PROGRESS AND ENLIGHTENMENT OF ETHNIC COMMUNITY RESEARCH UNDER THE BACKGROUND OF CROSS-BORDER MOBILITY
WANG Min1, JIANG Rong-hao2, LIN Yuan-cheng1
1. School of Geography, South China Normal University, Guangzhou 510631, China;
2. Department of Geography, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong 999077, China
Abstract：Cross-border movement has a long history. As a representation of the flow form of geographical space, it is deeply concerned by geography. In recent years, with the continuous advancement of globalization, cross-border movement has become a common phenomenon of geographical space flow. It not only shapes urban space and urban landscape, but also plays a role in ethnic communities, ethnic economies and ethnic culture. Under the transnational flow, different ethnic groups bring different cultures to mobile destinations, thus creating urban diversity, and forming issues such as consultation between foreign culture and local culture, identity and social integration of different ethnic groups, which have become an important topic of urban space governance and benign urban development. By combing domestic and foreign research on cross-border mobility and transnational ethnicity, we find that, 1) the study of human geography of immigrant ethnic groups at home and abroad is still more inclined to pay attention to the characteristics, evolution and context of transnational space, social and cultural geography. The perspective of social and cultural geography is still relatively lacking. 2) the migration or transnational ethnic studies in western human geography academia have shown a distinct "cultural turn", while the relevant domestic studies are still in their infancy. 3) the study of ethnic space in Chinese cities is still dominated by specific descriptive and explanatory studies. Multi-scale and multi-local comparative studies are undoubtedly lacking. Based on the progress of domestic and foreign immigration research, we find out the lack of perspectives of ethnic studies in domestic and foreign immigration research. Moreover, by comparing with foreign studies and sorting out domestic ethnic studies, with a view to introducing more "cross-border mobile research" in China to propose "Chinese experience" for comprehensive urban governance.
王敏, 江荣灏, 林元城. 跨境流动背景下族裔社区研究进展及启示[J]. 人文地理, 2020, 35(3): 1-9.
WANG Min, JIANG Rong-hao, LIN Yuan-cheng. PROGRESS AND ENLIGHTENMENT OF ETHNIC COMMUNITY RESEARCH UNDER THE BACKGROUND OF CROSS-BORDER MOBILITY. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY, 2020, 35(3): 1-9.
Thomas B. Migration and Urban Development[M]. London:Routledge, 2007:ix-xiii.
[2]
David H. The Condition of Postmodernity[M]. Oxford:Blackwell Publishers, 1989:284-307.
[3]
朱竑,封丹,王彬.全球化背景下城市文化地理研究的新趋势[J]. 人文地理,2008,23(2):6-10.[Zhu Hong, Feng Dan, Wang Bin. Globalization and new trends in cultural geography[J]. Human Geography, 2008,23(2):6-10.]
[4]
孙九霞,周尚意,王宁,等.跨学科聚焦的新领域:流动的时间,空间与社会[J].地理研究,2016,35(10):1801-1818.[Sun Jiuxia, Zhou Shangyi, Wang Ning, et al. Mobility in geographical research:Time, space and society[J]. Geographical Research, 2016,35(10):1801-1818.]
[5]
Pickles J. Social and cultural cartographies and the spatial turn in social theory[J]. Journal of Historical Geography, 1999,25(1):93-98.
[6]
Barnett C. The cultural turn:Fashion or progress in human geography?[J]. Antipode, 1998,30(4):379-394.
[7]
Cresswell T, Merriman P. Geographies of Mobilities:Practices, Spaces, Subjects[M]. Farnham:Ashgate Publishing, Ltd, 2011:1-12.
[8]
Crowe P. On progress in geography[J]. The Scottish Geographical Magazine, 1938,54(1):1-19.
[9]
傅义强.当代西方国际移民理论述略[J].世界民族,2007(3):45-55.[Fu Yiqiang. An overview of contemporary theories of international migration in the west[J]. World Ethno-National Studies, 2007(3):45-55.]
[10]
Massey D S, Arango J, Hugo G, et al. An evaluation of international migration theory:The North American case[J]. Population and Development Review, 1994,20(4):699-751.
[11]
Massey D S, Arango J, Hugo G, et al. Theories of international migration:A review and appraisal[J]. Population and Development Review, 1993,19(3):431-466.
[12]
Wallenstein I. Geopolitics and Geoculture:Essays on the Changing World-system[M]. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 1991:1-18.
[13]
Castles S, De Haas H, Miller M J. The Age of Migration:International Population Movements in the Modern World[M]. London:Palgrave Macmillan, 2013:1-18.
[14]
Nelson L, Hiemstra N. Latino immigrants and the renegotiation of place and belonging in small town America[J]. Social & Cultural Geography, 2008,9(3):319-342.
[15]
梁波,王海英.国外移民社会融入研究综述[J].甘肃行政学院学报, 2010(2):18-27.[Liang Bo, Wang Haiying. The integration of immigrants:A literature review of foreign researches[J]. Journal of Gansu Institute of Public Administration, 2010(2):18-27.]
[16]
Ma L J C, Cartier C L. The Chinese Diaspora:Space, Place, Mobility, and Identity[M]. Lanham:Rowman & Littlefield, 2003:1-37.
[17]
Jacobs D, Tillie J. Introduction:Social capital and political integration of migrants[J]. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 2004, 30(3):419-427.
[18]
陈丽园.近代海外华人研究的跨国主义取向探索——评徐元音的《梦金山, 梦家乡》[J].华侨华人历史研究,2003(1):70-75.[Chen Liyuan. The approach of transnationalism towards overseas Chinese studies:Review of Madeline Hsu's Dreaming of Gold, Dreaming of Home[J]. Overseas Chinese History Studies, 2003(1):70-75.]
[19]
Ong A. Flexible Citizenship:The Cultural Logics of Transnationality[M]. Durham:Duke University Press, 1999:16-24.
[20]
Schiller N, Basch L, Blanc-Szanton C. Towards a definition of transnationalism[J]. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1992,645(1):4-9.
[21]
Ley D. Transnational spaces and everyday lives[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2004,29(2):151-164.
[22]
Brettell C B, Hollifield J F. Migration Theory:Talking across Disciplines[M]. London:Routledge, 2014:115-137.
[23]
King R. Geography and migration studies:Retrospect and prospect[J]. Population, Space and Place, 2012,18(2):134-153.
[24]
Ravenstein E G. The laws of migration[J]. Journal of the Statistic Society, 1976,48(2):289-291.
[25]
Mabogunje A L. Systems approach to a theory of rural-urban migration[J]. Geographical Analysis, 2010,2(1):1-18.
[26]
Hägerstrand T. On the definition of migration[J]. Analyst, 1969,75(8):49-54.
[27]
Lake R W. Planning and applied geography:Positivism, ethics, and geographical information systems[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 1993,17(3):404-413.
[28]
Ogden P E. Weaving demography into society, economy and culture:progress and prospect in population geography[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2000,24(4):627-640.
[29]
Lawson V. Arguments within geographies of movement:The theoretical potential of migrants' stories[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2000,24(2):173-189.
[30]
Silvey R, Lawson V. Placing the migrant[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 1999,89(1):121-132.
[31]
宋郁玲.人文地理学人口迁移研究的跨界与转向:台湾与英美研究的比较[J].(台湾)地理学报,2006(43):61-79.[Song Yuling. Beyond the discipline and transition of migration studies in human geography:A comparison between Taiwanese and Anglophonic studies[J]. (Taiwan) Journal of Geographical Science, 2006(43):61-79.]
[32]
McHugh K. Inside, outside, upside down, backward, forward, round and round:A case for ethnographic studies in migration[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2000,24(1):71-89.
[33]
Anderson K, Domosh M, Pile S, et al. Handbook of Cultural Geography[M]. Thousand Oaks:SAGE, 2002:74-87.
[34]
Mavroudi E. Diaspora as process:(De)constructing boundaries[J]. Geography Compass, 2007,1(3):467-479.
[35]
Kobayash A, Preston V, Murnaghan A M. Place, affect, and transnationalism through the voices of Hong Kong immigrants to Canada[J]. Social & Cultural Geography, 2011,12(8):871-888.
[36]
Mai N, King R. Love, sexuality and migration:Mapping the issue(s)[J]. Mobilities, 2009,4(3):295-307.
[37]
Kaplan D H. Navigating Ethnicity:Segregation, Placemaking, and Difference[M]. Lanham:Rowman & Littlefield, 2017:65-112.
[38]
Burgess E W, McKenzie R D. The City[M]. Chicago:University of Chicago Press, 1967:1-46.
[39]
Kaplan D H, Holloway S. Urban Geography[M]. London:Wiley Global Education, 2014:166-178.
[40]
Van Kempen R, ?ule Özüekren A. Ethnic segregation in cities:New forms and explanations in a dynamic world[J]. Urban Studies, 1998, 35(10):1631-1656.
[41]
Burgess E W. Residential segregation in American cities[J]. The annals of the American academy of political and social science, 1928, 140(1):105-115.
[42]
Park R E. The city:Suggestions for the investigation of human behavior in the city environment[J]. American journal of sociology, 1915,20(5):577-612.
[43]
Kaplan D H, Woodhouse K. Research in ethnic segregation I:Causal factors[J]. Urban geography, 2004,25(6):579-585.
[44]
Kaplan D H, Woodhouse, K. Research in ethnic segregation Ⅱ:Measurements, categories and meanings[J]. Urban Geography, 2005,26(8):737-745.
[45]
Kaplan D H, Douzet F. Research in ethnic segregation Ⅲ:Segregation outcomes[J]. Urban Geography, 2011,32(4):589-605.
[46]
Johnston R, Poulsen M, Forrest J. Research note-Measuring ethnic residential segregation:Putting some more geography in[J]. Urban Geography, 2009,30(1):91-109.
[47]
Ellis M, Wright R, Parks V. Work together, live apart? Geographies of racial and ethnic segregation at home and at work[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 2004,94(3):620-637.
[48]
Gottdiener M, Budd L, Lehtovuori P. Key Concepts in Urban Studies[M]. London:SAGE, 2015:127-131.
[49]
Kaplan D H. Landscapes of the Ethnic Economy[M]. Lanham:Rowman & Littlefield, 2006:2-10.
[50]
Story B. In/different cities a case for contact at the margins[J]. Social & Cultural Geography, 2013,14(7):752-761.
[51]
Lawson, V. Questions of migration and belonging:Understandings of migration under neoliberalism in Ecuador[J]. International Journal of Population Geography, 1999,5(4):261-276.
[52]
Wang Q. Ethnic entrepreneurship studies in geography:A review[J]. Geography Compass, 2012,6(4):227-240.
[53]
Wang W. Revitalization of local community and ethnicity:Nagasaki's lantern festival among the immigrant Chinese[J]. International Journal of Japanese Sociology, 2003,12(1):17-32.
[54]
Wang L, Lo L. Immigrant grocery-shopping behavior:Ethnic identity versus accessibility[J]. Environment and Planning A, 2007,39(3):684-699.
[55]
Devadoss C, Kaplan D H. The immigration and settlement of Asian Indians in Phoenix, Arizona, 1965-2011:Ethnic pride vs. racial discrimination in the suburbs[J]. Journal of Regional Science, 2013,53(4):737-738.
[56]
Kurien P A. Who speaks for Indian Americans? Religion, ethnicity, and political formation[J]. American Quarterly, 2007,59(3):759-83.
[57]
Law L. Home cooking:Filipino women and geographies of the senses in Hong Kong[J]. Ecumene, 2001,8(3):264-283.
[58]
Li W, Skop E. Ethnicity[M]//Kitchin R, Thrift N. International Encyclopedia of Human Geography. New York:Wiley International, 2012:615-625.
[59]
王志弘,沈孟颖.疆域化, 缝隙接口与跨国空间:台北市安康市场[越南街] 族裔化地方研究[J].台湾社会研究季刊,2009(73):119-166.[Wang Zhihong, Shen Mengying. Territorialization, interstitial interface and transnational space:The Taipei vietnam street" as an ethnic place[J]. Taiwan:A Radical Quarterly in Social Studies, 2009(73):119-166.]
[60]
Valentine G. Living with difference:Reflections on geographies of encounter[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2008,32(3):323-337.
[61]
Darling J, Wilson H F. Encountering the City:Urban Encounters from Accra to New York[M]. Abingdon, Oxon:Routledge, 2016:1-24.
[62]
Matejskova T, Leitner H. Urban encounters with difference:The contact hypothesis and immigrant integration projects in eastern Berlin[J]. Social & Cultural Geography, 2011,12(7):717-741.
[63]
Dirksmeier P, Helbrecht I. Everyday urban encounters as stratification practices:Analysing affects in micro-situations of power struggles[J]. Cities, 2015,19(4):486-498.
[64]
Wilson H F. On geography and encounter:Bodies, borders, and difference[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2017,41(4):451-471.
[65]
Hackworth J, Rekers J. Ethnic packaging and gentrification:The case of four neighborhoods in Toronto[J]. Urban Affairs Review, 2005,41(2):211-236.
[66]
Shaw S, Bagwell S, Karmowska J. Ethnoscapes as spectacle:Reimaging multicultural districts as new destinations for leisure and tourism consumption[J]. Urban Studies, 2004,41(10):1983-2000.
[67]
Rath J, Bodaar A, Wagemaakers T, et al. Chinatown 2.0:The difficult flowering of an ethnically themed shopping area[J]. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 2018,44(1):81-98.
[68]
Takahashi K. Toronto's Little Portugal:Gentrification and social relations among local entrepreneurs[J]. Urban Geography, 2017,38(4):578-605.
[69]
Schmiz A. Staging a ‘Chinatown’ in Berlin:The role of city branding in the urban governance of ethnic diversity[J]. European Urban and Regional Studies, 2017,24(3):290-303.
[70]
Fincher R, Iveson K. Planning and Diversity in the City:Redistribution, Recognition and Encounter[M]. New York:Palgrave Macmillan, 2008:1-20.
[71]
Raco M. Living with diversity:Local social imaginaries and the politics of intersectionality in a super-diverse city[J]. Political Geography, 2018(62):149-159.
[72]
钱俊希,朱竑.新文化地理学的理论统一性与话题多样性[J]. 地理研究,2015,34(3):422-436.[Qian Junxi, Zhu Hong. Theoretical unity and thematic diversity in new cultural geography[J]. Geographical Research, 2015,34(3):422-436.]
[73]
林俊帆,林耿.意义,权力与再物质化:食物消费地理新进展[J]. 人文地理,2014,29(6):40-46.[Lin Junfan, Lin Geng. Meaning, power and rematerializing:Progress in geography of food consumption[J]. Human Geography, 2014,29(6):40-46.]
[74]
Tolia-Kelly D P. Materializing post-colonial geographies:Examining the textural landscapes of migration in the South Asian home[J]. Geoforum, 2004,35(6):675-688.
[75]
Law L. Defying disappearance:Cosmopolitan public spaces in Hong Kong[J]. Urban Studies, 2002,39(9):1625-1645.
[76]
蓝佩嘉.跨越国界的生命地图:菲籍家务移工的流动与认同[J]. 台湾社会研究季刊,2002(48):169-218.[Lan Peijia. A transnational topography for the migration and identification of Filipina migrant domestic workers[J]. Taiwan:A Radical Quarterly in Social Studies, 2002(48):169-218.]
[77]
王志弘. 我们有多元文化城市吗? 台北都会区东南亚族裔领域化的机制, 类型与作用[J]. 台湾社会研究季刊,2011(82):31-84.[Wang Zhihong. Do we have a multi-cultural city? The southeast Asian ethnic territorialization in Taipei metropolitan area[J]. Taiwan:A Radical Quarterly in Social Studies, 2011(82):31-84.]
[78]
张春炎.从异乡人到[艺] 乡人:中和区小缅甸美食街的文化景观和象征展演[J].台湾东南亚学刊,2011,8(2):139-170.[Zhang Chunyan. From strangers to actors:The cultural spectacle and performance of Myanmar cuisine court in Zhonghe dist[J]. Taiwan Journal of Southeast Asian Studies, 2011,8(2):139-170.]
[79]
Skop E, Bose P, Hackworth J, et al. Navigating Ethnicity:Segregation, placemaking, and difference[J]. The AAG Review of Books, 2019,7(1):68-76.
[80]
Shin H R. The territoriality of ethnic enclaves:Dynamics of transnational practices and geopolitical relations within and beyond a Korean transnational enclave in New Malden, London[J]. Annals of the American Association of Geographers, 2018,108(3):756-772.
[81]
Pieke F N. Immigrant China[J]. Modern China, 2012,38(1):40-77.
[82]
Mathews G, Yang Y. How Africans pursue low-end globalization in Hong Kong and mainland China[J]. Journal of Current Chinese Affairs, 2012,41(2):95-120.
[83]
Lyons M, Brown A, Li Z. In the dragon's den:African traders in Guangzhou[J]. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 2012,38(5):869-888.
[84]
Han H. Individual grassroots multilingualism in Africa Town in Guangzhou:The role of states in globalization[J]. International Multilingual Research Journal, 2013,7(1):83-97.
[85]
Lyons M, Brown A, Li Z. The ‘third tier’ of globalization:African traders in Guangzhou[J]. Cities, 2008,12(2):196-206.
[86]
Bodomo A. The African trading community in Guangzhou:An emerging bridge for Africa-China relations[J]. The China Quarterly, 2010,203:693-707.
[87]
Haugen H O. Chinese exports to Africa:Competition, Complementarity and cooperation between micro-level actors[J]. Forum for Development Studies, 2011,38(2):157-176.
[88]
Bodomo A, Ma E. We are what we eat:Food in the process of community formation and identity shaping among African traders in Guangzhou and Yiwu[J]. African Diaspora, 2012,5(1):3-26.
[89]
Castillo R. Landscapes of Aspiration in Guangzhou's African Music Scene:Beyond the trading narrative[J]. Journal of Current Chinese Affairs, 2016,4(4):83-115.
[90]
牛冬."过客社团":广州非洲人的社会组织[J].社会学研究,2015(2):124-148.[Niu Dong. "Transient Association":Africans' social organizations in Guangzhou[J]. Sociological Studies, 2015(2):124-148.]
[91]
Castillo R. ‘Homing’ Guangzhou:Emplacement, belonging and precarity among Africans in China[J]. International Journal of Cultural Studies, 2016,19(3):287-306.
[92]
Lan S. State regulation of undocumented African migrants in China:A multi-scalar analysis[J]. Journal of Asian and African Studies, 2015,50(3):289-304.
[93]
Haugen H Ø. Nigerians in China:A second state of immobility[J]. International Migration, 2012,50(2):65-80.
[94]
周雯婷,刘云刚,全志英.全球化背景下在华韩国人族裔聚居区的形成与发展演变——以北京望京为例[J].地理学报,2016,71(4):649-665.[Zhou Wenting, Liu Yungang, Quan Zhiying. Making, development and transformation of South Korean Enclave in China:A case study of Wangjing, Beijing[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2016,71(4):649-665.]
[95]
李志刚,薛德升.广州小北路黑人聚居区社会空间分析[J].地理学报,2008,63(2):207-218.[Li Zhigang, Xue Desheng. The African enclave of Guangzhou:A case study of Xiaobeilu[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2008,63(2):207-218.]
[96]
Li Z, Ma L J C, Xue D. An African enclave in China:The making of a new transnational urban space[J]. Eurasian Geography and Economics, 2009,50(6):699-719.
[97]
李志刚, 薛德升, 杜枫, 等. 全球化下"跨国移民社会空间" 的地方响应——以广州小北黑人区为例[J].地理研究,2009,28(4):920-932.[Li Zhigang, Xue Desheng, Du Feng, et al. The local response of transnational social space under globalization in urban China:A case study of African enclave in Guangzhou[J]. Geographical research, 2009,28(4):920-932.]
[98]
Zhang L. Ethnic congregation in a globalizing city:The case of Guangzhou, China[J]. Cities, 2008,25(6):383-395.
[99]
Li Z, Lyons M, Brown A. China's ‘Chocolate City’:An ethnic enclave in a changing landscape[J]. African Diaspora, 2012,5(1):51-72.
[100]
Gilles A. The social construction of Guangzhou as a translocal trading place[J]. Journal of Current Chinese Affairs, 2016,44(4):17-47.
[101]
Castillo R. Feeling at home in the "Chocolate City":An exploration of place-making practices and structures of belonging amongst Africans in Guangzhou[J]. Inter-Asia Cultural Studies, 2014,15(2):235-257.
[102]
Bork-Hüffer T, Rafflenbeul B, Li Z, et al. Mobility and the transiency of social spaces:African merchant entrepreneurs in China[J]. Population Space & Place, 2015,22(2):199-211.
[103]
Ho E L E. The geo-social and global geographies of power:Urban aspirations of ‘worlding’ African students in China[J]. Geopolitics, 2016,22(1):1-19.
[104]
刘云刚,陈跃.广州日本移民族裔经济的形成及其社会空间特征[J]. 地理学报,2014,69(10):1533-1546.[Liu Yungang, Chen Yue. Global economy, local landscape:Study on the ethnic economy of Japanese expatriates in Guangzhou City[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2014,69(10):1533-1546.]
[105]
周雯婷,刘云刚.上海古北地区日本人聚居区族裔经济的形成特征[J].地理研究,2015,34(11):2179-2194.[Zhou Wenting, Liu Yungang. Characteristics of the Japanese ethnic economy in the Gubei Japanese enclave of Shanghai city, China[J]. Geographical Research, 2015,34(11):2179-2194.]
[106]
Kong L. Globalisation and Singaporean transmigration:Re-imagining and negotiating national identity[J]. Political Geography, 1999,18(5):563-589.
[107]
Wu F, Webber K. The rise of "foreign gated communities" in Beijing:Between economic globalization and local institutions[J]. Cities, 2004,21(3):203-213.
[108]
Wang J, Lau S S Y. Forming foreign enclaves in Shanghai:State action in globalization[J]. Journal of Housing and the Built Environment, 2008,23(2):103-118.
[109]
刘云刚,周雯婷,黄徐璐,等.全球化背景下在华跨国移民社区的空间生产——广州远景路韩国人聚居区的案例研究[J].地理科学,2017,37(7):976-986.[Liu Yungang, Zhou Wenting, Huang Xulu, et al. Production of space of South Korean enclave in Yuanjing Road, Guangzhou[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2017,37(7):976-986.]
[110]
Ralph D, Staeheli L A. Home and migration:Mobilities, belongings and identities[J]. Geography Compass, 2011,5(7):517-530.
[111]
黄舒楣.外流城市改写香港湾仔旧区地景的服务式住宅生产[J]. (台湾)地理学报,2016(80):55-80.[Huang Shumei. Expatriation of the city the creation of serviced apartments landscape in Wanchai, Hong Kong[J]. (Taiwan) Journal of Geographical Science, 2016(80):55-80.]
[112]
Beaverstock J V. Transnational elites in global cities:British expatriates in Singapore's financial district[J]. Geoforum, 2002,33(4):525-538.
[113]
Pow C P. Living it up:Super-rich enclave and transnational elite urbanism in Singapore[J]. Geoforum, 2011,42(3):382-393.
[114]
Ong A. Mutations in citizenship[J]. Theory, culture & society, 2006,23(2/3):499-505.
[115]
Koh A. Global flows of foreign talent:Identity anxieties in Singapore's ethnoscape[J]. Sojourn:Journal of Social Issues in Southeast Asia, 2003,18(2):230-256.
[116]
王志弘,沈孟颖,林纯秀.族裔公共空间的划界政治:台北都会区外围东南亚消费地景分析[J].台湾东南亚学刊,2009,6(1):3-48.[Wang Zhihong, Shen Mengying, Lin Chunxiu. Politics of boundary-making in ethnic public spaces:Southeast Asian Landscapes of consumption in outer Taipei metropolitan area[J]. Taiwan Journal of Southeast Asian Studies, 2009,6(1):3-48.]
[117]
Sheller M, Urry J. The new mobilities paradigm[J]. Environment & Planning A, 2006,38(2):207-226.
[118]
Cresswell T. On the Move:Mobility in the Modern Western World[M]. London:Routledge, 2006:1-24.
[119]
杨茜好,朱竑.西方人文地理学的"流动性" 研究进展与启示[J]. 华南师范大学学报(自然科学版),2015,47(2):1-11.[Yang Xihao, Zhu Hong. Progress and revelation of researches on the anglophone geography of mobilities[J]. Journal of South China Normal University (Natural Science Edition), 2015,47(2):1-11.]
[120]
朱璇,解佳,江泓源.移动性抑或流动性?——翻译、沿革和解析[J].旅游学刊,2017,32(10):104-114.[Zhu Xuan, Xie Jia, Jiang Hongyuan. Mobility or liquidity? Translation, evolution and interpretation[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2017,32(10):104-114.]
