中国公众再生育态度的省际差异及影响因素——基于CGSS2021随机情境实验

冯志昕; 王斌; 林琳

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2025.04.009

PDF(2599 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2025, Vol. 40 ›› Issue (4) : 88-96. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2025.04.009

社会

中国公众再生育态度的省际差异及影响因素——基于CGSS2021随机情境实验

冯志昕^1,2,3, 王斌^1,2,3, 林琳¹

作者信息 +

PROVINCIAL DIFFERENCES AND DETERMINANTS OF PUBLIC ATTITUDES TOWARD ADDITIONAL BIRTHS IN CHINA: EVIDENCE FROM THE CGSS 2021 RANDOMIZED SCENARIO EXPERIMENT

FENG Zhi-xin^1,2,3, WANG Bin^1,2,3, LIN Lin¹

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

在三孩政策的推动下，各省的新生儿孩次结构呈现出新变化。再生育态度作为再生育行为的先导，研究其省际差异及影响因素有助于因地制宜地探索再生育支持政策。本研究利用2021年中国综合社会调查（CGSS）数据搭载的随机情境实验，使用多层次Logit回归模型探究公众在不同情境下对生育二孩、三孩态度的影响因素及省际差异。结果显示，三孩政策实施后公众再生育态度的空间格局发生变化，二孩生育态度“西高东低”，三孩生育态度“南高北低”；公众再生育态度加速向消极转变，持积极生育二孩与生育三孩态度的可能性呈正相关关系；“隔代照料”对再生育态度起促进作用，但高老年人口抚养比起抑制作用，老幼照护应统筹考虑。

Abstract

This study utilizes data from the 2021 China General Social Survey (CGSS), conducted by the China Survey and Data Center at Renmin University. The survey used a randomized scenario experiment to capture respondents' attitudes toward having a second or third child under different conditions: annual family income availability of family care, access to childcare services, and the gender of the existing child. Through the application of Multilevel Logit models, this analysis examines the factors influencing public attitudes and provincial differences regarding additional births. The results show that: 1) After the implementation of the three-child policy, the spatial pattern of the public's attitude towards additional births has changed. 2) Attitudes toward additional births have changed significantly, with a positive correlation between support for having a second child and a third child. 3) The combined care model of "one old and one young" needs to be developed.

导出引用

冯志昕, 王斌, 林琳. 中国公众再生育态度的省际差异及影响因素——基于CGSS2021随机情境实验[J]. 人文地理. 2025, 40(4): 88-96 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2025.04.009

FENG Zhi-xin, WANG Bin, LIN Lin. PROVINCIAL DIFFERENCES AND DETERMINANTS OF PUBLIC ATTITUDES TOWARD ADDITIONAL BIRTHS IN CHINA: EVIDENCE FROM THE CGSS 2021 RANDOMIZED SCENARIO EXPERIMENT[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2025, 40(4): 88-96 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2025.04.009

中图分类号： K901

参考文献

[1] 陈卫,段媛媛.中国近10年来的生育水平与趋势[J].人口研究,2019, 43(1):3-17.[Chen Wei, Duan Yuanyuan. Recent levels and trends of fertility in China[J]. Population Research, 2019,43(1):3-17.]
[2] 石智雷,滕聪波. 三孩政策下生育质量研究[J]. 人口学刊,2023, 45(5):1-16.[Shi Zhilei, Teng Congbo. Research on fertility quality under the three-child policy[J]. Population Journal, 2023, 45(5):1-16.]
[3] 龚顺,马墨琳,赵梦婷.当代中国青年生育态度与行为不一致研究[J].中国青年社会科学,2023,42(5):95-103.[Gong Shun, Ma Molin, Zhao Mengting. A study on the inconsistency between attitudes and behaviors of contemporary Chinese youth in childbearing[J]. Journal of Chinese Youth Social Science, 2023,42(5):95-103.]
[4] Marshall E A, Shepherd H. Variants of second demographic transition:Empirical evidence from young women's attitudes about childbearing[J]. Population Research and Policy Review, 2022, 41(6):2531-2554.
[5] Upmeyer A, Six B. Attitudes and Behavioral Decisions[M]. New York:Springer New York, 1989:244-246.
[6] 张红涛,王二平.态度与行为关系研究现状及发展趋势[J].心理科学进展,2007,15(1):163-168.[Zhang Hongtao, Wang Erping. Attitude and behavior relationship[J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2007,15(1):163-168.]
[7] Lee R. The demographic transition:Three centuries of fundamental change[J]. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 2003,17(4):167-190.
[8] Porter J R. Human development and the fertility reversal:A spatially centered sub-national examination in the US[J]. Spatial Demography, 2017,5(1):43-72.
[9] Bryant J. Theories of fertility decline and the evidence from development indicators[J]. Population and Development Review, 2007, 33(1):101-104.
[10] 葛润,施新政.全面二孩政策如何影响家庭生育决策?[J].经济学(季刊), 2023, 23(4):1392-1407.[Ge Run, Shi Xinzheng. How does universal two-child policy affect fertility behavior?[J]. China Economic Quarterly, 2023,23(4):1392-1407.]
[11] 王军. 生育政策和社会经济状况对中国出生性别比失衡的影响[J]. 人口学刊,2013,35(5):5-14.[Wang Jun. How sex ratio at birth in China is determined by fertility policy and social economy factors[J]. Population Journal, 2013,35(5):5-14.]
[12] 郭志刚,张二力,顾宝昌,等.从政策生育率看中国生育政策的多样性[J].人口研究,2003,(5):1-10.[Guo Zhigang, Zhang Erli, Gu Baochang, et al. Diversity of China's fertility policy by policy fertility[J]. Population Research, 2003,27(5):1-10.]
[13] 陈丽英. 家庭成员二孩生育态度的代际差异及相关因素分析——基于城市一孩六岁及以上家庭的调查[J].统计与管理,2021, 36(7):95-101.[Chen Liying. Intergenerational differences in attitudes towards second-childbirth and related factors:A survey based on urban one-child families with children aged six and above[J]. Statistics and Management, 2021,36(7):95-101.]
[14] 盛禾,李建新.生育动机的世代与性别差异分析基于CFPS2020数据[J]. 社会杂志,2023,43(3):187-212.[Sheng He, Li Jianxin. Cohort and gender disparities in childbearing motivation:Evidence from the China Family Panel Studies in 2020[J]. Chinese Journal of Sociology, 2023,43(3):187-212.]
[15] 陶涛,杨凡,张现苓". 全面两孩"政策下空巢老年人对子女生育二孩态度及影响因素——以北京市为例[J]. 人口研究,2016,40(3):90-100.[Tao Tao, Yang Fan, Zhang Xianling. Determinants of parenthood attitude toward adult children's second birth under the twochild policy:The case of Beijing[J]. Population Research, 2016,40(3):90-100.]
[16] Ozcan E, Topatan S. Examining engaged couples' opinions and attitudes towards fertility awareness, family planning and parenting in terms of gender[J]. Journal of Human Behavior in the Social Environment, 2023,33(7):1006-1017.
[17] 石智雷,郑州丽. 性别视角下生育意愿研究[J]. 财贸研究,2023, 34(6):9-20.[Shi Zhilei, Zhengzhou Li. Research on fertility intention from a gender perspective[J]. Finance and Trade Research, 2023,34(6):9-20.]
[18] Li Z, Yang H, Zhu X, et al. A multilevel study of the impact of egalitarian attitudes toward gender roles on fertility desires in China[J]. Population Research and Policy Review, 2021,40(4):747-769.
[19] 朱文婷,王梅.生育支持对青年职业女性三孩生育意愿的影响研究[J]. 中国青年社会科学,2022,41(6):78-85.[Zhu Wenting, Wang Mei. A study on the effect of reproductive support on the childbearing intention of young professional women[J]. Journal of Chinese Youth Social Science, 2022,41(6):78-85.]
[20] 夏璋煦,丁守海.人力资本贬值预期对女性生育决策的影响——基于职业生涯动态视角的分析[J].中国人口科学,2023,37(4):67-82.[Xia Zhangxu, Ding Shouhai. The impact of anticipated depreciation of human capital on women's fertility decisions:An analysis from a dynamic career perspective[J]. Chinese Journal of Population Science, 2023,37(4):67-82.]
[21] 风笑天.影响育龄人群二孩生育意愿的真相究竟是什么?[J].探索与争鸣,2018(10):54-61,142.[Feng Xiaotian. What is the truth behind the factors influencing the second-child fertility intentions of people of childbearing age?[J]. Exploration and Controversy, 2018(10):54-61,142.]
[22] Karabchuk T, Duelmer H, Gatskova K. Fertility attitudes of highly educated youth:A factorial survey[J]. Journal of Marriage and Family, 2022,84(1):32-52.
[23] 蔡玲.基于符号互动论视角下的个体生育态度探究[J].南方人口, 2016,31(3):69-80.[Cai Ling. An exploration of individual fertility attitudes based on symbolic interactionism[J]. South China Population, 2016,31(3):69-80.]
[24] 陈蓉,顾宝昌.实际生育二孩人群分析——基于上海市的调查[J]. 中国人口科学,2020(5):116-125,128.[Chen Rong, Gu Baochang. An analysis of the families actually having a second child:Based on the survey in Shanghai[J]. Chinese Journal of Population Science, 2020(5):116-125,128.]
[25] 沈体雁,古恒宇,劳昕. 走向空间的人口学研究:西方空间人口学研究的回顾、评价与展望[J]. 世界地理研究,2021,30(2):389-398.[Shen Tiyan, Gu Hengyu, Lao Xin. Towards spatial demography:A review, evaluation, and prospect of western spatial demography research[J]. World Regional Studies, 2021,30(2):389-398.]
[26] Feng Z, Wang B, Dai Y, et al. Fertility intention for two or more children among childbearing-age adults under China's changing fertility policies and economic development from 2010 to 2021[J]. Applied Spatial Analysis and Policy, 2024,17(2):753-777.
[27] Gu B, Wang F, Guo Z, et al. China's local and national fertility policies at the end of the twentieth century[J]. Population and Development Review, 2007,33(1):129-132.
[28] Phillips D R, Feng Z X. Challenges for the aging family in the people's republic of China[J]. Canadian Journal on Aging-Revue Canadienne Du Vieillissement, 2015,34(3):290-304.
[29] 李霖,周玉杰,靳凤攒.基于不同空间权重的总和生育率自相关分析[J]. 测绘地理信息,2015,40(5):62-64.[Li Lin, Zhou Yujie, Jin Fengzan. Autocorrelation analysis of total fertility rate based on different spatial weights[J]. Journal of Geomatics, 2015,40(5):62-64.]
[30] 张洪玉. 西部地区青年婚姻生育及家庭观念分析——基于中国综合社会调查(CGSS)年度调查数据[J]. 新生代,2023(2):62-70.[Zhang Hongyu. Analysis of marriage, fertility, and family values among youth in western China:Based on the CGSS[J]. Cenozoic Generations, 2023(2):62-70.]
[31] 王开泳,丁俊,王甫园.全面二孩政策对中国人口结构及区域人口空间格局的影响[J]. 地理科学进展, 2016, 35(11):1305-1316.[Wang Kaiyong, Ding Jun, Wang Fuyuan. Influence of the implementation of the universal two-child policy on demographic structure and population spatial distribution in China[J]. Progress in Geography, 2016,35(11):1305-1316.]
[32] 龙晓君,郑健松,李小建,等". 全面二孩"背景下我国省际人口分布时空演变[J]. 经济地理,2018,38(1):28-35.[Long Xiaojun, Zheng Jiansong, Li Xiaojian, et al. Provincial-level population spatial distribution evolution on background of "the universal two-child policy" in China[J]. Economic Geography, 2018,38(1):28-35.]
[33] 庄渝霞.厦门市青年流动人口生育态度转变研究[J].中国青年研究,2006(1):51-55.[Zhuang Yuxia. A study on the change of fertility attitudes among the floating youth population in Xiamen[J]. China Youth Study, 2006(1):51-55.]
[34] 李婕妤,王璋.三孩政策下城市青年生育偏好与生育计划[J].南方人口, 2023, 38(3):53-67.[Li Jieyu, Wang Zhang. Fertility preferences and plans among urban youth under the three-child policy[J]. South China Population, 2023,38(3):53-67.]
[35] 王新贤,高向东.中国穆斯林人口空间分布及演变特征[J].世界地理研究,2021,30(6):1297-1307.[Wang Xinxian, Gao Xiangdong. The spatial distribution and evolution characteristics of the Muslim population in China[J]. World Regional Studies, 2021,30(6):1297-1307.]
[36] 彭伟斌,陈晓慧.东部较发达省市人口下降区人口发展趋势——基于生育政策调整的县域个案诠释[J].经济地理,2015,35(2):37-45.[Peng Weibin, Chen Xiaohui. Population trends in declining regions of more developed eastern provinces and cities:An interpretation based on county-level cases of fertility policy adjustments[J]. Economic Geography, 2015,35(2):37-45.]
[37] Vitali A, Aassve A, Lappegard T. Diffusion of childbearing within cohabitation[J]. Demography, 2015,52(2):355-377.
[38] 贺丹,黄匡时,陈佳鹏,等. 中国生育水平的空间与社会趋同研究——基于"五普"和"六普"微观数据的比较分析[J]. 人口学刊, 2017,39(3):21-31.[He Dan, Huang Kuangshi, Chen Jiapeng, et al. The spatial and social convergence of Chinese fertility:Evidence from 2000 and 2010 census microdata[J]. Population Journal, 2017, 39(3):21-31.]
[39] 纪小美,曾群洲,王超.多尺度下中国人口老龄化风险集群的时空格局——Flexible空间扫描计量方法的应用[J]. 人文地理,2018, 33(2):116-123.[Ji Xiaomei, Zeng Qunzhou, Wang Chao. Timespace patterns of risk cluster of population aging in chinaat Multiscales:The application of Flexible spatial scan statistics[J]. Human Geography, 2018,33(2):116-123.]
[40] 庞尧,徐维祥,范彦成,等.我国劳动力质量对数量的抑制效应——基于高校招生和人口出生率的省级空间面板分析[J].经济地理, 2022,42(1):53-60.[Pang Yao, Xu Weixiang, Fan Yancheng, et al. The inhibitory effect of labor quality on quantity in china:a provincial spatial panel analysis based on college entrance examinations and birth rates[J]. Economic Geography, 2022,42(1):53-60.]
[41] 方慧芬,陈江龙,袁丰,等.中国城市房价对生育率的影响——基于长三角地区41个城市的计量分析[J].地理研究,2021,40(9):2426-2441.[Fang Huifen, Chen Jianglong, Yuan Feng, et al. The econometric analysis of the effect of city housing prices on fertility rates:A study from cities of the Yangtze River Delta in China[J]. Geographical Research, 2021,40(9):2426-2441.]
[42] Hayford S R. The evolution of fertility expectations over the life course[J]. Demography, 2009,46(4):765-783.
[43] Bachrach C A, Morgan S P. A cognitive-social model of fertility intentions[J]. Population and Development Review, 2013,39(3):459-485.
[44] King G, Wand J. Comparing incomparable survey responses:Evaluating and selecting anchoring vignettes[J]. Political Analysis, 2007, 15(1):46-66.
[45] 於嘉,沈小杰,谢宇.中国育龄人群生育潜力影响因素的随机实验研究[J]. 中国人口科学,2023,37(2):19-35.[Yu Jia, Shen Xiaojie, Xie Yu. An experimental conjoint analysis of fertility potential among reproductive-aged Chinese people[J]. Chinese Journal of Population Science, 2023,37(2):19-35.]
[46] Hox J J. Multilevel Analysis:Techniques and Applications (2nd ed.)[M]. New York:Taylor & Francis Group, 2010,20-25.
[47] Rasbash J S F, Browne W J, Goldstein H. A User's Guide to MLWIN Version 3.05[Z]. Bristol:University of Bristol, 2020.
[48] 张继元,廖小倩.地方政策百花齐放,破解生育意愿难题[J].中国社会保障,2023(12):82-83.[Zhang Jiyuan, Liao Xiaoqian. Local policies bloom to solve the problem of fertility willingness[J]. China Social Security, 2023(12):82-83.]
[49] 丁仁船,邬登辉,黄院玲.托育服务能否提高适龄生育人群生育意愿?——基于2021年 CGSS调查数据的实证研究[J]. 华南理工大学学报(社会科学版),2024,26(1):145-156.[Ding Renchuan, Wu Denghui, Huang Yuanling. Can childcare services improve the fertility intention of the child-bearing people?[J]. Journal of South China University of Technology (Social Science Edition), 2024, 26(1):145-156.]
[50] 庄渝霞,冯志昕.论生育事件对女性和男性职业地位获得的影响——基于CHNS1993-2015年追踪调查的实证研究[J]. 人口学刊,2022,44(5):1-20.[Zhuang Yuxia, Feng Zhixin. The effects of fertility events on women's and men's attainment of occupational status——Empirical research from CHNS 1993-2015 follow-up survey[J]. Population Journal, 2022,44(5):1-20.]
[51] 李婷,袁洁,夏璐,等.中国网络大众生育态度倾向变迁——兼论舆情大数据在人口学中的应用[J]. 人口研究,2019,43(4):36-49.[Li Ting, Yuan Jie, Xia Lu, et al. The transition of fertility intention propensity of Chinese web-users:The application of public——Opinion big data analysis[J]. Population Research, 2019,43(4):36-49.