移民地缘政治的西方地理学研究进展与启示

丁腾飞; 高权

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2024.02.002

PDF(1656 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2024, Vol. 39 ›› Issue (2) : 11-20. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2024.02.002

进展与动态

移民地缘政治的西方地理学研究进展与启示

丁腾飞¹, 高权^1,2

作者信息 +

THE PROGRESS AND IMPLICATIONS OF THE GEOPOLITICS OF MIGRATION IN WESTERN GEOGRAPHICAL RESEARCH

DING Teng-fei¹, GAO Quan^1,2

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

在全球化时代，移民是体现、调节和塑造地缘政治的一种不可忽视的力量。移民地缘政治作为一个新兴的研究领域，对于理解和促进“人类命运共同体”的构建有重要意义。本文回顾了移民地缘政治的发展脉络和主要议题，认为:①移民地缘政治强调移民与流动性作为塑造和承载地缘政治力量的主体，重点分析移民相关的实践和地缘政治在不同尺度下的相互作用。②作为对传统民族国家分析尺度的突破，移民地缘政治将超国家实体、城市、家庭、身体等纳入了批判地缘政治的研究议程，是对移民治理、地缘政治实践变化的回应，也受后现代理论思潮的启发。③难民、边境工作、劳工、离散族裔是目前讨论较多的四个研究议题，它们从不同维度丰富了移民如何作为地缘政治的过程、中介和主体的理解。本文认为国内地理学应该更加关注移民多尺度、多主体的社会文化实践与地缘政治过程的关系。

Abstract

In the era of globalization, migrants are unneglectable forces that magnify, mediate, and modify geopolitics. In geographical literature, the geopolitics of migration has become an emerging field of study that critically juxtaposes migrants' experiences with geopolitical processes. By tracing the theoretical and empirical progress of the field, this article outlines the ontological and epistemological reflections that facilitate the ongoing dialogues between geopolitics and migration studies. It argues that:1) Ontologically, the geopolitics of migration stresses migration-related practices as the embodiment of geopolitical tensions and the enmeshment of geopolitical actors. This challenges the state-centered characterization of international relations, by politicalizing the territorialization and deterritorialization of human mobility. 2) The geopolitics of migration offers decentered, relational, and materialist epistemologies by harnessing postmodern theories such as feminism, biopolitics, and assemblage thinking. Then, this article maps four often-discussed themes of empirical concern, including refugees, borderwork, labors, and diasporas. By doing so, it illustrates how each theme enriches the documentation and theorization of geopolitical processes, mediations, and subjects from different angles. Zooming in on the themes allows an engagement of research with evolving migration governance and geopolitical praxis. Lastly, this article suggests exploring more possible junctions of migration and geopolitics in previously neutralized interfaces between migration and nonhumans, technologies, and environment.

导出引用

丁腾飞, 高权. 移民地缘政治的西方地理学研究进展与启示[J]. 人文地理. 2024, 39(2): 11-20 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2024.02.002

DING Teng-fei, GAO Quan. THE PROGRESS AND IMPLICATIONS OF THE GEOPOLITICS OF MIGRATION IN WESTERN GEOGRAPHICAL RESEARCH[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2024, 39(2): 11-20 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2024.02.002

中图分类号： K901

参考文献

[1] Hyndman J. The geopolitics of migration and mobility[J]. Geopoli-tics, 2012,17(2):243-255.
[2] Agnew J. Emerging China and critical geopolitics:Between world politics and Chinese particularity[J]. Eurasian Geography and Eco-nomics, 2010,51(5):569-582.
[3] Gamlen A. The emigration state and the modern geopolitical imagi-nation[J]. Political Geography, 2008,27(8):840-856.
[4] Vollset S E, Goren E, Yuan C W, et al. Fertility, mortality, migration, and population scenarios for 195 countries and territories from 2017 to 2100:A forecasting analysis for the global burden of disease study[J]. Lancet, 2020,396(10258):1285-1306.
[5] Walker K E, Leitner H. The variegated landscape of local immigra-tion policies in the United States[J]. Urban Geography, 2011,32(2):156-178.
[6] Nagel C R. Geopolitics by another name:Immigration and the poli-tics of assimilation[J]. Political Geography, 2002,21(8):971-987.
[7] Dittmer J, Sharp J. Geopolitics:An Introductory Reader[M]. Lon-don:Routledge, 2014:209-212.
[8] Tesfahuney M. Mobility, racism and geopolitics[J]. Political Geogra-phy, 1998,17(5):499-515.
[9] Kearney M. The local and the global:The anthropology of globaliza-tion and transnationalism[J]. Annual Review of Anthropology, 1995, 24:547-565.
[10] Sloan G. Sir Halford J. Mackinder:The Heartland theory then and now[J]. Journal of Strategic Studies, 1999,22(2-3):15-38.
[11] Crothers L, Lockhart C. Culture and Politics:A Reader[M]. New York:Palgrave Macmillan US, 2000:99-118.
[12] Hyndman J. Mind the gap:Bridging feminist and political geography through geopolitics[J]. Political Geography, 2004,23(3):307-322.
[13] 胡志丁,李钰华,王学文,等.西方流行地缘政治研究进展与展望[J].地理研究, 2020, 39(7):1463-1477.[Hu Zhiding, Li Yuhua, Wang Xuewen, et al. The research progress and prospect of popular geo-politics in the West[J]. Geographical Research, 2020,39(7):1463-1477.]
[14] Kuusisto-Arponen A-K, Gilmartin M. The politics of migration[J]. Political Geography, 2015,48:143-145.
[15] Leitner H. Reconfiguring the spatiality of power:The construction of a supranational migration framework for the European Union[J]. Political Geography, 1997,16(2):123-143.
[16] Bialasiewicz L. Off-shoring and out-sourcing the borders of EU-rope:Libya and EU border work in the Mediterranean[J]. Geopoli-tics, 2012,17(4):843-866.
[17] Barabantseva E, Mhurchú A N, Peterson V S. Introduction:Engag-ing geopolitics through the lens of the intimate[J]. Geopolitics, 2021,26(2):343-356.
[18] Wiertz T. Biopolitics of migration:An assemblage approach[J]. En-vironment and Planning C:Politics and Space, 2021,39(7):1375-1388.
[19] Mitchell K, Jones R, Fluri J L. Handbook on Critical Geographies of Migration[M]. Cheltenham:Edward Elgar Publishing, 2019:18-29.
[20] Collyer M. Geopolitics as a migration governance strategy:Euro-pean Union bilateral relations with Southern Mediterranean coun-tries[J]. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 2016,42(4):606-624.
[21] Stoffelen A. Managing people's (in) ability to be mobile:Geopolitics and the selective opening and closing of borders[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2022,47(1):243-256.
[22] Fakhoury T. Multi-level governance and migration politics in the Arab world:The case of Syria's displacement[J]. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 2019,45(8):1310-1326.
[23] Van Riemsdijk M. Everyday geopolitics, the valuation of labour and the socio-political hierarchies of skill:Polish nurses in Norway[J]. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 2013,39(3):373-390.
[24] Hyndman J, Giles W. Waiting for what?The feminization of asylum in protracted situations[J]. Gender Place and Culture, 2011,18(3):361-379.
[25] Dowler L, Sharp J. A feminist geopolitics?[J]. Space and Polity, 2001,5(3):165-176.
[26] Puar J K. Prognosis time:Towards a geopolitics of affect, debility and capacity[J]. Women&Performance, 2009,19(2):161-172.
[27] Squire V. The Contested Politics of Mobility[M]. London:Rout-ledge, 2010:1-25.
[28] Johnson C, Jones R. The biopolitics and geopolitics of border en-forcement in Melilla[J]. Territory, Politics, Governance, 2018,6(1):61-80.
[29] Rokem J, Fregonese S, Ramadan A, et al. Interventions in urban geopolitics[J]. Political Geography, 2017,61:253-262.
[30] Ridgley J. Cities of refuge:Immigration enforcement, police, and the insurgent genealogies of citizenship in U.S. Sanctuary cities[J]. Urban Geography, 2008,29(1):53-77.
[31] Varsanyi M W. Immigration policing through the backdoor:City or-dinances, the"right to the city ", and the exclusion of undocumented day laborers[J]. Urban Geography, 2008,29(1):29-52.
[32] Knights M. Bangladeshi immigrants in Italy:From geopolitics to micropolitics[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geogra-phers, 1996,21(1):105-123.
[33] Choi E. North Korean women's narratives of migration:Challeng-ing hegemonic discourses of trafficking and geopolitics[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 2014,104(2):271-279.
[34] Wilkins A. Gender, migration and intimate geopolitics:Shifting senses of home among women on the Myanmar-Thailand border[J]. Gender, Place&Culture, 2017,24(11):1549-1568.
[35] Botterill K, Hopkins P, Sanghera G. Familial geopolitics and onto-logical security:Intergenerational relations, migration and minority youth (in) securities in Scotland[J]. Geopolitics, 2020,25(5):1138-1163.
[36] Ehrkamp P. Geographies of migration I:Refugees[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2016,41(6):813-822.
[37] Myadar O, Dempsey K E. Making and unmaking refugees:Geopoli-tics of social ordering and struggle within the global refugee regime[J]. Geopolitics, 2022,27(2):367-374.
[38] Torres R M, Glockner V, Niño-Vega N, et al. Lockdown and the list:Mexican refugees, asylum denial, and the feminist geopolitics of es-perar (waiting/hoping)[J/OL]. Environment and Planning C:Politics and Space, 2022. https://doi.org/10.1177/2399654422111890.
[39] United Nations. Convention relating to the status of refugees[Z/OL].(1951-06-28)[2023-09-10]. Human Rights Instruments, 1951. https://www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/conventionrelating-status-refugees.
[40] Mukhtar S, Che Rose R A, Choy L K, et al. Boko Haram and the geopolitics of forced migration in Nigeria[J]. Journal of Interna-tional Studies, 2018,14:51-63.
[41] Ashutosh I, Mountz A. The geopolitics of migrant mobility:Tracing state relations through refugee claims, boats, and discourses[J]. Geopolitics, 2012,17(2):335-354.
[42] Dempsey K E. Migrant agency and counter-hegemonic efforts among asylum seekers in the Netherlands in response to geopoliti-cal control and exclusion[J]. Geopolitics, 2022,27(2):402-423.
[43] Gill N. Governmental mobility:The power effects of the movement of detained asylum seekers around Britain's detention estate[J]. Po-litical Geography, 2009,28(3):186-196.
[44] Biehl K S. Governing through uncertainty:Experiences of being a refugee in turkey as a country for temporary asylum[J]. Social Analysis, 2015,59(1):57-75.
[45] Ho E L.'Refugee'or'returnee'?The ethnic geopolitics of diasporic resettlement in China and intergenerational change[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2013,38(4):599-611.
[46] Mitchell K, Sparke M. Hotspot geopolitics versus geosocial solidar-ity:Contending constructions of safe space for migrants in Europe[J]. Environment and Planning D:Society and Space, 2018,38(6):1046-1066.
[47] Dempsey K E, Mcdowell S. Disaster depictions and geopolitical representations in Europe's migration'crisis'[J]. Geoforum, 2019, 98:153-160.
[48] Braghiroli S, Makarychev A. Redefining Europe:Russia and the 2015 refugee crisis[J]. Geopolitics, 2018,23(4):823-848.
[49] Sanyal R. Urbanizing refuge:Interrogating spaces of displacement[J]. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 2014, 38(2):558-572.
[50] Zylinska J. The universal acts[J]. Cultural Studies, 2004,18(4):523-537.
[51] Makarychev A. Bordering and identity-making in Europe after the 2015 refugee crisis[J]. Geopolitics, 2018,23(4):747-753.
[52] Johnson C, Jones R, Paasi A, et al. Interventions on rethinking'the border'in border studies[J]. Political Geography, 2011,30(2):61-69.
[53] Collyer M. Deportation and the micropolitics of exclusion:The rise of removals from the UK to Sri Lanka[J]. Geopolitics, 2012,17(2):276-292.
[54] Martin L L.'Catch and remove':Detention, deterrence, and disci-pline in US noncitizen family detention practice[J]. Geopolitics, 2012,17(2):312-334.
[55] Mainwaring ?, Brigden N. Beyond the border:Clandestine migra-tion journeys[J]. Geopolitics, 2016,21(2):243-262.
[56] Savio Vammen I M, Cold-Ravnkilde S, Lucht H. Borderwork in the expanded EU-African borderlands[J]. Geopolitics, 2022,27(5):1317-1330.
[57] Rumford C. Introduction:Citizens and borderwork in Europe[J]. Space and Polity, 2008,12(1):1-12.
[58] Coleman M. Immigration geopolitics beyond the Mexico-US border[J]. Antipode, 2007,39(1):54-76.
[59] Hiemstra N. Geopolitical reverberations of US migrant detention and deportation:The view from Ecuador[J]. Geopolitics, 2012, 17(2):293-311.
[60] Crane A. The politics of development and humanitarianism in EU externalization:Managing migration in Ukraine[J]. Environment and Planning C:Politics and Space, 2020,38(1):20-39.
[61] Cold-Ravnkilde S M. Borderwork in the grey zone:Everyday resis-tance within European border control initiatives in Mali[J]. Geo-politics, 2022,27(5):1450-1469.
[62] Williams J M. Affecting migration:Public information campaigns and the intimate spatialities of border enforcement[J]. Environment and Planning C:Politics and Space, 2020,38(7-8):1198-1215.
[63] Vammen I M S.'When migrants become messengers':Affective bor-derwork and aspiration management in Senegal[J]. Geopolitics, 2022,27(5):1410-1429.
[64] Achtnich M. Waiting to move on:Migration, borderwork and mo-bility economies in Libya[J]. Geopolitics, 2022,27(5):1376-1389.
[65] Prokkola E K. Geopolitics of border securitization:Sovereignty, na-tionalism and solidarity in asylum reception in Finland[J]. Geopoli-tics, 2020,25(4):867-886.
[66] Panebianco S. Migration governance in the Mediterranean:The Sir-acusa experience[J]. Geopolitics, 2022,27(3):752-772.
[67] Dean K. Assembling the Sino-Myanmar borderworld[J]. Eurasian Geography and Economics, 2020,61(1):34-54.
[68] Triandafyllidou A. Decentering the study of migration governance:A radical view[J]. Geopolitics, 2022,27(3):811-825.
[69] Borrelli L, Pinkerton P, Safouane H, et al. Agency within mobility:Conceptualising the geopolitics of migration management[J]. Geo-politics, 2022,27(4):1140-1167.
[70] Varsanyi M W, Nevins J. Introduction:Borderline contradictions:Neoliberalism, unauthorised migration, and intensifying immigra-tion policing[J]. Geopolitics, 2007,12(2):223-227.
[71] Varsanyi M W. Documenting undocumented migrants:The matrícu-las consulares as neoliberal local membership[J]. Geopolitics, 2007, 12(2):299-319.
[72] Creţan R, Light D. COVID-19 in Romania:Transnational labour, geopolitics, and the Roma'outsiders'[J]. Eurasian Geography and Economics, 2020,61(4-5):559-572.
[73] Nevins J. Dying for a cup of coffee?Migrant deaths in the USMexico border region in a neoliberal age[J]. Geopolitics, 2007, 12(2):228-247.
[74] Hua X B, Kono Y, Zhang L, et al. How transnational labor migration affects upland land use practices in the receiving country:Find-ings from the China-Myanmar borderland[J]. Land Use Policy, 2019,84:163-176.
[75] Eder R. I am where I think I will work:Higher education and labor migration regime in the Philippines[J]. Educational Studies, 2016, 52(5):452-468.
[76] Silvey R. Unequal borders:Indonesian transnational migrants at im-migration control[J]. Geopolitics, 2007,12(2):265-279.
[77] Chowdhury M, Rajan S I. South Asian Migration in the Gulf:Causes and Consequences[M]. Cham:Springer International Pub-lishing, 2018:191-210.
[78] Kutz W, Wolff S. Urban geopolitics and the decentring of migration diplomacy in EU-Moroccan affairs[J]. Geopolitics, 2022,27(3):703-728.
[79] Carter S. The geopolitics of diaspora[J]. Area, 2005,37(1):54-63.
[80] Clifford J. Diasporas[J]. Cultural Anthropology, 1994,9(3):302-338.
[81] 周雷,牛忠光.国际移民视域下的" Diaspora "话语:概念反思与译介困境[J].世界民族,2018(3):73-81.[Zhou Lei, Niu Zhongguang. The discourse of diaspora from the perspective of international im-migration:Reflections on the concept and difficulties in translation[J]. Journal of World Peoples Studies, 2018(3):73-81.]
[82] Brubaker R. The'diaspora'diaspora[J]. Ethnic and Racial Studies, 2005,28(1):1-19.
[83] Cohen R. Global Diasporas:An Introduction[M]. New York:Rout-ledge, 2008:15-19.
[84] Popescu G. Diaspora geopolitics:Romanian-Americans and NATO expansion[J]. Geopolitics, 2005,10(3):455-481.
[85] Liu J M. When diaspora politics meet global ambitions:Diaspora institutions amid China's geopolitical transformations[J]. Interna-tional Migration Review, 2022,56(4):1255-1279.
[86] Suslov M." Russian world "concept:Post-Soviet geopolitical ideol-ogy and the logic of" spheres of influence"[J]. Geopolitics, 2018, 23(2):330-353.
[87] Ho E L, Hickey M, Yeoh B S A. Special issue introduction:New re-search directions and critical perspectives on diaspora strategies[J]. Geoforum, 2015,59:153-158.
[88] Pain R, Smith S J. Fear:Critical Geopolitics and Everyday Life[M]. London:Routledge. 2016:19-40.
[89] Hyndman J, Amarasingam A, Naganathan G. Diaspora geopolitics in Toronto:Tamil nationalism and the aftermath of war in Sri Lanka[J]. Geopolitics, 2022,27(2):424-443.
[90] Hui L H D. Critical geopolitics of Palestinian diasporas'autobio-graphical practice[J]. Area, 2020,52(4):758-765.
[91] Ho E L E, Mcconnell F. Conceptualizing'diaspora diplomacy':Ter-ritory and populations betwixt the domestic and foreign[J]. Prog-ress in Human Geography, 2017,43(2):235-255.
[92] Cole J, Dodds K. Unhealthy geopolitics?Bordering disease in the time of coronavirus[J]. Geographical Research, 2021,59(2):169-181.
[93] Grundy-Warr C, Lin S. COVID-19 geopolitics:Silence and erasure in Cambodia and Myanmar in times of pandemic[J]. Eurasian Ge-ography and Economics, 2020,61(4-5):493-510.
[94] Greenhough B. Where species meet and mingle:Endemic humanvirus relations, embodied communication and more-than-human agency at the common cold unit 1946-90[J]. Cultural Geographies, 2012,19(3):281-301.
[95] Hinchliffe S, Bingham N. Securing life:The emerging practices of biosecurity[J]. Environment and Planning A:Economy and Space, 2008,40(7):1534-1551.
[96] Ingram A. The geopolitics of disease[J]. Geography Compass, 2009, 3(6):2084-2097.
[97] Séguin B, Singer P A, Daar A S. Scientific diasporas[J]. Science, 2006,312(5780):1602-1603.
[98] Meyer J-B. Network approach versus brain drain:Lessons from the diaspora[J]. International Migration, 2001,39(5):91-110.
[99] Larner W. Globalising knowledge networks:Universities, diaspora strategies, and academic intermediaries[J]. Geoforum, 2015,59:197-205.
[100] Van Wichelen S. Scales of grievability:On moving children and the geopolitics of precariousness[J]. Social&Cultural Geography, 2015,16(5):552-566.
[101] Martin L. The geopolitics of vulnerability:Children's legal subjec-tivity, immigrant family detention and us immigration law and en-forcement policy[J]. Gender, Place&Culture, 2011,18(4):477-498.
[102] Wilson T M, Donnan H. A Companion to Border Studies[M]. West Sussex:Blackwell Publishing Ltd. 2012:1-25.
[103] 安宁,张博.地缘政治视角下的跨境移民和族裔社区研究[J].世界地理研究,2022,31(6):1119-1129.[An Ning, Zhang Bo. The research of transnational migration and ethnic communities from the perspective of geopolitics[J]. Wolrd Regional Studies, 2022,31(6):1119-1129.]
[104] Zhu H, Qian J. New theoretical dialogues on migration in China:Introduction to the special issue[J]. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 2021,47(12):2685-2705.
[105] 吴金平.地缘政治与当代大陆中国人移民加拿大[J].东南亚研究, 2007(2):72-77.[Wu Jinping. Geopolitics and contemporary mainland Chinese immigration to Canada[J]. Southeast Asian Studies, 2007(2):72-77.]
[106] 吴丽君,朱宇,颜俊,等".一带一路"沿线国家或地区间人口迁移的空间格局及其演化特征[J].世界地理研究,2022,31(2):249-258, 328.[Wu Lijun, Zhu Yu, Yan Jun, et al. A study on the spatial pat-terns and their evolution of international migration among countries or areas along the Belt and Road[J]. Wolrd Regional Studies, 2022, 31(2):249-258,328.]
[107] Ho E L. The geo-social and global geographies of power:Urban aspirations of'worlding'African students in China[J]. Geopolitics, 2017,22(1):15-33.
[108] Gao Q, Tse J K, Woods O. What and whose Confucianism?Sinophone communities and dialogical geopolitics[J]. Dialogues in Human Geography, 2021,11(2):244-247.