旅游地流动摊贩的空间生存状态及其影响机制

吴传龙; 孙九霞; 邓家霖

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.04.018

PDF(5323 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2020, Vol. 35 ›› Issue (4) : 146-153. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.04.018

旅游

旅游地流动摊贩的空间生存状态及其影响机制

吴传龙^1,2, 孙九霞^1,2, 邓家霖¹

作者信息 +

BETWEEN IN PLACE AND OUT OF PLACE: THE SPATIAL SURVIVAL CONDITION AND ITS INFLUENCING MECHANISM OF STREET VENDORS IN CHINESE TOURISM DESTINATIONS

WU Chuan-long^1,2, SUN Jiu-xia^1,2, DENG Jia-lin¹

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

流动摊贩的空间治理成效关系着目的地的可持续发展。本文建立了关于弱势群体空间政治中“不得其所”与“安适其位”的理论分析框架，并应用于阳朔西街的流动摊贩空间生存状态的案例分析中。发现：①受新自由主义思想主导下的城市管理模式影响，阳朔西街的流动摊贩被政策法规在正式制度层面认定为“不得其所”，但其在旅游经营活动中却受到其他空间使用者的欢迎，在非正式制度层面是“安适其位”；②西街流动摊贩的空间生存状态具有“不得其所”与“安适其位”的双重性，由此也塑造出流动摊贩在阳朔西街时空嵌入的空间结构；③内部群体特征（灵活流动性、规范化提升）与外部社会文化情景（和谐稳定的社会话语、旅游场域的特殊性）两个方面因素不仅有效消解了正式制度层面所形塑出的“不得其所”空间规范，同时也强化了非正式制度层面与空间结构上西街流动摊贩的“安适其位”。

Abstract

Spatial governance of the street vendors is a crucial issue for sustainable development of a tourism destination. However, it has not been fully recognized in the research, because along with frequent conflicts, tourism research is difficult to guide the process of governance to street vendors in tourist destinations. Although researches in the field of urban space management investigate such issues focusing on the managers and the governed, they ignore the importance of other users in the space. Based on the concepts of "out of place" and "in place" by Cresswell, this study establishes a theoretical analysis framework of "out of place" and "in place" in the space politics of vulnerable groups, and applies it to the case analysis of the spatial survival condition of street vendors in West Street Yangshuo. The findings are as followed: 1) Although the street vendors in West Street are recognized as "out of place" by the formal institutions and targets of strict eviction regulations, they are accepted by other space users in tourism business activities and "appropriateness" in the informal institutions. 2) The ambivalent social expectation to street vendors in West Street shapes a space structure, which result in the time and space embedding of street vendors in West street. 3) The influencing factors of street vendors "in place" mainly come from both internal and external aspects.

导出引用

吴传龙, 孙九霞, 邓家霖. 旅游地流动摊贩的空间生存状态及其影响机制[J]. 人文地理. 2020, 35(4): 146-153 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.04.018

WU Chuan-long, SUN Jiu-xia, DENG Jia-lin. BETWEEN IN PLACE AND OUT OF PLACE: THE SPATIAL SURVIVAL CONDITION AND ITS INFLUENCING MECHANISM OF STREET VENDORS IN CHINESE TOURISM DESTINATIONS[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2020, 35(4): 146-153 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2020.04.018

中图分类号： C912.8 F590

参考文献

[1] Harvey D. Neoliberalism and the city[J]. Studies in Social Justice, 2007,1(1):2-13.
[2] Smith N. The New Urban Frontier:Gentrification and the Revanchist City[M]. London:Routledge, 2005:210-232.
[3] 杨昀,保继刚.旅游大发展阶段的治理困境——阳朔西街市场乱象的特征及其发生机制[J]. 旅游学刊,2018,33(11):16-25.[Yang Yun, Bao Jigang. Governance dilemmas in tourist destinations' rapid development:Market chaos in Yangshuo West Street[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2018,33(11):16-25.]
[4] Yatmo Y A. Street vendors as "out of place" urban elements[J]. Journal of Urban Design, 2008,13(3):387-402.
[5] Timothy D J, Wall G. Selling to tourists:Indonesian street vendors[J]. Annals of Tourism Research, 1997,24(2):322-340.
[6] Henderson J C, Yun O S, Poon P, et al. Hawker centres as tourist attractions:The case of Singapore[J]. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 2012,31(3):849-855.
[7] 黄耿志,薛德升,徐孔丹,等.中国大城市非正规公共空间治理——对城市流动摊贩空间疏导模式的后现代反思[J]. 国际城市规划, 2019,34(2):47-55.[Huang Gengzhi, Xue Desheng, Xu Kongdan, et al. Governance of informal public space in urban China:A postmodern critique of spatial formalization of urban street vending[J]. Urban Planning International, 2019,34(2):47-55.]
[8] Boonjubun C. Conflicts over streets:The eviction of Bangkok street vendors[J]. Cities, 2017,70:22-31.
[9] MacLeod G. From urban entrepreneurialism to a "revanchist city"? On the spatial injustices of Glasgow's renaissance[J]. Antipode, 2002,34(3):602-624.
[10] 黄耿志,李天娇,薛德升.包容还是新的排斥?——城市流动摊贩空间引导效应与规划研究[J]. 规划师,2012,28(8):78-83.[Huang Gengzhi, Li Tianjiao, Xue Desheng. Inclusiveness or exclusiveness? Vendor space effects and planning[J]. Planners, 2012,28(8):78-83.]
[11] Cresswell T. In Place-Out of Place:Geography, Ideology, and Transgression[M]. Minneapolis:University of Minnesota Press, 1992:1-145.
[12] 陈霄.宁波老外滩酒吧街的不得其所与地方建构[J]. 地理研究, 2014,33(7):1217-1229.[Chen Xiao. Out of place and place constructing in Oldbund in Ningbo[J]. Geographical Research, 2014,33(7):1217-1229.]
[13] Cross J. Street vendors, and postmodernity:Conflict and compromise in the global economy[J]. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 2000,20(1/2):29-51.
[14] Eidse N, Turner S. Doing resistance their own way:Counter-narratives of street vending in Hanoi, Vietnam through solicited journaling[J]. Area, 2014,46(3):242-248.
[15] Xue D, Huang G. Informality and the state's ambivalence in the regulation of street vending in transforming Guangzhou, China[J]. Geoforum, 2015,62:156-165.
[16] Onodugo V A, Ezeadichie N H, Onwuneme C A, et al. The dilemma of managing the challenges of street vending in public spaces:The case of Enugu city, Nigeria[J]. Cities, 2016,59:95-101.
[17] 崔占峰,吴浩宇. "摊" 经济70年:城市治理中的"嵌入性" 弹性治理逻辑[J]. 经济问题,2019(6):1-10.[Cui Zhanfeng, Wu Haoyu. "Stall" economy for 70 years:The logic of "embedded" flexible governance in urban governance[J]. On Economic Problem, 2019(6):1-10.]
[18] 黄耿志,薛德升.1990年以来广州市摊贩空间政治的规训机制[J]. 地理学报,2011,66(8):1063-1075.[Huang Gengzhi, Xue Desheng. Geographical journal of the discipline mechanism of space politics for street vendors in Guangzhou since 1990[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2011,66(8):1063-1075.]
[19] Eidse N, Turner S, Oswin N. Contesting street spaces in a socialist city:Itinerant vending-scapes and the everyday politics of mobility in Hanoi, Vietnam[J]. Annals of the American Association of Geographers, 2016,106(2):340-349.
[20] Huang G, Zhang H, Xue D. Beyond unemployment:Informal employment and heterogeneous motivations for participating in street vending in present-day China[J]. Urban Studies, 2018,55(12):2743-2761.
[21] 玛丽·道格拉斯.洁净与危险[M]. 黄剑波,译.北京:民族出版社, 2008:1-6.[Douglas M. Purity and Danger[M]. Huang Jianbo, trans. Beijing:The Ethnic Publishing House, 2008:1-6.]
[22] Lofland L H. A World of Strangers:Order and Action in Urban Public Space[M]. Prospect Heights IL:Waveland Press, 1973:1-21.
[23] 孙九霞,黄秀波,王学基.旅游地特色街区的"非地方化":制度脱嵌视角的解释[J]. 旅游学刊,2017,32(9):24-33.[Sun Jiuxia, Huang Xiubo, Wang Xueji. The de-localization tendency of tourism streets:Based on the perspective of institutional disembeddment[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2017,32(9):24-33.]
[24] 桂林生活网.旅游名县怎能与脏乱相伴?阳朔县城综合大整治[EB/OL]. (2005-11-10)[2019-10-05]. http://www.yangshuo.gov.cn/jrys/shdt/200511/t20051115_313520.htm.[Guilin life network. Can tourism county be accompanied by dirty? comprehensive renovation of Yangshuo[EB/OL]. (2005-11-10)[2019-10-05]. http://www.yangshuo.gov.cn/jrys/shdt/200511/t20051115_313520.htm.]
[25] 詹姆斯·C·斯科特.弱者的武器:农民反抗的日常形式[M]. 郑广怀,张敏,何江穗,译.南京:译林出版社,2007:47-64.[Scott C J. Weapons of the Weak[M]. Zheng Guanghuai, Zhang Min, He Jiangsui, trans. Nanjing:Jiangshu People's Press, 2007:47-64.]
[26] 孙九霞,周一.日常生活视野中的旅游社区空间再生产研究——基于列斐伏尔与德塞图的理论视角[J]. 地理学报,2014,69(10):1575-1589.[Sun Jiuxia, Zhou Yi. Study on the reproduction of space of tourism community from the perspective of everyday life:Based on theories of Lefebvre and De Certeau[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2014,69(10):1575-1589.]
[27] Bayat A. Un-civil society:The politics of the "informal people"[J]. Third World Quarterly, 1997,18(1):53-72.
[28] 崔占峰,王剑锋.城市治理中的"软法"逻辑:摊贩的利益组织化与协商治理[J]. 湖南科技大学学报(社会科学版),2018,21(6):98-104.[Cui Zhanfeng, Wang Jianfeng. Soft law logic in urban governance:Organization of vendor's interest and deliberative governance[J]. Journal of Hunan University of Science & Technology (Social Science Edition), 2018,21(6):98-104.]
[29] Huang G, Xue D, Li Z. From revanchism to ambivalence:The changing politics of street vending in Guangzhou[J]. Antipode, 2014,46(1):170-189.
[30] 秦波,孟青.我国城市中的街头商贩:政策思辨与规划管理[J]. 城市发展研究,2012,19(2):83-87,93.[Qin Bo, Meng Qin. Street vendors in the cities:Policy debate and planning management[J]. Urban Development, 2012,19(2):83-87,93.]
[31] Martínez L, Short J R, Estrada D. The diversity of the street vending:A case study of street vending in Cali[J]. Cities, 2018,79:18-25.
[32] Cukier J, Wall G. Informal tourism employment:Vendors in Bali, Indonesia[J]. Tourism Management, 1994,15(6):464-467.