重返&ldquo;物质&rdquo;：新文化地理学视角下的消费研究及进展评述

马凌; 朱竑; 王敏

doi:10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2019.03.007

PDF(1461 KB)

人文地理 ›› 2019, Vol. 34 ›› Issue (3) : 44-52,82. DOI: 10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2019.03.007

文化

重返“物质”：新文化地理学视角下的消费研究及进展评述

马凌^1,2, 朱竑^1,2, 王敏³

作者信息 +

REVIEW OF RE-MATERIALIZATION AND CONSUMPTION STUDIES IN NEW CULTURAL GEOGRAPHY

MA Ling^1,2, ZHU Hong^1,2, WANG Min³

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

随着物质地理研究的兴起，消费已成为新文化地理学关注的热点之一。本文回顾了物质地理和消费间的关系，并对物质消费品及其品牌生产的地方性与跨地方性、物质消费中的文化政治及身体实践等相关研究议题进行了评述。新文化地理学“重返物质”倡导下的消费研究，强调以物为线索的“行为—主体—物质”的复杂关系和日常实践，有力拓展了传统“人—地”关系中对“物”维度的关注。同时，这也为消费研究提供了地理学的新视角和新方法，有利于理解物质流动和消费背后的全球—地方关系、文化经济和文化政治。这一新兴交叉研究领域值得国内人文地理界关注和重视。

Abstract

In Anglo-American social and cultural geography, consumption has been emerging as a new theoretical frontier and empirical focus point alongside with the rising of re-materialization and material turn, in particular after the "cultural turn" since 1980s. This material geography calls for attention on human material system and its representing social ideologies/social norms, as well as people's everyday life. In this regard, this paper reviews the complex relations between material geography and consumption. Under the advocacy of the "returning to materialization" in new cultural geography, the consumption research focuses significantly on the complex interaction and daily practice of "subject-objects(things)-place(society)" with the material as the clue. For instance, by "living with the things", one can observe how people build their life world through material objects. Through "following the things", one can examine the place-relations and different socio-cultural contexts during the flow of things across the globe. And by "feeling the things", one can investigate the affective relations between people, material objects and places. In sum, the paper calls for attention to the material part of human system and the introduction of dimension of "things" in people's daily living practice and traditional "human-place" relationship.

导出引用

马凌, 朱竑, 王敏. 重返“物质”：新文化地理学视角下的消费研究及进展评述[J]. 人文地理. 2019, 34(3): 44-52,82 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2019.03.007

MA Ling, ZHU Hong, WANG Min. REVIEW OF RE-MATERIALIZATION AND CONSUMPTION STUDIES IN NEW CULTURAL GEOGRAPHY[J]. HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. 2019, 34(3): 44-52,82 https://doi.org/10.13959/j.issn.1003-2398.2019.03.007

中图分类号： K901.6

参考文献

[1] 王宁.消费社会学(第二版)[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2011:1-3.[Wang Ning. Consumer Sociology (Second Edition)[M]. Beijing:Social Sciences Academic Press, 2011:1-3.]
[2] Martyn J Lee. Consumer Culture Reborn:The Cultural Politics of Consumption[M]. London:Routledge, 1993:13.
[3] Miller D. Acknowledging Consumption:A Review of New Studies[M]. London:Routledge, 1995:31-34.
[4] 贺灿飞,郭琪,马妍,等.西方经济地理学研究进展[J].地理学报, 2014,69(8):1207-1223.[He Canfei, Guo Qi, Ma Yan, et al. Progress of economic geography in the West:A literature review[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2014,69(8):1207-1223.]
[5] Pike A. Economic geographies of brands and branding[J]. Economic Geography, 2013,89(4):317-339.
[6] Karpik L. Valuing the Unique[M]. Oxford:Oxford University Press, 2010:15-16.
[7] Stark D. "What's valuable?"[M]//Beckert J, Aspers P. (eds). The Worth of Goods:Valuation and Pricing in the Economy. Oxford:Oxford University Press, 2011:340-351.
[8] Zelizer V A. Economic Lives:How Culture Shapes the Economy[M]. New Jersey:Princeton University Press, 2010.
[9] Mitchell D. There's no such thing as culture:Towards a reconceptualization of the idea of culture in geography[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 1995,20(1):102-116.
[10] Jackson P. Rematerializing social and cultural geography[J]. Social and Cultural Geography, 2000,1(1):9-14.
[11] Hudson L B. Modern material culture studies:Anthropology as archaeology[J]. American Behavioral Scientist, 1984,28(1):31-39.
[12] Crang P. Material geographies[M]//Cloke P, Crang P, Goodwin M. Introducing Human Geographies (3nd Edition). London:Taylor & Francis Publishers, 2014:276-291.
[13] Cook I, Crang P. The world on a plate:Culinary culture, displacement and geographical knowledges[J]. Journal of Material Culture, 2003,1(2):131-153.
[14] Cook I, Harrison M. Cross over food:Re-materializing postcolonial geographies[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2010,28(3):296-317.
[15] Miller D. Home Possessions:Material Culture behind Closed Doors[M]. Oxford:Berg, 2001:5-11.
[16] Miller D. Car culture[M]. Oxford:Berg, 2001:1-2.
[17] Miller D. Coca-cola:A black sweet drink from Trinidad[M]//Miller D. Material Cultures:Why Some Things Matter. London:UCL Press, 1998:167-187.
[18] Laurier E. Why people say where they are during mobile phone calls[J]. Environment and Planning D:Society and Space, 2001,19(4):485-504.
[19] Doel M, Segrott J. Beyond belief? Consumer culture, complementary medicine and the disease of everyday life[J]. Environment and Planning D:Society and Space, 2003,21(6):739-759.
[20] Leslie D, Reimer S. Gender, modern design and home consumption[J]. Environment and Planning D:Society and Space, 2003,21(3):293-316.
[21] Miller D. Material Culture and Mass Consumption[M]. Oxford:Blackwell, 1987:41.
[22] Kearnes M B. Geographies that matter:The rhetorical deployment of physicality[J]. Social and Cultural Geography, 2003,4(2):139-152.
[23] Crang P. The geographies of material culture[M]//Cloke P, Crang P, Goodwin M. Introducing Human Geographies (2nd Edition). London:Arnold, 2005:168-181.
[24] Gregson N, Metcalfe A, Crewe L. Identity, mobility, and the throwaway society[J]. Environment and Planning D:Society and Space, 2007,25(4):682-700.
[25] Tolia-kelly D. Locating processes of identification:Studying the precipitates of re-memory through artefacts in the British Asian home[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2004, 29(3):314-329.
[26] Tolia-kelly D. Materializing post-colonial geographies:Examining the textural landscapes of migration in the South Asian home[J]. Geoforum, 2004,35(6):675-688.
[27] Shove E. Converging conventions of comfort, cleanliness and convenience[J]. Journal of Consumer Policy, 2003,26(4):395-418.
[28] Shove E, Chappells H. Ordinary Consumption and Extraordinary Relationships:Utilities and Their Users[M]. London:Routledge, 2001:22-36.
[29] Wu D Y H, Cheung S C H. The Globalization of Chinese Food[M]. Surrey:Curzon Press, 2002.
[30] Anderson B, Harrison P. The promise of non-representational theories[M]//Anderson B, Harrison P. Taking-place:Non-representational Theories and Geography. Farnham:Ashgate, 2008:1-34.
[31] Lorimer H. Cultural geography:The busyness of being ‘more-thanrepresentational’[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2005,29(1):83-94.
[32] Pile S. Emotions and affect in recent human geography[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2010,35(1):5-20.
[33] Kraftl P, Adey P. Architecture/Affect/Inhabitation:Geographies of being-in buildings[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 2008,98(1):213-231.
[34] Blunt A, Dowling R. Home (Key Ideas in Geography)[M]. Abingdon:Routledge, 2006:14-23.
[35] Thrift N. Non-representational Theory:Space, Politics, Affect[M]. Abingdon:Routledge, 2008:1-10.
[36] Simpson P. Apprehending everyday rhythms:Rhythmanalysis, timelapse photography, and the space-times of street performance[J]. Cultural Geographies, 2012,19(4):423-445.
[37] Simpson P. ‘So, as you can see...’:Some reflections on the utility of video methodologies in the study of embodied practices[J]. Area, 2011,43(3):343-352.
[38] Cook I. Follow the thing:Papaya[J]. Antipode, 2004,36(4):642-664.
[39] Cook I, Harrison M. Follow the thing:"West Indian hot pepper sauce"[J]. Space and Culture, 2007,10(1):40-63.
[40] Thrift N. Intensities of feeling:Towards a spatial politics of affect[J]. Geografiska Annaler, 2004,86(1):57-78.
[41] Wright J K. Terrace incognitae:The place of the imagination in geography[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 1947,37(1):1-15.
[42] Hetherington K, Law J. After networks[J]. Environment and Planning D, 2000,18(2):127-133.
[43] 林耿,王炼军.全球化背景下酒吧的地方性与空间性——以广州为例[J].地理科学,2011,31(7):794-801.[Lin Geng, Wang Lianjun. Placeness and spaciality of bar under globalization:Case of Guangzhou city, China[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2011,31(7):794-801.]
[44] 蔡晓梅,朱竑,刘晨.情境主题餐厅员工地方感特征及其形成原因——以广州味道云南食府为例[J].地理学报,2012,67(2):239-252.[Cai Xiaomei, Zhu Hong, Liu Chen. Characteristics and causes of situational theme restaurant staff's sense of place:A case study of the Taste-Yunnan restaurant in Guangzhou[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2012,67(2):239-252.]
[45] 刘晨,蔡晓梅,曾国军.西方厨房研究及其对中国文化地理家庭空间研究之启示[J].热带地理,2014,34(4):445-453.[Liu Chen, Cai Xiaomei, Zeng Guojun. Kitchen studies through western gaze and cultural geographies of home in urban China[J]. Tropical Geography, 2014,34(4):445-453.]
[46] 林俊帆,林耿.意义、权力与再物质化:食物消费地理新进展[J].人文地理,2014,29(6):40-46.[Lin Junfan, Lin Geng. Meaning, power and rematerializing:Progress in geography of food consumption[J]. Human Geography, 2014,29(6):40-46.]
[47] Watts M. Commodities[M]//Cloke P, Crang P, Goodwin M. Introducing Human Geographies (2nd Edition). London:Arnold, 2005:305-315.
[48] Smith A, Rainnie A, Dunford M, et al. Networks of value, commodities and regions:Reworking divisions of labour in macro-regional economies[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2002,26(1):41-63.
[49] Holt D. Toward a sociology of branding[J]. Journal of Consumer Culture, 2006,6(3):299-302.
[50] Pike A. Brand and brand geographies[J]. Geography Compass, 2009,3(1):190-213.
[51] Bilkey W J, Nes E. Country-of-origin effects on product evaluations[J]. Journal of International Business Studies, 1982,8(1):89-99.
[52] Gürhancanli Z, Maheswaran D. Determinants of country-of-origin evaluations[J]. Journal of Consumer Research, 2000,27(1):96-108.
[53] Johansson J K. Missing a strategic opportunity:Manager's denial of country-of-origin effects[M]//Papadopoulos N, Heslop L A. (eds). Product Country Images:Impact and Role in International Marketing. New York:International Business Press, 1993:77-86.
[54] Papadopoulos N G, Heslop L. Product-country images:Impact and role in international marketing[J]. Journal of Marketing, 1988,59(2):115-128.
[55] Kapferer J N. Is there really no hope for local brands?[J]. Brand Management, 2002,9(3):163-170.
[56] Appadurai A. Introduction:Commodities and the politics of value[M]//Appadurai A. The Social Life of Things. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 1986:3-63.
[57] Kopytoff I. The cultural biographies of things:Commoditization as process[M]//Appadurai A. The Social Life of Things. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 1986:64-94.
[58] 钱丽芸,朱竑.地方性与传承:宜兴紫砂文化的地理品牌与变迁[J]. 地理科学,2011,31(10):1166-1171.[Qian Liyun, Zhu Hong. Circulation and the localness:Geographical brand of Yixing purple sand cultural change[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2011,31(10):1166-1171.]
[59] 刘博,朱竑.ZARA跨国品牌升级——空间发展史视角[J].热带地理,2016,36(2):174-180.[Liu Bo, Zhu Hong. Transnational upgrading of ZARA:Perspective of spatial-temporal history[J]. Tropical Geography, 2016,36(2):174-180.]
[60] 曾国军,孙树芝.跨地方饮食品牌重塑的理论模型与实证分析[J]. 地理学报,2016,71(2):338-351.[Zeng Guojun, Sun Shuzhi. Theoretical model and empirical study of translocal food rebranding[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2016,71(2):338-351.]
[61] 曾国军,孙树芝,朱竑,等.全球化与地方性冲突背后的跨地方饮食文化生产——基于广州的案例[J].地理科学,2013,33(3):291-298.[Zeng Guojun, Sun Shuzhi, Zhu Hong, et al. Translocal restaurants' cultural production under the paradox of globalization and locality:Case studies from Guangzhou[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2013,33(3):291-298.]
[62] 谢晓如,封丹,朱竑.对文化微空间的感知与认同研究——以广州太古汇方所文化书店为例[J].地理学报, 2014,69(2):184-198.[Xie Xiaoru, Feng Dan, Zhu Hong. The perception and identity to the cultural micro-space:A case study of Fangsuo Commune in TaiKoo Hui, Guangzhou[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2014,69(2):184-198.]
[63] 王敏,马纯莉,朱竑. "互联网+" 时代下的乡村地方品牌建构——以从化市良口镇三村为例[J].经济地理,2017, 37(1):115-122.[Wang Min, Ma Chunli, Zhu Hong. Rural local brand construction in "Internet +" era:Case study of Liangkou town in Conghua[J]. Economic Geography, 2017,37(1):115-122.]
[64] Urry J. Global Complexity[M]. Cambridge:Policy Press, 2003:60, 68.
[65] Klingmann A. Brandscapes:Architecture in the Experience Economy[M]. Massachusetts:The MIT Press, 2007.
[66] Jackson P, Russell P, Ward N. Brands in the making:A life history approach[M]//Pike A. Brands and Branding Geographies. Cheltenham:Edward Elgar, 2011:59-74.
[67] Polanyi K. The Great Transformation[M]. Boston:Beacon Press, 1957:2-10.
[68] 王宁.消费全球化:视野分歧与理论重构[J].学术研究,2012(8):30-42.[Wang Ning. Consumption globalization:Vision divided and theoretical reconstruction[J]. Academic Research, 2012(8):30-42.]
[69] Cosgrove D, Denis E. Prospect, perspective and the evolution of the landscape idea[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series, 1985,10(1):45-62.
[70] Daniels S. Marxism, cultural, and the duplicity of landscape[J]. New Models in Geography, 1989(2):196-220.
[71] Cosgrove D, Daniels S. Iconography and landscape[M]//Cosgrove D, Daniels S. The Iconography of Landscape. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 1988:1-10.
[72] Hall S. Representation:Cultural Representations and Signifying Practices[M]. New York:Sage, 1997:3-5.
[73] 叶超.社会空间辩证法的由来[J].自然辩证法研究,2012,28(2):56-60.[Ye Chao. The origins of socio-spatial dialectic[J]. Studies in Dialectics of Nature, 2012,28(2):56-60.]
[74] 蔡晓梅,苏晓波.迷失的优雅:广州白天鹅宾馆景观演变中的文化政治[J]. 旅游学刊,2016,31(3):16-25.[Cai Xiaomei, Su Xiaobo. Falling from grace:Cultural politics and the changing landscape of White Swan hotel, Guangzhou[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2016,31(3):16-25.]
[75] 唐晓峰,周尚意,李蕾蕾. "超级机制" 与文化地理学研究[J].地理研究,2008,27(2):431-438.[Tang Xiaofeng, Zhou Shangyi, Li Leilei. The concept of super-organism in the study of cultural geography[J]. Geographical Research, 2008,27(2):431-438.]
[76] 殷洁,张京祥,罗小龙.重申全球化时代的空间观:后现代地理学的理论与实践[J].人文地理,2010,25(4):12-17.[Yin Jie, Zhang Jingxiang, Luo Xiaolong. Reaffirmation of the view of space in the globalization era:Theories and practice of postmodern geographies[J]. Human Geography, 2010,25(4):12-17.]
[77] Larner W. Neoliberialism[J]. Environment and Planning D:Society and Space, 2003,21(5):509-512.
[78] Jackson P, Thomas N, Dwyer C. Consumer culture in London and Mumbai:Exploring the transnational geographies of food and fashion[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2004,29(2):165-178.
[79] Jackson P, Thrift N. Geographies of consumption[M]//Miller D. Acknowledging Consumption:A Review of New Studies. London and New York:Routledge, 1995:204-237.
[80] Gregson N. Living with Things:Ridding, Accommodation, Dwelling[M]. Wantage:Sean Kingston Publishing, 2007:102-131.
[81] Hooper B. Globalisation and resistance in post-Mao China:The case of foreign consumer products[J]. Asian studies review, 2000,24(4):439-470.
[82] Jackson P. Local consumption cultures in a globalizing world[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2004,29(2):165-178.
[83] Deborah D. The Consumer Revolution in Urban China[M]. Oakland:University of California Press, 2000:56-58.
[84] Inglis D, Gimlin D. The Globalization of Food[M]. Oxford:Berg Publishers, 2009:200-210.
[85] Tomlinson J. Cultural Imperialism:A Critical Introduction[M]. Baltimore:Johns Hopkins University Press, 1991.
[86] Ritzer G. The McDonaldization of Society[M]. London:Sage, 1995.
[87] Richards G. Gastronomy:An essential ingredient in tourism production and consumption?[M]//Richards G. Tourism and Gastronomy. London:Routledge, 2002:17-34.
[88] Richards G. Tourism and Gastronomy[M]. London:Routledge, 2002:3-20.
[89] Symons M. The Shared Table:Ideas for Australian Cuisine[M]. Canberra:AGPS, 1993:1-5.
[90] Ahmed S. Uprootings/Regroundings:Questions of Home and Migration[M]. Oxford:Berg, 2003:3-26.
[91] Collins F L. Of kimchi and coffee:Globalization, transnationalism and familiarity in culinary consumption[J]. Social & Cultural Geography, 2008,9(2):151-169.
[92] Hudson R. Regions and regional uneven development forever? Some reflective comments upon theory and practice[J]. Regional Studies, 2007,41(9):1149-1160.
[93] Pike A. Economic geographies of brands and branding[J]. Economic Geography, 2013,89(4):317-339.
[94] Lury C. Brands:The Logos of the Global Economy[M]. London:Routledge, 2004:27.
[95] Moor L. The Rise of Brands[M]. London:Berg, 2007:1-10.
[96] Sack R D. Place, Modernity and the Consumer's World:A Relational Framework for Geographical Analysis[M]. Baltimore and London:John Hopkins University Press, 1992:51-90.
[97] Gregson N, Crang M, Ahamed F, et al. Following things of rubbish value:End-of-life ships, ‘chock-chocky’ furniture and the Bangladeshi middle class consumer[J]. Geoforum, 2010,41(6):846-854.
[98] Letarte A, Dub E L, Troche V. Similarities and differences in affective and cognitive origins of food likings and dislikes[J]. Appetite, 1997,28(2):115-129.
[99] Mathew G, Lui T L. Consuming Hongkong[M]. Hongkong:Hongkong University Press, 2001:2-30.
[100] 索尔斯坦·凡勃伦.有闲阶级论[M].赵伯英,译.西安:陕西人民出版社,2011.[Solstein Vanblen. Leisure Class Theory[J]. Zhao Boying, trans. Xi'an:Shaanxi People's Publishing House, 2011.]
[101] 陶东风.消费文化语境中的身体研究热[J].当代文坛,2007(5):4-6.[Tao Dongfeng. Body research in the context of consumer culture[J]. Contemporary Literary World, 2007(5):4-6.]
[102] 张晓.消费社会中的身体消费研究[D].成都:西南交通大学,2014:3-5.[Zhang Xiao. Research on Physical Consumption in Consumer Society[D]. Chengdu:Southwest Jiaotong University (Master Thesis), 2014:3-5.]
[103] Delhaye C. The development of consumption culture and the individualization of female identity[J]. Journal of Consumer Culture, 2006,6(1):87-115.
[104] 陶伟,王绍续,朱竑.身体、身体观以及人文地理学对身体的研究[J].地理研究,2015,34(6):1173-1187.[Tao Wei, Wang Shaoxu, Zhu Hong. The body, the view of body, and the study of body in human geography[J]. Geography Research, 2015,34(6):1173-1187.]
[105] Barney W. Encyclopedia of Human Geography[M]. London:Sage, 2004:1-8.
[106] Gregory D, Johnston R. The Dictionary of Human Geography (5th edition)[M]. Oxford:Wiley-Blackwell, 2009:1-30.
[107] Longhurst R. The body and geography[J]. Gender, Place and Culture, 1995,2(1):97-106.
[108] Zhang J J. Borders on the mover:Cross-strait tourists' material moments on ‘the other side’ in the midst of rapprochement between China and Taiwan[J]. Geoforum, 2013,48(8):94-101.
[109] Bessiere J. Local development and heritage:Traditional food and cuisine as tourist attractions in rural areas[J]. Sociological Ruralis, 1983,38(1):21-34.
[110] Lang H, Bienale V. "I smell you on my clothes"[M]//Crewe L. The Geographies of Fashion:Consumption, Space and Value. London:Bloomsbury, 2017:24.
[111] Crewe L. The Geographies of Fashion:Consumption, Space and Value[M]. London:Bloomsbury, 2017:21-34.
[112] Steele V. Style in revolt[M]//Wilcox C. Radical Fashion. London:V & A Publications, 2001:46-55.
[113] Britton S. Tourism, capital, and place:Towards a critical geography of tourism[J]. Environment and Planning D:Society and Space, 1991,9(4):452-478.
[114] Sharpley R. Tourism, Tourists & Society[M]. Huntingdon, Cambridgeshire:ELM, 1994:220-256.
[115] Mowforth M, Munt I. Tourism and Sustainability:Development and Tourism in the Third World[M]. London:Routledge, 2003.