Abstract：Heritage tourism sites have undergone a transformation in their main contradiction from a competition for the economic value of heritage resources among stakeholders to conflicts between multiple values. Existing theoretical perspectives based on public resource governance overlook the significance of heritage values and its connection to the meaning behind governance practices and power relations. The definition and use of heritage values are closely tied to social processes of knowledge production and dissemination. This paper examines the role of knowledge as a governance tool in the case study of Danxia Mountain World Natural Heritage tourism destination. Findings show that knowledge can serve as an effective governance mechanism in the face of conflicts arising from multiple values in heritage tourism sites. 1) Knowledge discourse serves as the foundation of governance power operation and the source of authority for management agency. 2) Knowledge discourse further leverages spatial reorganization of heritage tourism sites to exert its governance power. 3) Knowledge fosters the identity and responsibility of heritage resource users and turns them into active participants. Knowledge shapes heritage resource users' cognition and imagination of heritage tourism sites and instills in them a sense of identity and responsibility, making heritage resource users autonomous agents who conform to the knowledge discourse and actively participate in heritage protection and value dissemination.
杨继荣, 张朝枝. 基于知识的遗产旅游地治理——丹霞山的案例研究[J]. 人文地理, 2024, 39(1): 153-160.
YANG Ji-rong, ZHANG Chao-zhi. KNOWLEDGE-BASED GOVERNANCE OF HERITAGE TOURISM SITE: A CASE STUDY OF DANXIA MOUNTAIN. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY, 2024, 39(1): 153-160.
徐嵩龄,刘宇,钱薏红,等.西湖模式的意义及其对中国遗产旅游经济学的启示[J].旅游学刊,2013,28(2):23-34.[Xu Songling, Liu Yu, Qian Yihong.The significance of the West Lake pattern and its heuristic implications for creating China's heritage tourism economics[J].Tourism Tribune, 2013,28(2):23-34.]
[2]
周睿,钟林生,刘家明.乡村类世界遗产地的内涵及旅游利用[J].地理研究,2015,34(5):991-1000.[Zhou Rui, Zhong Linsheng, Liu Jiaming.Research on rural world heritage sites:Connotation and tourism utilization[J].Geographical Research, 2015,34(5):991-1000.]
[3]
张成渝,谢凝高".真实性和完整性" 原则与世界遗产保护[J].北京大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2003,40(2):62-68.[Zhang Chengyu, Xie Ninggao.The principles of authenticity and integrity and the conservation of the world heritage[J].Journal of Peking University (Philosophy and Social Sciences), 2003,40(2):62-68.]
[4]
安传艳,李同昇,翟洲燕.话语、资本与遗址区空间的生产——以安阳市殷墟为例[J].旅游学刊,2021,36(7):13-26.[An Chuanyan, Li Tongsheng, Zhai Zhouyan.Discourse, capital and production of the heritage space:A case study of Yinxu in Anyang city[J].Tourism Tribune, 2021,36(7):13-26.]
[5]
时少华,孙业红.社会网络分析视角下世界文化遗产地旅游发展中的利益协调研究——以云南元阳哈尼梯田为例[J].旅游学刊, 2016,31(7):52-64.[Shi Shaohua, Sun Yehong.Research on interests coordination in the tourism development of the world cultural heritage site from the perspective of social network analysis:Taking Hani Rice Terraces in Yunnan as an example[J].Tourism Tribune, 2016,31(7):52-64.]
[6]
王纯阳,冯芷菁.制度压力、旅游地社会责任及其治理绩效——基于开平碉楼与村落的实证调查[J].河南师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2021,48(2):89-94.[Wang Chunyang, Feng Zhijing.Insitutional pressure, tourism destination social responsibility and governance performance:Empirical investigation based on Diaolou and village Kaiping[J].Journal of Henan Normal University (Philosophy and Social Sciences), 2021,48(2):89-94.]
[7]
Zhang C, Fyall A, Zheng Y.Heritage and tourism conflict within world heritage sites in China:A longitudinal study[J].Current Issues in Tourism, 2015,18(1-4):110-136.
[8]
潘运伟,杨明,刘海龙.濒危世界遗产威胁因素分析与中国世界遗产保护对策[J].人文地理,2014,29(1):26-34.[Pan Yunwei, Yang Ming, Liu Hailong.A study on threat factors of world heritages in danger and protection countermeasure of world heritages in China[J].Human Geography, 2014,29(1):26-34.]
[9]
邹统钎,张朝枝,张捷,等.遗产旅游研究如何响应国家战略需求——"重新认识遗产旅游" 系列对话连载(五)[J].旅游论坛,2021, 14(5):85-92.[Zou Tongqian, Zhang Chaozhi, Zhang Jie, et al.How heritage tourism research responds to national strategy:Serial dialogue of "re-understanding heritage tourism" (5)[J].Tourism Forum, 2021,14(5):85-92.]
[10]
王刚,宋锴业.治理理论的本质及其实现逻辑[J].求实,2017,38(3):50-65.[Wang Gang, Song Kaiye.The essence of governance theory and its implementation logic[J].Truth Seeking, 2017,38(3):50-65.]
[11]
庄志民.文化遗产旅游价值取向的新探索[J].旅游学刊,2012, 27(5):3-5.[Zhuang Zhimin.A new exploration on the value orientation of cultural heritage tourism[J].Tourism Tribune, 2012,27(5):3-5.]
[12]
郭强.知识与行动:结构化凝视[J].社会,2005,25(5):18-38.[Guo Qiang.Knowledge and behavior:From the perspective of structuration[J].Chinese Journal of Sociology, 2005,25(5):18-38.]
[13]
Smith L.Archaeological Theory and the Politics of Cultural Heritage[M].London:Routledge, 2004:57-81.
[14]
王绍光.治理研究:正本清源[J].开放时代,2018,37(2):153-176.[Wang Shaoguang.A Study of governance:Etymological clarification[J].Open Times, 2018,37(2):153-176.]
[15]
Bramwell B, Lane B.Critical research on the governance of tourism and sustainability[J].Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2011, 19(4/5):411-421.
[16]
Bramwell B.Governance, the state and sustainable tourism:A political economy approach[J].Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2011, 19(4/5):459-477.
[17]
王林,廖国一.从困境到理性:村落遗产旅游中的自组织研究——以龙脊平安寨为例[J].旅游科学,2013,27(2):36-45.[Wang Lin, Liao Guoyi.From dilemma to rationality:A research on selforganization in vill heritage tourism:A case study of Ping'an village in northern Guangxi[J].Tourism Science, 2013,27(2):36-45.]
[18]
张朝枝,保继刚,徐红罡.旅游发展与遗产管理研究:公共选择与制度分析的视角——兼遗产资源管理研究评述[J].旅游学刊,2004, 19(5):35-40.[Zhang Chaozhi, Bao Jigang, Xu Honggang.Tourism development and heritage management research:Public choice and institutional analysis:A study summary of heritage resources management[J].Tourism Tribune, 2004,19(5):35-40.]
[19]
张朝枝.旅游与遗产保护——政府治理视角的理论与实证[M].北京:中国旅游出版社,2006:11.[Zhang Chaozhi.Tourism and Heritage Protection:Theory and Empirical Research from the Perspective of Government Governance[M].Beijing:China Tour Publishing House, 2006:11.]
[20]
胡北明,雷蓉.社区自治型遗产旅游地公地悲剧及其治理——以民族村寨型景区为例[J].西南民族大学学报(人文社会科学版), 2014,35(2):150-154.[Hu Beiming, Lei Rong.The tragedy of commons and its governance in community autonomous heritage tourism sites:A case study of the ethnic village scenic spots[J].Journal of Southwest Minzu University(Humanities and Social Science), 2014,35(2):150-154.]
[21]
白如山,王晓文.跨界区域品牌共享型旅游地冲突及其治理机制研究——以福建土楼为例[J].亚热带资源与环境学报,2012,7(4):55-63.[Bai Rushan, Wang Xiaowen.Conflicts and governance mechanism of brand-sharing tourism destination in cross-border region:A case study on Fujian Tulou[J].Journal of Subtropical Resources and Environment, 2012,7(4):55-63.]
[22]
王林.乡村旅游社区文化遗产的精英治理——以广西龙脊梯田平安寨村委会选举为例[J].旅游学刊,2009,24(5):67-71.[Wang Lin.On the elite governance of cultural heritage in rural tourism communities:Discussion about the election in Pingan stockaded village, Guangxi province[J].Tourism Tribune, 2009,24(5):67-71.]
[23]
朱建安.世界遗产旅游发展中的政府定位研究[J].旅游学刊,2004, 19(4):79-84.[Zhu Jianan.A study on the role of the government in the development of world heritage travel[J].Tourism Tribune, 2004, 19(4):79-84.]
[24]
彭华,何瑞翔,翁时秀.乡村地区旅游城镇化的多主体共治模式——以福建泰宁水际村为例[J].地理研究,2018,37(12):2383-2398.[Peng Hua, He Ruixiang, Weng Shixiu.Collaborative governance model of tourism urbanization in rural areas:A case study of Shuiji village in Taining county, Fujian[J].Geographical Research, 2018,37(12):2383-2398.]
[25]
Hall C M.A typology of governance and its implications for tourism policy analysis[J].Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2011,19(4/5):437-457.
[26]
唐仲霞,刘梦琳,向程,等.旅游社区治理多主体共生模式研究——基于青海省两个典型社区实例[J].人文地理,2018,33(6):125-131.[Tang Zhongxia, Liu Menglin, Xiang Cheng, et al.Analysis of multiple-agents' symbiotic patterns of tourism community governance:Based on the case of two typical communities of Qinghai province[J].Human Geography, 2018,33(6):125-131.]
[27]
保继刚,杨兵.旅游开发中旅游吸引物权的制度化路径与实践效应——以"阿者科计划" 减贫试验为例[J].旅游学刊,2022,37(1):18-31.[Bao Jigang, Yang Bing.Institutionalization and practices of the "rights to tourist attractions"(RTA) in "Azheke Plan":A fieldstudy of tourism development and poverty reduction[J].Tourism Tribune, 2022,37(1):18-31.]
[28]
Wang Y, Bramwell B.Heritage protection and tourism development priorities in Hangzhou, China:A political economy and governance perspective[J].Tourism Management, 2012,33(4):988-998.
[29]
郭凌,王志章.新制度经济学视角下旅游目的地社会冲突治理研究——基于对四川泸沽湖景区的案例分析[J].旅游学刊,2016, 31(7):32-42.[Guo Ling, Wang Zhizhang.Research on the governance of social conflicts in the perspective of new institutional economics:A case study of Sichuan Lugu Lake destinations[J].Tourism Tribune, 2016,31(7):32-42.]
[30]
王华,郑艳芬.遗产地农村社区参与旅游发展的制度嵌入性——丹霞山瑶塘村与断石村比较研究[J].地理研究,2016,35(6):1164-1176.[Wang Hua, Zheng Yanfen.Tourism participation of rural communities at the heritage sites in the perspective of institutional embeddedness:A comparative study of Yaotang village and Duanshi village in the Danxia mountain[J].Geographical Research, 2016,35(6):1164-1176.]
[31]
吴炆佳,孙九霞.哈尼梯田世界文化遗产地文化治理研究[J].旅游学刊,2020,35(8):71-80.[Wu Wenjia, Sun Jiuxia.The study of cultural governance in Honghe Hani rice terraces world cultural heritage site[J].Tourism Tribune, 2020,35(8):71-80.]
[32]
裴齐容.节事互动中的认同:文化治理的视角[J].旅游学刊,2020, 35(11):9-11.[Pei Qirong.Identity in festival interaction:The perspective of cultural governance[J].Tourism Tribune, 2020,35(11):9-11.]
[33]
李正欢.话语、权力与目的地治理转型:鼓浪屿遗产化研究[J].旅游论坛,2015,8(2):7-13.[Li Zhenghuan.Discourse, power and the transformation of destination governance:The heritabilizaion of Kulangsu[J].Tourism Forum, 2015,8(2):7-13.]
[34]
Hultman J, Hall C M.Tourism place-making:Governance of locality in Sweden[J].Annals of Tourism Research, 2012,39(2):547-570.
[35]
Moscardo G.Exploring social representations of tourism planning:Issues for governance[J].Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2011, 19(4/5):423-436.
[36]
劳拉简·史密斯.遗产本质上都是非物质的:遗产批判研究和博物馆研究[J].文化遗产, 2018(3):62-71.[Smith L (Zhang Yu, trans.).All heritage is intangible:Critical heritage studies and museums[J].Cultural Heritage, 2018(3):62-71.]
[37]
张朝枝,游旺.遗产申报与社区居民遗产价值认知:社会表象的视角——开平碉楼与村落案例研究[J].旅游学刊,2009,24(7):43-47.[Zhang Chaozhi, You Wang.Applying for world heritage and local residents' cognition of heritage values:A perspective of social representation:Based on the case study of Kaiping[J].Tourism Tribune, 2009,24(7):43-47.]
[38]
刘永谋.论知识的权力研究的四大传统[J].天津社会科学,2013, 5(5):60-67.[Liu Yongmou.On the four traditions of the study of the power of knowledge[J].Tianjin Social Sciences, 2013,5(5):60-67.]
[39]
姚伟.知识治理研究回顾:成因、现象、表现维度、机理及作用综述[J].软科学,2013,27(11):121-126.[Yao Wei.Knowledge governance revisited:A review on causes, phenomenon, dimensions, mechanism and effect[J].Soft Science, 2013,27(11):121-126.]
[40]
于淼,朱方伟,张杰,等.知识治理:源起、前沿研究与理论框架[J].科研管理,2021,42(4):65-72.[Yu Miao, Zhu Fangwei, Zhang Jie, et al.Knowledge governance:The origin, frontier and theoretical framework of the research[J].Science Research Management, 2021, 42(4):65-72.]
[41]
Blackman D, Kennedy M, Ritchie B.Knowledge management:The missing link in DMO crisis management?[J].Current Issues in Tourism, 2011,14(4):337-354.
[42]
Paraskevas A, Altinay L, McLean J, et al.Crisis knowledge in tourism:Types, flows and governance[J].Annals of Tourism Research, 2013,41(2):130-152.
[43]
Cooper C.Knowledge management and tourism[J].Annals of Tourism Research, 2006,33(1):47-64.
[44]
Shaw G, Williams A.Knowledge transfer and management in tourism organizations:An emerging research agenda[J].Tourism Management, 2009,30(3):325-335.
[45]
Hoarau H, Kline C.Science and industry:Sharing knowledge for innovation[J].Annals of Tourism Research, 2014,46(3):44-61.
[46]
余传鹏,叶宝升,朱靓怡.知识交换能否提升旅游企业员工的服务创新行为?[J].旅游学刊,2020,35(12):92-108.[Yu Chuanpeng, Ye Baosheng, Zhu Jingyi.Will knowledge exchange really promote service innovative behavior of employees in tourism enterprise?[J].Tourism Tribune, 2020,35(12):92-108.]
[47]
Zach F J, Hill T L.Network, knowledge and relationship impacts on innovation in tourism destinations[J].Tourism Management, 2017,62(5):196-207.
[48]
欧阳英.关于知识社会学的政治哲学分析——从马克思、舍勒、曼海姆到福柯[J].天津社会科学,2014,34(4):67-71.[Ouyang Ying.A political philosophical analysis of the sociology of knowledge:From Marx, Scheler, Mannheim to Foucault[J].Tianjin Social Sciences, 2014,34(4):67-71.]
[49]
彼得·伯格,托马斯·卢克曼.现实的社会建构:知识社会学论纲[M].吴肃然,译.北京:北京大学出版社,2019:47-59.[Berger P, Luckmann T.The Social Construction of Reality:A Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge[M].Wu Suran, trans.Beijing:Peking University Press, 2019:47-59.]
[50]
任唤麟,马小桐.培根旅游观及其对研学旅游的启示[J].旅游学刊, 2018,33(9):145-150.[Ren Huanlin, Ma Xiaotong.Francis Bacon's concepts of tourism and its enlightenment on study tours[J].Tourism Tribune, 2018,33(9):145-150.]
[51]
袁振杰,谢宇琳,何兆聪.主体、知识和地方:一个研学旅行研究的探索性理论框架[J].旅游学刊,2022,37(11):14-26.[Yuan Zhenjie, Xie Yulin, He Zhaocong.Subject, knowledge, and place:An exploratory theoretical framework of study tour[J].Tourism Tribune, 2022,37(11):14-26.]
[52]
赵万里,穆滢潭.福柯与知识社会学的话语分析转向[J].天津社会科学,2012,32(5):62-68.[Zhao Wanli, Mu Yingtan.Foucault and the discourse analysis turn of the sociology of knowledge[J].Tianjin Social Sciences, 2012,32(5):62-68.]
[53]
郑震.空间:一个社会学的概念[J].社会学研究,2010,25(5):167-191.[Zheng Zhen, Space:A concept of sociology[J].Sociological Studies, 2010,25(5):167-191.]
[54]
赵万里.打开知识社会的黑箱——重读斯特尔的《知识社会》[J].社会科学管理与评论,2001,3(2):38-43.[Zhao Wanli.Opening the black box of knowledge society:Rereading Nico Stehr's Knowledge Societies[J].Management and Review of Social Sciences, 2001,3(2):38-43.]
[55]
翁时秀,杨继荣.领域化理论视角下的乡村旅游社区社会空间变迁——以丹霞山青湖塘村为例[J].地理科学进展,2020,39(7):1149-1159.[Weng Shixiu, Yang Jirong.Understanding the changing social space of rural tourism community based on territorialization theory:A case study of Qinghutang village, Mount Danxia[J].Progress in Geography, 2020,39(7):1149-1159.]
[56]
倪思斯,李孟曦,黎结仪,等.中国世界遗产价值的认知与评估——以世界自然遗产广东丹霞山为例[J].旅游论坛,2013,6(5):39-44.[Ni Sisi, Li Mengxi, Li Jieyi, et al.Cognition and evaluation about Chinese world heritage values:A case study of world natural heritage in Danxia Shan, Guangdong[J].Tourism Forum, 2013,6(5):39-44.]
[57]
Elden S.Governmentality, calculation, territory[J].Environment and Planning D:Society and Space, 2007,25(3):562-580.
[58]
翁时秀,卢建鸣.空间治理的社区实践与正当性建构——以浙江省永嘉县芙蓉村传统村落保护为例[J].地理研究,2019,38(6):1322-1332.[Weng Shixiu, Lu Jianming.The local practices and legitimacy construction in spatial governance:A case study of traditional village protection in Furong village, Zhejiang province[J].Geographical Research, 2019,38(6):1322-1332.]
