中国城乡流动人口&ldquo;回流&rdquo;研究进展与述评

李志刚; 刘达; 林赛南

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.01.001

PDF(6854 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2020, Vol. 35 ›› Issue (1) : 1-10,62. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.01.001

进展与动态

中国城乡流动人口“回流”研究进展与述评

李志刚^1,2, 刘达^1,2, 林赛南^1,2

作者信息 +

A LITERATURE REVIEW OF THE STUDY ON RETURN FLOATING POPULATION IN CHINA

LI Zhi-gang^1,2, LIU Da^1,2, LIN Sai-nan^1,2

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

人口流动折射人地关系，在地理学"流动性"转向和全球化背景下，人口流动研究尤其是中国流动人口回流的研究意义愈发凸显。本文以知网核心期刊文献为基础，进行计量分析，从主题、理论演变、研究方法等角度对我国流动人口回流研究进行系统梳理，发现当前研究主要关注的主题包括：乡村发展、政策制度、社会问题、倾向选择、群体差异等，涉及回流人口基本特征、回流动力、回流时机、回流影响等关键问题，对回流空间的研究相对不足；已有研究重视人力资本、国家体制对流动人口回流的影响，较为缺少对于家庭、市场、社会维度的深入分析，研究框架有待进一步完善；重视群体尺度研究，个体尺度的深入实证相对薄弱。未来应积极探索建立跨学科视角的流动人口回流研究框架，重视空间格局、回流机制、回流与城乡发展的互动等方面的研究，加强个体尺度的实证。

Abstract

The great rural-urban population mobility in post-reform China reflects the dynamic human-land relationship, the core of the geography. Against the background of globalization, China's industrial transformation and upgrading, and "mobility turn" in geography, rural-urban floating population, especially the returnees, is playing an important role in urban and rural development. The return floating population emerged in the late 1990s in China, but it has not gained much attention of academia. Based on the extensive literature obtained from the core journals included in Chinese National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), this paper reviews the research progresses of rural-urban return floating population from three aspects, which are the evolution of research topics, the theories and research methods. The main findings are as following:1) The current research focuses on five topics including rural development, policies, social issues, preferences, and group differences. 2) Four major issues have been examined:The characteristics of returnees, mechanism of returning, reflux timing and effects of return floating population. 3) Existing studies have emphasized the impact of human capital and the state. 4) The population-level research has been the focus of the study. Yet the individual-level research should be strengthened. Based on the literature review above, we discuss the future development trend:1) Centering on individual-, family-, community-, regional-level and state, market, society in the mechanism of returning to develop an interdisciplinary theoretical framework. 2) Research on return spatial pattern. 3) Examine the relationship between returnees and the development strategies of new urbanization, rural revitalization.

导出引用

李志刚, 刘达, 林赛南. 中国城乡流动人口“回流”研究进展与述评[J]. 人文地理. 2020, 35(1): 1-10,62 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.01.001

LI Zhi-gang, LIU Da, LIN Sai-nan. A LITERATURE REVIEW OF THE STUDY ON RETURN FLOATING POPULATION IN CHINA[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2020, 35(1): 1-10,62 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.01.001

中图分类号： K901.3

参考文献

[1] 国家人口和计划生育委员会流动人口服务管理司.中国流动人口发展报告[M].北京:中国人口出版社,2018.[Floating Population Family Planning Service and Manage Division of National Health and Family Planning Commission of the People's Republic of China. Report of China's Migrant Population Development[M]. Beijing:China Population Publishing House, 2018.]
[2] 朱宇,林李月.流动人口的流迁模式与社会保护:从"城市融入"到"社会融入"[J].地理科学,2011,31(3):264-271.[Zhu Yu, Lin Liyue. Mobility patterns of floating population and their social protection:Moving from "urban inclusion" to "social inclusion"[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2011,31(3):264-271.]
[3] Chen C, Fan C. China's hukou puzzle:Why don't rural migrants want urban hukou?[J]. The China Review, 2016,16(3):9-39.
[4] 陈宏胜,王兴平,刘晔,等. "理性"与"感性"之间:上海流动人口迁居意愿研究[J].现代城市研究,2017(7):100-106.[Chen Hongsheng, Wang Xingping, Liu Ye, et al. Between sensibility and rationality:Study on Shanghai migrant's residential mobility intention[J]. Modern Urban Research, 2017(7):100-106.]
[5] Sylvie D, Xu H. Return migrants:The rise of new entrepreneurs in rural China[J]. World Development, 2011,39(10):1847-1861.
[6] 李郇,殷江滨.劳动力回流:小城镇发展的新动力[J].城市规划学刊, 2012(2):55-61.[Li Xun, Yin Jiangbin. Returning migrants:A new impetus for small town development[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2012(2):55-61.]
[7] Massey D. Understanding Mexican migration to the United States[J]. American Journal of Sociology, 1987,92(6):1372-1403.
[8] Rhoades R. Toward an anthropology of return migration[J]. Papers in Anthropology, 1979,20:57-74.
[9] Hugo G. Circular migration:Keeping development rolling?[R]. Washington, D.C:Migration Information Source, Migration Policy Institute, 2003.
[10] Dustmann C. Return migration, wage differentials, and the optimal migration duration[J]. European Economic Review, 2003,47(2):353-369.
[11] Gmelch G. Return migration[J]. Annual Review of Anthropology, 1980,9(1):135-159.
[12] Hare D. ‘Push’ versus ‘pull’ factors in migration outflows and returns:Determinants of migration status and spell duration among China's rural population[J]. The Journal of Development Studies, 1999,35(3):45-72.
[13] Wang W, Fan C. Success or failure:Selectivity and reasons of return migration in Sichuan and Anhui, China[J]. Environment and Planning A:Economy and Space, 2006,38(5):939-958.
[14] 王桂新,潘泽瀚.我国流动人口的空间分布及其影响因素——基于第六次人口普查资料的分析[J].现代城市研究,2013,28(3):4-11.[Wang Guixin, Pan Zehan. China's floating population spatial distribution and influencing factors:Evidence from year 2010 population census of China[J]. Modern Urban Research, 2013,28(3):4-11.]
[15] 石忆邵.中国新型城镇化与小城镇发展[J].经济地理,2013,33(7):47-52.[Shi Yishao. New-type urbanization and small town development in China[J]. Economic Geography, 2013,33(7):47-52.]
[16] Yang C, Xu W, Liu Y, et al. Staying in the countryside or moving to the city:The determinants of villagers' urban settlement intentions in China[J]. The China Review, 2016,16(3):41-68.
[17] Fan C. Settlement intention and split households:Findings from a survey of migrants in Beijing's urban villages[J]. The China Review, 2011,11(2):11-42.
[18] Zhu Y, Chen W. The settlement intention of China's floating population in the cities:Recent changes and multifaceted individual-level determinants[J]. Population, Space and Place, 2010,16(4):253-267.
[19] 国家统计局.2009年全国农民工监测调查报告[EB/OL].(2009-03-25)[2019-04-30]. http://www.gov.cn/gzdt/2009-03/25/content_1268173.htm.[National Bureau of Statistics of China. Monitoring and survey report on national rural migrant workers in 2009[EB/OL]. (2009-03-25)[2019-04-30]. http://www.gov.cn/gzdt/2009-03/25/content_1268173.htm.]
[20] 张善余,杨晓勇. "民工潮"将带来"回乡创业潮"——以安徽省阜阳地区为例[J].人口与经济,1996,17(1):43-47.[Zhang Shanyu, Yang Xiaoyong. "Flood" will bring "home business boom":A case study of Anhui Fuyang[J]. Population & Economics, 1996,17(1):43-47.]
[21] 刘云刚,燕婷婷.地方城市的人口回流与移民战略——基于深圳-驻马店的调查研究[J].地理研究,2013,32(7):1280-1290.[Liu Yungang, Yan Tingting. Types of the return migrations from megacities to local cities in China:A case study of Zhumadian's return migrants[J]. Geographical Research, 2013,32(7):1280-1290.]
[22] 李强.影响中国城市流动人口的推力与拉力因素分析[J].中国社会科学,2003,24(1):125-136.[Li Qiang. An analysis of push and pull factors in the migration of rural workers in China[J]. Social Sciences in China, 2003,24(1):125-136.]
[23] 朱宇.户籍制度改革与流动人口在流入地的居留意愿及其制约机制[J].南方人口,2004,19(3):21-28.[Zhu Yu. Households registration system reform and the dwelling willing of floating population in the areas they are dwelling and its restrictive mechanism[J]. South China Population, 2004,19(3):21-28.]
[24] 张宗益,周勇,卢顺霞,等.西部地区农村外出劳动力回流:动因及其对策[J]. 统计研究,2007,24(12):9-15.[Zhang Zongyi, Zhou Yong, Lu Shunxia, et al. Study on the causes and countermeasures of rural migration return in western China[J]. Statistical Research, 2007,24(12):9-15.]
[25] 石智雷,杨云彦.家庭禀赋、家庭决策与农村迁移劳动力回流[J]. 社会学研究,2012,17(3):157-181.[Shi Zhilei, Yang Yunyan. Family endowment, family decision and the returning of rural migrants[J]. Sociological Studies, 2012,17(3):157-181.]
[26] 田明.进城农民工的高流动性及其解释[J].清华大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2013,28(5):69-80.[Tian Ming. An investigation on job mobility of China's migrant workers[J]. Journal of Tsinghua University (Philosophy and Social Science), 2013,28(5):69-80.]
[27] 程广帅,谭宇.返乡农民工创业决策影响因素研究[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2013,23(1):119-125.[Cheng Guangshuai, Tan Yu. Analysis of returned migrant laborers' venture decisive factors[J]. China Population Resources and Environment, 2013,23(1):119-125.]
[28] 袁方,史清华,卓建伟.农民工回流行为的一个新解释:基于森的可行能力理论[J].中国人力资源开发,2015,32(1):87-96.[Yuan Fang, Shi Qinghua, ZhuoJianwei. A new explanation of return of migrant workers based on Sen's capability theory[J]. Human Resource Development of China, 2015,32(1):87-96.]
[29] 刘于琪,刘晔,李志刚.中国城市新移民的定居意愿及其影响机制[J].地理科学,2014,34(7):780-787.[Liu Yuqi, Liu Ye, Li Zhigang. Settlement intention of new migrants in China's large cities:Patterns and determinants[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2014,34(7):780-787.]
[30] 谢霏雰,陈宏胜,刘于琪,等.中国大城市流动人口幸福感研究——以上海为例[J].现代城市研究,2015,30(12):2-8.[Xie Feifen, Chen Hongsheng, Liu Yuqi, et al. Study on migrants' subjective wellbeing in large cities in China:A case study of Shanghai[J]. Modern Urban Research, 2015,30(12):2-8.]
[31] Mohabir N, Jiang Y, Ma R. Chinese floating migrants:Rural-urban migrant labourers' intentions to stay or return[J]. Habitat International, 2017,60:101-110.
[32] 欧顺仙,肖扬,李志刚.新生代农民工的社会空间流动研究——以深圳富士康为例[J].城市规划,2016,40(4):69-74.[Ou Shunxian, Xiao Yang, Li Zhigang. Socio-spatial mobility of new migrant workers:A case study on Foxconn, Shenzhen[J]. City Planning Review, 2016,40(4):69-74.]
[33] 李志刚,刘晔,陈宏胜.中国城市新移民的"乡缘社区":特征、机制与空间性——以广州"湖北村"为例[J].地理研究,2011,30(10):1910-1920.[Li Zhigang, Liu Ye, Chen Hongsheng. Characteristics, mechanism, and spatiality of neo-migrants' homeplace-based communities in China:A case study of Hubei Village, Guangzhou[J]. Geographical Research, 2011,30(10):1910-1920.]
[34] 万涛.权力的文化网络视角下的新乡贤返乡困境及对策——基于H省G村的调查和实验[J].城市规划,2016,40(11):21-29.[Wan Tao. Predicaments and countermeasures of new country squires refluxing from the perspective of the cultural nexus of power:Based on the investigation and experiment of G village, H province[J]. City Planning Review, 2016,40(11):21-29.]
[35] 杨智勇,李玲.论农民工"回流"现象的原因及其消极影响[J].当代青年研究,2015(1):94-100.[Yang Zhiyong, Li Ling. On the reasons of countryside labor's reflow and negative impact[J]. Contemporary Young Research, 2015(1):94-100.]
[36] Dustmann C, Kirchkamp O. The optimal migration duration and activity choice after re-migration[J]. Journal of Development Economics, 2002,67(2):351-372.
[37] 杨忍,徐茜,张琳,等. 珠三角外围地区农村回流劳动力的就业选择及影响因素[J].地理研究,2018,37(11):2305-2317.[Yang Ren, Xu Qian, Zhang Lin, et al. Employment choice of rural return migrants around the Pearl River Delta region and its influencing factors[J]. Geographical Research, 2018,37(11):2305-2317.]
[38] Zhao Y. Causes and consequences of return migration:Recent evidence from China[J]. Journal of Comparative Economics, 2002,30(2):376-394.
[39] Cao G, Li M, Ma Y, et al. Self-employment and intention of permanent urban settlement:Evidence from a survey of migrants in China's four major urbanizing areas[J]. Urban Studies, 2015,52(4):639-664.
[40] Liu Z, Wang Y, Chen S. Does formal housing encourage settlement intention of rural migrants in Chinese cities? A structural equation model analysis[J]. Urban Studies, 2017,54(8):1834-1850.
[41] Zang B, Lv P, Warren C. Housing prices, rural-urban migrants' settlement decisions and their regional differences in China[J]. Habitat International, 2015,50:149-159.
[42] 余运江,孙斌栋,孙旭.社会保障对农民工回流意愿有影响吗?——基于上海调查数据的实证分析[J].人口与经济,2014,35(6):102-108.[Yu Yunjiang, Sun Bindong, Sun Xu. Can social security influence migrant workers' return intention? An analysis based on Shanghai survey data[J]. Population & Economics, 2014,35(6):102-108.]
[43] 王利伟,冯长春,许顺才,等.传统农区外出劳动力回流意愿与规划响应——基于河南周口市问卷调查数据[J].地理科学进展,2014, 33(7):990-999.[Wang Liwei, Feng Changchun, Xu Shuncai, et al. Return intention of migrant workers in a traditional agricultural area and planning response:Based on a questionnaire survey in Zhoukou, Henan province[J]. Progress in Geography, 2014,33(7):990-999.]
[44] Yu L, Yin X, Zheng X, et al. Lose to win:Entrepreneurship of returned migrants in China[J]. The Annals of Regional Science, 2017, 58(2):341-374.
[45] 孙中伟.农民工大城市定居偏好与新型城镇化的推进路径研究[J].人口研究,2015,39(5):72-86.[Sun Zhongwei. Settlement intention of migrant workers in big cities and development path of China's new-type urbanization[J]. Population Research, 2015,39(5):72-86.]
[46] 杨传开,刘晔,徐伟,等.中国农民进城定居的意愿与影响因素——基于CGSS2010的分析[J].地理研究,2017,36(12):2369-2382.[Yang Chuankai, Liu Ye, Xu Wei, et al. The determinants for peasants' migration intentions of moving to cities in China:An analysis based on the CGSS2010[J]. Geographical Research, 2017,36(12):2369-2382.]
[47] 高更和,曾文凤,刘明月.省际流动农民工回流区位及影响因素——以河南省12个村为例[J].经济地理,2017,37(6):151-155.[Gao Genghe, Zeng Wenfeng, Liu Mingyue. Backflow location and influence factors of inter-provincial migrant workers:A case study for 12 villages in Henan province[J]. Economic Geography, 2017, 37(6):151-155.]
[48] Clark W, Maas R. Interpreting migration through the prism of reasons for moves[J]. Population, Space and Place, 2015,21(1):54-67.
[49] Chen C, Fan C. Gender and generational differences in first outward-and first inward-moves:An event-history analysis of rural migrants in China[J]. Environment and Planning A:Economy and Space, 2018,50(8):1646-1669.
[50] Tang S, Feng J. Cohort differences in the urban settlement intentions of rural migrants:A case study in Jiangsu Province, China[J]. Habitat International, 2015,49:357-365.
[51] Yue Z, Li S, Feldman M, et al. Floating choices:A generational perspective on intentions of rural-urban migrants in China[J]. Environment and Planning A:Economy and Space, 2010,42(3):545-562.
[52] 朱宇.新生代农民工:特征、问题与对策[J].人口研究,2010,34(2):31-56.[Zhu Yu. China's new generation of migrant workers:Characteristics, problems and countermeasures[J]. Population Research, 2010,34(2):31-56.]
[53] Zhu Y, Lin L Y. Continuity and change in the transition from the first to the second generation of migrants in China:Insights from a survey in Fujian[J]. Habitat International, 2014,42:147-154.
[54] 刘传江,程建林.我国农民工的代际差异与市民化[J].经济纵横, 2007,19(7):18-21.[Liu Chuanjiang, Cheng Jianlin. Trans-generational difference and becoming citizen of migrant workers[J]. Economic Review, 2007,19(7):18-21.]
[55] Liu Y, Li Z, Breitung W. The social networks of new-generation migrants in China's urbanized villages:A case study of Guangzhou[J]. Habitat International, 2012,36(1):192-200.
[56] 朱宇,余立,林李月,等.两代流动人口在城镇定居意愿的代际延续和变化——基于福建省的调查[J].人文地理,2012,27(3):1-6.[Zhu Yu, Yu Li, Lin Liyue, et al. The continuity and change in the urban settlement intention between the two generation migrants:Based on a survey in Fujian province[J]. Human Geography, 2012,27(3):1-6.]
[57] 刘成斌,王舒厅.留守经历与农二代大学生的心理健康[J].青年研究, 2014,37(5):23-32.[Liu Chengbin, Wang Shuting. The experience of left-behind and mental health of college students from second generation of floating population:Based on the perspective of reform in floating population system[J]. Youth Studies, 2014,37(5):23-32.]
[58] Groot C, Mulder C, Das M, et al. Life events and the gap between intention to move and actual mobility[J]. Environment and Planning A:Economy and Space, 2011,43(1):48-66.
[59] Dustmann C, Fadlon I, Weiss Y. Return migration, human capital accumulation and the brain drain[J]. Journal of Development Economics, 2011,95(1):58-67.
[60] Chen Y, Wang J. Social integration of new-generation migrants in Shanghai China[J]. Habitat International, 2015,49:419-425.
[61] Song Y. From newcomers to middle class:The social and spatial mobility of new urban migrants[J]. The China Review, 2016,16(3):121-147.
[62] Chan K, Buckingham W. Is China abolishing the hukou system?[J]. The China Quarterly, 2008,195:582-606.
[63] 夏柱智,贺雪峰.半工半耕与中国渐进城镇化模式[J].中国社会科学,2017,38(12):117-137.[Xia Zhuzhi, He Xuefeng. China's semiindustrial, semi-agricultural mode and incremental urbanization[J]. Social Science in China, 2017,38(12):117-137.]
[64] 陈宏胜,刘振东,李志刚.中国大城市新移民社会融合研究——基于六市抽样数据[J].现代城市研究,2015,30(6):112-119.[Chen Hongsheng, Liu Zhendong, Li Zhigang. Social integration of neoimmigrants in urban China:A case study of six large cities[J]. Modern Urban Research, 2015,30(6):112-119.]
[65] Stark O. The Migration of Labor[M]. Cambridge, MA:Basil Blackwell, 1991:37-84.
[66] 李强,毛学峰,张涛.农民工汇款的决策、数量与用途分析[J].中国农村观察,2008,29(3):2-12.[Li Qiang, Mao Xuefeng, Zhang Tao. Decision making, quantity and application of peasant workers' remittance[J]. China Rural Survey, 2008,29(3):2-12.]
[67] Clark W, Lisowski W. Prospect theory and the decision to move or stay[J]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2017, 114(36):7432-7440.
[68] Clark W, Coulter R. Who wants to move? The role of neighbourhood change[J]. Environment and Planning A:Economy and Space, 2015,47(12):2683-2709.
[69] 蔡禾,王进. "农民工"永久迁移意愿研究[J].社会学研究,2007,12(6):86-113.[Cai He, Wang Jin. A study on migrant workers' permanent migration intentions[J]. Sociological Studies, 2007,12(6):86-113.]
[70] 周皓,梁在.中国的返迁人口:基于五普数据的分析[J].人口研究, 2006,30(3):61-69.[Zhou Hao, Liang Zai. Return migration in China:An analysis of the fifth census data[J]. Population Research, 2006,30(3):61-69.]
[71] Clark W, Lisowski W. Decisions to move and decisions to stay:Life course events and mobility outcomes[J]. Housing Studies, 2017,32(5):1-19.
[72] Sonja H. Migration networks and migration decision-making[J]. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 2008,34(4):585-605.
[73] Ley D, Kobayashi A. Back to Hong Kong:Return migration or transnational sojourn?[J]. Global Networks, 2005,5(2):111-127.
[74] 刘望保,闫小培.转型期广州市居住迁移影响因素于户籍之间的比较[J].地理研究,2007,26(5):1055-1066.[Liu Wangbao, Yan Xiaopei. Comparison of influencing factors for residential mobility between different household register types in transitional urban China:A case study of Guangzhou[J]. Geographical Research, 2007,26(5):1055-1066.]
[75] 彭璐,朱宇,林李月.流动人口在流动过程中的暂时性回流及其影响因素——基于生命历程的视角[J].南方人口,2017,32(6):1-13.[Peng Lu, Zhu Yu, Lin Liyue. The temporary return in the floating population's migration and their determinants:A life-course perspective[J]. South China Population, 2017,32(6):1-13.]
[76] Fan C. China on the move:Migration, the state, and the household[M]. London and New York:Routledge, 2008:95-116.
[77] 李志刚,刘晔.中国城市"新移民"社会网络与空间分异[J].地理学报,2011,66(6):785-795.[Li Zhigang, Liu Ye. Beyond spatial segregation:Neo-migrants and their social networks in Chinese cities[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2011,66(6):785-795.]
[78] Liu Y, Li Z, Liu Y, et al. Growth of rural migrant enclaves in Guangzhou, China:Agency, everyday practice and social mobility[J]. Urban Studies, 2015,52(16):3086-3105.
[79] 林李月,朱宇.流动人口城市间流动的时空结构特征及其性别差异:基于福建省的实证研究[J].地理科学,2015,35(6):725-732.[Lin Liyue, Zhu Yu. The space-time paths of the migrants' mobility across cities and their gender difference:Based on a survey in Fujian Province[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2015,35(6):725-732.]
[80] Morris T, Manley D, Sabel C. Residential mobility:Towards progress in mobility health research[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2016,42(1):112-133.
[81] 宋长青,程昌秀,史培军.新时代地理复杂性的内涵[J].地理学报, 2018,73(7):1204-1213.[Song Changqing, Cheng Changxiu, Shi Peijun. Geography complexity:New connotations of geography in the new era[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2018,73(7):1204-1213.]
[82] Nelson L, Hiemstra N. Latino immigrants and the renegotiation of place and belonging in small town America[J]. Social & Cultural Geography, 2008,9(3):319-342.
[83] 朱竑,张博,马凌.新型城镇化背景下中国流动人口研究:议题与展望[J].地理科学,2019,39(1):1-11.[Zhu Hong, Zhang Bo, Ma Ling. A review of Chinese internal migration research under the background of new-type urbanization:Topics and prospects[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2019,39(1):1-11.]