国家认同与旅游研究：回顾与展望

刘为潍; 李咪咪; 蒋依依

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2023.05.003

PDF(5039 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2023, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (5) : 16-23. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2023.05.003

进展与动态

国家认同与旅游研究：回顾与展望

刘为潍¹, 李咪咪², 蒋依依³

作者信息 +

A REVIEW OF STUDY ON NATIONAL IDENTITY AND TOURISM

LIU Wei-wei¹, LI Mi-mi², JIANG Yi-yi³

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

文章依托在web of science、中国知网等数据库中检索并整理出的384篇旅游领域国家认同研究文献，结合定量与定性分析方法，从文献的研究地域、主要作者与核心文献等方面系统梳理了国家认同与旅游研究进展，并重点分析了现有文献的研究热点、研究主题，以及研究理论与方法。综合来看，现有国家认同与旅游研究理论转向明显、研究方法多样，研究主题以遗产旅游、黑色旅游、红色旅游和返乡旅游情境中的国家认同研究较为常见，研究线索以旅游如何形塑主体的国家认同为主，而国家认同对旅游的影响研究、旅游者个体维度和主体性视角的国家认同建构和展演研究有待进一步加强。基于相关分析，文章从国家认同与旅游研究互动关系、集体与个体维度国家认同建构的整合路径、旅游者主体性视角、平庸的国家主义与旅游目的地案例、研究方法的科学创新几个方面提出了国家认同与旅游研究的未来发展方向。

Abstract

The issue of national identity has existed since the founding of the first nation-states, and globalization has further promoted the development of this issue. The essence of national identity is a social construction, and tourism contributes to this social construction. However, the current studies on national identity and tourism still focus on empirical analysis of various particular cases, and there is a lack of comprehensive review literature, which to a certain extent hinders in-depth discussion of the interaction between national identity and tourism. Through the search results in Web of Science, CNKI, and other databases, this research has sorted out a total of 384 articles regarding national identity and tourism research. The data source for the quantitative analysis is 384 initially screened documents, with the purpose of having an overview of studies on national identity and tourism. From those articles, 120 SSCI and CSSCI papers in the field of tourism were further refined and selected as the core data source of qualitative analysis. On the basis of reviewing the relevant research literature, combined with quantitative and qualitative analysis methods, this paper systematically analyses the research progress of national identity and tourism from the research area, core author, and core literature, research keywords, research topics, research theories, and research methods. In summary, there are many research achievements on national identity and tourism with various theories and research methods.

导出引用

刘为潍, 李咪咪, 蒋依依. 国家认同与旅游研究：回顾与展望[J]. 人文地理. 2023, 38(5): 16-23 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2023.05.003

LIU Wei-wei, LI Mi-mi, JIANG Yi-yi. A REVIEW OF STUDY ON NATIONAL IDENTITY AND TOURISM[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2023, 38(5): 16-23 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2023.05.003

中图分类号： K901.6

参考文献

[1] 王卓君,何华玲.全球化时代的国家认同:危机与重构[J].中国社会科学,2013(9):16-27.[Wang Zhuojun, He Hualing. National identity in the era of globalization:Crisis and reconstruction[J]. Social Sciences in China, 2013(9):16-27.]
[2] 袁娥. 民族认同与国家认同研究述评[J]. 民族研究,2011(5):91- 103.[Yuan E. A comment on the study about ethnic identity and national identity[J]. Ethno-National Studies, 2011(5):91-103.]
[3] 贺金瑞,燕继荣.论从民族认同到国家认同[J].中央民族大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2008(3):5-12.[He Jinrui, Yan Jirong. From ethnic recognition to national recognition[J]. Journal of The Central University for Nationalities(Philosophy And Social Sciences Edition), 2008(3):5-12.]
[4] Ariely G. Globalisation and the decline of national identity? An exploration across sixty-three countries[J]. Nations and Nationalism, 2012,18(3):461-482.
[5] Anderson B. Imagined Communities:Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism[M]. London:Verso, 1991:5-36.
[6] Smith, A. National Identity[M]. Reno:University of Nevada Press, 1991:8-18.
[7] Park H Y. Heritage tourism:Emotional journeys into nationhood[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2010,37(1):116-135.
[8] Palmer C. Tourism and the symbols of identity[J]. Tourism Management, 1999,20(3):313-321.
[9] Pretes M. Tourism and nationalism[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2003,30(1):125-142.
[10] Lepp A, Harris J. Tourism and national identity in Uganda[J]. International Journal of Tourism Research, 2008,10(6):525-536.
[11] Packer J, Ballantyne R, Uzzell D. Interpreting war heritage:Impacts of Anzac museum and battlefield visits on Australians' understanding of national identity[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2019, 76:105-116.
[12] Palmer C A. Tourism and colonialism:The experience of the Bahamas[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 1994,21(4):792-811.
[13] 左冰.红色旅游与政党认同——基于井冈山景区的实证研究[J]. 旅游学刊,2014,29(9):60-72.[Zuo Bing. Red tourism and communist party identity in China:An empirical study based on Jinggangshan scenic area[J]. Tourism Tribune,2014,29(9):60-72.]
[14] 李彦辉,朱竑.地方传奇、集体记忆与国家认同——以黄埔军校旧址及其参观者为中心的研究[J]. 人文地理,2013,28(6):17-21.[Li Yan-hui, Zhu Hong. Place myth, collective memory and national identity:A case study of Huangpu military academy in Guangzhou[J].Human Geography, 2013,28(6):17-21.]
[15] 孙艳,李咪咪,肖洪根.海外移民返乡家庭旅游的集体记忆和国家认同建构[J].旅游学刊,2022,37(2):46-61.[Sun Yan, Li Mimi, Xiao Honggen. Construction of collective memory and national identity through homeland visits:Narratives from Chinese immigrants[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2022,37(2):46-61.]
[16] Griffiths I, Sharpley R. Influences of nationalism on tourist-host relationships[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2012,39(4):2051-2072.
[17] Yang I M, French J A, Lee C, et al. The symbolism of international tourism in national identity[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2020, 83:102966. DOI:10.1016/j.annals.2020.102966.
[18] Miller D. On Nationality[M]. Oxford:Oxford University Press, 1995:19.
[19] 李志伟,赵志峰.现代旅游语境中的认同[J].旅游学刊,2019,34(7):46-59.[Li Zhiwei, Zhao Zhifeng. Identity in the context of modern tourism:Scientometric analysis of SSCI journal publications[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2019,34(7):46-59.]
[20] Jamalian M, Kavaratzis M, Saren M. A happy experience of a dark place:Consuming and performing the Jallianwala Bagh[J]. Tourism Management, 2020,81:104168. DOI:10.1016/j.tourman.2020.104168.
[21] Greenfeld L. Nationalism and modernity[J]. Social Research, 1996, 63(1):3-40.
[22] White L, Frew E. Tourism and national identities:Connections and conceptualisations:An international perspective[M]//Tourism and National Identities. New York:Routledge, 2011:1-11.
[23] 江宜桦.自由主义、民族主义与国家认同[M].台北:扬智文化事业股份有限公司,1998:15.[Jiang Yihua. Liberalism, Nationalism and National Identity[M]. Taibei:Yang-Chih Book, 1998:15.]
[24] 曹兴. 缘何走出民族主义与国家主义悖论——对西方传统民族国家理论的反思与批判[J]. 世界民族,2017(6):22-30.[Cao Xing. The paradox of ethnicism and nationalism:Reflections and critical analyses on traditional western nation-state theories[J]. Journal of World Peoples Studies, 2017(6):22-30.]
[25] Chen C, Song M. Visualizing a field of research:A methodology of systematic scientometric reviews[J]. PloS ONE, 2019,14(10):1-25.
[26] Onwuegbuzie A J, Leech N L, Collins K M T. Qualitative analysis techniques for the review of the literature[J]. Qualitative Report, 2012,17(28):1-28.
[27] Billig, M. Banal Nationalism[M]. London:Sage, 1995:37-59.
[28] Urry, J. Tourist Gaze:Travel, Leisure and Society[M]. London:Sage, 1990:1-15.
[29] Maccannell D. Staged authenticity:Arrangements of social space in tourist settings[J].American Journal of Sociology, 1973,79(3):589- 603.
[30] Lowenthal D. The Past is a Foreign Country[M]. New York:Cambridge University Press, 1985:1-50.
[31] Cohen E, Cohen S A. Current sociological theories and issues in tourism[J]. Annals of Tourism research, 2012,39(4):2177-2202.
[32] Ashworth G J, Isaac R K. Have we illuminated the dark? Shifting perspectives on 'dark' tourism[J]. Tourism Recreation Research, 2015,40(3):316-325.
[33] Light D. Progress in dark tourism and thanatourism research:An uneasy relationship with heritage tourism[J]. Tourism Management, 2017,61:275-301.
[34] Edensor, T. National Identity, Popular Culture and Everyday Life[M]. Oxford:Berg, 2002:12-98.
[35] Palmer C. An Ethnography of Englishness:Experiencing Identity Through Tourism[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2005,32(1):7- 27.
[36] Hall C M. Tourism and Politics:Policy, Power and Place[M]. Chichester:Wiley, 1994:2-93.
[37] Light D. Dracula tourism in Romania cultural identity and the state[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2007,34(3):746-765.
[38] Chiang C Y, Shaffer M S. See America first:Tourism and national identity, 1880-1940[J]. The Journal of American History, 2003,8(4):692-693.
[39] Light D. Gazing on communism:Heritage tourism and postcommunist identities in Germany, Hungary and Romania[J]. Tourism Geographies, 2000,2(2):157-176.
[40] Roppola T, Uzzell D, Packer J, et al. National identities and war heritage:Acceptance and resistance of an authorised heritage discourse among visitors to the Australian war memorial[J]. International Journal of Heritage Studies:IJHS, 2020:1-16. https://doi.org/10.1080/13527258.2020.1798270.
[41] Park H Y. Shared national memory as intangible heritage[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2011,38(2):520-539.
[42] Palmer N. Ethnic equality, national identity and selective cultural representation in tourism promotion:Kyrgyzstan, Central Asia[J]. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2007,15(6):645-662.
[43] Tinson J S, Saren M A J, Roth B E. Exploring the role of dark tourism in the creation of national identity of young Americans[J]. Journal of Marketing Management, 2015,31(7-8):856-880.
[44] Wang E X, Shen C Y, Zheng J J, et al. The antecedents and consequences of awe in dark tourism[J]. Current Issues in Tourism, 2020:1-15. https://doi.org/10.1080/13683500.2020.1782857.
[45] Rivera L A. Managing "spoiled" national identity:War, tourism, and memory in Croatia[J]. American Sociological Review, 2008, 73(4):613-634.
[46] Pezzullo P C. "This is the only tour that sells":Tourism, disaster, and national identity in New Orleans[J]. Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change, 2009,7(2):99-114.
[47] 中共中央办公厅,国务院办公厅.2004-2010年全国红色旅游发展规划纲要[Z].北京:中共中央办公厅,国务院办公厅,2004.[CPC Central Committee and State Council. National Red Tourism Development Plan 2004-2010[Z]. Beijing:CPC Central Committee and State Council, 2004.]
[48] 郭俊伶,卢东,金鹏.红色旅游中敬畏情绪对游客国家认同的影响研究[J]. 资源开发与市场,2018,34(7):1026-1031.[Guo Junling, LU Dong, JIN Pen. Study on influence of awe on tourists' national identity in red tourism[J]. Resource Development & Market, 2018, 34(7):1026-1031.]
[49] 张圆刚,刘鲁.红色旅游资源地游客国家认同的影响因素与多元路径研究——基于模糊集定性比较分析[J].自然资源学报,2021, 36(7):1658-1672.[Zhang Yuangang, Liu Lu. Research on the influencing factors of national identity of red tourism resource destination from the perspective of configuration and multiple paths:Based on the fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis[J]. Journal of Natural Resources, 2021,36(7):1658-1672.]
[50] Wall G, Zhao N R. China's red tourism:Communist heritage, politics and identity in a party-state[J]. International Journal of Tourism Cities, 2017,3(3):305-320.
[51] Light D. 'Facing the future':Tourism and identity-building in postsocialist Romania[J]. Political Geography, 2001,20(8):1053-1074.
[52] Bhandari K. Imagining the Scottish nation:Tourism and homeland nationalism in Scotland[J]. Current Issues in Tourism, 2016,19(9):913-929.
[53] Fernández N. Constructing national identity through Galician homeland tourism[J]. Genealogy, 2019,4(1):1-21.
[54] Sim D, Leith M. Diaspora tourists and the Scottish Homecoming 2009[J]. Journal of Heritage Tourism, 2013,8(4):259-274.
[55] Skey M. 'Thank God, I'm back!':(Re)Defining the nation as a homely place in relation to journeys abroad[J]. Journal of Cultural Geography, 2011,28(2):233-252.
[56] Mulligan A N. A Forgotten'Greater Ireland':The transatlantic development of Irish nationalism[J]. Scottish Geographical Journal, 2002,118(3):219-234.
[57] Yang L. Ethnic tourism and cultural representation[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2011,38(2):561-585.
[58] Tie C, Holden A, Park H Y. A'reality of return':The case of the Sarawakian-Chinese visiting china[J]. Tourism Management, 2015, 47:206-212.
[59] Marschall S. Transnational migrant home visits as identity practice:The case of African migrants in south Africa[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2017,63:140-150.
[60] Zhang Y C, Coghlan A, Knox K. Understanding the depersonalisation process in post-disaster sites[J]. Tourism Recreation Research, 2018,43(4):497-510.
[61] Nanjangud A, Reijnders S. 'I felt more homely over there…':Analysing tourists' experience of Indianness at Bollywood Parks Dubai[J]. Current Issues in Tourism, 2021:1-14.
[62] Zhang S N, Ruan W Q, Yang T T. National identity construction in cultural and creative tourism:The double mediators of implicit cultural memory and explicit cultural learning[J]. SAGE Open, 2021, 11(3):2158-2440211040789. DOI:10.1177/21582440211040789.
[63] 唐雪琼,钱俊希,杨茜好.跨境流动视阈下的节庆文化与民族认同研究——中越边境苗族花山节案例[J].地理科学进展,2017,36(9):1081-1091.[Tang Xueqiong, Qian Junxi, Yang Xihao. Examining festival culture and ethnic identity from the perspective of crossborder mobility:A case study of Huashan Festival at the SinoVietnamese[J]. Progress in Geography, 2017,36(9):1081-1091.]
[64] Unger O, Uriely N, Fuchs G. On-site animosity and national identity:Business travelers on stage[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 2021,88:103181. DOI:10.1016/j.annals.2021.103181.
[65] Gieling J, Ong C. Warfare tourism experiences and national identity:The case of airborne museum 'Hartenstein' in Oosterbeek, the Netherlands[J]. Tourism Management, 2016,57:45-55.
[66] White L. Imagining the nation:Signifiers of national capital status in Washington, DC and Canberra[J]. Current Issues in Tourism, 2012,15(1-2):121-135.
[67] Gordon D L A, Osborne B S. Constructing national identity in Canada's capital, 1900-2000:Confederation Square and the National War Memorial[J]. Journal of Historical Geography, 2004, 30(4):618-642.
[68] Knudsen D C, Rickly-Boyd J M, Greer C E. Myth, national identity, and the contemporary tourism site:The case of Amalienborg and Frederiksstaden[J]. National Identities, 2013,16(1):53-70.
[69] Pookaiyaudom G, Tan N H. The Buppaesanniwas phenomenon:'Thainess' and national identity as a film tourism motivation[J]. Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change, 2020,18(5):497-513.
[70] Scherer E, Thelen T. On countryside roads to national identity:Japanese morning drama series (asadora) and contents tourism[C]//Japan Forum. Routledge, 2020,32(1):6-29.
[71] Zantides E. Looking inwards, designing outwards:National identity and print advertisements of the Cyprus tourism organisation[J]. Visual studies, 2016,31(3):248-259.
[72] Cheng M, Wong A I. Tourism and Chinese popular nationalism[J]. Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change, 2014,12(4):307-319.
[73] Zhang C X, Fong L H N, Li S, et al. National identity and cultural festivals in postcolonial destinations[J]. Tourism Management, 2019,73:94-104.
[74] Ali F, Kim W G, Ryu K. The effect of physical environment on passenger delight and satisfaction:Moderating effect of national identity[J]. Tourism Management, 2016,57:213-224.
[75] Mclean F, Cooke S. Constructing the identity of a nation:The tourist gaze at the museum of Scotland[J]. Tourism Culture & Communication, 2003,4(3):153-162.
[76] Kong S, Zhu H. Unpacking millennial Chinese women's risk perceptions in outbound travel:An intersectional perspective[J]. Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management, 2021,49:407-417.
[77] Roppola T, Packer J, Uzzell D, et al. Nested assemblages:Migrants, war heritage, informal learning and national identities[J]. International Journal of Heritage Studies, 2019,25(11):1205-1223.
[78] Hearn J. National identity:Banal, personal and embedded[J]. Nations and Nationalism, 2007,13(4):657-674.
[79] Lavi L. Making time for national identity:Theoretical concept and empirical glance on the temporal performance of national identity[J]. Nations and Nationalism, 2013,19(4):696-714.
[80] Scourfield J, Dicks B, Drakeford M, et al. Children, Place and Identity:Nation and Locality in Middle Childhood[M]. London:Routledge, 2006:40-58.