社区旅游内卷化与去内卷化：基于云台山社区的案例解析

梁增贤; 苏思晴; 保继刚

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2023.05.018

PDF(3967 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2023, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (5) : 154-161. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2023.05.018

旅游

社区旅游内卷化与去内卷化：基于云台山社区的案例解析

梁增贤^1,2, 苏思晴¹, 保继刚^1,2

作者信息 +

THE INVOLUTION AND DE-INVOLUTION OF COMMUNITY TOURISM: CASE STUDY ON YUNTAI MOUNTAIN

LIANG Zeng-xian^1,2, SU Si-qing¹, BAO Ji-gang^1,2

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

过往研究将社区旅游增长困境归因于权力关系不平衡导致的社区权益受损或冲突，并通过社区参与和增权解决。然而，社区参与和增权的有效运用依赖于外部条件和社区能力。本文试图从内卷化视角重新审视社区旅游增长困境，构建社区旅游内卷化分析框架，并用于解析焦作云台山案例。社区旅游内卷化是社区旅游发展到一定形态后，停滞不前或无法转变到新的形态，旅游产品或企业同质化竞争激烈，无法适应市场变化，导致社区内部权力和利益复杂化，社区总体边际收益或旅游效益相对下降。案例研究表明，云台山社区先后经历农业内卷化、去农业内卷化、社区旅游内卷化、以及社区旅游去内卷化4个阶段。各阶段交叠，并具有不同的背景、成因和特点。本研究在去内卷化建议中指出，提升社区内生能力是根本，破解外部条件限制是关键，而政府和核心企业应起示范或主导作用。

Abstract

China's peasant economy has been the longest lasting and largest in the world, also its most highly "involuted" economic system which makes rural community tourism of China different. This study addresses the stagnation and void development of rural community tourism and introduces the theory of involution to the analysis on the rural community development. Using five communities (Anshang, Gudongyao, Wujiatai, Chapengzhang, and Heishiling) with defined boundaries within China's Yuntai Mountain area as case, this study conducts a longitudinal case study to explore the process and mechanism of involution and deinvolution of rural community tourism. The involution of rural community tourism refers to a certain stage or condition of community tourism development where tourism development is stagnating or unable to transform and upgrade to a new form, repetition in quantity but less evolution in quality. Under the circumstances, the community become more complicated and homogeneous, and the marginal returns of the whole community decline as the increase community tourism, the increase of tourism is unable to adapt to new market demand finally. This case study identified that in the past decades, the five Yuntai communities have gone through four phases of (de-) involution, including involution in agriculture, de-involution in agriculture through developing tourism, involution in community tourism, and de-involution in community tourism.

导出引用

梁增贤, 苏思晴, 保继刚. 社区旅游内卷化与去内卷化：基于云台山社区的案例解析[J]. 人文地理. 2023, 38(5): 154-161 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2023.05.018

LIANG Zeng-xian, SU Si-qing, BAO Ji-gang. THE INVOLUTION AND DE-INVOLUTION OF COMMUNITY TOURISM: CASE STUDY ON YUNTAI MOUNTAIN[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2023, 38(5): 154-161 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2023.05.018

中图分类号： F590

参考文献

[1] 徐冬,黄震方,洪学婷,等.乡村旅游地文化胁迫类型、格局与机理研究——以苏州东山镇为例[J]. 地理研究,2020,39(10):2249- 2267.[Xu Dong, Huang Zhenfang, Hong Xueting, et al. Types, spatial pattern and mechanism of cultural stress of rural tourism destination:A case study of Dongshan town in Suzhou[J]. Geographical Research, 2020,39(10):2249-2267.]
[2] 麻学锋,刘玉林,谭佳欣. 旅游驱动的乡村振兴实践及发展路径——以张家界市武陵源区为例[J]. 地理科学,2020,40(12):2019- 2026.[Ma Xuefeng, Liu Yulin, Tan Jiaxin. The practice and development path of rural revitalization driven by tourism:Taking Wulingyuan district of Zhangjiajie city as an example[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2020,40(12):2019-2026.]
[3] 孙九霞,黄秀波.民族旅游地社区参与中的空间协商与利益博弈——以丽江白沙村为例[J].广西民族大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2017, 39(2):40-48.[Sun Jiuxia, Huang Xiubo. Competing interests and spatial negotiation in ethnic tourism community:A case study of Baisha village in Lijiang city[J]. Journal of Guangxi University for Nationalities (Philosophy and Social Science Edition), 2017,39(2):40-48.]
[4] 左冰. 共容利益:社区参与旅游发展之利益协调[J]. 旅游科学, 2013,27(1):1-14.[Zuo Bing. Encompassing interest:Interest coordination of community involving pattern of tourism development[J]. Tourism Science, 2013,27(1):1-14.]
[5] 孟凯,李佳宾,陈险峰,等.乡村旅游地发展过程中"公地悲剧" 的演化与治理[J]. 旅游学刊,2018,33(8):19-28.[Meng Kai, Li Jiabin, Chen Xianfeng, et al. Revolution and governance of "tragedy of the commons" in the developing process of rural tourism destination[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2018,33(8):19-28.]
[6] 翁时秀,彭华. 旅游发展初级阶段弱权利意识型古村落社区增权研究——以浙江省楠溪江芙蓉村为例[J]. 旅游学刊,2011,26(7):53-59.[Weng Shixiu, Peng Hua. On the study of empowerment in weak-right awareness-type ancient village community under the initial stage of tourism development:A case of Furong village at Nanxi river basin, Zhejiang province[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2011,26(7):53- 59.]
[7] 左冰,保继刚. 从"社区参与" 走向"社区增权"——西方"旅游增权" 理论研究述评[J]. 旅游学刊,2008,23(4):58-63.[Zuo Bing, Bao Jigang. From community participation to community empowerment:Review on theoretical study of "tourism empowerment" in Western countries[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2008,23(4):58-63.]
[8] 保继刚,孙九霞.雨崩村社区旅游:社区参与方式及其增权意义[J]. 旅游论坛,2008,1(1):58-65.[Bao Jigang, Sun Jiuxia. Community participation in tourism of Yubeng village:Means of participation and its significance for empowerment[J]. Tourism Forum, 2008,1(1):58-65.]
[9] 保继刚,左冰. 旅游招商引资中的制度性机会主义行为解析——西部A地旅游招商引资个案研究[J].人文地理,2008,23(3):1-6,91.[Bao Jigang, Zuo Bing. Institutional opportunistic behavior in tourism investment promotion:A case from Western China[J]. Human Geography, 2008,23(3):1-6,91.]
[10] 左冰,保继刚. 旅游吸引物权再考察[J]. 旅游学刊,2016,31(7):13- 23.[Zuo Bing, Bao Jigang. Revisiting tourist attractions rights[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2016,31(7):13-23.]
[11] 翁时秀,卢建鸣.空间治理的社区实践与正当性建构——以浙江省永嘉县芙蓉村传统村落保护为例[J]. 地理研究,2019,38(6):1322-1332.[Weng Shixiu, Lu Jianming. The local practices and legitimacy construction in spatial governance:A case study of traditional village protection in Furong village, Zhejiang province[J]. Geographical Research, 2019,38(6):1322-1332.]
[12] Service E R. Cultural Evolutionism:Theory in Practice[M]. New York:Holt, Rinehart & Winston, 1971:1-38.
[13] 赵黎.发展还是内卷?——农村基层医疗卫生体制改革与变迁[J]. 中国农村观察,2018(6):89-109.[Zhao Li. Development or involution? A critical reflection on China's grassroots health system reform in rural areas[J]. China Rural Survey, 2018(6):89-109.]
[14] 刘世定,邱泽奇. "内卷化" 概念辨析[J]. 社会学研究,2004(5):96- 110.[Liu Shiding, Qiu Zeqi. The concept discrimination of "involution"[J]. Sociological Studies, 2004(5):96-110.]
[15] Geertz C. Agricultural Involution:The Process of Ecological Change in Indonesia[M]. Berkeley:University of California Press, 1963:1-37.
[16] 黄宗智. 长江三角洲小农家庭与乡村发展[M]. 北京:中华书局, 2000:21-93.[Huang Zongzhi. Small Farmer Families and Rural Development in the Yangtze River Delta[M]. Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company, 2000:21-93.]
[17] 黄宗智.华北的小农经济与社会变迁[M].北京:中华书局出版社, 2000:65-124.[Huang Zongzhi. Peasant Economy of North China and Social Change[M]. Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company, 2000:65-124.]
[18] 杜赞奇. 文化、权力与国家:1900-1942年的华北农村[M]. 王福明,译. 南京:江苏人民出版社,2018:1-12.[Prasenjit D. Cultural Power and the State:Rural North China, 1900-1942[M]. Wang Fuming, translate. Nanjing:Jiangsu People's Publishing House, 2018:1-12.]
[19] 何艳玲,蔡禾.中国城市基层自治组织的"内卷化" 及其成因[J].中山大学学报(社会科学版),2005,45(5):104-109,128.[He Yanling, Cai He. An analysis of involution of Chinese residents' committee and its reason[J]. Journal of Sun Yat-sen University (Social Science Edition), 2005,45(5):104-109,128.]
[20] 张晨,刘育宛. "红色管家" 何以管用?——基层治理创新"内卷化" 的破解之道[J]. 公共行政评论,2021,14(1):2-22,217-218.[Zhang Chen, Liu Yuwan. How does the "Red Steward" work? Solving the problem of "involution" in grassroots governance innovation[J]. Journal of Public Administration, 2021,14(1):2-22,217-218.]
[21] 孔翔,宋志贤.开发区周边新建社区内卷化现象研究——以昆山市蓬曦社区为例[J]. 城市问题,2018(5):4-14.[Kong Xiang, Song Zhixian. Community involution of new communities around the development zones:A case study of Pengxi community around Kunshan economic and technological development zone[J]. Urban Problems, 2018(5):4-14.]
[22] 叶鹏飞.探索农民工城市社会融合之路——基于社会交往"内卷化" 的分析[J]. 城市发展研究,2012,19(1):81-85,109.[Ye Pengfei. The way of the migrant workers' social inclusion:Based on the involution feature of social interaction[J]. Urban Development Studies, 2012,19(1):81-85,109.]
[23] 周常春,刘剑锋,石振杰.贫困县农村治理"内卷化" 与参与式扶贫关系研究——来自云南扶贫调查的实证[J].公共管理学报,2016, 13(1):81-91,156-157.[Zhou Changchun, Liu Jianfeng, Shi Zhenjie. Research on the relationship between poverty rural governance involution and participatory poverty reduction:A case study in Yunnan province[J]. Journal of Public Management, 2016,13(1):81-91, 156-157.]
[24] 邓小海,云建辉.我国乡村旅游产业"去内卷化" 动力机制研究[J]. 商业经济研究, 2020(19):178-181.[Deng Xiaohai, Yun Jianhui. Study on driving force to involution of rural tourism industry in China[J]. Journal of Commercial Economics, 2020(19):178-181.]
[25] 贺雪峰.论乡村治理内卷化——以河南省K镇调查为例[J].开放时代,2011(2):86-101.[He Xuefeng. On the involution of rural governance:Take K town in Henan province as an example[J]. Open Times, 2011(2):86-101.]
[26] 黄宗智. 再论内卷化,兼论去内卷化[J]. 开放时代,2021(1):8,157- 168.[Huang Zongzhi. Re-thinking involution and de-involution[J]. Open Times, 2021(1):8,157-168.]
[27] 郭继强. "内卷化" 概念新理解[J]. 社会学研究,2007(3):194-208, 245-246.[Guo Jiqiang. A new interpretation of the concept of "involution"[J]. Sociological Studies, 2007(3):194-208,245-246.]
[28] 向云发. "内卷化" 与"去内卷化":民族旅游村寨治理的结构、困境与路径[J].云南民族大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2021,38(5):107- 114.[Xiang Yunfa. "Involution" and "deinvolution":The structure, dilemmas and approaches of governance of ethnic tourism villages[J]. Journal of Yunnan Minzu University (Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition), 2021,38(5):107-114.]
[29] 郑普建. "去内卷化":有为政府与有效市场的互动逻辑——以浙江为例[J]. 浙江树人大学学报(人文社会科学),2021,21(1):60-66.[Zheng Pujian. "De-involute":The interaction logic of active government and effective markets:Taking Zhejiang as an example[J]. Journal of Zhejiang Shuren University (Humanities and Social Sciences), 2021,21(1):60-66.]
[30] 彭慕兰. 大分流:欧洲中国及现代世界经济的发展[M]. 史健云, 译. 南京:江苏人民出版社,2016:85-99.[Pomeranz K. The Great Divergence:Economic Development in Europe, China and the Modern World[M]. Shi Jianyun, translate. Nanjing:Jiangsu People's Publishing House, 2016:85-99.]
[31] 左冰,万莹.去内卷化:乡村旅游对农业发展的影响研究[J].中国农业大学学报(社会科学版),2015,32(4):21-30.[Zuo Bing, Wan Ying. De-involution:The impacts of rural tourism on agriculture development[J]. Journal of China Agricultural University (Social Sciences), 2015,32(4):21-30.]
[32] 黄宗智.小农经济理论与"内卷化" 及"去内卷化"[J].开放时代,2020(4):9,126-139.[Huang Zongzhi. The theory of peasant economy and "involution" and "de-involution"[J]. Open Times, 2020(4):9,126-139.]
[33] 翁时秀,彭华.权力关系对社区参与旅游发展的影响——以浙江省楠溪江芙蓉村为例[J]. 旅游学刊,2010,25(9):51-57.[Weng Shixiu, Peng Hua. The impact of power relationship on community participation in tourism development:A case from Furong village at Nanxi river basin, Zhejiang province[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2010, 25(9):51-57.]
[34] 陈锋.分利秩序与基层治理内卷化:资源输入背景下的乡村治理逻辑[J]. 社会, 2015, 35(3):95-120.[Chen Feng. The hierarchy of profit division and grassroots governance involution:The logic of rural governance under the background of the resource input[J]. Chinese Journal of Sociology, 2015,35(3):95-120.]
[35] 饶勇,杨岳轩,林雪琼,等.旅游扶贫中的"外来劳动者-本地贫困人口" 知识转移[J].旅游学刊,2018,33(12):26-35.[Rao Yong, Yang Yuexuan, Lin Xueqiong, et al. Knowledge transfer from migrant workers to the impoverished local population in pro-poor tourism[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2018,33(12):26-35.]
[36] 文彤,苏晓波.关系与制度:地方嵌入中的旅游小企业[J].旅游学刊,2017,32(10):39-46.[Wen Tong, Su Xiaobo. Relationship and institution:Small tourism business embedded in local social networks[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2017,32(10):39-46.]
[37] Vargas-Sánchez A, Plaza-Mejía M D L Á, Porras-Bueno N. Understanding residents' attitudes toward the development of industrial tourism in a former mining community[J]. Journal of Travel Research, 2009,47(3):373-387.
[38] Sætórsdóttir A D, Hall C M. Visitor satisfaction in wilderness in times of overtourism:A longitudinal study[J]. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2021,29(1):123-141.
[39] Gioia D A, Corley K G, Hamilton A L. Seeking qualitative rigor in inductive research:Notes on the Gioia methodology[J]. Organizational Research Methods, 2013,16(1):15-31.
[40] Eisenhardt K M. Building theories from case study research[J]. Academy of Management Review, 1989,14(4):532-550.
[41] 梁增贤. 旅游地社区居民生活质量评估——检验多重差异理论的适用性[J]. 旅游学刊,2018,33(2):38-47.[Liang Zengxian. Residents' quality of life in tourist destinations:A confirmatory study on multiple discrepancies theory[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2018,33(2):38- 47.]
[42] 刘晓静,梁留科.地质公园景区科普旅游评价指标体系构建及实证——以河南云台山世界地质公园为例[J].经济地理,2016,36(7):182-189.[Liu Xiaojing, Liang Liuke. Construction of geopark popular science tourism evaluation system and empirical research[J]. Economic Geography, 2016,36(7):182-189.]
[43] Liang Z, Bao J. Targeted poverty alleviation in China:Segmenting small tourism entrepreneurs and effectively supporting them[J]. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2018,26(11):1984-2001.
[44] 李锋. 基于双重空间的后开发景区成长性研究——以焦作云台山为例[J]. 旅游学刊,2007,22(10):55-60.[Li Feng. A study on the growth degree of post-development scenic spot based on double space:A case study of Mount Yun Tai scenic spot[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2007,22(10):55-60.]
[45] 孟凯. 旅游发展引导下乡村城市化的驱动力——以云台山景区内乡村为例[J]. 热带地理,2016,36(5):786-794,877.[Meng Kai. Driving forces of rural urbanization led by tourism development:A case study of the villages in Yuntai Mountain[J]. Tropical Geography, 2016,36(5):786-794,877.]
[46] 黄宗智. 中国的隐性农业革命[M]. 北京:法律出版社,2010:127- 137.[Huang Zongzhi. China's Hidden Agricultural Revolution[M]. Beijing:Law Press, 2010:127-137.]
[47] 彭永祥,曹小曙,吴成基.地质公园的旅游者收益及其核心影响力——以河南云台山世界地质公园为例[J].地理研究,2012,31(9):1722-1735.[Peng Yongxiang, Cao Xiaoshu, Wu Chengji. Tourists benefits of geoparks and its core impact:A case study of Mt.Yuntai global geopark in China[J]. Geographical Research, 2012,31(9):1722-1735.]
[48] 陈楠,乔光辉.大众旅游者与生态旅游者旅游动机比较研究——以云台山世界地质公园为例[J].地理科学进展,2010,29(8):1005- 1010.[Chen Nan, Qiao Guanghui. A comparative study on the tourism motivation of ecological tourists:A case of the geopark at the Mount Yuntai scenic spot[J]. Progress in Geography, 2010, 29(8):1005-1010.]
[49] 史普原.政府组织间的权责配置——兼论"项目制"[J].社会学研究, 2016,31(2):123-148,243-244.[Shi Puyuan. Allocation mechanism of authority and accountability between Chinese government hierarchies:On the "earmarked system"[J]. Sociological Studies, 2016,31(2):123- 148,243-244.]