.
[17] Moore D.'The teacher doesn't know what it is, but she knows where we are':Young children's secret places in early childhood outdoor environments[J].International Journal of Play, 2015,4(1):20-31.
[18] Derr V.Children's sense of place in northern New Mexico[J].Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2002,22(1-2):125-137.
[19] Linzmayer C D, Halpenny E A.'I might know when I'm an adult':Making sense of children's relationships with nature[J].Children's Geographies, 2014,12(4):412-428.
[20] 李钢,谭然,王会娟,等.中国拐卖儿童犯罪时空格局演变及其影响因素[J].人文地理,2018,33(2):26-34.[Li Gang, Tan Ran, Wang Huijuan, et al.Spatio-temporal change and influencing factors of trafficking in children in China[J].Human Geography, 2018,33(2):26-34.]
[21] 李钢,王会娟,谭然,等.中国拐卖儿童犯罪的时空特征与形成机制——基于"成功案例"的管窥[J].地理研究,2017,36(12):2505-2520.[Li Gang, Wang Huijuan, Tan Ran, et al.Spatiotemporal characteristics and formation mechanism of child trafficking in China based on "successful cases"[J].Geographical Research, 2017,36(12):2505-2520.]
[22] 毛华松,詹燕.关注城市公共场所中的儿童活动空间[J].中国园林,2005(9):14-17.[Mao Huasong, Zhan Yan.Attention needed for children activity space in city public place[J].Chinese Landscape Architecture, 2005(9):14-17.]
[23] 张彬彬.公益项目影响流动儿童学业的评估研究——以昆明市X项目为例[D].昆明:云南大学,2015:1-45.[Zhang Binbin.Research on the Assessment of Public Projects for Migrant Children's Academic Performance:Taking X project for Example[D].Kunming:Yunnan University, 2015:1-45.]
[24] 张婷婷.社会工作视角下流动儿童的社区融入研究——以昆山市J社区为例[D].兰州:兰州大学,2018:1-49.[Zhang Tingting.A Study on Community Integration of Migrant Children from the Perspective of Social Work:Taking the Community of J in Kunshan as an Example[D].Lanzhou:Lanzhou University, 2018:1-49.]
[25] 梁启政.流动儿童社区教育中的社会工作介入研究——以青岛H社区"流动儿童公益课堂"项目为例[D].青岛:青岛大学,2018:1-38.[Liang Qizheng.Research on Social Work Intervention in Community Education of Migrant Children:Take the"Public Welfare Classroom for Migrant Children"Project of Qingdao H Community as an Example[D].Qingdao:Qingdao University, 2018:1-38.]
[26] 杨思圆.公益礼物中的微观权力——基于某流动儿童公益项目的人类学考察[J].湖北社会科学,2020(11):47-54.[Yang Siyuan.Micro power in public welfare gifts:An anthropological study based on a public welfare project for migrant children[J].Hubei Social Sciences, 2020(11):47-54.]
[27] 杨昀.地方依恋的国内外研究进展述评[J].中山大学研究生学刊(自然科学.医学版),2011,32(2):26-37.[Yang Jun.A literature review of place attachment both at home and abroad[J].Journal of The Graduates Sun Yat-Sen University (Natural Sciences, Medicine), 2011,32(2):26-37.]
[28] 朱竑,刘博.地方感、地方依恋与地方认同等概念的辨析及研究启示[J].华南师范大学学报(自然科学版),2011(1):1-8.[Zhu Hong,Liu Bo.Concepts analysis and research implications:Sense of place, place attachment and place identity[J].Journal of South China Normal University (Natural Science Edition), 2011(1):1-8.]
[29] 郑昌辉.在城镇化背景下重新认识地方感——概念与研究进展综述[J].城市发展研究,2020,27(5):116-124.[Zheng Changhui.Rerecognizing the sense of place in the context of urbanization:Literature review on the concept and research progress[J].Urban Development Studies, 2020,27(5):116-124.]
[30] 段义孚.恋地情结[M].志丞,刘苏,译.北京:商务印书馆,2018:136.[Tuan Yifu.Topophilia:Study of Environmental Perception, Attitudes and Values[M].Zhi Cheng, Liu Su, trans.Beijing:The Commercial Press, 2018:136.]
[31] Cresswell T.Place:A Short Introduction[M].Malden, MA:Blackwell Publishing, 2004:24-26.
[32] den Besten O.Local belonging and'geographies of emotions':Immigrant children's experience of their neighbourhoods in Paris and Berlin[J].Childhood, 2010,17(2):181-195.
[33] Moskal M.'When I think home I think family here and there':Translocal and social ideas of home in narratives of migrant children and young people[J].Geoforum, 2015,58:143-152.
[34] 陈淳,朱竑.城镇化背景下城中村流动儿童的空间感知——以广州市天河区石牌村为例[J].华南师范大学学报(社会科学版),2016(6):110-117,191.[Chen Chun, Zhu Hong.Spatial cognition of migrant children in urban villages under the background of urbanization:A case study of Shipai village, Tianhe district, Guangzhou[J].Journal of South China Normal University (Social Science Edition), 2016(6):110-117,191.]
[35] Börjesson U, ForkbyÅS.The concept of home-unaccompanied youths voices and experiences[J].European Journal of Social Work, 2020,23(3):475-485.
[36] SouralováA.Grandparents, kinship ties, and belonging after migration:the perspective of second-generation grandchildren[J].Global Networks, 2020,20(2):362-379.
[37] Chan A K, Chiu M M, Yang S Y, et al.Mobility, belongingness and schooling experiences of Chinese cross-border students[J].Children and Youth Services Review, 2020,111.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.childyouth.2020.104870.
[38] Zontini E, Reynolds T.Mapping the role of'transnational family habitus'in the lives of young people and children[J].Global Networks, 2017,18(3):418-436.
[39] Lim M, Barton A C.Exploring insideness in urban children's sense of place[J].Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2010,30(3):328-337.
[40] 刘玉照,王元腾.上海市流动儿童教育状况分析[M]//杨东平,等.中国流动儿童教育发展报告(2016).北京:社会科学文献出版社,2017:121-140.[Liu Yuzhao, Wang Yuanteng.Education for migrant children in Shanghai[M]//Yang Dongping, et al.Annual Report on Education For China's Migrant Children (2016).Beijing:Social Sciences Academic Press (China), 2017:121-140.]
[41] Blaut J M, Stea D.Studies of geographic learning[J].Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 1971,61(2):387-393.
[42] Downs R M, Liben L S, Daggs D G.On Education and geographers:The role of cognitive developmental theory in geographic education[J].Annals of the Association of American Geographers,1988,78(4):680-700.
[43] Avriel-Avni N, Spektor-Levy O, Zion M, et al.Children's sense of place in desert towns:A phenomenographic enquiry[J].International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education, 2010,19(3):241-259.
[44] Mcdonnell S.Narrating homes in process:Everyday politics of migrant childhoods[J].Childhood, 2020,28(1):1-19.
[45] 多琳·马西.空间、地方与性别[M].毛彩凤,袁久红,丁乙,译.北京:首都师范大学出版社,2018:1-20,186-201.[Massey D.Space, Place and Gender[M].Mao Caifeng, Yuan Jiuhong, Ding Yi, trans.Beijing:Capital Normal University Press, 2018:1-20,186-201.]
[46] 韩嘉玲,余家庆.为教育而再次流动:新型城镇化背景下农民工家庭的子女教育抉择[M]//韩嘉玲,等.中国流动儿童教育发展报告(2019-2020).北京:社会科学文献出版社,2020:283-302.[Han Jialing, Yu Jiaqing.Population dispersal and migrant children returning/remigranting and mobile home:Choices of children's education of migrant families of the new generation in the context of new urbanization[M]//Han Jialing, et al.Annual Report on China's Education for Migrant Children (2019-2020).Beijing:Social Sciences Academic Press (China), 2020:283-302.]
[47] 陈炳辉.福柯的权力观[J].厦门大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2002(4):84-90.[Chen Binghui.On foucault's conception of power[J].Journal of Xiamen University (Arts&Social Sciences), 2002(4):84-90.]
[48] 上海市妇女儿童工作委员会办公室.上海市启动部署儿童友好社区创建试点工作[EB/OL].(2019-09-11)[2020-12-28].http://www.nwccw.gov.cn/2019-09/11/content_270357.htm.[Shanghai Municipal Women&Children Commttee.Shanghai started to deploy the pilot work of creating child friendly communities[EB/OL].(2019-09-11)[2020-12-28].http://www.nwccw.gov.cn/2019-09/11/content_270357.htm.]
[49] 于澍原.大城市流动人口社区紧缩型治理[D].上海:上海师范大学,2017:1-3.[Yu Shuyuan.Community Tightening Governance of Floating Population in Big Cities[D].Shanghai:Shanghai Normal University, 2017:1-3.]
[50] 刘璐.离与合:结构论视角下混居群体的日常生活研究[D].上海:华东师范大学,2018:44-45.[Liu Lu.Off And Close:A Study of Daily Life in Cohabitation Group from the Perspective of Structurization Theory:Based on X Community of Shanghai[D].Shanghai:East China Normal University, 2018:44-45.]
[51] 沈瑶,刘晓艳,云华杰,等.走向儿童友好的住区空间——中国城市化语境下儿童友好社区空间设计理论解析[J].城市建筑,2018(34):40-43.[Shen Yao, Liu Xiaoyan, Yun Huajie, et al.Towards child friendly residential space:Analysis of space design theory of children-friendly community in the context of urbanization in China[J].Urbanism and Architecture, 2018(34):40-43.]
[52] 高莉莎.日常生活与手机实践[D].昆明:云南大学,2018:134-139.[Gao Lisha.Everyday Life and Smart Phone Practice an Ethnography of Yi and Hani Rural-urban Migrants from Yunnan[D].Kunming:Yun Nan University, 2018:134-139.]
[53] Lewicka M.Place attachment:How far have we come in the last 40years?[J].Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2011,31(3):207-230.
[54] 朱晓丹,叶超,李思梦.可持续城市研究进展及其对国土空间规划的启示[J].自然资源学报,2020,35(9):2120-2133.[Zhu Xiaodan,Ye Chao, Li Simeng.Research progress of sustainable cities and its implications for national territory spatial plan[J].Journal of Natural Resources, 2020,35(9):2120-2133.]
[55] 叶超,于洁,张清源,等.从治理到城乡治理:国际前沿、发展态势与中国路径[J].地理科学进展,2021,40(1):15-27.[Ye Chao, Yu Jie,Zhang Qingyuan, et al.From governance to rural-urban co-governance:Research frontiers, trends, and the Chinese paths[J].Progress in Geography, 2021,40(1):15-27.]
[56] Chatterjee S.Children's friendship with place:A conceptual inquiry[J].Children, Youth and Environments, 2005,15(1):1-26.