区域经济韧性：研究综述与展望

贺灿飞; 盛涵天

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2023.01.001

PDF(2874 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2023, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (1) : 1-10. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2023.01.001

进展与动态

区域经济韧性：研究综述与展望

贺灿飞, 盛涵天

作者信息 +

REGIONAL ECONOMIC RESILIENCE: A REVIEW AND FUTURE DEVELOPMENT OUTLOOK

HE Can-fei, SHENG Han-tian

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

自金融危机以来，区域经济韧性成为了研究热点。现有文献从均衡论及演化论的视角建构了区域经济韧性的理论框架，认为区域经济韧性不仅是区域发展的结果也是区域发展的动态过程。大量实证研究关注区域发展过程，探讨了不同尺度下经济系统对冲击的抵抗力、恢复力，并分析了经济韧性的影响机理。区域经济韧性是时间维度与空间尺度的统一。现有研究多关注区域本身特性，缺乏从动态性、多主体互动性、多尺度融合视角审视区域经济韧性的形成过程。因此未来研究一方面应当在现有理论基础上与关系经济地理、管理学等领域紧密结合，更重视危机与冲击的异质性，系统揭示行为主体在区域经济韧性形成、维持过程中的重要作用；另一方面应当进一步关注中国发展背景与制度优势，重视韧性研究对经济发展深远的意义，从而增强中国经济在不确定环境下的稳定性。

Abstract

Since the global financial crisis, regional economic resilience has become a research hot-spot. The meaning of "resilience" in mechanics is the ability of an object to return to its initial state after being stressed. In subsequent studies, resilience is gradually transformed into a metaphor for research in the fields of ecology, economics and economic geography. Regional economic resilience has spatial scale characteristics, and its research object is the ability of multi-scale spatial economic systems responding to external shocks. Existing literature constructs the theoretical framework of regional economic resilience from the perspective of equilibrium theory and evolution theory. Regional resilience research integrates temporal and spatial characteristics. Existing research has also begun to excavate the micro-foundation of regional economic resilience from the perspective of network resilience in order to achieve macro-micro-scale unification. First, network resilience represents the ability of factors within a region to connect with each other, and important nodes play a global role in connection with each other. Second, the structure of the complex network itself has a significant impact on regional economic resilience. In terms of outlook, on the one hand, future research should pay more attention to the heterogeneity of crises and shocks, and systematically reveal the important role of actors in the formation and maintenance of regional economic resilience. Finally, in China, the multi-agent interaction process with the government as the main participant may systematically improve the resilience of the regional economy and enhance the stability of the Chinese economy in an uncertain environment.

导出引用

贺灿飞, 盛涵天. 区域经济韧性：研究综述与展望[J]. 人文地理. 2023, 38(1): 1-10 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2023.01.001

HE Can-fei, SHENG Han-tian. REGIONAL ECONOMIC RESILIENCE: A REVIEW AND FUTURE DEVELOPMENT OUTLOOK[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2023, 38(1): 1-10 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2023.01.001

中图分类号： K902

参考文献

[1] Hudson R. Resilient regions in an uncertain world:Wishful thinking or a practical reality?[J]. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society, 2009,3(1):11-26.
[2] Christopherson S, Michie J, Tyler P. Regional resilience:Theoretical and empirical perspectives[J]. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society, 2010,3(1):3-10.
[3] 胡晓辉.区域经济弹性研究述评及未来展望[J].外国经济与管理, 2012,34(8):64-72.[Hu Xiaohui. Review and future prospects of research on regional economic resilience[J]. Foreign Economics & Management, 2012,34(8):64-72.]
[4] Pendall R, Kathryn A F, Cowell M. Resilience and regions:Building understanding of the metaphor[J]. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society, 2010,3(1):71-84.
[5] Martin R. Regional economic resilience, hysteresis and recessionary shocks[J]. Journal of Economic Geography, 2012,12(1):1-32.
[6] Martin R. Roepke lecture in economic geography-rethinking regional path dependence:Beyond Lock-In to evolution[J]. Economic Geography, 2015,86(1):1-27.
[7] Simmie J, Martin R. The economic resilience of regions:Towards an evolutionary approach[J]. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society, 2010,3(1):27-43.
[8] 韩增林,朱文超,李博.区域弹性研究热点与前沿的可视化[J].热带地理,2021,41(1):206-215.[Han Zenglin, Zhu Wenchao, Li Bo. Research hotspots of regional resilience and the visualization of research frontiers[J]. Tropical Geography, 2021,41(1):206-215.]
[9] Martin R. Rebuilding the economy from the covid crisis:Time to rethink regional studies?[J]. Regional Studies, Regional Science, 2021, 8(1):143-161.
[10] 孙久文,孙翔宇.区域经济韧性研究进展和在中国应用的探索[J]. 经济地理,2017,37(10):1-9.[Sun Jiuwen, Sun Xiangyu. Research progress of regional economic resilience and exploration of its application in China[J]. Economic Geography, 2017,37(10):1-9.]
[11] 彭翀,袁敏航,顾朝林,等.区域弹性的理论与实践研究进展[J].城市规划学刊,2015(221):84-92.[Peng Chong, Yuan Minhang, Gu Chaolin, et al. Research progress on the theory and practice of regional resilience[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2015(221):84-92.]
[12] 苏杭. 经济韧性问题研究进展[J]. 经济学动态,2015(8):144-151.[Su Hang. Research progress on economic resilience[J]. Economic Perspectives, 2015(8):144-151.]
[13] Modica M, Reggiani A. Spatial economic resilience:Overview and perspectives[J]. Networks and Spatial Economics, 2015,15(2):211-233.
[14] Hassink R. Regional resilience:A promising concept to explain differences in regional economic adaptability?[J]. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society, 2010,3(1):45-58.
[15] Pike A, Dawley S, Tomaney J. Resilience, adaptation and adaptability[J]. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society, 2010, 3(1):59-70.
[16] Holling C. Resilience and stability of ecological systems[J]. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 1973(4):1-23.
[17] Martin R, Gardiner B. The resilience of cities to economic shocks:A tale of four recessions (and the challenge of Brexit)[J]. Papers in Regional Science, 2019,98(4):1801-1832.
[18] Dawley S, Pike A, Tomaney J. Towards the resilient region?[J]. Local Economy:The Journal of the Local Economy Policy Unit, 2010, 25(8):650-667.
[19] 陈梦远. 国际区域经济韧性研究进展——基于演化论的理论分析框架介绍[J].地理科学进展,2017,36(11):1435-1444.[Chen Mengyuan. An international literature review of regional economic resilience:Theories and practices based on the evolutionary perspective[J]. Progress in Geography, 2017,36(11):1435-1444.]
[20] Boschma R, Martin R. Constructing an evolutionary economic geography[J]. Journal of Economic Geography, 2007,7(5):537-548.
[21] Martin R, Sunley P. Path dependence and regional economic evolution[J]. Journal of Economic Geography, 2006,6(4):395-437.
[22] Boschma R. Towards an evolutionary perspective on regional resilience[J]. Regional Studies, 2015,49(5):733-751.
[23] Tsiapa M, Kallioras D, Tzeremes N. The role of path-dependence in the resilience of EU regions[J]. European Planning Studies, 2018, 26(6):1099-1120.
[24] Bristow G. Resilient regions:Re-'place'ing regional competitiveness[J]. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society, 2010, 3(1):153-167.
[25] Frenken K, Boschma R A. A theoretical framework for evolutionary economic geography:Industrial dynamics and urban growth as a branching process[J]. Journal of Economic Geography, 2007,7(5):635-649.
[26] Boschma R, Iammarino S. Related variety, trade linkages, and regional growth in Italy[J]. Economic Geography, 2009, 85(3):289-311.
[27] Cainelli G, Ganau R, Modica M. Does related variety affect regional resilience? New evidence from Italy[J]. The Annals of Regional Science, 2019,62(3):657-680.
[28] He C F, Chen T, Zhu S J. Do not put eggs in one basket:Related variety and export resilience in the Post-Crisis Era[J]. Industrial and Corporate Change, 2022,30(6):1-22.
[29] Tóth G, Elekes Z, Whittle A, et al. Technology network structure conditions the economic resilience of regions[J]. Economic Geography, 2022,98(4):355-378.
[30] 林耿,徐昕,杨帆. 佛山市产业专业化、多样化与经济韧性的关系研究[J]. 地理科学, 2020, 40(9):1493-1504.[Lin Geng, Xu Xin, Yang Fan. Specialization, variety and economic resilience of specialized towns in Foshan[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2020, 40(9):1493-1504.]
[31] Xiao J, Boschma R, Andersson M. Resilience in the European Union:The effect of the 2008 crisis on the ability of regions in Europe to develop new industrial specializations[J]. Industrial and Corporate Change, 2018,27(1):15-47.
[32] Martin R, Sunley P. On the notion of regional economic resilience:Conceptualization and explanation[J]. Journal of Economic Geography, 2014,15(1):1-42.
[33] Mackinnon D, Cumbers A, Pike A, et al. Evolution in economic geography:Institutions, political economy, and adaptation[J]. Economic Geography, 2015,85(2):129-150.
[34] Tóth B. Regional economic resilience:Concepts, empirics and a critical review[J]. Miscellanea Geographica-Regional Studies on Development, 2015,19(3):70-75.
[35] 胡晓辉,董柯,杨宇.战略耦合演化视角下的区域经济韧性分析框架[J]. 地理研究,2021,40(12):3272-3286.[Hu Xiaohui, Dong Ke, Yang Yu. An analytical framework on regional economic resilience from the perspective of evolutionary strategic coupling[J]. Geographical Research, 2021,40(12):3272-3286.]
[36] Neffke F, Hartog M, Boschma R, et al. Agents of structural change:The role of firms and entrepreneurs in regional diversification[J]. Economic Geography, 2018,94(1):23-48.
[37] Ardito L, Messeni Petruzzelli A, Panniello U. Unveiling the breakthrough potential of established technologies:An empirical investigation in the aerospace industry[J]. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management, 2016,28(8):916-934.
[38] Del Giudice M, Campanella F, Dezi L. The bank of things:An empirical investigation on the profitability of the financial services of the future[J]. Business Process Management Journal, 2016, 22(2):324-340.
[39] Billington M G, Karlsen J, Mathisen L, et al. Unfolding the relationship between resilient firms and the region[J]. European Planning Studies, 2017,25(3):425-442.
[40] Santoro G, Messeni-Petruzzelli A, Del Giudice M. Searching for resilience:The impact of employee-level and entrepreneur-level resilience on firm performance in small family firms[J]. Small Business Economics, 2021,57(1):455-471.
[41] Diodato D, Weterings A. The resilience of regional labour markets to economic shocks:Exploring the role of interactions among firms and workers[J]. Journal of Economic Geography, 2015,15(4):723-742.
[42] Mccann P, Ortega-Argilés R. Smart specialization, regional growth and applications to European Union Cohesion Policy[J]. Regional Studies, 2015,49(8):1291-1302.
[43] Neffke F, Henning M. Skill relatedness and firm diversification[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2013,34(3):297-316.
[44] Shaw K, Maythorne L. Managing for local resilience:Towards a strategic approach[J]. Public Policy and Administration, 2011,28(1):43-65.
[45] 朱正威,刘莹莹.韧性治理:风险与应急管理的新路径[J].行政论坛,2020,27(5):81-87.[Zhu Zhengwei, Liu Yingying. Resilient governance:A new approach for risk and emergency management[J]. Administrative Tribune, 2020,27(5):81-87.]
[46] 陈玉梅,李康晨.国外公共管理视角下韧性城市研究进展与实践探析[J].中国行政管理,2017(1):137-143.[Chen Yumei, Li Kangchen. Overseas studies progress and practice exploration on resilient citybased on the perspective of public administration[J]. Chinese Public Administration, 2017(1):137-143.]
[47] 仇保兴.基于复杂适应系统理论的韧性城市设计方法及原则[J]. 城市发展研究,2018,25(10):1-3.[Qiu Baoxing. Methods and principles of designing resilient city based on complex adaptive system theory[J]. Urban Development Studies, 2018,25(10):1-3.]
[48] Ezcurra R, Rios V. Quality of government and regional resilience in the European Union. Evidence from the great recession[J]. Papers in Regional Science, 2018,98(3):1267-1290.
[49] Rios V, Gianmoena L. The link between quality of government and regional resilience in Europe[J]. Journal of Policy Modeling, 2020, 42(5):1064-1084.
[50] 周黎安. "官场+市场"与中国增长故事[J]. 社会,2018,38(2):1-45.[Zhou Li-An. "Bureaucratic & Economic Markets" and China's growth story[J]. Chinese Journal of Sociology, 2018,38(2):1-45.]
[51] Gong H, Hassink R, Wang C. Strategic coupling and regional resilience in times of uncertainty:The industrial chain chief model in Zhejiang, China[J]. Papers in Economic Geography and Innovation Studies, 2021(6):1-28.
[52] 刘逸,纪捷韩,许汀汀,等. 战略耦合对区域经济韧性的影响研究——以广东省为例[J].地理研究,2021,40(12):3382-3398.[Liu Yi, Ji Jiehan, Xu Tingting, et al. The impact of strategic coupling on regional economic resilience under globalization:A case study of Guangdong province[J]. Geographical Research, 2021,40(12):3382-3398.]
[53] Hu X L, Li L G, Dong K. What matters for regional economic resilience amid COVID-19? Evidence from cities in northeast China[J]. Cities, 2021,120:103440. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cities.2021.103440.
[54] Yeung H W. Regional worlds:From related variety in regional diversification to strategic coupling in global production networks[J]. Regional Studies, 2021,55(6):989-1010.
[55] 魏冶,修春亮.城市网络韧性的概念与分析框架探析[J].地理科学进展,2020,39(3):488-502.[Wei Ye, Xiu Chunliang. Study on the concept and analytical framework of city network resilience[J]. Progress in Geography, 2020,39(3):488-502.]
[56] Reggiani A. The architecture of connectivity:A key to network vulnerability, complexity and resilience[J]. Networks and Spatial Economics, 2022,22(2):1-23.
[57] Liu X M, Li D Q, Ma M Q, et al. Network resilience[J/OL]. Physics Reports, 2022,971:1-108.[2022-03-20]. https://www.sciencedirect.com/journal/physics-reports/vol/971/suppl/C.
[58] O'Kelly M. Network hub structure and resilience[J]. Networks and Spatial Economics, 2015,15(2):235-251.
[59] 谭俊涛,赵宏波,刘文新,等.中国区域经济韧性特征与影响因素分析[J]. 地理科学,2020,40(2):173-181.[Tan Juntao, Zhao Hongbo, Liu Wenxin, et al. Regional economic resilience and influential mechanism during economic crises in China[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2020,40(2):173-181.]
[60] 巩灿娟,张晓青,徐成龙.中国三大城市群经济韧性的时空演变及协同提升研究[J].软科学,2022, 36(5):1-13.[Gong Canjuan, Zhang Xiaoqing, Xu Chenglong. Study on the spatial-temporal evolution and collaborative improvement of economic resilience of three major urban agglomerations in China[J]. Soft Science, 2022,36(5):1-13.]
[61] 王鹏飞,李红波.基于产业结构关联视角的区域经济韧性作用机理研究——以江苏省为例[J].地理科学进展,2022,41(2):224-238.[Wang Pengfei, Li Hongbo. Mechanism of regional economic resilience from the perspective of industrial structure relevance:Taking Jiangsu Province as an example[J]. Progress in Geography, 2022, 41(2):224-238.]
[62] Kitsos A, Bishop P. Economic resilience in great Britain:The crisis impact and its determining factors for local authority districts[J]. The Annals of Regional Science, 2018,60(2):329-347.
[63] Clark J, Bailey D. Labour, work and regional resilience[J]. Regional Studies, 2018,52(6):741-744.
[64] Ray D. Economic shock and regional resilience:Continuity and change in Canada's regional employment structure, 1987-2012[J]. Environment and Planning A, 2017,49(4):952-973.
[65] 王奇珍,朱英明.中国城市经济韧性及影响因素研究[J].生态经济, 2021,37(10):84-92.[Wang Qizhen, Zhu Yingming. Research on urban economic resilience and its influencing factors in China[J]. Ecological Economy, 2021,37(10):84-92.]
[66] Graziano P, Rizzi P. Vulnerability and resilience in the local systems:The case of Italian Provinces[J]. Science of The Total Environment, 2016,553:211-222.
[67] 陈丛波,叶阿忠.数字经济、创新能力与区域经济韧性[J].统计与决策,2021,37(17):10-15.[Chen Congbo, Ye Azhong. Digital economy, innovation capacity and regional economic resilience[J]. Statistics & Decision, 2021,37(17):10-15.]
[68] 刘瑞,张伟静.空间集聚能否提升中国制造业韧性——基于产业适应性结构调整的视角[J]. 当代财经,2021(11):16-27.[Liu Rui, Zhang Weijing. Can spatial agglomeration enhance the resilience of China's manufacturing industry-From the perspective of industrial adaptive structure adjustment[J]. Contemporary Finance & Economics, 2021(11):16-27.]
[69] Dzigbede K D, Gehl S B, Willoughby K. Disaster resiliency of U.S. local governments:Insights to strengthen local response and recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic[J]. Public Administration Review, 2020,80(4):634-643.
[70] Gong H W, Hassink R, Tan J T, et al. Regional resilience in times of a pandemic crisis:The case of COVID-19 in China[J]. Tijdschrift Voor Economische en Sociale Geografie, 2020,111(3):497-512.
[71] Crescenzi R, Luca D, Milio S. The geography of the economic crisis in europe:National macroeconomic conditions, regional structural factors and short-term economic performance[J]. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society, 2016,9(1):13-22.
[72] Cappelli R, Montobbio F, Morrison A. Unemployment resistance across EU regions:The role of technological and human capital[J]. Journal of Evolutionary Economics, 2020,31(1):147-178.
[73] 张振,李志刚,胡璇. 城市群产业集聚、空间溢出与区域经济韧性[J].华东经济管理,2021,35(8):59-68.[Zhang Zhen, Li Zhigang, Hu Xuan. Industrial agglomeration, spatial spillover, and regional economic resilience of urban agglomeration[J]. East China Economic Management, 2021,35(8):59-68.]
[74] 徐圆,邓胡艳.多样化、创新能力与城市经济韧性[J].经济学动态, 2020(8):88-104.[Xu Yuan, Deng Huyan. Diversification, innovation capability and urban economic resilience[J]. Economic Perspectives, 2020(8):88-104.]
[75] Dijkstra L, Garcilazo E, Mccann P. The effects of the global financial crisis on european regions and cities[J]. Journal of Economic Geography, 2015,15(5):935-949.
[76] Bruneau M, Chang S, Eguchi R, et al. A framework to quantitatively assess and enhance the seismic resilience of communities[J]. Earthquake Spectra, 2003,19(4):733-752.
[77] 俞国军,贺灿飞,朱晟君.产业集群韧性:技术创新、关系治理与市场多元化[J]. 地理研究,2020,39(6):1343-1356.[Yu Guojun, He Canfei, Zhu Shengjun. Industrial cluster resilience:Technological innovation, relational governance, and market diversification[J]. Geographical Research, 2020,39(6):1343-1356.]
[78] 王鹏,钟敏.危机冲击下产业集群韧性演化与提升路径研究[J].经济社会体制比较, 2021(6):76-88.[Wang Peng, Zhong Min. Research on the evolution and improvement path of industrial cluster's resilience under the imapct of crisis[J]. Comparative Economic & Social Systems, 2021(6):76-88.]
[79] Behrens K, Boualam B, Martin J. Are clusters resilient? Evidence from Canadian textile industries[J]. Journal of Economic Geography, 2019,20(1):1-36.
[80] Wang Z, Wei W. Regional economic resilience in China:Measurement and determinants[J]. Regional Studies, 2021,55(7):1228-1239.
[81] 李连刚,张平宇,程钰,等.黄河流域经济韧性时空演变与影响因素研究[J]. 地理科学,2022,42(4):557-567.[Li Liangang, Zhang Pingyu, Cheng Yu, et al. Spatio-temporal evolution and influencing factors of economic resilience in the Yellow River Basin[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2022,42(4):557-567.]
[82] 张跃胜,邓帅艳,张寅雪. 城市经济韧性研究:理论进展与未来方向[J]. 管理学刊,2022,35(2):54-67.[Zhang Yuesheng, Deng Shuaiyan, Zhang Yinxue. Research on urban economic resilience:Theoretical progress and future directions[J]. Journal of Management, 2022,35(2):54-67.]
[83] Hu X H, Hassink R. Exploring adaptation and adaptability in uneven economic resilience:A tale of two Chinese mining regions[J]. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society, 2017,10(3):527-541.
[84] Tan J T, Lo K, Qiu F D, et al. Regional economic resilience of resource-based cities and influential factors during economic crises in China[J]. Growth and Change, 2020,51(1):362-381.
[85] 李连刚,张平宇,王成新,等.区域经济韧性视角下老工业基地经济转型过程——以辽宁省为例[J]. 地理科学,2021,41(10):1742-1750.[Li Liangang, Zhang Pingyu, Wang Chengxin, et al. Economic transformation process of old industrial bases from the perspective of regional economic resilience:A case study of Liaoning province[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2021,41(10):1742-1750.]
[86] 郭卫东,钟业喜,冯兴华.基于脆弱性视角的中国高铁城市网络韧性研究[J].地理研究,2022,41(5):1371-1387.[Guo Weidong, Zhong Yexi, Feng Xinghua. Research on the resilience of China's high-speed rail urban network from the perspective of vulnerability[J]. Geographical Research, 2022,41(5):1371-1387.]
[87] Dey A, Gel Y, Poor H. What network motifs tell us about resilience and reliability of complex networks[J]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences-PNAS, 2019,116(39):19368-19373.
[88] 李博,曹盖.基于涉海A股上市公司的中国沿海地区海洋经济网络结构韧性演化研究[J]. 地理科学进展,2022,41(6):945-955.[Li Bo, Cao Gai. Structural resilience change of China's marine economic network based on the data of sea-related A-share listed companies[J]. Progress in Geography, 2022,41(6):945-955.]
[89] 侯兰功,孙继平.复杂网络视角下的成渝城市群网络结构韧性演变[J]. 世界地理研究,2022,31(3):561-571.[Hou Langong, Sun Jiping. Evolution of network structure resilience of ChengduChongqing urban agglomeration from the perspective of complex networks[J]. World Regional Studies, 2022,31(3):561-571.]
[90] 魏石梅,潘竟虎.中国地级及以上城市网络结构韧性测度[J].地理学报, 2021, 76(6):1394-1407.[Wei Shimei, Pan Jinghu. Network structure resilience of cities at the prefecture level and above in China[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2021,76(6):1394-1407.]